Melanie Amaro "Hero" 1st Song Final 4 X Factor Dec 14, 2011

[mailmellilot]

not really in tune, either on purpose or cant tune it right with her voice. nice voice actually

[chansondefrance]

Flawless...

[DnZnFOREu]

It's pretty amazing what a minor chord can do for a song.

[ziled023]

i don't think i had ever seen simon get on his feet for someone.

[871387131]

woooowww!!!!!! very very NICE!!!!!!

[TheBartozinhu]

beautiful beautiful Besth besth Melaine

[zblamm2121]

*Goes to listen to original*...no offense this is good, but let's be real no one touches Mariah

[ziled023]

@zblamm2121 absolutely!!!

[eveningstar1982]

@zblamm2121 They have to proof that they can make an old song their own, so it's just not another copy.

[shadeealldaye11]

shes so mean :D ,& this is her live,imajin her with all tha shit they use wen recording..

honest my idol :))

[kmi09100]

I just get hypnotize with her voice i love it!! its amazing

[75AMALKA]

Melanie is talent.a gift from God,he who criticizes,envies her talent

[MrAngelo1980]

Chris Rene is not a fucking singer that is it we need a true talent enought with fucking britney spear another hoe cant sing and many more sick and tired about those people cant fucking sing

[MrAngelo1980]

@maxvain get the fuck out here u dumb ass bitch u dont know about unique talent

[TheGmorris56]

I guess that why she won...that's for all you hater's out there who can't recognize true talent.......

[dhw314]

@TheGmorris56 i was glad she won, but then again the majority of the voters (young females) had to split their votes between Joshn and Rene. and i believe that why Melanie won.

[2525RONY]

lindaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaa­a campea com certeza do the x factor,ja ganhouuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuu­uuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuu,torço por vc aqui do brazil melanie sou seu fa numero 1 xero bainano pra vc.

[Huong2384109348]

i think the vocal is amazing.....but not much emotino.Just saying :)

[Huong2384109348]

no one can beats Mariah Carey !!!!! Thumbs up if u agree

[nice3ck]

@Huong2384109348 no one can BEATS you in english wow! grammar dude grammar

[tydcosta]

She's divine and i love her!!!

[EmaLovesAvriil]

Fuck THIS!

[leecheehee]

She's gonna win. I loved Rachel Crow but look at that audience. Melanie is going to win.

[PCT82]

The next mariah carey

[jacobyk1]

SHE SHOULD WIN !!!!

[ranieridamasceno]

Her "copies" are way way better than the originals. Just saying. She´s outstanding. What a voice!

[jmzgalaxy]

i love melanie..i do but i dont think she would sell albums...maybe im wrong but there is nothing to look forward to. zero originality. she might win this competition but i think pple like rachel crow or josh krajcik could be more succesful...jus sayin

[MacHorak2012]

Haha i think its hilarious when people bash Melanie when they don't even know her. They are obviously just jealous that she is better then everyone in the competition.

[ontheair91]

WHY DO I LIKE MELANIE, BECAUSE HER VOICE JUST SOUNDS GOOD UNLIKE CHRIS.

[stavp8]

@ontheair91 more then chris

[TheSnehula]

beautiful, perfect Melanie:)

[Faxness4ever1]

I am so happy Simon brought her back. She did an amazing job on this song. I bet Simon is proud of his girl :)

[eringer56]

marcus canty was awful i flipped the hell out when drew was kicked off instead of him she had more talent in her pinky then he will ever have in his life, i also hate how la reed is bias. He never has anything bad to say about his guys and onl bad things to say about the girls who were obviously the best in the competition hands down.

[CassidyJoell]

@eringer56 my thoughts exactly!! I thought I was the only one who thought that!

[eringer56]

@CassidyJoell yea it's hard to watch the show still after drew got kicked off also. She sang baby by justin bieber way better than he did and she has an amazing voice. Melanie sang hero to perfection they both deserve recording contracts.

[misssmithviii]

beautiful... I remember sitting there thinking "not Hero... please no..." but I love it. I will always be partial to the original but she DEF does it justice ^_^

[ShockNAweMack]

Beautiful voice...clear and crisp...but not unique. Not her own. Josh....now thats a voice thats unique, powerful, emotional and just rips the soul out of you. Thats the X Factor.

No offense but as beautiful as her voice is she should do very well. But Josh should win this hands down.

