Added: 3 years ago
From: hrock9
Views: 404,014
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:
see all

All Comments (4,046)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • I think dave is better coz he has his own chords spider chords!!!!!

  • 0:41 Robert Trujillo ?

  • zakk easly wins dave's soloing is realy slopy and zakk you can actualy hear what is going on.

  • NAO DA PRA DEFINIR, SAO GENEROS DIFERENTES DE MUSICA (AMBOS SAO ROCK)

  • I love Dave and everything, but zakk is the Shit dude

  • Any one that played with Ozzy is a legend. Ozzys band members would blow Daves out the water.

  • Comparing Zakk and Dave is like comparing Eddie Van Halen and Randy Rhodes. If you like the guy or the music better, you'll most likely like his guitar playing better. I'm an Eddie Van Halen fan. You won't convince me that Randy Rhodes is better than Eddie, even though I love and respect Randy's work. It's all in the eye (or ear) of the beholder.

  • zakk !!!!!!!

  • They're both utterly incredible. You can't call a winner on this stuff. I think Zakk is smoother and can milk things a little more, but Dave is rough- not in a non-technical way, but in the same blunt and explosive brash way that he is in real life, there's more edge. They both put the most they can of themselves into their music and their skill is the least of their barriers, so I'm not one to judge. I'm thankful for both.

  • Damn hrock9 (video uploader) give Dave a chance!... You got 15 secs of Zakk with great recording quality and then a couple seconds of suppressed random clips of interlude type stuff from cheesy you tubes and live fan clips and then back to professionally produced Zakk Wylde highlights! Dave friggin shreds if you'd show it.

  • Zakk doesn't have shit on Dave.

  • what? walle-e on key-word?

    hhaha

  • They both kickass !!

  • la neta ni a cual irle los dos estan cabrones

  • i agree with fishinandjeppin both equal!

  • Comment removed

  • caralho Zakk wylde é o Baixista do Metallica

    !

  • what Megadeth concert is 2:03??

  • Funny, compairing the main lead player, Wylde, and the #2 guitar player in Megadeth. I guess that should say something about Mustaine. I love 'em both, completely different players. Clearly Zakk is Blues based where Mustaine is influenced (his words) more by the British metal guitarists.

    Fair enough they were mostly, at some point, blues based.

    I'm sure Zakk's guitar is black and blue by the end of the night.

  • i love both of them. but i gotta say when it comes to guitar zakk just totally annihilates dave at everything. zakk's confidence, charisma and stage presence is out of this world. when dave, however, plays he's so still and so stiff. zakk has his own unqiue style of playing, you can tell his solo from a mile away whereas with dave it's like just another metal solo. if you were going to compare anyone with zakk with someone it should've marty friedman or chris broderick.

  • @kungfudragon99 I agree, as far as who's a better guitar player, I don't really care, but I prefer watching Zakk play WAY more. Something about Mustaine's picking and fretting style just looks strange and awkward to me. And Zakk's stage presence is so much more powerful in my opinion. I guess I'm more of a Rock/Hard rock guy than straight up Metal so I'm probably more biased towards Zakk anyways.

  • @kungfudragon99 Dave's stage presence in in the music itself lol and by the way if you can play a megadeth riff and go apeshit on stage and still sound valid then you deserve a medal because Dave writes some tricky complex shit.

  • @kungfudragon99 To further prove your point, look how zakk places his picking hand in farewell ballad, exactly like marty

  • Dave wins for me

  • Zakk Video are louder and Zakk used tooo much WAH pedal

  • I like both but definitely Zackk FTW here.

  • Zakk for far

  • zakk owns davee , i feel sorry for dave while i was watching the video ...

  • Dave Mustaine win

  • its hard to determine... they play different styles so really theres no way to compare... i would say mustaine is by far a faster and more technical guitarist and zakks guitar playing comes straight from his soul....for zakk the technical aspect doesnt factor in and it doesnt need to.

  • @fishinandjeepin your a moron dude are you kidding me zakk wylde is way faster than this guy and zakk has a blues background and thats why he's more soulful the other guy just isn't as good

  • @fishinandjeepin i agree 100% but i think dave is more from his heart and soul. he hasn't changed style and how would you say "his views of the wolrd"

  • @fishinandjeepin Mustaines music also comes from the soul, If you read his bio then you see that he lets all of his frustration out on the guitar, and that is also a way to express yourself musically, so yea daves music does come from the soul just as much as zakks

  • fairwell ballad is a blues/metal masterpeice

  • I'm a big Megadeth fan but Zakk is technically better at lead but he couldn't hold a candle to Dave's rhythms or his lyricism

  • I am guilty just by the scratch..ugh

  • I hate Zak

  • You didnt even put the best from Mustaine up there. And I love both guitarists but you people need to realize that Zakk plays the same stuff all the time, both riffs and solos. Dave is a better technical guitarist, listen to everything he made, Metallica, and Megadeth, and you should see his skill to beat out Wyldes.

