What I think people are missing is that while her voice may not be perfect live, she puts passion into her vocals. Look at her sing! Look at her face. She feels the lyrics, and knows the pain the draw. That, to me, is what makes her voice so beautiful, flaws or not. She takes that pain and lets it color her words.
@Ninitos1 well i have the opinion that the word can't is actually two words(can not),so you have 4 words she can not sing,i have 7 and a mark for you:what the fuck are you talking about?
@King19962000 the truth.she can't fuckin sing.She is overated.Period.I wouldn't pay more than 10 euros to see THAT.Again,their studio albums are GREAT and i do enjoy them...but live....no.....
@Ninitos1 well i enjoy them but to be honest i prefer the old lives of amy,i think amy can sing live betten than this for example(although again i think it's good just not as good as her first lives).and again it's just what my opinion
@King19962000 All i am saying is i listen to evanescence studio albums and then this and this has nothing to do with what she appears to be in studio tracks...which means she tunes her voice ALOT and she cant even reach the minimum of expectations...she writes difficult vocals and she cant sing them.Thats my point.
surely she can't be this bad at live performances? i'm not an evanescence fan or anything (i just happen to like a few of their tracks,this particular one being on top of that list) so i haven't seen each and every one of their live shows but this is just bad :/
@t3hs1aCk3r Noo!! she is never this bad at live performance!!! She most of the times sounds same as the studio except a few performance where she was sick!!!!
@ffacfreak I really havent found a SINGLE live video that she performs as good as you describe.Can you please link me ONE of them?I think Amy is a wonderful songwriter but she is using too much backing vocals tracks and she makes the mistake (imo) to use them live as well...Set aside that,she really cant sing as she would like to,thts a fact.Studio albums,i enjoy them 100%,i wouldnt pay to see live.
@ffacfreak I really love her voice.She can't perform live.That was my point.She screws up.I would not pay to see Evanescence live cause i simply don't enjoy Amy's voice on live shows.
@PurplyStripes She has to jump around, she get's tired, she headbangs plenty, and she has been singing for a long time. Goodness, she can't be perfect.
Live in Much is a better version in my opinion, I also prefer the Origin version from this song. Well, no matter where it is, this song is always awesome *-*
@Amorettaflower excuse me but the best version of Imaginary is the one they played at the Hammerstein Ballroom. I think you won't find it on youtube, you'll have to download it from Evanescencewebsite. it's amazing. highly recommended!
@Amorettaflower Oh, wait it is here! The best version EVER of Imaginary is this one: youtube com/watch?v=Baxz4z6kN4s ! I think it's awesome and it's better than the Live in Much version, and it's even better than this version!
Rice Soul- You prefer HIP HOP and R&B.... reeeeally? Compared to this??? Why do most people alive have no clue what REAL music is? Music is a marriage of emotion, melody, people skilled in playing instruments, and a vocalist who can really sing! Which includes someone with multiple octaves and range and who can keep a good pitch.
Amy Lee is such a singer who just bleeds emotion in her songs... you can really feel the music deep within you. Most songs had qualities like that long ago but only a handful of groups around now possess it... and Amy Lee is definitely one of the top contenders.
The rest of her band are very talented but their look needs to change. They don't even match her style at all and the drummer just looks like a wannabe rapper. (ugh!) They should go really full goth with dark renaissance type costumes and better stage props like a sinister looking gothic graveyard for instance with dead wilting trees, leaves on the ground, huge old looking stone and iron crosses all around them. Also a fog machine with lights turning the fog different eerie colors.
And in the background could be a huge screen projecting different scenes as they play various songs as well. That's how I would like to see this band progress. They are doing awesome right now but I think changes like this would make them even better!!
I had an Evanescence phase about 2 years ago and I switched to Hip-Hop and R&B type songs now. Just last November, I went to a Chris Brown concert. As you know or can possibly imagine, Evanescence's and Chris Brown's music are QUITE different, but it seemed easy to "rock out" at Chris Brown's concert, if you know what I mean. Honestly, not to hate or anything, but I think Evanescence's songs are kind of depressing... Out of curiosity, how exactly do people enjoy them at a concert?
