Added: 4 years ago
From: 1norrie1
Views: 106,997
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:
see all

All Comments (264)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • This Guy is very good, but nobody can sing like Carl Anderson, nobody on this planet today !!!  Can sing like Carl ....

    Bud!! Still this is à pleasure for my ears

    Respect!!

  • Wow! Amazing! Jan Dulles rocks!

  • Why is it that the new versions want to have Judas confronting the apostles in the opening song? When I first saw the 1973 version it made sense to me that Judas was having a monologue, reflecting on his thoughts before acting on them or saying something he might regret...which I think is what most people would do if they had a disagreement with a good friend. I don't know...throwing this out there in the beginning kind of makes you wonder why they even keep him around.

  • wow gaaf gedaan zeg wist niet dat hij zo mooi kon zingen jammer dat je dit niet in hun eigen nummers terug hoord

  • Comment removed

  • He's fucking amazing!

  • hmmm I don't think he acts too well(except for the end )...probably because I'm used to acters who act more ... well not more exaggerated but stronger... I guess this acting would be really good if it was a movie...but if you do a musical i feel you have to overdo it a bit.... really nice singing though *-*

  • every time i see a new judas perform i can't decide my favorite! they are all so talented!

  • Good singer, terrible actor. Whyis it you can never have both? The 2000 version had AMAZING acting, but terrible singing. Only really good one I've seen in both those aspects is Drew Sarich

  • Ik had het geluk dit live te zien .Als ik het terug kijk nog steeds kippevel !

  • The Casting Director has to be a genious... What is his name?¿ ... and what is the name of the director of this cover of andrew lloyd webber? are this company moving around the world? is there any possibility to watch them in Spain?.

    Todas estas versiones me han parecido impresionantes, y sus voces increibles tan similares a las pelicula, me he quedado sin palabras.

  • Gewoonweg FANTASTISCH! Echt de beste zanger van Nederland...

  • Yes, he is no Carl. Frankly, I think his voice is WAY better. His vibe is much more Judassy.

  • This Judas blows the Judas from the Straford production I just saw out of the water. Amazing voice...this sets the bar very very high.

  • I just saw the version from 1973 of this song here, and he sings it in the same way, he realized that one was the best. :)

  • I love this guy. I really, really love him.

    Ahem... Uh... For the part of course... Cough cough...

  • amazing!! great great voice! (but he's no carl )

  • jeetje jan wat mooi hoorde t net op de radio heb hem maar meteen bij mijn favoriten gezet

  • Wow -- what a voice -- he nailed it.  Gave me goosebumps.

  • Very good voice and tempo!!! Like Murray and Carl.

  • I agree, I'm in love with Jan Dulles's voice.

    Where was this performed? It looks like a church o_O

  • @ExploringReal In a Sports accommodation

  • Amazing. Any chance to get some CD/DVD of this?

  • WOW. Just wow. This guy better record stuff or something, that voice is gold.

  • This is great! Judas is amazing. the music is a bit too loud though...

  • when this was recorded, I sat in the audience :)

  • great voice. acting/movements need work.

  • 2:50

    oh thank god

    hes wearing a vest

    i thought he just had red duct tape suspenders

  • <3

  • Great vocals and the music is true to the original overall. I've viewed several of the songs from this production on youtube. My only complaint is one of the female musicians can be seen at times mouthing the words to some of the songs which is a little distracting. The musicians should be invisible, not bringing attention to themselves.

  • This man is not human dude...

  • The only complaint I have with this performance is that the Apostles seem to clap for no reason. In the movie they're worshiping Jesus, in the 2000 production, they're coming on stage, here they're just kind of. . .clapping.

  • @blithium It's not much of a complaint is it.

    This performance is outstanding.....

  • You did it as written - well done!

  • NEEF:D:D

  • Heel erg goed! Da's toch de ene van eeh... waar ken ik hem van..

    Nou ja ECHT SUPER GOED!!!!! Tof!

  • @lindyloe 3 J's:D:D

  • He is good, but in my eyes Drew Sarich is the better Judas.

  • Ive heard many live performances and they almost all have one glaring part that just doesn't sound right. It seems the word "every" gets tossed onto the butcher's block. Like they heard someone with the hiccups sing it and copied it ever since.

  • You can tell he's basing his version on Carl Anderson's, which, in my opinion, is a very good thing to do! I think he does a great job. Effortless rock voice which is very pleasing on the ear!