  • Zakk is much better than Mustaine, and still is a singer and pianist !

    Zakk destroy dude

  • well well.

    I think zakk wins !

  • I say Dave Mustaine

  • por nada mas o zakk wylde e praticamente um palhaço de guitarra

    ele brina demaiskkk

  • at 3:40 no one can do that but it would be fun to try

  • to me mustaine's a way better song and lyricist than a vocalist, sometimes his nasally vocals get to me; but as far as guitarists is concerned, zakk is hard to rival, as he fits into the elite's class, definitely a Hall of Famer

  • Everybody have thier own style, Mustaine got his own and Wylde got his own. They are both good at what they do 8D

  • DAVE MUSTAINE!!!!!!!!!!!! what's wrong with you people!

  • seriously?? the people here chose zakk??? WTF? FTW

  • how the fuck is this a guitar battle ...you should be comparing Friedman to Zack , not Dave...and music aint some sort of competion ,but in any case Dave has taken Megadeth to place's that Zack's Black Label Society can only dream about

  • zakk forever...no worries!!!!!

  • zakk is a great guitarist, faster and sometimes not everything, but I still say is a great guitarist, but if I can not say it better then Dave and I say that and more musically unpredictable, who sings and plays at the same time, I I prefer Dave ... Dave is a very complete guitarist. Dave does not use very fast because the technique of the theory .. but still very fast and Dave Mustaine for president.

  • Dave

  • seriously its pretty obvious that zakk blows dave away zakk is effortless and the guitar an extension of his body otherwise he wouldnt be so agile with so much movement during his solos dave always looks so tense and stiff...lots of technical ability but music should ebb and flow and knock you right the hell over and mesmerise you it should take you along with it and make you feel you are a part of it....zakk does this

  • Mustaine!!

  • zakk wylde is better player, i prefer dave mustaine and megadeth to black label society anyday.

  • What's the song from 00:10 to 00:15 ????? Thanks.

  • Dave se la mata con el Solo de Holy MEGADETH MEGADETH Aguante MEGADETH !

  • dave's solos are more musical/interesting. Zakk plays the same pentatonics over and over and over and over and ov.......................

  • @SnypaXoXo dave is lead guitarrist to, but is just in some songs, like holy wars(last solo), and hangar 18(last solo to)

  • DM

  • Zakk wins, but Zakk is a lead player and Dave is rhythm player. So it would be more fair to compare Chris Broderick and Zakk

  • @SnypaXoXo In that case I'm sure that Broderick would win. He's a fantastic guitarist.

  • @sili0 Yeah i know. Broderick is one of the greatest players on this planet ^^

  • Dave Mustaine better cuz he plays and combine rythm and lead guitar at the same time.

  • Zakk is the better lead player, Dave is the better rhythm player.

  • Zakk shits on Dave. Not that Dave is bad...Zakk is that good.

  • Marty Friedman Wins !

  • mustaine tutta la vita

  • ABSOLUTELY ZAKK!

  • mustaine

  • Comment removed

  • Zakk Wylde Is awesome!!

    

  • Zak Wylde Wins

    There's no fucking way ! Zak Wylde 4ever

  • @skaladeritcher666 mustaine had better solos and riffs dave could plzay as fast as wylde

  • zakk wylde laws

  • Zack is a better guitarist, Dave is a better song writer and musician.

  • @LTDGuitars420 agreed, megadeth is far better than black label society. they way more original and interesting.

  • Comment removed

  • @LTDGuitars420 but dave cant play the piano or banjo so...dave would be a better...ok daves not better but he is awesome

  • @LTDGuitars420

    Dave is better rhythm guitarist

  • @LTDGuitars420 agreed

  • @LTDGuitars420 That is so FALSE. I actually joined Youtube to say this... Dave ISN'T a better songwritter than Zakk, are you crazy? Man, you are just wrong.

  • In regards to your other comment, I never said Dave was the better guitarist, I said Zakk was. Sorry if you disagree but Mustaine is a far better songwriter, his lyrics are very polititcal and they usually have some significant meaning. Zakk's songs are either gay love songs or have no meaning at all. And saying he's better guitarist than Dave isn't completely true, Zakk wets up his tone with several effects and NEVER plays without a wah pedal.

  • "his lyrics are very polititcal and they usually have some significant meaning. Zakk's songs are either gay love songs or have no meaning at all"

    Jeez, you're 13. Bye.

  • Well you make a very sophisticated argument yourself, dumbfuck.