@RiceSoul not all of their songs are depressing but some of them are...but you have to admit they're so beautiful and amazing at the same time... its kinda hard not to listen to their songs and enjoy them...even though they can be depressing at times.. =)
I was them live a few years back and I've gotta say, judging from my own experience and what recordings I've seen, whereas Amy Lee puts on an amazing show she should concentrate mote on her vocals than twirling around on stage. Amazing show nonetheless. Just thought I'd voice my opinion. Love them.
Am I the only one who saw pikachu on top of the speakers? 3:16 to see.
Cosmo0819 6 days ago
What I think people are missing is that while her voice may not be perfect live, she puts passion into her vocals. Look at her sing! Look at her face. She feels the lyrics, and knows the pain the draw. That, to me, is what makes her voice so beautiful, flaws or not. She takes that pain and lets it color her words.
Lunara13 1 month ago
Lol I love hip hop and rap but rock is awsome as well!!
2pkjs1351 1 month ago
Thumbs up uf you miss rocky, jonh and ben moody
MissRitaLee 3 months ago
I praise her \m/_(O.O)_\m/
xKellyPuNkx 3 months ago
Beautiful Song
leticiasc97 4 months ago
Flawless
juanpomm94 4 months ago
<3
Thexpumazoxrock 6 months ago
this si one of her wordt lives, but her haunted live is SICK
ihazmadskills 7 months ago
3 words.she cant sing.
Ninitos1 7 months ago
@Ninitos1 well i have the opinion that the word can't is actually two words(can not),so you have 4 words she can not sing,i have 7 and a mark for you:what the fuck are you talking about?
King19962000 7 months ago
@King19962000 the truth.she can't fuckin sing.She is overated.Period.I wouldn't pay more than 10 euros to see THAT.Again,their studio albums are GREAT and i do enjoy them...but live....no.....
Ninitos1 7 months ago
@Ninitos1 well i enjoy them but to be honest i prefer the old lives of amy,i think amy can sing live betten than this for example(although again i think it's good just not as good as her first lives).and again it's just what my opinion
King19962000 7 months ago
@King19962000 All i am saying is i listen to evanescence studio albums and then this and this has nothing to do with what she appears to be in studio tracks...which means she tunes her voice ALOT and she cant even reach the minimum of expectations...she writes difficult vocals and she cant sing them.Thats my point.
Ninitos1 7 months ago
@Ninitos1 I agree dude
misscharliebrown121 7 months ago
@Ninitos1 I'd like to see you sing and jump around the stage like she does.
ivanaNika15 4 months ago
@ivanaNika15 i cant do that.If she wants to jump around AND sing but the outcome is horrible,then dont do it.Simple as that.
Ninitos1 4 months ago
@Ninitos1 If you don't like it then don't listen to her.
ivanaNika15 4 months ago
@ivanaNika15 I would never pay to see them live.I love their studio work though.
Ninitos1 4 months ago
surely she can't be this bad at live performances? i'm not an evanescence fan or anything (i just happen to like a few of their tracks,this particular one being on top of that list) so i haven't seen each and every one of their live shows but this is just bad :/
t3hs1aCk3r 9 months ago
@t3hs1aCk3r Noo!! she is never this bad at live performance!!! She most of the times sounds same as the studio except a few performance where she was sick!!!!
ffacfreak 9 months ago
@ffacfreak I really havent found a SINGLE live video that she performs as good as you describe.Can you please link me ONE of them?I think Amy is a wonderful songwriter but she is using too much backing vocals tracks and she makes the mistake (imo) to use them live as well...Set aside that,she really cant sing as she would like to,thts a fact.Studio albums,i enjoy them 100%,i wouldnt pay to see live.
Ninitos1 7 months ago
@Ninitos1 she is amazing in most of her lives.her singing techniques are bad but dont say she doesnt has an amazing voice
ffacfreak 7 months ago
@ffacfreak I really love her voice.She can't perform live.That was my point.She screws up.I would not pay to see Evanescence live cause i simply don't enjoy Amy's voice on live shows.
Ninitos1 7 months ago
Half of it was out of tune, but still impressive
Alexberryscarylovee 9 months ago
Sounds so different from the album version... Half of it was out of tune, but still impressive
Alexberryscarylovee 9 months ago
The dress. *_*
Sacrificechen 10 months ago
I have come to realize that evanescence uses lots of biblical passages in their songs, which makes their lyrics more interesting !
Evanescence rules this decade of gothic metal !
havidian 11 months ago
Is it,um, bad...?
(sorry if you get mad)
That I can sing this better than she did here?
