I'm still unbelievably pissed that they made this scene so short in the film. Why bother casting the actors who played young Lupin and Wormtail if we only see them in the background, and why cast young Lily when you complletely drop the scene where she tells James off?????????????
I think Snape was a better person than Snape. Snape's treatment of certain students was outright horrible and inexcusable, but at least his motivations were understandable. What was James motivation for bullying snape? He was in a different house. The period between the 'Mudblood' incident and Snape joining Dumbledore was Snape at his worst, whilst James supposedly 'grew up'. And who said he 'grew up'? Sirius, James BEST MATE.
@daleksvscybermen And considering that Sirius's idea of growing up means being outright cruel to Kreacher, what must James have been like? I do think that Snape did somewhat care for Harry, but did his best not to show it.
@daleksvscybermen James was also 15 years old when he bullied Snape. His bullying Snape isn't the true focus of the incident anyway, the incident is significant to Snape for encompassing all the pain of his life in one example, and significant to Harry because he could no longer view his dead father as perfect. It demonstrated James' flawed humanity for its own sake.
I wish they had showed the whole part where James hex Snape and then Lily comes and stops him... And then Snape calls her a 'Mudblood' because it seemed odd that Lily stopped James from hexing him, but even thought that inside he loves her! :) <3
@maybriri haha okay, James was kind of a bully to snape, though. Like out of nowhere, to impress Lily he would like jinx Snape, which is a bit of a douchey move. But thats just my opinion :)
What a knob Harry's dad is! He'd better be fucking proud of his asshole of a parent! I'd rather fucking have Snape as a father and as anyone who is familiar with the series will know, that is saying a fucking lot!
@TsoLan1 James wasn't that bad. Sure, James was kinda a bully but Snape wasn't innocent. Snape would hex James at every chance he got. James was 15 but eventually grew up. Snape never did and when he became a teacher he bullied his students.
@Zoey4223 I'm 15 now and no one I know would behave like that. Also Snape probably only bullied students because of the bad things that had happened to him. Which is understandable, but still not right. Even so James is a wanker.
@Yuna425 That's one thing but Snape didn't do that. He bullied Neville so badly that he became the thing that Neville was most afraid of. He took it too far.
@maybriri nah James was also portrayed as a douche in the books. he's supposed to be that way, thats one of the legitimate reasons why Snape disliked Harry so much, because he thought that Harry was as bad as his father.
Also, people honestly shouldn't bash James so much. At -worst,- he was a spoiled, arrogant git who liked to pants Severus to give Sirius a sexual thrill or whatever the hell it was in the book.
Hardcore Snape fans need to chill the fuck out and focus on some read villains, like Rick Perry.
@deadrabbit30 let's look at some of the things James did:
got into Gryffindor, became an animagus to comfort his werewolf friend 1 night a month, bullied people around when he was 15 years old, matured and stopped bullying people, took in his best friend when he ran away, became Head Boy, joined an Order that fought in a war that he could’ve easily stayed out of, defied Voldemort 3 times, married Lily and had a child with her, died protecting both of them.
And also - I don't care about people who did not see the last 2 movies - Sanpe was fallen for LILY! He loved her and the person who made made fun of him/bullied him married her!
@Leatherlyy Yeah, sure he's important for the whole story but I always experienced him as a very bigheaded character. And since I'm a big fan of snape, I just couldn't forgive James for what he did to him when they were in school, even though he saved him.And I just don't like the way he appears, even though he changed when he's older.
@kol634 Idk.. of course if there hadn't been james there hadn't been harry and without harry the whole story wouldn't exist but I just hate this jerk so so much :DD
James was not a jerk. Snape turned out to be a good guy but at first he wanted to become a death eater and join Voldemort and James knew it and hated him for it. James was loyal to Dumbledore and him and Sirius were typical rabble-rousers but they grew out of that into really great wizards. Not to say I don't like Snape but damn, James had the best reasons to embarrass him.
Not to mention when they first meet Snape is the one who insults James first. So it's on both of them.
And tailedmalfoy in book 6.I think the filmakers really failed to bring these books to life with the exeption of the first two movies because the books they were based on were the shortest of the series.Although there was a small bit taken out from the 1st two movies and things switched around,like no peeves ,harry without green eyes.By the time of the fourth movie they had to leave out a lot because the book was so big.I know most people probably liked the movies but I still say the books more.
This scene went hand in hand with the princes tale but for some reason the filmakers decided to mutilate the scenes.And the scene in deathly hallows 2 where snape is holding dead lily is nowhere in the book.The princes tale in the movie has no real emotional impact much like the death of dobby has no emotional impact because dobby wasn't in harry potter 4 5 or 6 films.In the books dobby supplied harry with the gillyweed,told harry about the room of requirement in book 5.
@xmileycyrusfanx100 i have to stop you at spying on the order. he was a spy for dumbledore and did anything for him because he was in love with Lily. he even protected Harry but was cruel to him at the same time. snape is a very complex character he saw James in Harry but also found Lily in him to"You have your mothers eyes"
You guys got to be seriously kidding me. I'm surprised with the like bars. Do you actually think the ending was an extended scene? THERE THE DAMN SCENES FROM THE FILM SKY HIGH!
James and Snape were both good people just in different ways. Snape with his love for Lily and bravery to do what Lily would of wanted him to do. James because he sacrificed himself so Lily and harry could get away from Voldermort. Everyone has flaws but love conquers all.
@LIGHTNINGTHIF It's just Harry. People had told him all his life that James was wonderful like you would tell any child that lost a parent. Not speaking ill of the dead. He's so young that no one wanted to tell him the truth. That James was a bully to Snape. Even Snape wouldn't tell Harry the truth directly. Would Harry have believed it? No. So he went on beliving that his father was a hero when in reality James was a bully. Harry took after his mother. Lily's love changed James in time.
James is not a bad person, and neither is Snape. Given certain circumstances, I think Lily would have fallen for Snape over Potter. But she didn't, because James 'grew up' and stopped being a prick when he was seventeen. He learned, and she fell in love with him for that. Snape learned that when he was on his death bed, which was far too late. That's why she picked James over Snape - she fell in love with him first. James deserves more credit. He's not as bad a bloke as everyone thinks.
