This is made from the version on Joy Division's "Warsaw" album (Recorded AFTER they were JD. The album was not released but available on bootleg, until finally officially released in 1994 (including some additional bonus tracks recorded when they were Warsaw).
This recording, however, has been remixed and possibly had some overdubs put on as well. The proper recording from the Warsaw album is posted elsewhere on YouTube.
@yetimichael I was surfing the web trying to find an answer for this. I was listening to "Substance" and thought there are a few songs that don't sound like the Ian I know. Didn't know he didn't always use the bariton sound. He sang like this during the "Warsaw" days? Thanks for the info
This is truly incredible. Last night was the first time I heard it. Knew I HAD to hear it again tonight....FANTASTIC! This is a unique band for me in that everything I hear from them for the first time sounds even more amazing than what I've already heard from them. The musicianship is outta this world...creative and very rhythmically on..
@MayIRemindYouSumtin It was drawn by Bernard Sumner, who at this time went by the name Bernard Albrecht. The fact that he took a german surname for a while and designed a Nazi inspired front cover, contradicts their statement about not wanting to be associated with National Socialism, I think in the beginning they actively courted it to get them noticed.
@MaylRemindYouSumtin Joy Division made their recorded debut in June 1978 when the band self-released An Ideal for Living. The packaging of An Ideal for Living featured a drawing of a Hitler Youth member on the cover.
The band hated this album they did for R.C.A due to the producer overdubbing synthesizers on a few of the tracks. Pretty odd considering what they did later on with Martin Hannett, and of course with New Order.
just a weird question to y'all, do u think the structure of its song with that kinda krautrock influenced motorik at the beginning was influenced by station to station? i dno. just heard that album/song influenced post punk a fair some
You people are all too funny. This is from the aborted RCA album sessions that ended up on the original JD "Warsaw" boot (the one with the album and the extra 7" single) that came out in late 1981 or early 1982. See
This song is about Jewish women who were forced by the Nazis into prostitution in concentration camps during WW2. The women worked in what were called Freudenabteilung, or "Joy Divisions". Now this song and the band itself can be better understood and appreciated.
@lokeradekadente81 This is on the "Warsaw" album. Somebody's tried to mess with it and add a bit more echo/space but it's definitely the "Warsaw" album version.
This is the material made specifically for An Ideal for Living, they came up with the money themselves for this and the music in this is more than awsome ,its pure cutting edge.Joy Division my friend are fkn huge,this is them becoming mighty and the rest my friend is history.
The best Joy Division song ever...... My favourite. Very innovative sound for 1978....
I got a version close to this with a young girl talking before the song starts on a tape, around 1982, called Warsaw Warsaw..... and so began a long search for this on cd. got a couple of cds but no luck. finally got it on Remains a compilation cd and since then an a cd called Warsaw Warsaw (MPG 74034). reading the cd info and it says that it was recorded at Arrow Studios Manchester, england May 1978.
Am I right in thinking this might be from the Martin Hannett mixes? Anyone know? It just sounds far too 'post Joy Division' to my ears to be from 1980 or 1979. Maybe its a mix from later in Hannets life?
@seanreillyireland I can tell you that this is not the original No Love Lost recorded by Warsaw... or the re-recorded version of Joy Division. This must be, as you said, a Martin Hannett mix.
WTF!! They must have had a time machine to know this would hold up... waaaay ahead of the pack for 1978!
gspd750 16 hours ago in playlist Favorite videos
This is fucking amazing!!! thanks!
jaynesinflight 21 hours ago
The guitar at 2:35 never fails to melt my face off.
TateMTheGreatM 1 day ago
FREAKING FUCKING AMAZING!!
PAULINAKADABRA 2 days ago
just so awesome!
Libstergirl74 1 week ago
KICKEN BEAT
Aliesok64 1 week ago in playlist Luxe
This is the version that has two guitars. The additional guitar part is being played by Ian Curtis himself.
ElectricLabel 1 week ago
awesome
nihilius32 1 week ago
porco giuda che canzone spettacolare, il basso semplicemente te entra dentro il cuore, c'ho le casse che stanno tremando
bagninobranda 2 weeks ago
FUCK YES.
WeinerInYourMouth 3 weeks ago
A different mix of this was brought out on a 12" EP Titled"An Ideal for Living"around 77/78
1471ization 3 weeks ago
WOOOOOOOOOW
DonVanVliet83 3 weeks ago
awesome
GigiHare 3 weeks ago
Fooking Raw mate, makes my hairs stand on end
...thanks so much for sharing this gem....