[milemile62]

i really think she is a greatest singer . i dissagreed with maxvain. because she sang the song like her own way

[uggybigboots]

amazing singer but im bored.................. good luck to her though- hope she starts writing her own stuff

[bostonk1]

sooooooooo good . u cant deny that she is pure talent

[SychBandiTh]

great vocals BUT almost KARAOKE, shes playing SAFe and because of that SHE does NOT deserve to win!!! ITS down to CHRIS and JOSH!!!!>.

FROM Philippines!!!!

[jmtorrato]

singing a song doesn't mean she should change the whole song. or maybe some people want her to sing "HERO" in the tune of the Queen's "BOHEMIAN RHAPSODY".

[MrWatevagal]

waay to go gurl...you'll win that 5 million =)

[peliferj100]

melanie!! the best!!!

[taylor26101]

Did any of you ever listen to the songs Leona Lewis sang on her X factor progression to winning I suppose you would have put those down too. After all over the rain bow is just another ballad but after winning SIMON got her the right songs with the right production and boom you have a star. Leona had the voice, Melanie has the voice songs can be written for tallent not the other way around.

[marcorelo2007]

yeah...copycatty

[08Cdancer]

@marcorelo2007 It's takes true talent to be able to successfully mimic vocals from a Mariah Carey song. Also, it's not copycatty. Trust me Hero is one of my favorite songs so I know every vocal of that song. TRUST ME, THIS IS NOT COPYCATTING.

[kotchakornvansnick]

เสียงเพราะมากๆๆๆๆ Very beautiful voice.

[lolo2hot25]

this was dynamic love you melanie....you are a star

[mitzlee1]

Copycat so BORING.

[08Cdancer]

@mitzlee1 How is it "Copycat"? 

[JL153S1]

Melanie, I love you!! You must win! You are good! America - VOTE FOR MELANIE!

[JL153S1]

VOTE FOR MELANIE!! VOTE FOR MELANIE!!

[rebelliousgift]

สุดยอดดดดดดดดดดดดดดดดดด so cool i follow u ^^

[TheRealCritique]

yeah, this was scary. Twisted sister meets Mariah Carey on that high note. She needs to discover an identity. That's her problem. Of course, the music she's used to singing is such cookie cutter bullshit ballads, she prob never will.

[TheRunnerboy4]

She is the winner sound,heart and feelings...i believe you Melanie!!! from first audtion to the end

[MariahLambie92]

I have to agree with Paula, the arrangement took away the "happiness" and and "up lifting" you get when you hear the song, but I agree with Simon at least it wasn't another Mariah Carey-oke.. Chris and Melanie should win!

[TheLbk123]

damn she sounded ugly on this she went overboard on the high note

[GrumpyOnline]

This is just another Beyonce --_____--

[willobre]

I agree, I think GaGa was able to overcome her lack of beauty by having such an artistic perspective and writing songs herself that the common person goes cra cra over. Jennifer Hudson is hot though. Who thought she was ugly? Send a survey out to every NBA player and I bet 95% would say that they would love to get up in Jennifer Hudson's guts. Beat'em up like cake batter

[mariah3510]

Hero is a hard song, even though the highest note is just Eb5, i adore you !

[willobre]

ute

[willobre]

I do not really like how she started covering her badass florida accent with that schwag virgin island accent. She will never be pop star for one reason.....she's a little ugly....kinda dumpy. Mariah-dime piece, Whitney-cracked out dime piece, Carrie Underwood-gives me wood....point is Melanie just doesn't have IT. Best voice on the X Factor USA but you cannot take her voice to Bone Zone

Her only chance at making it big is to get nose job....and snort tons of booger sugar off LA Reid's skin fl

[maxvain]

@willobre Same thing was said about Jennifer Hudson, and Lady GaGa faced the same early in her career.

[MrBigShotCaller]

@willobre Hey, hey!!!!! No one is perfect in this world...I'm sure you have insecurity about yourself, but just don't want to admit it. By far, I bet Melanie has more talent than you

[musiclova2471]

@willobre Get real you shallow bitch.......

[heatherosu]

who gives a hoot what this girl sings! ballads is by far the hardest to hit. That's her style, and within time, the right coaching, and media attention she'll branch into more genres and varieties. Mariah, Whitney, and Celion started off with ballads. With the little time they have to prepare, and being thrown into the media Melanie has PIPES, and on her way to be the next Mariah.