Look! JK Approved everything they did in the movie, so if she didn't want the movies to be EXACTLY like the books that that should be fine! I think they did a brilliant job with the movies. If all you have to say is horrid things about the movies and all the hard work they did, why are you even watching this? Go do something else. We came here to watch an extended clip from the movie, because we enjoy it, stop ruining it!!
okay i have to say that most hp fans have read the books and certain scenes are just an excuse for people to show others that they know more about the hp story than others.....which they really don't......thats what pisses me off
oh my god who cares if its wrong!? its just a movie. this is why some (not all) hp fans are annoying........ i mean, the harry potter movies/books are great and all...... but just enjoy them rather than point out precisely what is wrong and what should be and what should be. not every detail matters..... no offense to hp fans. (im one too) it just bothers me when people blow things out of proportion.
Anyway, I wish J.K. Rowling would write an entire book on just James and Lily's time at Hogwarts. It would have Sirius, Snape, Remus, Peter, etc. I think it would be so awesome!
After being bullied for a good 10 years of my life just because of having a certain opinion and/or by the way I look, I can relate with Snape. Maybe personal experience has something to do to the contribution with my utter hatred and loathing of James, but who knows. Snape might have had his issues, but at least he didn't go around hexing people 'just because he could'. James represents every enemy I've had and I really, strongly, truly, hate his character w/ every fiber in my being. ^.^
@Dancingwithotters Actually, this was a sharing of opinion. Never said anything bad about him, just said I despise his character. Not trying to fight with anyone or anything. So thank you for your judgmental and equally untrue statement.
@Dancingwithotters LOL, you're really funny! Your stupidity is actually quite entertaining. This is actually not effecting me whatsoever. I have no emotional attachment to any of the unwitty comments you're making. You actually kind of remind me a lot of James. Arrogant and egotistical. Good on you! xD
@Dancingwithotters Not so fun anymore, you're not making any good argumentative points whatsoever. You're new at this, eh? Spelling and grammar obviously lacking as well. Go back to school, hypocrite. To save you from anymore self-embarrassment, I'm going to stop replying. Goodbye :]
@Dancingwithotters this is really funny. great Star Wars reference. oh, and xtracreative, btw, Snape isn't really the amazing guy everyone made him out to be.
1. He did Dark Arts in school
2. He became a Death Eater
3. He called Lily a mudblood when she was trying to help him
4. He stole from Petunia, causing Lily and Petunia's poor relationship
Don't come to conclusions without researching your text. Reread Harry Potter, and you'll see.
@Dancingwithotters Technically, he could only bully that 11 year old boy for one year, (then he would be twelve, thirteen, fourteen...) Haha, but yes, we see your point.
@PotterGal394 you are a piece of shit for sticking up for the troll he is just trying to get on peoples nerves and you give him props prepare to be flamed for now on bitch. None of what you say is actually bad so you fail again you sorry piece of shit.
@Dancingwithotters you sound like a fucking bully you fucking bitch.don't get all high mighty when you are a bitch and trying to make fun of someone for being bullied with your lame sarcastic bitch ass posts. I'll roast you some more but I want to hear one of your little bitch posts so I can get a little laugh at a little bitch ass coward that can't say what he feels. So fuck you if you don't get I don't like you and I am insulting you so why don't you try telling me something a we all don't kno
@MyGreatestFailure To be fair, JK did that a lot to them :P 'Oh, Dobby, he's gone and been a free elf now :) He only comes round to give them free food.... wait, he did WHAT NOW?!' I think at points the producers regret not doing the books scene by scene simply because she brings literally every minute detail possible back to the final :P
sigh* ppl plz READ the books before u comment and make an ass our of urself snape wasnt exacttly innocent ok jus read the dam book im a potter fan to the bone and i get rlly pissed off wen ppl who dont no anything jus comment and change the meanin of the books
I dunno about people that like Snape better than James or vice-versa, but what JK Rowling was trying to show here is that Snape wasn't a complete arse, and that James wasn't a complete saint, and that both men for some strange reason, turned out for the better people because of Lily Evans.
This is why the movies are stupid. Harry was ALLOWED to defend himself in the Occlumency lessons and when he managed to use Protego on Snape, yes he was mad, but he got over it and they continued their lessons. He kicked Harry out when he saw this memory - which is shorter and missing the point as Lily isn't even in it - when Harry went into his pensieve when he wasn't there to stop him. These movies miss alot then morons try and act like they know what they're talking about and argue.
@mikeortiz410 lol newwb he kicked harry out cuz if he would have done it again he might have seen some stuff about liliy and that wasnt the itme to happen or else the other upcoming movies where very confusing and harry would have be more around snape cuz he knew his mother very well ...
I have to admit, I think they should have played up Lily and Snapes relationship a little, see that they know each other already. My brother was rather shocked in DH part 2 where suddenly Snjape is in love with Lily with practially no clues... luckily I've read the books so I already knew lol.
@emoellieroks problem is, is that when this movie was made, it was made before the books were finish so the directors never thought anything of it.....though i am glad they made the movies and everything, sometimes I wished they waited until the books were over so they wouldn't leave out anything important =/
you just don't get snape. he protected them from voldemort. he did what he has to do even though he's putting his life on the line. and yes, he did so many wrong decisions but it's all because of hatred and memories of him with the marauders. however, james was a bully.but didn't you realize that james only changed because he wants lily to like him,as you all know lily gest hurt if her bestfriend been bullied by those kids. he stop bullying severus because its her bestfriend. lily fell w/ james
@barroluna08 [continuation] because of that, and then severus is jealous ofcourse, so while he's free from them, he masters dark arts and joined death eaters just to impress lily, but, lily didn't want death eaters so he failed again. btw, the time severus was being bullied, lily tried to help him but b'coz of anger and humiliation infront of everyone, he called lily a "mudblood" and thats the end of their friendship. he get depressed and started doing dark things. JUST SO YOU KNOW :)
All in all, Snape an innocent schoolboy? James a bully? Please. If anything the worst that can be said about James is that he was "slightly arrogant" . And the best spin you can give Snape is that he's more of a Anti-Hero rather than a "tragic figure"
@Publicenemy85 wow you are stupid you made 4 paragraphs and not one thing said anything that Snape did was bad and anything James did good. So what if he liked Dark arts that is the best way to get back at bitch ass bullies like James. I would join Voldemort too if the so called "good side" put me in trees and embarassed me infront of the girl I loved. Everything you said is stupid and doesn't prove anything.