  • @LTDGuitars420 I could stand you saying Dave is a better guitar player, which is also untrue, but what you said is just annoying. FUCK YOU.

  • Comment removed

  • Мухоха!) Афтар скромно поставил громкость зака в два раза громче дэйва-)))))) И типа незаинтересованно спрашивает кто лучше)

  • Well both of them are great in their own ways....The only difference is that on Zakk's hand the guitar is his bitch and on Dave's hand it's a weapon...but I too vote for The Best Ever...Randy Rhoads!!!!!!\m/

  • Both are meh. Compared to the Jarzombeks and Skolnicks of this world neither are special in any way.

  • Jimi Hendrix :D LOL

  • They are both great but I like dave more

  • O Mustaine palheta (aparentemente) com mais facilidade do que o Zakk

    Mais o Zakk é mais criativo do que o Dave Mustaine........

    prefiro o ........

  • Awe shit...can't decide!!! Both of these dudes are formidable guitarists!

  • Megadeth Megadeth, Aguante Megadethhhh

  • I dont see Dave playing with a guitar behing his back and still playing as good as he does normal

  • Oh please .. Zakk can play anything hes more open Dave just plays the same thrash over and over again with his high treble.

  • Well considering you showed the best of Zakk and the worst of Dave, im guessing Zakk.

  • xodrh patata leme

  • whats the song in the beginning? (Zakk's intro)

  • @thefr00bstv Concrete Jungle

  • Zakk!

    

  • Wylde 

  • ZAKK IS DA PRO

  • Devils Island, Holy Wars, Wake Up Dead, Washington is Next

  • half those of daves werent even solos.. it was riffs..

  • I dont get why most ppl say dave cant play with feeling...he plays with anger in every solo

  • Mustaine

  • Dave.

    

  • 4:20 what song is this?

  • @megametallicah she-wolf

  • I prefer Zakk for solos and nice ballads over Mustaine, but Dave have really kick ass Riffs under his belt that Zakk can't rival with. Can't say which one I really prefer, I like both of them for different stuffs.

  • I'm gonna say Dave partially because he has more memorable riffs. Zakk is too much fake biker image+pinch harmonics+wah. The cliche metal way too ruin every song by over doing it. Dave Mustaine has wrote some of Metallica's best songs too. I mean..really..no comparison.

  • dave mustaine

  • zakk wylde.

  • zak wylde

  • How about the sound quality of the Megadeth clips is far inferior to the ZW ones! with exception to 1.06. not a fair comparison!

  • zakk

  • Zakk Wylde!

    

  • zakk can singing with high pitch sound while playing some fucking riffs?

  • zakk wins in solos. Dave really isnt very good at writing solos, except for only a few.

  • MUSTAINE TIENE QUE CANTAR Y TOCAR , ADEMÁS EL OTRO SOLO TIENE QUE TOCAR ES MÁS FÁCIL ASÍ... POR ESO GANA ZAKK

  • very good :)

  • Zakk Wylde é gênio,não da para comparar

  • DAVE!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!­!!!!!

  • You'd have to be a non-guitarist, a complete die hard megadeth fan or tone-deaf to think that mustaine is better.

  • Every guitar player would answer, that Zakk Wylde is ten times better than Mustaine!

  • dave mustaine its better!!! THE SOUND HAS BEEN SHUTTED DOWN!!

  • dave all the way....even though the volume is turned way down so you cant here that he is better

  • What´s the song at 2:02 ?

  • @268samuel farewell ballad

  • @268samuel it's an improvisation that they made in the song "She Wolf" for the album "Rude Awakening"

  • im better then both of them put together :)

    but then i woke up.. :(

    both are good at what they do, why create competition thats not neccasary

    nothing is going to be fact, its just all opinions..

  • Jimi

  • Comment removed

  • I hate this kind of videos when you have to say wich one is better.

  • You can tell that dude favored Zakk if you watch the video #1 Should have used a few more of the "Rust In Peace" LP! #2 look how long he lets Zakk's solo go at the end!!

    Bottom line is: Dave's solo's are more intricate. Go listen to "Take No Prisoners" (or if you've heard it before, listen to it again to refresh your memory) ..Zakk does play some amazing solo's,so, don't get me wrong, but Dave's solo's are hard to beat. So, yeah, I gotta go with Dave Mustaine on this 1! ..}\/[ e g a d e t }-[..

  • @SilverDragon4War

    Dave aint too hard to beat.. Can mention plenty of people thats better.. (Zakk, Synyster Gates, Heafy etc..)

  • @TheNorwegianEmo Heafy?Synyster?Seriously

  • @MrAndyman290

    Very seriously.

