Added: 2 years ago
From: caprihare
Views: 33,760
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:
see all

All Comments (45)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • Цой на всегда! (Такие люди просто так не уходяят) зря она взялась за это.

  • Comment removed

  • It said there were going to be lyrics. I like the Kino version slightly better but my Russian isn't good enough to understand it all. I'm not completely disappointed though. There is something incredibly sexy about a woman shooting Nazis.

  • Мы еще победим!!!!!!!!!

  • неужели "сильные и смелые сложили головы" ... и никого не осталось?

    неужели мы на самом деле так надорвались (как говорит наш Патриарх) в этих трех войнах ?

  • Смотрится на одном выдохе. Мы защитим наших Женщин - Федот показал пример.

  • Comment removed

  • Our people during the war did what your opportunities when you have - shat his pants

  • Stupid Americans, you will never be able understand our fortitude during the war , and our movies you just can not understand , they have a soul and it is not possible to fight

  • @caprihare From your point of view you are right, but my observation refers to the way Russians show the Second World War. Russians as well as Germans wore aggressors at that time, that is why these movies are pathetic and grotesque. I am not in the position to judge Stalin and others like him, because it does not change anything. So that is not the case, in which we try to put these two countries into schema: winner or loser. It is like say, the first one was punished, the second one was not.

  • @Depressionsbehandlin 1)One can't be aggressor struggling on his own land. 2)Well, Andrzej, Stalin wasn't punished but his (my) nation was -the army irretrievables of >10 mlns +comparable civil losses made a great footprint in people's mentality -mirrored in movies like "At Dawn It's Quiet Here". The movie's emotional charge overwhelms the ideological one. Of course, it's asymmetric (enemy is fierce or faceless)-I'd like to see a remake from the aspect of German squad -probably in horror jenre))

  • Comment removed

  • @Depressionsbehandlin Russians are not victims for they WON -at an ARGUABLY AFFORDABLE price. Does the price of a human life depend on whose government was "more guilty"? IMHO losing a war is a worse "sin" than starting it. War starter spills blood/spends money for an aim that may be ridiculous. War loser does that for eventually NOTHING. Russians will always argue who was Stalin -a great criminal or a great hero -and who were Gorbachev&Yeltsin (cold war losers)-great criminals or great idiots.

  • @caprihare Don't sit long at a computer, the teenager. Parents will abuse. Tomorrow in school.

    You know nothing about this war. For textbooks!

  • @75Veter Ты так категоричен, уважаемый - наверное, воевал?

  • @caprihare Большинство из тех, кто выйграли Вторую Мировую (в т. е. ВОВ) до тех пор ни то что не воевали, но даже не держали в руках оружие.

    Иди учи ботанику

  • @Depressionsbehandlin How did they start it? I don't know that question, but I know they finished it, destroying 80% of all combined axis forces in Europe.

  • @mikerileysband No interviews in the movie. Vasiliev said the plot was a convergence of two real episodes: 1)The German paratroopers assault on Murmansk railroad repulsed by a tiny group of soldiers undergoing medical treatment and old civilians. They suddenly faced enemy at a “quiet” station - and most of them died in a "rifle-vs-SMG" battle. 2)His own observation in July 1941 of two civil dead girls in a forest - believed to be occasional witnesses terminated by German saboteurs.

  • Красивая песня...

  • I´m ecuadorian ...yesterday I saw this movie and ....beautiful!!!

  • One of my favorite movies about war. Every girl is such a character. (what happened to our "Pepsi" generation?) It was done by Stanislav Postozkii, a war veteran, therefore every detail was true to life (unlike Hollywood versions about WWII action heroes). Thank you for your vid!!!

  • @Ivorybird09 To widen your impressive knowledge of Russian cinematography it should be noted that when the film appeared, the WWII soldier Boris Vasiliev (author of the story & co-author of the script) disliked the work of the WWII soldier Stanislav Rostotsky for being more beautiful than tragic. So the concept of "true to life" may lay beyond the details.

  • @caprihare Zemfira's song is kind of simplistic but still thank you for your effort, Mr Hare of Capri. I wonder what Boris Vasilyev would say about it! As for my knowledge of cinematography, hmm, let's not make any hasty assumptions based on one single comment.

  • Очень хорошо! И Земфира..."А зори здесь тихие"...все в тему. " Я женщина! Я все смогу!" (Лидия Фогель)

  • Haroshaja rabota dolodets

  • @aks4kj

    мал ты еще

  • @aks4kj Да представляться было не обязательно, достаточно ника... А не нравится - смотри "Том и Джерри" - там весело.....

  • спсибо

  • Люблю Земфиру, люблю этот фильм. Спасибо за видео!

Loading...
0 / 00Unsaved Playlist Return to active list
    1. Your queue is empty. Add videos to your queue using this button:
      or sign in to load a different list.
    Loading...Loading...Saving...
    • Clear all videos from this list
    • Learn more