4. Lilly didn't end her friendship with Snape only because he called her a mudblood, as shown in Snape's memory it was his love of the dark arts, he idiolizing of Voldermort and in Lilly's words "Hatred for my kind" meaning muggle borns. It should also be noted that when Snape asked Voldermort to spare her life he showed no regard for her husband and child. Something even Dumbledore uncharacteristically lashed at him for "YOU DISGUST ME!"
@Publicenemy85 Your comments are so right!Don't get me wrong I like Snape but I'm sick of people passing all the hatred onto James...he's one of my favorite characters and like all the character's that Jo wrote he wasn't perfect-but he got better.If anything Snape was a bigger bully because he carried his grudge with him the rest of his life and picked on the son of the man he hated even though the child did nothing wrong.I love Snape but he was a bigger bully.Thank you.
(Continued) 3. James Joined the Order of the Phoenix after leaving Hogwarts. We can only imagine what Snape did during his time as a death eater. And despite his loathing for Snape he STILL saved his life in the shrieking shack 4. Adult Lives: James sacrificed himself for his family, financially supported Lupin as he couldn't get a job as a werewolf. And Loathed the dark arts. Snape: Showed favoritism, verbally abused his students, and tormented Harry simply for the life he never had. Pathetic!
This is precisely why I hate movies baased on books. So many important details are left out that people tend to get the wrong idea. Here are a few facts 1) Snape wasn't exactly the innocent schoolboy. It was noted that he hexed James whenever he had the chance as well. Was in love with the dark arts. Hung around with soon to be deatheaters 2) James "deflated" his head, enough for Lilly to fall in love with him and dumbledore to apoint him head boy. Snape...became a death eater.
@Publicenemy85 Perhaps, but the movie adaptation can still be enjoyable and in fact can become its own alternate reality/interpretation of the original source material.
@Publicenemy85......i'd say its really from your own perspective........i think the movies portrayed the books better than its ever been done before.......the only things ever to piss me off is the centourless final battle and the thing that pisses most people off......'peeves'
@ATLSportsGirl i do two , i love all the character , i love james and snape , and sirius , and the others and im proud to love them , because loving james better then loving the twilight characters ... lol .
Ok everyone James was a great man yes he was an ass for no reason but I believe he was jealous of snape because lily in skool hated him but was good friends with Severus!!! Jealousy makes us do stupid things!!! I believe if he was alive and saw eat Severus has done for his son he wud apologize!! And Severus isn't at fault either obviously he was fueled by anger he was mad and thought everyone wud think of him as a coward for needing a girls help though tht doesn't excuse wat he said he regrets
@Haleybaby456 i agree with you,jk rowling want us to learn from james personality that we have to change to be good persons,and that love change people,and that mabey some parents was bad but they changed for us,just like sirius,and james,and even lupin,exp:my father was a such troublemker when he was 15 and he changed for us he work in the police and he sucrfice himself everyday for us,when i only remember james i remember my father , all what we have to know about them that they love us.
@13Elementguy well, t'ill that i was respecting snape , so i don't get why you love the fucking snape . well, don't forget that snape is the biggest piece of shit bully in the world of harry potter.mabey that kind of LEGENDRY LOVE FOR LILY makes you blind.cause the first ever bully was snape,bullying all the houses exept slytherin , spying on the order of pheonix,hating harry for no reason, a man in 30 doing all that comparing to a boy in 15,who's the real bully now,fuck you.thnx .
@xmileycyrusfanx100 I believe you haven't read all of the Harry Potter books. Even if you did, you certainly did not understand Snape. He's a bully but one who would do anything to protect his loved ones. Can't you tell that he did all he could to protect Harry? Ugh, there's no point in explaining this to you because you're too stupid to understand this simple fact.
@igoteggigotchicken11 i didn't say anything about his legendary love for lily,i respect snape the lover only,and i have read all the books,and i know what he did to protect harry,and one of my favorite chapter is the prince tale,and exuse me,i'm not stupid,were all harry potter fans here ,the stupids are twilight fans,cause they didn't choose the hp books to read,oh i forgeot there's no point in explaining this to you because you're too stupid to understand this simple fact
@xmileycyrusfanx100 Snape spied on the Order? Snape hates Harry? Umm, excuse me, but that was all of your sayings. He may have been a bully but he still protect those that are close to him. Btw, I wasn't talking just about his love for Lily. As I said 2 sentences before, he still protects those who are close to him. Who cares about how stupid Twilight fans are as long as they're not a hater.
@igoteggigotchicken11 now listing to me SNAPElittleFAN, first watch this vid, jk rowling tells us about the spy snape /watch?v=mBLqWffUSWI, two if snape didn't hate harry why he bullying him all the time, oh, he just wants revenge for his past with harry's father, he protect harry only because his lily's son, if he wasn't he ouldn't care about him, as you can see in the vid i gaved you, so have a nice day watching what jk rowling said about your love, and ultimate hero .
@xmileycyrusfanx100 Snape hates Harry but cares for him at the same time. As you said, he only protected him because he was Lily's son. At the end of the day, Snape is still a good guy at some point. I'm a Snape lover just because I defend him? You know, jumping to conclusions isn't good. It can get you into big trouble
I always thought that harry said "POTATO" instead of protego until I read the book lol
Calamityyyyyyy 8 hours ago
Also his actions in the book (calling her a mudblood) is the main reason why these actions happened in the first.
BlueAngelLe012 1 day ago
I'm still unbelievably pissed that they made this scene so short in the film. Why bother casting the actors who played young Lupin and Wormtail if we only see them in the background, and why cast young Lily when you complletely drop the scene where she tells James off?????????????
ladycplum 1 day ago
I love the actor who played James in this scene <3 He looks exactley how I imagined him in the books!
cattledogandstaffy 2 days ago
snape is awesome and cool we need to respect snivillus oops severus
BlackMountain150 4 days ago 2
I think Snape was a better person than Snape. Snape's treatment of certain students was outright horrible and inexcusable, but at least his motivations were understandable. What was James motivation for bullying snape? He was in a different house. The period between the 'Mudblood' incident and Snape joining Dumbledore was Snape at his worst, whilst James supposedly 'grew up'. And who said he 'grew up'? Sirius, James BEST MATE.
daleksvscybermen 5 days ago
@daleksvscybermen And considering that Sirius's idea of growing up means being outright cruel to Kreacher, what must James have been like? I do think that Snape did somewhat care for Harry, but did his best not to show it.
daleksvscybermen 5 days ago
@daleksvscybermen James was also 15 years old when he bullied Snape. His bullying Snape isn't the true focus of the incident anyway, the incident is significant to Snape for encompassing all the pain of his life in one example, and significant to Harry because he could no longer view his dead father as perfect. It demonstrated James' flawed humanity for its own sake.