[37lmao]

im sorry but my theory is NEVER ATTEMPT a MARIAH CAREY SONG...

but melanie killed it! i freakin love her voice!!

team MELANIE!!!!!

[mikhaldavid2010]

i love it,, not as good as mariah but ,, i love this ,, coz its a mariah carey song,,GOODLUCK MELANIE!!

[MrBojingjing]

She sings Hella good! She better win, either he or Chris Rene

[Really164]

If Melanie doesnt win this competition there is something WRONG.. . she is by FAR the best

[itsjackson91]

If she doesn't win this thing it will be a damn shame. Her voice is incredible. She doesn't need all those dancers and theatrics to be amazing.

[SKPF1]

Melanie! I love your voice!!!!!!!!

[eduardolalo82]

Boooo!!!! Mariah sings it way, way, way better.

[jlynne028]

Wow just Amazing! LOVE HER

[njspecz]

Karaoke. She's a good singer, but she has absolutely no originality.

[maxvain]

@njspecz lol laughable comment

[njspecz]

@maxvain Note really. ALL she does is regurgitate the same thing every talent show has ever claimed its winner. Ballad after balled, tone for tone. I'm not discrediting her vocal quality, I think shes better than Marcus and Chris, but she doesn't make the songs her own. Just copies them perfectly.

[maxvain]

@njspecz ahhh ok... not even going to bother to debate further, after that comment you made. It will be futile.

[MrMannysworld]

@njspecz That's part of the arrangement and you can't blame her for that, cuz that's on Simon.

[taniran3]

@njspecz ......as do the rest of the remaining contestants... the diff with her and the others tho is , she sings and sounds better than them ....LOL

[candyblinggg]

@njspecz that alone is a major talent!!

[horselover571]

@njspecz She's basicaly Beyonce, Maria, and a bunch of amazing singers all in one:)

[njspecz]

@horselover571 No she's not.

[stavp8]

@njspecz dont tock like thet. shes the best in the x factor. more then josh more then marcus (the worst marcus) and the only one who is better then her its rachel crow.

[coppertop2710]

@njspecz - Exactly... And this is why Josh (who is an original) should win.

[njspecz]

@coppertop2710 Agreed.

[MacHorak2012]

@njspecz did you not see her sing "Feeling Good"?

[MacHorak2012]

@njspecz too bad thats NOT her fault. blame simon for that.

[dhw314]

@njspecz i agree. she acts/sings like she is in a recording studio, instead of being in front of a live audience

[karston9]

Wow Mel...that was the best performance of the night.

[MacHorak2012]

SHE NEEDS TO WIN!

[saratogawayne]

VOTE VOTE VOTE VOTE VOTE VOTE VOTE VOTE VOTE VOTE for MELANIE AMARO!!!! I am using the comp. and the phone at the same time voting for her:) WE LOVE YOU! MEALANIE AMARO IS A SUPERSTAR!

[saratogawayne]

MELANIE AMARO IS A SUPERSTAR!!!!!!! That sound was BEAUTIFUL, I sometimes wonder where some of these people that make comments, what the hell do there BRAINS think, or do they even have anything between there ears???? NO, I dont think they do, because if you make a neg. comment against this girl, you must be REALLY FUCKED UP! We LOVE YOU MELANIE, knock them all off that STAGE:)

[jazzy19001]

133- 1:34 - ouch... not a nice sound - over singing. It would be good if she moved around a little. Mimi can walk and sing.

[Itsvanessa1000]

@jazzy19001 Well she isn't Mimi Shes Melanie :) Totally different person!! SO I DISAGREE WITH YOU :) She is herself :)

[tommykrongyut123]

She did so well.

[Punisher0073]

Such a beautiful voice...

[lettylabarca]

AMAZING!!! SHE IS THE BEST. I HOPE AMERICA VOTES TO HER.

[JeffChristieFan]

Why can't the audience just show some respect for the singers? Please you guys let us listen to the performance in peace. Stop those YEAH!, OOOH!, AAAH!

[realbath]

Une grande voix... une belle artiste dans l'âme.

[pishu23]

ooooooooooooooooooh por dios !! mori !!

[kevincosthner]

nossa ela é muito boa mesmo... talento esplendido de uma diva, não a duvida q será a ganhadora desse reality show... quando canta whitney é perfeita... quando canta mariah carey é perfeita, quando canta michael jacskon é perfeita... melanie você é perfeita... o brasil te ama ... xoxoxoxoxox