AlDarko 1 month ago
Simplemente un genio joy división es lo máximo
becorn1 1 month ago
THIS TRACK IS SOOOO SERIOUS, ONE O MY JD FAVS STILL TRIPPIN' THIS ONE!!!!1
nva62 1 month ago
This is made from the version on Joy Division's "Warsaw" album (Recorded AFTER they were JD. The album was not released but available on bootleg, until finally officially released in 1994 (including some additional bonus tracks recorded when they were Warsaw).
This recording, however, has been remixed and possibly had some overdubs put on as well. The proper recording from the Warsaw album is posted elsewhere on YouTube.
UTubeIsTrackingYou 1 month ago
Anyone with 5 minutes exposure to JD knows this is a cover. But whose?
GamesFrontiers 1 month ago
This is not Joy Division and most certainly not Warsaw. So who is it?
GamesFrontiers 1 month ago
@GamesFrontiers Joy Division re-mixed possibly with overdubs.
UTubeIsTrackingYou 1 month ago
thanks for upping this .... sounds brilliant
labambiboo 1 month ago
KRAUTROCK IN ENGLAND
themetropolitains 1 month ago in playlist Favorite videos
its from when they were actually called Warsaw
alienspratley 1 month ago
this version os off their "aborted" album titled WARSAW.
LuckyCuspWishes413 1 month ago
THIS IS FUCKING GREAT!!!!! GREAT RECORDING!!!! THANK YOU!!!! I NEEDED TO HEAR THIS RIGHT NOW!!!
79stephaniem 1 month ago
WOW I CANT STOP MOVING!
flupachi 1 month ago 2
Definitely the best Joy Division song!!!Jeli tako Miodraze?
dkrnetad 1 month ago
LUDILOOOO..MADNESS !! Their best song ! Real..raw power...AAAAAAAAAAAAA !!!!!!!!
miodraggo 1 month ago 2
Best....
Intro....
EVER!...
BillKaps65 1 month ago 6
Popped my cherry for this version you have...
Still love the explosion at 3:02
coetmor 1 month ago 2
@coetmor
kinky
DerrEinzige 1 month ago
intro sounds like a black metal track
lemmidos 1 month ago
@lemmidos well the first few seconds
lemmidos 1 month ago
@nphanlon1973 what?! no... its ian curtis
subforsubbbb 2 months ago
that fucking SOUND MAN! YES!
michaelismichael 2 months ago
close to 30,000 views with no dislikes, that's saying something..
SpAcEpOp9800 2 months ago in playlist Liked videos
is that Barney Sumner on vocals?
nphanlon1973 2 months ago
@nphanlon1973 Ian Curtis before he adopted the Baritone sound
yetimichael 2 months ago
@yetimichael I was surfing the web trying to find an answer for this. I was listening to "Substance" and thought there are a few songs that don't sound like the Ian I know. Didn't know he didn't always use the bariton sound. He sang like this during the "Warsaw" days? Thanks for the info
Rene2D2 2 months ago
Thanks for posting, I've gotta go buy this CD if it's available.
petrologyboy 2 months ago
This is truly incredible. Last night was the first time I heard it. Knew I HAD to hear it again tonight....FANTASTIC! This is a unique band for me in that everything I hear from them for the first time sounds even more amazing than what I've already heard from them. The musicianship is outta this world...creative and very rhythmically on..
petrologyboy 2 months ago
Drums are tragic! :) But i love it!
CoffeHeaven22 2 months ago
great version!
idulajev 2 months ago
@MayIRemindYouSumtin It was drawn by Bernard Sumner, who at this time went by the name Bernard Albrecht. The fact that he took a german surname for a while and designed a Nazi inspired front cover, contradicts their statement about not wanting to be associated with National Socialism, I think in the beginning they actively courted it to get them noticed.
makky123 2 months ago
@MaylRemindYouSumtin Joy Division made their recorded debut in June 1978 when the band self-released An Ideal for Living. The packaging of An Ideal for Living featured a drawing of a Hitler Youth member on the cover.
Misfitspunk1023 2 months ago
LISTENING TO THIS LOOOOOOOOOOOUD
az0r22 3 months ago
This is a different mix than the one on the Warsaw album. It's the same recorded version, just a different post-production mix.