PaulineTriage 3 days ago
Thats so cute i love it snapes my fave hp character
4LunaLovegood 1 week ago
This is quite good? :L <3
mrsacardle 1 week ago
I came here expecting to see Snape naked…
ApplesRubbish 1 week ago
I wish they had showed the whole part where James hex Snape and then Lily comes and stops him... And then Snape calls her a 'Mudblood' because it seemed odd that Lily stopped James from hexing him, but even thought that inside he loves her! :) <3
anime20lover 1 week ago
james was really a swine in the beggining!!! at last he became a better person later!! r.i.p.
nisiriti 2 weeks ago
@maybriri haha okay, James was kind of a bully to snape, though. Like out of nowhere, to impress Lily he would like jinx Snape, which is a bit of a douchey move. But thats just my opinion :)
123onlyforyou 2 weeks ago
wasn't*
maybriri 2 weeks ago
What a knob Harry's dad is! He'd better be fucking proud of his asshole of a parent! I'd rather fucking have Snape as a father and as anyone who is familiar with the series will know, that is saying a fucking lot!
TsoLan1 2 weeks ago
@TsoLan1 James wasn't that bad. Sure, James was kinda a bully but Snape wasn't innocent. Snape would hex James at every chance he got. James was 15 but eventually grew up. Snape never did and when he became a teacher he bullied his students.
Zoey4223 2 weeks ago 4
@Zoey4223 I'm 15 now and no one I know would behave like that. Also Snape probably only bullied students because of the bad things that had happened to him. Which is understandable, but still not right. Even so James is a wanker.
TsoLan1 2 weeks ago 3
@Zoey4223
He is just teaching them that life is not fair.
Yuna425 1 week ago
@Yuna425 That's one thing but Snape didn't do that. He bullied Neville so badly that he became the thing that Neville was most afraid of. He took it too far.
Zoey4223 6 days ago
@maybriri nah James was also portrayed as a douche in the books. he's supposed to be that way, thats one of the legitimate reasons why Snape disliked Harry so much, because he thought that Harry was as bad as his father.
123onlyforyou 3 weeks ago
@123onlyforyou er, no, he was'nt. he and snape disliked each other a lot, but james wasn't a douche.
maybriri 2 weeks ago
Also, people honestly shouldn't bash James so much. At -worst,- he was a spoiled, arrogant git who liked to pants Severus to give Sirius a sexual thrill or whatever the hell it was in the book.
Hardcore Snape fans need to chill the fuck out and focus on some read villains, like Rick Perry.
Leatherlyy 3 weeks ago
@Leatherlyy *real villains. Heh.
Leatherlyy 3 weeks ago
did you film this with a potato?
ChewieBringsMusic 3 weeks ago
Were.dose Rose.and jack...LOL!:D
mahira57339 3 weeks ago
@kgirl998 yeah, like a 'The hobbit' of LOTR.
Just4Quick 3 weeks ago
they make james look like such an arse in the movies
the director must have been a snily shipper lol
maybriri 3 weeks ago 49
@maybriri he's not a better guy in the books..not a bit. ._.
deadrabbit30 3 weeks ago
@deadrabbit30 let's look at some of the things James did:
got into Gryffindor, became an animagus to comfort his werewolf friend 1 night a month, bullied people around when he was 15 years old, matured and stopped bullying people, took in his best friend when he ran away, became Head Boy, joined an Order that fought in a war that he could’ve easily stayed out of, defied Voldemort 3 times, married Lily and had a child with her, died protecting both of them.
what a jerk!
maybriri 3 weeks ago 40
@maybriri Oh well that's nice. .. ... I still don't like him. :D
deadrabbit30 3 weeks ago
@maybriri
And also - I don't care about people who did not see the last 2 movies - Sanpe was fallen for LILY! He loved her and the person who made made fun of him/bullied him married her!
Yuna425 1 week ago
@Yuna425 that is the biggest load of shit i have ever heard
lily can choose whoever she fucking wants to marry
and i think people tend to forget that SNAPE WAS A DEATH EATER
bloody hell
maybriri 6 days ago
@maybriri
I was actualy talking about the fact that Snape loved Lily... nothing more
Yuna425 5 days ago
@maybriri BUT... He was a double agent, more loyal to Dumbledore than Lord Voldemort.
lilmissybyebye 4 days ago
@lilmissybyebye not at the start
he was the one who told voldemort about the prophecy
maybriri 4 days ago
@deadrabbit30 What. Er, no.
Have you even read the books, or did you just watch the movies and read a few Snily fanfics? :|
Leatherlyy 3 weeks ago
@Leatherlyy yes I have read the books =.= I still don't like him.^^
deadrabbit30 3 weeks ago
@deadrabbit30 Care to elaborate? I mean, James isn't my favourite character, but he never actually did anything to deserve the hate he gets.
Leatherlyy 3 weeks ago
@Leatherlyy Yeah, sure he's important for the whole story but I always experienced him as a very bigheaded character. And since I'm a big fan of snape, I just couldn't forgive James for what he did to him when they were in school, even though he saved him.And I just don't like the way he appears, even though he changed when he's older.
deadrabbit30 3 weeks ago
@Leatherlyy sure he did, stole Lily from the love of her life! =p
oneperson2person 2 weeks ago
Ever since I read the scene in the book I hated Harry's dad! >:(
Naruhinaluv77 3 weeks ago
Ugh, I hate James. Such an idiot.
deadrabbit30 3 weeks ago
@deadrabbit30 I KNOW RIGHT? i hated him as a child, but he turn out(suprizingly) a preety good guy after all (even though it took, like ten years!)
kol634 3 weeks ago
@kol634 Idk.. of course if there hadn't been james there hadn't been harry and without harry the whole story wouldn't exist but I just hate this jerk so so much :DD
deadrabbit30 3 weeks ago
your father was a swine!
lolidk40 3 weeks ago
I love you Snape.... ;')
EmeraldAngel8 3 weeks ago
Awh Severus.. you were so misunderstood :'(
KuddlyKatie 4 weeks ago
James was not a jerk. Snape turned out to be a good guy but at first he wanted to become a death eater and join Voldemort and James knew it and hated him for it. James was loyal to Dumbledore and him and Sirius were typical rabble-rousers but they grew out of that into really great wizards. Not to say I don't like Snape but damn, James had the best reasons to embarrass him.