  • @TheNorwegianEmo Heafy play really sloppy.I saw some of their videos.Just drop d powerchords and sloppy attempts at sweep picking in tempos hes not even able to sweep.And synyster is also an ovverated guitarist in an overated band.Matt Heafey gets easily owned by both zakk and dave mustaine.Probably synyster gates too.

  • @MrAndyman290

    I respect your opinion, and I agree with the Zakk part, but not Dave. Dave could not own Synyster, though, I agree Zakk could.

  • @TheNorwegianEmo Most metal guitarist I know about could own synyster gates easily including dave,Herman Li,Alexi,hetfield and all those guys.

  • @MrAndyman290

    Hetfield? You've smoked some bad shit dude...

  • @TheNorwegianEmo And im not a mettalica fanboy or fan,I don't smoke.The early metallica stuffs are way better than everything a7x has ever done.Holy wars and hangar 18 are way more difficult to play on guitar than farewell ballad or a7x.I am not agree with people saying dave is the best guitarist ever but hes way better than thos avenged sevenfold guys put together most metal guitarists are in my opinion.

  • @MrAndyman290

    If you're not a Metallica fanboy, then how can you say James is better than Syn? I'm a Metallica fanboy and I don't even say that... I'm not even gonna reply to you anymore, as you're so damn arrogant.

  • @TheNorwegianEmo What if i don't find synyster so great as everyone wants him to be?

  • @MrAndyman290

    What if I said like "I respect your opinion" and "Thats your opinion" like ten times, and then you just talk shit back, and now you're saying that YOU don't find him as great as everyone else? I think I've said that plenty of times, seriously, your argument is irrelevant.

  • @TheNorwegianEmo fuck your mother.....

  • @serhathoca

    Shes too good for you. Did yours a couple of times tho..

  • How can you Fuckin compare this 2 uh? They are different styles so WTF ?

  • gotta pick zakk

  • Zakk wins hands down when it comes to putting emotion and feel into his solos but it's hard to compare these 2 cause even though they are both Metal they have very different styles. Both are amazing guitarist but Zakk does cover a wider range of sounds and styles of music where Dave just sticks with his comfort zone in the Thrash metal style so gonna have to vote for Zakk Wylde as the winner.

  • si hablamso de Riff es Dave Mustaine, pero si hablamos de Solos caga Zakk Wylde

  • Mustaine Es Basura Al Lado De Zakk Wylde XD

  • Dave is fucking amazing! Kicks Hammets ass all day long.....but Zakk u can't compare them, both the best in there style.

  • ZAKK WYLDE!!!!!

  • ZAAAKK WYLDEEE !!!

  • Zakk kicks ass

  • 0:36 he made some shit out of the great song, whatta dumb

  • RANDY RHOADS (VOTE HERE)

  • mustaine for me everytime!!

  • all I can say is this: Fuck your mother for giving birth to an idiot that you are! Next time adjust the volume of your clips, you cockbag!

  • there's no comparison

  • How can you compare the two when Dave Mustaine has always said he is a rhythm player more than a lead player :/

  • @NEProductions111

    Yes you can, based on tone and playing ability.

  • y porque en este video omitiste los mejores solos de dave ?

  • wylde no doubt. but yet u cant really compare guitarists so ya.

  • dave!!

    

  • Dave's Rythm are more dificult to play than Zakk Wylde solos

    But both of them are kick ass guitar players

  • zakk o/

  • dave is for the most part the rythm player of Megadeth and a damn good one,while zakk is more the lead player and in fact was ozzy's "hired gun" for twenty odd years,that being said is enough. However they are both very accomplished musicians.If any critique is done it would be more credible from accomplished guitarists.

  • Both of them are very kick ass guitar players. End of story.

  • We can all argue on the internet till someone dies....

    Both are equally superior technical players, fastest pickers on this planet.

    Me? I personally dig Zakk's solos and songwriting style much better. He can go fast as hell metal wise, but if you've listened to Book of Shadows, and Pride and Glory, he clearly has more soul.

    It all depends on what style you dig.

  • zak wylde is cool but mustaine songwriting is far superior

  • 1:47 Ride that humbucker cowboy. This is from page 147 of Guitar Player Kama Sutra ... WARNING: Do Not Attempt with Whammy Bar Attached~!

  • zakk wylde.

  • DABE MUSTAINE!!

    dont get me wrong zakk wylde is awesome too

  • what's the name of the song at the end ?

  • WTF you have sick clips of Zakk but only shitty clips of Mustaine playing....if u want a true comparrison check out Daves early solos on Peace Sells and Killing is my business OR their newest album

  • How is this even a competition?? Zakk will ALWAYS win! Hands down. This is like comparing apples to oranges. Zakk makes Dave look like he's just learning how to play.