PurplyStripes 11 months ago
@PurplyStripes She's been singing for 3 and a half hours.... What do u think ur voice would do if u had to sing for that long
BesttotheFriends 10 months ago
@PurplyStripes She has to jump around, she get's tired, she headbangs plenty, and she has been singing for a long time. Goodness, she can't be perfect.
gloomyxcookie 10 months ago
I agree.
PurplyStripes 11 months ago
not her best
brokenbloodedwings 11 months ago
3:18 omg pikachu is an evanescence fan!
dragonpaw101 11 months ago
awesomenessnessnesssssssss
dragonpaw101 11 months ago
A M A Z I N G !
CarlaRockPrinz 1 year ago
I think the version live in paris is the best live but they rock my world anyhow ^.^
BiancaRosalie 1 year ago
Perfect...
tyzet4ever 1 year ago 5
Comment removed
SHARON35248 1 year ago
Comment removed
dragonpaw101 1 year ago
Comment removed
dragonpaw101 1 year ago
this is one of those songs shes gotta plan for early in the concert you can tell it takes alot out of her to do this song
bluedevil43055 1 year ago
Live in Much is a better version in my opinion, I also prefer the Origin version from this song. Well, no matter where it is, this song is always awesome *-*
Amorettaflower 1 year ago
@Amorettaflower excuse me but the best version of Imaginary is the one they played at the Hammerstein Ballroom. I think you won't find it on youtube, you'll have to download it from Evanescencewebsite. it's amazing. highly recommended!
evanescence9314 11 months ago
@Amorettaflower Oh, wait it is here! The best version EVER of Imaginary is this one: youtube com/watch?v=Baxz4z6kN4s ! I think it's awesome and it's better than the Live in Much version, and it's even better than this version!
evanescence9314 11 months ago
My favorite song from evanescence! So glad to find this on Youtube...and the live version at that.
KILLMOUNT 1 year ago
And some people say that they are pop... -.-
mamioca 1 year ago 3
@mamioca thats worse than calling em emo..everytime somebody says that, ill do an epic facepalm
pu3nadira 1 year ago 3
@pu3nadira well dont forget that pop is the stupidest, broadest term in music. essentially it just means people like it lol
Quinn05 1 year ago 2
@Quinn05 pop is a generic term used to refer to any form of music a large number of people like,but it is also a musical genre.
13fanboi 10 months ago
@mamioca Evanescence? Pop? Those People Need To Like...Get Their Ears Checked or Something
EvFanForever131 1 year ago 5
Amy Lee is my freakin' hero <3
watchcloudspassmeby 1 year ago
This song completely describes me... I mean, I LOVE MY ROOM!!!
PrinceOblivion 1 year ago
She is such a goddess! This is so damn good!
sakuralaura2 1 year ago
Rice Soul- You prefer HIP HOP and R&B.... reeeeally? Compared to this??? Why do most people alive have no clue what REAL music is? Music is a marriage of emotion, melody, people skilled in playing instruments, and a vocalist who can really sing! Which includes someone with multiple octaves and range and who can keep a good pitch.
vicctorknight 1 year ago 11
Amy Lee is such a singer who just bleeds emotion in her songs... you can really feel the music deep within you. Most songs had qualities like that long ago but only a handful of groups around now possess it... and Amy Lee is definitely one of the top contenders.
vicctorknight 1 year ago 6
The rest of her band are very talented but their look needs to change. They don't even match her style at all and the drummer just looks like a wannabe rapper. (ugh!) They should go really full goth with dark renaissance type costumes and better stage props like a sinister looking gothic graveyard for instance with dead wilting trees, leaves on the ground, huge old looking stone and iron crosses all around them. Also a fog machine with lights turning the fog different eerie colors.
vicctorknight 1 year ago
And in the background could be a huge screen projecting different scenes as they play various songs as well. That's how I would like to see this band progress. They are doing awesome right now but I think changes like this would make them even better!!
vicctorknight 1 year ago
my favorite song by evanescence thanks for uploading this is deffinatly a like / thumbs up(:
jessygirl111000 1 year ago
I had an Evanescence phase about 2 years ago and I switched to Hip-Hop and R&B type songs now. Just last November, I went to a Chris Brown concert. As you know or can possibly imagine, Evanescence's and Chris Brown's music are QUITE different, but it seemed easy to "rock out" at Chris Brown's concert, if you know what I mean. Honestly, not to hate or anything, but I think Evanescence's songs are kind of depressing... Out of curiosity, how exactly do people enjoy them at a concert?