Not to mention when they first meet Snape is the one who insults James first. So it's on both of them.
Popfan93 4 weeks ago
This scene is absolutely awful in the movie. Amazing in the book though.
PhantomBolt 1 month ago
10 points from all houses.
sharingan510 1 month ago
And tailedmalfoy in book 6.I think the filmakers really failed to bring these books to life with the exeption of the first two movies because the books they were based on were the shortest of the series.Although there was a small bit taken out from the 1st two movies and things switched around,like no peeves ,harry without green eyes.By the time of the fourth movie they had to leave out a lot because the book was so big.I know most people probably liked the movies but I still say the books more.
AgnosticProle 1 month ago
This scene went hand in hand with the princes tale but for some reason the filmakers decided to mutilate the scenes.And the scene in deathly hallows 2 where snape is holding dead lily is nowhere in the book.The princes tale in the movie has no real emotional impact much like the death of dobby has no emotional impact because dobby wasn't in harry potter 4 5 or 6 films.In the books dobby supplied harry with the gillyweed,told harry about the room of requirement in book 5.
AgnosticProle 1 month ago
@xmileycyrusfanx100 i have to stop you at spying on the order. he was a spy for dumbledore and did anything for him because he was in love with Lily. he even protected Harry but was cruel to him at the same time. snape is a very complex character he saw James in Harry but also found Lily in him to"You have your mothers eyes"
simplymiranification 1 month ago
i agree and wow harry potter has his dad looks but his attitude is 360 degrees the opposite
xiaospirit 1 month ago
Poor Snape ;_;
Cicide76536 1 month ago
sky high REPRESENT :)
xavierulzok 1 month ago
Does Harry say 0:09 "Potato!"??
Cicide76536 1 month ago
@Cicide76536 i think he says protego or something............but it does sound like potato
leacharms101 1 month ago
@leacharms101 yeah, protego is the sheild charm, latin for mask or cover
xavierulzok 1 month ago
@Cicide76536 That's what I thought :')
GreenDayKate 1 month ago
You guys got to be seriously kidding me. I'm surprised with the like bars. Do you actually think the ending was an extended scene? THERE THE DAMN SCENES FROM THE FILM SKY HIGH!
JeffHtun 1 month ago 2
James and Snape were both good people just in different ways. Snape with his love for Lily and bravery to do what Lily would of wanted him to do. James because he sacrificed himself so Lily and harry could get away from Voldermort. Everyone has flaws but love conquers all.
luvya117 1 month ago 2
I dont get why they think james potter was so great but really he was just an asshole
LIGHTNINGTHIF 1 month ago
@LIGHTNINGTHIF It's just Harry. People had told him all his life that James was wonderful like you would tell any child that lost a parent. Not speaking ill of the dead. He's so young that no one wanted to tell him the truth. That James was a bully to Snape. Even Snape wouldn't tell Harry the truth directly. Would Harry have believed it? No. So he went on beliving that his father was a hero when in reality James was a bully. Harry took after his mother. Lily's love changed James in time.
Songsmirth 1 month ago
0:43
The moment he sees Lily's eyes.
NyxFTW 1 month ago
This should have been how the film really was.
SusanBaudelaire 1 month ago
I thought it was the kids WITH glasses that were bullied.
djchubz911 1 month ago 3
Where's the "Leave Brittany alone" guy when you need him.
ninjaheart92 2 months ago 4
Snape... mocked by everyone, lost the love of his life... why didn't he become Voldemort?
PortugalGP 2 months ago 3
wat?! y were they teaseing him?! he was hot as a teen 0.0
officalkorra 2 months ago
The last part is from SKY HIGH, THE FIRST PARTS ARE REAL.
VFKMissLizzy 2 months ago
ARE YOU ALL STUPID?
This is not an extended scene, it's from SKY HIGH!
VFKMissLizzy 2 months ago
James is not a bad person, and neither is Snape. Given certain circumstances, I think Lily would have fallen for Snape over Potter. But she didn't, because James 'grew up' and stopped being a prick when he was seventeen. He learned, and she fell in love with him for that. Snape learned that when he was on his death bed, which was far too late. That's why she picked James over Snape - she fell in love with him first. James deserves more credit. He's not as bad a bloke as everyone thinks.
Rikulicous 2 months ago 4
Snape as hot as a teen.
Saschikun 2 months ago
Great, just what he needs his worst memory extended.
Mr11tadhg 2 months ago 93
well if they made the movies exactly like the books they're be no point in watching them would there? :/
they need to change around SOME stuff, you know...
AstralBlueWolf 2 months ago
I love Sirius Black :D haha he's awesome! And James is cool too, but he is sometimes a ass :D Lily is missing in this scene
BzPKS 2 months ago
Harry's dad was an ass -.-
hannahwantcookie 2 months ago
Look! JK Approved everything they did in the movie, so if she didn't want the movies to be EXACTLY like the books that that should be fine! I think they did a brilliant job with the movies. If all you have to say is horrid things about the movies and all the hard work they did, why are you even watching this? Go do something else. We came here to watch an extended clip from the movie, because we enjoy it, stop ruining it!!
izziiha 2 months ago 2
okay i have to say that most hp fans have read the books and certain scenes are just an excuse for people to show others that they know more about the hp story than others.....which they really don't......thats what pisses me off
dot2dot67 2 months ago
oh my god who cares if its wrong!? its just a movie. this is why some (not all) hp fans are annoying........ i mean, the harry potter movies/books are great and all...... but just enjoy them rather than point out precisely what is wrong and what should be and what should be. not every detail matters..... no offense to hp fans. (im one too) it just bothers me when people blow things out of proportion.
bowlocheerios97 2 months ago
Alan Rickman AMAZING Actor
Jerseyqueens4 2 months ago
You have to admit, James is kind of a jerk. lol
Anyway, I wish J.K. Rowling would write an entire book on just James and Lily's time at Hogwarts. It would have Sirius, Snape, Remus, Peter, etc. I think it would be so awesome!
kgirl998 2 months ago 57
@kgirl998 That would be a great extension!
ggbear99 3 weeks ago
Sirius looked like that?
firefly2552025 2 months ago
Is it me or was Snape kinda Cute when he was Young ?!
warriorsel 2 months ago
i can't understrand how Rowling could accept the movis, expecially the Yate ones!