  • i love the Middle-Eastern like riff at 0:42

  • Very good performance by Judas!

  • hier een hartgrondige JEZUS wat een stem!!!! een hele nieuwe waardering voor deze muziek, wat een emoties!

  • Ik heb het al vaker gezegd hier, wat heeft die man een dijk van een stem.

  • hij kan egt alles zeg die jan dulles geweldig

  • I Looooove him!! What is his name?? :DD

  • @Kaffeization Jan Dulles

  • wow, one the best "heaven on their minds" I've heard in while. wish I had seen this live

  • he will be on the eurovision songcontest 2011

  • If I had the money to finance it this is exactly how I would do it. This show needs a big set and cast.

  • This is the best judas ive heard, far superior to the original

  • Many ppl comparing him to carl, but i gotta feeling most ppl forget the movie was recorded in a studio, and this is live. thumbs up for judas. btw, he and his band are gonna perform on eurovision for the Netherlands next year. If they put down a performance like this it's gonna be, wait for it.. legendary.

  • Wow, great performance! I'm really impressed! :D

  • really good, i really liked this

  • Great! I love this, what a great performance.

  • Very nice. Yeah i agree with the not being as good as carl but thats like watch someone ppay leading player and comparing them to vereen. He did excellant. I loved it

  • Thanks 1 norrie1. It gets always better with time

  • His voice is pretty good, but his acting, it lacks emotion.

  • Demais,,!! muito bom poder escutar essa Opera Rok..Obrigada 

  • The guy as Judas is AWESOME! LOVE his voice !

  • does anyone know if there is a cd or dvd of this performance? please tell me

  • not as good as carl imho, but EXCELLENT rendition. kept it very close. many thumbs up

  • not too bad

  • wow!!!

  • Woah ik wist niet dat hij zo goed was. :P Respect.

  • A very well done!

    One of the best Judas I've e seen!

    Whoever he is, he is great!

    Regards

    Edward Hyde

  • good woice

  • Every time I listen to this, I think what a great singer he is.

    Every time I watch this, I think what a horrible actor he is.

    Fair trade off though.

  • @thissignupisannoying The thing he's actually a Dutch pop singer so I'm not surprised by the bad acting.

  • EXCELLENT !!!

  • i love this version the 1973 one :) this guy has done a good job

  • Nice voice

  • There's been probably 1000 Judas' being played through the years, yes! Carl Anderson is the one in the movie, and he's awesome. Don't be so narrow-minded, listen and quit with the Carl Anderson comparisons.

  • Geweldig!

    XJ

  • Geweldig!

    XJ

  • No, he isn't as good as Carl. No-one is in this role imho. But he does a very good rendition and has a very, very pleasing sounding voice. I would like to hear him sing some other stuff as well. When Carl did this song he had so much soul and emotion it wasn't funny.

  • @babystinky See for  some other stuff these tags: 3js,  de3jees, 2norrie2.

    Greetings,Norrie

  • @babystinky he has a little bit easier quality to his voice than carl

  • @babystinky who the hell is carl??

  • WOW dit is de 2e Judas die ik na de film heel erg goed vind. De Judas uit de film van 1973 is geweldig daarna heb je natuurlijk martin van der starre in de nederlandse versie maar echt petje af heel erg mooi.

  • can i get these songs on itunes or is there a soundtrack, anyone know?

  • can i get these songs on itunes or is there a soundtrack, anyone know?

  • Now seriously, this is playback, isnt it?

    There`s not the slightest dissonance in Juda`s singing!

    Even during fast movements that would affect the breathing...-> 0.59

  • Now seriously, this is playback, isnt it?

    There`s not the slightest dissonance in Juda`s singing!

    Even during fast movements that would affect the breathing...-> 0.59

  • Now seriously, this is playback, isnt it?

    There`s not the slightest dissonance in Juda`s singing!

    Even during fast movements that would affect the breathing...-> 0.59

  • now seriously, this is playback, isnt it?

    Theres not the slightest bit of dissonance in juda`s singing!

    Even during fast movements that would affect the breathing -> 0.59

  • now seriously, this is playback, isnt it?

    Theres not the slightest bit of dissonance in juda`s singing!

    Even during fast movements that would affect the breathing -> 0.59

  • This is so great! Jan Dules sings this maybe even better than in the movie.