RiceSoul 1 year ago
@RiceSoul Wow you obviously don't know what music actually you have issues...you have issues
ThePrincessSisi 1 year ago
@RiceSoul not all of their songs are depressing but some of them are...but you have to admit they're so beautiful and amazing at the same time... its kinda hard not to listen to their songs and enjoy them...even though they can be depressing at times.. =)
MegaParamoreAddict 1 year ago 3
@RiceSoul Wooow.....U R Pissin Off A LOT of EvFans Right Now....Go Fuck A Duck Girly Cuz U Dont No Rock Music
EvFanForever131 1 year ago
can i get this on dvd ??
wtwh1 1 year ago
This is so awesome! Best live Imaginary performance ever! :D
DistractedFirefly 1 year ago
One of my favourite songs and very well sung, really...Loved it...Very much like the real thing...
yasirbhojani 1 year ago
THE BEST BAND IN THE WORLD
Amy Lee has an amazing voice <3
dannyroks66 1 year ago
I was them live a few years back and I've gotta say, judging from my own experience and what recordings I've seen, whereas Amy Lee puts on an amazing show she should concentrate mote on her vocals than twirling around on stage. Amazing show nonetheless. Just thought I'd voice my opinion. Love them.
rawrrcupcakeface 2 years ago
Get some autotune on that shit.
smashingpumpkin1986 2 years ago
Evanescence is the best, i can't wait for the new album!!!
tuxedo1549 2 years ago 4
Amy Lee has the voice of an angel.
ProudSpeakerofWhale 2 years ago 11
@ProudSpeakerofWhale so true....she's so beautiful
sfnpkgalati 2 years ago
@deaglea
more than half of the words you used i did not and most likely do not want to understand
i am narrowminded and unwilling to look into conspiracy theories, you can call me dim but do such elsewhere and not on an evanescence video.
oder b1g wurdz hert mah eerz D:
sharki9876 2 years ago 2
This has been flagged as spam show
Man this is the only good song that ever came out of this band and she frigging butchered it up with her excessive wailing and moaning
SeaKitten00 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
go die. listen to your dog vomit metal and rap.
fail
sharki9876 2 years ago
@SeaKitten00 wtf......if you dont like her or the band DONT LISTEN TO THEM.. =D
MegaParamoreAddict 1 year ago
looooooove this song
arianeh2 2 years ago 17
amy is soo cute x)
sharki9876 2 years ago 3
This has been flagged as spam show
Good group but kinda "soft".
Areldrich 2 years ago
sorry evanescence doesn't do death metal and "sick riffs".. we're more for the meaning in the lyrics and the sheer beauty of her singing
sharki9876 2 years ago 13
@sharki9876 Don't generalize death metal. ever heard of melodic death metal? some of the prettiest shit i've ever heard
froggyoathwearsprada 3 months ago
@froggyoathwearsprada lmfao rn
100NiggaWatts 3 months ago
I love this song! I esp. love how she sings the beginning of this song as well! Love Evanescence!!! =)
void15 2 years ago 11
This comment has received too many negative votes show
not great energy. maybe amy but none of the others
jamiepoultonadult 2 years ago
fuckin awesome!!!!
jimbo222000 2 years ago 7
one of the most epic songs in history. this would have to be my theme song.
rimbaud521 2 years ago 82
This has been flagged as spam show
I love Amy Lee, but i don't think she did very good in this vid...=[
RiseAgainstOne 2 years ago
I like when Rocky does the drumming in the keyboard part...he did it when they played here, it was awesome.
lumen1012 2 years ago 6
evanescence can put on quite a show! i love them! OMG! best band ever...in my opinion <33
jessica29406 2 years ago 61
agreed!
Never disappointed with them. Every song is amazing.
shadowbloo3000 2 years ago 11
right no other rock singer can do that...
haroulisevanescence 2 years ago 7
she is the only singer that can actually put the high note with rock into a nice clasicel then put it back up again
margaretandlee 2 years ago 7
I'm in love with this song.
MelodicIllusion 3 years ago 5
she's amazing!
divassssssssss 3 years ago 8
evanescence for ever! \,,/ !
MusiiicTube 3 years ago 7
coooooooooooool
fmlnorte 3 years ago 5