815Camilla 2 months ago
After being bullied for a good 10 years of my life just because of having a certain opinion and/or by the way I look, I can relate with Snape. Maybe personal experience has something to do to the contribution with my utter hatred and loathing of James, but who knows. Snape might have had his issues, but at least he didn't go around hexing people 'just because he could'. James represents every enemy I've had and I really, strongly, truly, hate his character w/ every fiber in my being. ^.^
xtracreative 2 months ago
@xtracreative
Good man! Fight hate with hate!
Dancingwithotters 2 months ago
@Dancingwithotters Actually, this was a sharing of opinion. Never said anything bad about him, just said I despise his character. Not trying to fight with anyone or anything. So thank you for your judgmental and equally untrue statement.
xtracreative 2 months ago
@xtracreative
Thats it son! Get into a negative downward emotional spiral! Loving it!!
Dancingwithotters 2 months ago
@Dancingwithotters LOL, you're really funny! Your stupidity is actually quite entertaining. This is actually not effecting me whatsoever. I have no emotional attachment to any of the unwitty comments you're making. You actually kind of remind me a lot of James. Arrogant and egotistical. Good on you! xD
xtracreative 2 months ago
@xtracreative
Naming calling! Obvious agression to a complete stranger! Passive agression! Score son! Shoot for the stars!
Dancingwithotters 2 months ago
@Dancingwithotters Not so fun anymore, you're not making any good argumentative points whatsoever. You're new at this, eh? Spelling and grammar obviously lacking as well. Go back to school, hypocrite. To save you from anymore self-embarrassment, I'm going to stop replying. Goodbye :]
xtracreative 2 months ago
@xtracreative
More passive agression! More insults! Dont become what you swore to destroy Anakin! It isnt how you are apart but how you are not!
Dancingwithotters 2 months ago
@Dancingwithotters this is really funny. great Star Wars reference. oh, and xtracreative, btw, Snape isn't really the amazing guy everyone made him out to be.
1. He did Dark Arts in school
2. He became a Death Eater
3. He called Lily a mudblood when she was trying to help him
4. He stole from Petunia, causing Lily and Petunia's poor relationship
Don't come to conclusions without researching your text. Reread Harry Potter, and you'll see.
PotterGal394 2 months ago
@PotterGal394
Plus, he bullied an 11 year old boy for years and years.
Dancingwithotters 2 months ago
@Dancingwithotters Technically, he could only bully that 11 year old boy for one year, (then he would be twelve, thirteen, fourteen...) Haha, but yes, we see your point.
caman5 2 months ago
@caman5
The moment I wrote that comment, I knew that someone sensible would go and correct me. But yes, thank you :)
Dancingwithotters 2 months ago
@caman5 stupidest thing on Youtube said by you congrats for being completely retarded.
13Elementguy 1 month ago
@PotterGal394 you are a piece of shit for sticking up for the troll he is just trying to get on peoples nerves and you give him props prepare to be flamed for now on bitch. None of what you say is actually bad so you fail again you sorry piece of shit.
13Elementguy 1 month ago
@13Elementguy you think im gonna be flamed? because, as of now, your comments have gotten more hate than mine and my comment is over a month old...
PotterGal394 1 month ago
@Dancingwithotters you sound like a fucking bully you fucking bitch.don't get all high mighty when you are a bitch and trying to make fun of someone for being bullied with your lame sarcastic bitch ass posts. I'll roast you some more but I want to hear one of your little bitch posts so I can get a little laugh at a little bitch ass coward that can't say what he feels. So fuck you if you don't get I don't like you and I am insulting you so why don't you try telling me something a we all don't kno
13Elementguy 1 month ago
@13Elementguy
.....Cartman?
Dancingwithotters 1 month ago
@xtracreative Amen :)
Cyberscribe100 2 months ago
I hated James Potter before it was cool.
Leatherlyy 2 months ago 4
@Leatherlyy Hating James Potter is not cool. James was the best. He was always a good person, and Snape was always horrible.
Jojodabunneh 1 month ago
"GET...OUT..." Man if I were a hogwarts student and he says that to me I'd took off running lol
GalaxyMagician 2 months ago
when does it show in the movies when snape calls lily a mudblood
knicksfan13171 2 months ago
@knicksfan13171 The wonderful producers found it unimportant for the scene............if they only knew lol
MyGreatestFailure 2 months ago
@MyGreatestFailure To be fair, JK did that a lot to them :P 'Oh, Dobby, he's gone and been a free elf now :) He only comes round to give them free food.... wait, he did WHAT NOW?!' I think at points the producers regret not doing the books scene by scene simply because she brings literally every minute detail possible back to the final :P
MrsLovett112 2 months ago
@knicksfan13171 I don't think it does.
bluerakuchan 2 months ago
From which Harry Potter is this scene from?
SargsyanA 2 months ago
@SargsyanA The Half Blood Prince.
coolarrow7 2 months ago
James wasn't Severus' worst memory ... It was how he called his Lily a mudblood ;-(
Mehlsuppe 2 months ago 7
@Mehlsuppe i agree this wasn't very well done, lily wasn't even in it
Puzzsta 2 months ago
@Mehlsuppe He would have called her a mudblood eventually, that was the way their friendship was going.
Jojodabunneh 1 month ago 2
sigh* ppl plz READ the books before u comment and make an ass our of urself snape wasnt exacttly innocent ok jus read the dam book im a potter fan to the bone and i get rlly pissed off wen ppl who dont no anything jus comment and change the meanin of the books
Thekimmyc15 2 months ago
I dunno about people that like Snape better than James or vice-versa, but what JK Rowling was trying to show here is that Snape wasn't a complete arse, and that James wasn't a complete saint, and that both men for some strange reason, turned out for the better people because of Lily Evans.