  • judas' voice is amazing but he could use some work regarding his acting. but truly an amazing vocal, I can't believe how he can sing this effortlessly

  • Wow... just wow

    The first version who can actually compete with the original. Great voice, worth of recognition. Kudos for all of you guys, great work! You should've done the new version, lol!

  • Yeah this is the best first so far ive heard execpt off that from carl himself hes a god to me (A)

  • Great voice! Very similar to the original Murray Head.

  • ik hou van deze versie!

    en van GOD!

    I love this version!

    and I love GOD!

  • I posted this up on Facebook. One of the best vocal performances of this song I've heard.

  • Wow.

  • Finally, I've found a version with a singer who can match Murray Head and Carl Anderson!

  • he is a much better singer then actor

  • jan dulles is a hero

  • Wordclass performance by the man singing Judas... well done!

  • very good (Y)

  • Great Voice.. but OMG he looks bored and emotionless! Take some Acting lessons to match the voice PLEASE..

  • but he's not an actur he is a dutch singer

  • @elchicho25

    He never acted before, hes in a dutch popkinda band. This is all done by amateur singers from holland barely any of them are famous for acting.

  • Tremendous voice and a beautiful cast and play altogether. Congratulations to the good people of Volendam.

    I hope you stage other ones.

  • Amazing voice! I even like this one more then Carl's or any others version.

    U should all know that this is held with a group of neighbours in a local gym ;) They didn't have any budget or professional coaching or whatever.

  • And it just keeps getting better! This guy is better than either of the movie Judases and almost as good as Murray Head on the concept album.

  • I love Jan as Judas, but didn't West Side Story teach us that snapping or clapping in rhythm isn't intimidating?

  • Great Drummer

  • amazing vocals. shit acting

  • wow! Brilliant!

  • Better than the Australian crap. These guys can sing.

  • woow

  • dang he's good. why couldn't he be in the 2000 version? he's amazing, almost as good as the original

  • Fantastic Judas very close to Carl, heh, yet I still prefer him over this man.

    The staging is terrible, weird heh, these people should be interested in Jesus ahhaha

  • What a voice, but damn the acting on that stage is a mess

  • WOW what a clean voice, you can tell that he has natural talent, would love to have seen this live

  • Jan is zeker geweldig! <33

  • Jan is geweldig! <3

  • omg i LOVE the guy who does judas. LOVE him!!!

  • Zal een beetje te tuben en kwam ineens langs de Volendam cast filmpjes van JCS. Ik vond Jan Dulles al 'best goed', maar dit is echt absolute, absolute buitencategorie!!! Tuurlijk is het qua stijl een kopie van het origineel, maar als je remake wilt maken moet dat ook. Zijn zang is net zo meesterlijk als het origineel. Een fan erbij, Jan. Ongelofelijk...sprakeloos.

  • my complaint is that jesus and the apostles hear what judas is singing/saying. i think that this song is just what judas is thinking in his mind

  • totally agree!!

  • I second that

  • plus, when you think about it, it will make 'Strange Thing Mystifying' kinda repeditive.

  • wow

  • it's a carbon copy of the carl anderson version, he never put himself in the role. the best versions of this song are Zubin Varla and Drew sarich.

  • a total copy!!

    you're 100% right

  • The best version on here period.

  • Jan Dulles does sing this song a bit more powerfull overall, instead of some pieces which Carl did..

    I guess i like this interpretation more then the one from Carl.

  • nice job at 1:58... does it like carl did it... this new video of adam lambert going crazy on those notes is stupid...

  • The best I heard after Carl!!! fantastic job!!!

  • Jan, Jan, Jan....wat ben je een toppertje. Wat een dijk van een stem heb je toch. Wat zet je Judas mooi neer. Wat ben je leuk.... Deze rol is op je mooie lijf geschreven.

  • judas is intense! such a tough role to fill, but he does it so well! that's a tough role to fill, but he is def the best i've seen after carl anderson.

  • mygod,

    `oke my first reaction was`; DAMN HES GOOD

    my second: HE IS JAN DULLES FROM THE 3J's

    then i started shouting at it XD for being in that stupid band while he is so much better. and `i know the 3 j's are really good. But the music they make isn't half as good as they can be.

    then I wanted to be maria XD her voice in this musical is also good. I was really impressed by this musical. love it!!!! Jan Dulles is a true artist.