NintendoSegaSonyGuy 3 months ago
Superb.
7855waldo 3 months ago
This is 1978 and sounds like 2078. Music of the future.
e6e2e3e1 3 months ago
WOW
the way this tune ends
overwhelming... haunting.. brilliant
totopatter 3 months ago
one of the greatest and most influential bands ever
MaTchBoOkPoEt 3 months ago
love this gritty shit.
V19torrent 3 months ago
The band hated this album they did for R.C.A due to the producer overdubbing synthesizers on a few of the tracks. Pretty odd considering what they did later on with Martin Hannett, and of course with New Order.
MrFreakboy77 3 months ago
FUCK OFF LOVE WILL TEAR US APART
ANTI GAGA LEAGUE
GALLERIEVONDADA 3 months ago
wicked
joydivision808 3 months ago
Great version! Thanks for your upload.
krautjork 3 months ago
just a weird question to y'all, do u think the structure of its song with that kinda krautrock influenced motorik at the beginning was influenced by station to station? i dno. just heard that album/song influenced post punk a fair some
qoakzm2qoakzm 4 months ago
Rewelacja
mrallcz 5 months ago
best version so far
s2003m0205 5 months ago
fucking awsome !
kloppskalli 6 months ago 2
fucking awsome !
kloppskalli 6 months ago
@guyfromnewcastle where did you get this song?
neverFearIisHere 6 months ago 2
@neverFearIisHere From the comp 'Let the Movie Begin'
guyfromnewcastle 6 months ago 7
You people are all too funny. This is from the aborted RCA album sessions that ended up on the original JD "Warsaw" boot (the one with the album and the extra 7" single) that came out in late 1981 or early 1982. See
joydiv dot org slash w2lp dot htm
for more info on that bootleg.
RiotNrrrdUTube 6 months ago
This song is about Jewish women who were forced by the Nazis into prostitution in concentration camps during WW2. The women worked in what were called Freudenabteilung, or "Joy Divisions". Now this song and the band itself can be better understood and appreciated.
texasBMXer 6 months ago
where can I find this version? It's not the one on the warsaw or substance album.
lokeradekadente81 1 year ago
@lokeradekadente81 This is on the "Warsaw" album. Somebody's tried to mess with it and add a bit more echo/space but it's definitely the "Warsaw" album version.
RiotNrrrdUTube 6 months ago
Comment removed
lokeradekadente81 1 year ago
They recorded this when they were called Warsaw back in '78.
Fucking epic tune.
MorningGlory1997 1 year ago
This is the material made specifically for An Ideal for Living, they came up with the money themselves for this and the music in this is more than awsome ,its pure cutting edge.Joy Division my friend are fkn huge,this is them becoming mighty and the rest my friend is history.
cmjags1 1 year ago
i need it!
thermonuclearwarfare 1 year ago
never heard this version before...
jiannis72 1 year ago 3
The best Joy Division song ever...... My favourite. Very innovative sound for 1978....
I got a version close to this with a young girl talking before the song starts on a tape, around 1982, called Warsaw Warsaw..... and so began a long search for this on cd. got a couple of cds but no luck. finally got it on Remains a compilation cd and since then an a cd called Warsaw Warsaw (MPG 74034). reading the cd info and it says that it was recorded at Arrow Studios Manchester, england May 1978.
Ailleacht 1 year ago 23
@Ailleacht they were definately awesome in my point of view because of their innovation and untimelyness
toomanyangryidiots 2 weeks ago
@Ailleacht Agreed! amazing!
jaynesinflight 21 hours ago
Am I right in thinking this might be from the Martin Hannett mixes? Anyone know? It just sounds far too 'post Joy Division' to my ears to be from 1980 or 1979. Maybe its a mix from later in Hannets life?
seanreillyireland 1 year ago 4
@seanreillyireland This was recorded in 1978 for an album they aborted. That's all I know mate.
guyfromnewcastle 1 year ago 7
@seanreillyireland I can tell you that this is not the original No Love Lost recorded by Warsaw... or the re-recorded version of Joy Division. This must be, as you said, a Martin Hannett mix.
novamasterking 8 months ago
So damn RAW !
vintagezigg 1 year ago 19
This may be my favourite version yet. Thanks for sharing!!!
cherrymaryx 1 year ago 4
GREAT!!!!
watchtower183 1 year ago 4