DamianAhmadi 3 months ago 20
I've NEVER liked James Potter.
NimrodOnElmStreet 3 months ago
I do like though how in the film he said, "C'mon Moony and Padfoot" because i hated how they never explained the Marauders Map.
sunshinebutter 3 months ago
This is why the movies are stupid. Harry was ALLOWED to defend himself in the Occlumency lessons and when he managed to use Protego on Snape, yes he was mad, but he got over it and they continued their lessons. He kicked Harry out when he saw this memory - which is shorter and missing the point as Lily isn't even in it - when Harry went into his pensieve when he wasn't there to stop him. These movies miss alot then morons try and act like they know what they're talking about and argue.
mikeortiz410 3 months ago 84
@mikeortiz410 lol newwb he kicked harry out cuz if he would have done it again he might have seen some stuff about liliy and that wasnt the itme to happen or else the other upcoming movies where very confusing and harry would have be more around snape cuz he knew his mother very well ...
sletzorz 1 month ago
I have to admit, I think they should have played up Lily and Snapes relationship a little, see that they know each other already. My brother was rather shocked in DH part 2 where suddenly Snjape is in love with Lily with practially no clues... luckily I've read the books so I already knew lol.
emoellieroks 3 months ago 5
@emoellieroks Yeah I agree, my sister was like that too. She was surprsied at DH2 and I had to explain it all to her lol
chaoticXmisfit 2 months ago
@emoellieroks problem is, is that when this movie was made, it was made before the books were finish so the directors never thought anything of it.....though i am glad they made the movies and everything, sometimes I wished they waited until the books were over so they wouldn't leave out anything important =/
MyGreatestFailure 2 months ago
@MyGreatestFailure Agreed
emoellieroks 2 months ago
@emoellieroks There was no "relationship" because it was completely one-sided.
Jojodabunneh 1 month ago 3
Woah guys chill out its just a book/movie. Nothing to go all rage out on...
mohammedrun 3 months ago 3
Love it better than the movies.
They could have done it better.
I mean I was hoping for the memory scene to be better, didn't explain much.
XxMoonLitNightxX1 3 months ago
They call him "Snivelous Snape" i call him "Sour Grape Snape he also has been and always be a butt trumpet!"(AVPM & AVPS Remus & Sirius)
christy41145 3 months ago 5
@christy41145 BUTT TRUMPET!! PFFT! PFFT!! PFT PFT PFT!! who looks stupid now YOU DO!!!!
x3
LionshadeElricfan 3 months ago 4
@christy41145 Only in the first film. When he is taunting Harry about the upcoming Quidditch match, he quite OBVIOUSLY farts.
fs11klrk 3 months ago
0:09 When is patoe a spell?
Superstarskd 3 months ago
@Superstarskd Protego lol. When I first saw this I though he said Potatoe!
TheWolfmaid 3 months ago in playlist Liked
@TheWolfmaid Protego! That dont sound like it
Superstarskd 3 months ago
@Superstarskd that's what it's supposed to be, it says so in the books.
TheWolfmaid 3 months ago
@TheWolfmaid Oh well im not done with the the 5th book
Superstarskd 3 months ago
ahhh...that awkward moment when you watch your potions teacher's worst memory and realize that he was bullied as a kid...
4evaRonandMione 3 months ago
you just don't get snape. he protected them from voldemort. he did what he has to do even though he's putting his life on the line. and yes, he did so many wrong decisions but it's all because of hatred and memories of him with the marauders. however, james was a bully.but didn't you realize that james only changed because he wants lily to like him,as you all know lily gest hurt if her bestfriend been bullied by those kids. he stop bullying severus because its her bestfriend. lily fell w/ james
barroluna08 3 months ago 3
@barroluna08 [continuation] because of that, and then severus is jealous ofcourse, so while he's free from them, he masters dark arts and joined death eaters just to impress lily, but, lily didn't want death eaters so he failed again. btw, the time severus was being bullied, lily tried to help him but b'coz of anger and humiliation infront of everyone, he called lily a "mudblood" and thats the end of their friendship. he get depressed and started doing dark things. JUST SO YOU KNOW :)
barroluna08 3 months ago
i personally think snape is the worlds biggest creeper lololol
desr2395 3 months ago
James looks like Josh Alvies
anythingnew 3 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
i hate that they didnt show lily defending snape
heartstruck1995 3 months ago
i hate that they diddnt show lily defending snape
heartstruck1995 3 months ago 3
@GamerElite1000
that made no sense at all. If snape hadn't been bullied maybe he would have been happy instead of so depressed all the time :(
And the sad thing is that this parallels real people's lives all the time.
TotalZukoFan 3 months ago
Vote for Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows Part 2 at the Scream Awards at spike . com (no spaces)
p0kemons 4 months ago
All in all, Snape an innocent schoolboy? James a bully? Please. If anything the worst that can be said about James is that he was "slightly arrogant" . And the best spin you can give Snape is that he's more of a Anti-Hero rather than a "tragic figure"
Publicenemy85 4 months ago 4
@Publicenemy85 wow you are stupid you made 4 paragraphs and not one thing said anything that Snape did was bad and anything James did good. So what if he liked Dark arts that is the best way to get back at bitch ass bullies like James. I would join Voldemort too if the so called "good side" put me in trees and embarassed me infront of the girl I loved. Everything you said is stupid and doesn't prove anything.
13Elementguy 1 month ago
4. Lilly didn't end her friendship with Snape only because he called her a mudblood, as shown in Snape's memory it was his love of the dark arts, he idiolizing of Voldermort and in Lilly's words "Hatred for my kind" meaning muggle borns. It should also be noted that when Snape asked Voldermort to spare her life he showed no regard for her husband and child. Something even Dumbledore uncharacteristically lashed at him for "YOU DISGUST ME!"