  • My God! Great Judas...The best I heard after Carl!

  • I watched this and the rest of the show on Youtube, and thought it was great! Yes it's an amateur production and a very close interpretation of the movie, but everyone on stage looked like they were enjoying themselves! I agree that Judas was the best performance overall, but I thought Jesus and Mary Magdalene were pretty good too.

  • But come on, it's just an amateur production. `what else do they have then the original production? yes the 2000 production but a lot of people sing really bad in that one. Couldn't believe that it was an official one. The 2000 version is a disgrace to andrew lloyd wbber in my opinion. The singers are good low, but when they go high they just miss a lot of things

  • Excellent singing, though Judas could be a little more passionate in his body language.

  • wow, an amateur? He'll amazing voice, not to mention gorgeous too =]

  • is de zanger van de 3 j's en nick en simon zitten er ook in (L)

  • Wooooow this guy is amaaazing!! x

  • I just cant believe that someone outside the US can so such a good job with this material!

  • Seriously... You can't believe that someone outside the US can do a good job with a musical made by two british guys? Not to mention that the best Judas to date, Murray Head, was british...

  • what a dumb comment...

    but yes, this judas is fantastic, very much like carl anderson

  • not to mention that the original judas was colm wilkinson, from ireland

  • exactly!! Isaw this link on youtube and I expected something much worse than this!

  • i agree with markasalvarore 110%

  • I have seen a lot of Judas' in my day and this guy just freakin nailed it! Great voice, great control and beautiful command of the song. I agree the stage direction needed some work, but this guy has got the raw talent to go far! Reminds me of Drew Sarich. I hope he does this for a living. If not, he should

  • i think this version is based more on carl anderson

    also drew sarichs voice is more effortless

    but this dude is still amazin

  • Waarom is deze gast niet beroemd over de hele wereld?

  • This was held in a gym, so we didn't have much space.

    And yes, we know our Judas rocks :-)

    His name is Jan Dulles

  • Het blijft super , Jan.

    Misschien volgend jaar weer?

  • 3:25  gave me chills

  • i'm not gonna write this judas is amazing, it's just obvious!

  • This Judas is damn fucking amazing!

  • Best Judas i´ve ever heard. :)

  • Judas is amazing!

  • This judas is amazing.

  • Jesus should NOT be looking at Judas...That's kind of the whole point of the song...

    Awesome singing, but the stage direction was terrible.

  • Beautiful rendering.

  • This Judas is fantastic! =D

  • que bueno es este judas. Uno de los mejores que he visto

  • This is the best Judus I've seen. Never had the opportunity to go to Broadway tho.

  • is dit met live band of met opname als muziek?

  • Dit is live, kijk maar in het midden van het podium, daar zitten de muziekanten.

  • Je kan ook de Afspeellijst: JCS (repetitie/repetition/repetici­ón) Opperdam 2007 filmpjes bekijken!!!

  • Ja,, Dit is live..

    Ben er zelf geweest..

    En een meester van de basischool speelde in die band..

  • Jerome Pradon was a joke in the 2000 version compared to this singer. Pradon was a good actor- but horrible singer.

    This guy should have been in the 2000 film!

  • Clearly a good singer, I wish they had just used their own interpretations of the songs rather than just copying the 1973 film version...

  • You know what? I actually don´t care how good or bad actor he is because of his voice, which doesn´t allow me to think... outstanding!!!

  • To be honest, I was afraid to watch this video thinking it would be pretty crap... but it's quite the contrary. Very well done, sir! It must be scary to be compared to Anderson continuously!

  • One of the few Judas that are comparable with Carl Anderson

  • i very much like his voice, it's quite unique and rock n' rolly, but i dont like his acting at all.

  • agree 100%

  • This is Jan Dulles from the Netherlands.

    Hij zingt dit werkelijk waar fantastisch! Ik geniet hier zo van om dit te zien. Overal weer kippenvel.

  • This guy is the perfect fusion of Jerome Pradon and Carl Anderson. His voice has Anderson's edginess and a range comparable to Pradon's. While he is perhaps not as "mobile" as either one, I would wager he sounds as good (if not better) than either one in the studio.

  • he has an amazing vioce

    he must be a profesional

    i think the costumes are good but the acting needs more working on, but im sure it will improve