Publicenemy85 4 months ago 7
@Publicenemy85 Your comments are so right!Don't get me wrong I like Snape but I'm sick of people passing all the hatred onto James...he's one of my favorite characters and like all the character's that Jo wrote he wasn't perfect-but he got better.If anything Snape was a bigger bully because he carried his grudge with him the rest of his life and picked on the son of the man he hated even though the child did nothing wrong.I love Snape but he was a bigger bully.Thank you.
weirdofun1 3 months ago 7
(Continued) 3. James Joined the Order of the Phoenix after leaving Hogwarts. We can only imagine what Snape did during his time as a death eater. And despite his loathing for Snape he STILL saved his life in the shrieking shack 4. Adult Lives: James sacrificed himself for his family, financially supported Lupin as he couldn't get a job as a werewolf. And Loathed the dark arts. Snape: Showed favoritism, verbally abused his students, and tormented Harry simply for the life he never had. Pathetic!
Publicenemy85 4 months ago 6
This is precisely why I hate movies baased on books. So many important details are left out that people tend to get the wrong idea. Here are a few facts 1) Snape wasn't exactly the innocent schoolboy. It was noted that he hexed James whenever he had the chance as well. Was in love with the dark arts. Hung around with soon to be deatheaters 2) James "deflated" his head, enough for Lilly to fall in love with him and dumbledore to apoint him head boy. Snape...became a death eater.
Publicenemy85 4 months ago 87
@Publicenemy85 Perhaps, but the movie adaptation can still be enjoyable and in fact can become its own alternate reality/interpretation of the original source material.
ryanson209 4 months ago
Comment removed
MrBurgundy76 2 months ago
@Publicenemy85......i'd say its really from your own perspective........i think the movies portrayed the books better than its ever been done before.......the only things ever to piss me off is the centourless final battle and the thing that pisses most people off......'peeves'
dot2dot67 2 months ago
Its such a pity that they left so much out, I wish each movie could have been a full 4 hours
MsAgnosticatheist 4 months ago
I wish them would have put Harry talking to Sirius and Remus about his dad in the movies :(
HedwigandHarry 4 months ago 5
extended its same as in film . but i dont get this . snape was slythrin how did he get beaten up by a grifindor
SuperAiden007 4 months ago
@ATLSportsGirl i do two , i love all the character , i love james and snape , and sirius , and the others and im proud to love them , because loving james better then loving the twilight characters ... lol .
xmileycyrusfanx100 4 months ago
what par of movie is that?
JuliaBandosz 4 months ago
@ATLSportsGirl me too
JuliaBandosz 4 months ago
Ok everyone James was a great man yes he was an ass for no reason but I believe he was jealous of snape because lily in skool hated him but was good friends with Severus!!! Jealousy makes us do stupid things!!! I believe if he was alive and saw eat Severus has done for his son he wud apologize!! And Severus isn't at fault either obviously he was fueled by anger he was mad and thought everyone wud think of him as a coward for needing a girls help though tht doesn't excuse wat he said he regrets
Haleybaby456 4 months ago
@Haleybaby456 i agree with you,jk rowling want us to learn from james personality that we have to change to be good persons,and that love change people,and that mabey some parents was bad but they changed for us,just like sirius,and james,and even lupin,exp:my father was a such troublemker when he was 15 and he changed for us he work in the police and he sucrfice himself everyday for us,when i only remember james i remember my father , all what we have to know about them that they love us.
xmileycyrusfanx100 4 months ago
@xmileycyrusfanx100 figures that a former piece of shit bully is now a bully piece of shit cop. Thanks for making that guys point.
13Elementguy 1 month ago
@13Elementguy well, t'ill that i was respecting snape , so i don't get why you love the fucking snape . well, don't forget that snape is the biggest piece of shit bully in the world of harry potter.mabey that kind of LEGENDRY LOVE FOR LILY makes you blind.cause the first ever bully was snape,bullying all the houses exept slytherin , spying on the order of pheonix,hating harry for no reason, a man in 30 doing all that comparing to a boy in 15,who's the real bully now,fuck you.thnx .
xmileycyrusfanx100 1 month ago
@xmileycyrusfanx100 I believe you haven't read all of the Harry Potter books. Even if you did, you certainly did not understand Snape. He's a bully but one who would do anything to protect his loved ones. Can't you tell that he did all he could to protect Harry? Ugh, there's no point in explaining this to you because you're too stupid to understand this simple fact.
igoteggigotchicken11 4 weeks ago
@igoteggigotchicken11 i didn't say anything about his legendary love for lily,i respect snape the lover only,and i have read all the books,and i know what he did to protect harry,and one of my favorite chapter is the prince tale,and exuse me,i'm not stupid,were all harry potter fans here ,the stupids are twilight fans,cause they didn't choose the hp books to read,oh i forgeot there's no point in explaining this to you because you're too stupid to understand this simple fact
xmileycyrusfanx100 4 weeks ago
@xmileycyrusfanx100 Snape spied on the Order? Snape hates Harry? Umm, excuse me, but that was all of your sayings. He may have been a bully but he still protect those that are close to him. Btw, I wasn't talking just about his love for Lily. As I said 2 sentences before, he still protects those who are close to him. Who cares about how stupid Twilight fans are as long as they're not a hater.
igoteggigotchicken11 4 weeks ago
@igoteggigotchicken11 now listing to me SNAPElittleFAN, first watch this vid, jk rowling tells us about the spy snape /watch?v=mBLqWffUSWI, two if snape didn't hate harry why he bullying him all the time, oh, he just wants revenge for his past with harry's father, he protect harry only because his lily's son, if he wasn't he ouldn't care about him, as you can see in the vid i gaved you, so have a nice day watching what jk rowling said about your love, and ultimate hero .
xmileycyrusfanx100 3 weeks ago
@xmileycyrusfanx100 Snape hates Harry but cares for him at the same time. As you said, he only protected him because he was Lily's son. At the end of the day, Snape is still a good guy at some point. I'm a Snape lover just because I defend him? You know, jumping to conclusions isn't good. It can get you into big trouble
igoteggigotchicken11 3 weeks ago
@igoteggigotchicken11oh good, finally you understand , and don't worry i'm not up to no good these days ;) .
xmileycyrusfanx100 3 weeks ago
@xmileycyrusfanx100 Btw, he always cared for Harry.
D: Have you ever cared about him?
S: Yes
D: Always?
S: Always.
Or something like that. Not sure if it's cause of Lily or not but he's still an awesome character. Very mysterious..
igoteggigotchicken11 3 weeks ago