Added: 4 years ago
From: seduff
Views: 40,901
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:
see all

All Comments (219)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • Prolly the best Who fan vid ive ever seen. Really, your brilliant ,and this video is fantastic. Thank you.

  • I love the clip at 3:08 when the Doctor says "Her name was Rose." It gets me every time how you can hear the tears in his voice. And I love the scene you put in from the Wire of them saying "Hi."

  • And the horse-wink scene from GiTF. LOVE IT.

  • Makes me all nostalgiccy :)

  • the editing at 1:00 to 1:05 just makes me feel really sad inside for him...

  • Oh wow. This is gorgeous. I watched the new Who from the first evening it returned, and have kept up with it and rewatched it all so many times, and never in anything else i've ever read, watched or experienced have i seen something as magical as the relationship between Rose and The Doctor. It's just the most beautiful thing in the universe.

  • I have a question

    How did roses "dad" get to her perfect timing?

  • I feel so sad that they didn't give the doctor & rose a happy ending.

    They gave him a broken heart that will never heal.

    I also feel that there was only 1 Doctor Who.

    The show stopped for me after the episode in which he deleted himself from Donna's memory & left Rose with Doctor #2. It was never the same. He was just so sad, I felt a piece missing from him.

  • WONDERFUL video!!! Beautiful!!!

    I adore 1:00 - 1:05. Such beautiful editing.

    I also love how he looks at her in 1:12. Like she's the whole universe.

  • This is heart crushing (sorry I've been watching to much Bones). It's so wonderful, I can't believe how beautiful and amazing your videos are.

  • wow i just LOVE this ^.^

  • hands down the best video i have ever seen - brilliant song choice, brilliant editing, perfect timing, fantastic blend of clips. Really, i cried, (and i do not cry easily) A doomed love story hands down. But its the best relationship ever and its the kind i wish i had. It was another world when they were together. and he was a bitter bitter man who tried living a lonely life with a lonely heart. I loved the "human as i am, i had to give up my defenses" and he did have to do that. Perfection.

  • i really miss her

  • It's your Videos that make me miss David Tennant so much D:

    BUT... They mare Brilliant videos... Somethings are worth getting your heart broken for.. I.. think.. Someone said that in Doctor who.. Uhm.. Sarah Jane Smith?

    THIS is a Brilliant Videoi :)

  • I love LIKA and I love DOCTOR WHO so this is a beautiful video like all you do =)

  • @rock0in0the0campagne sorry it's "MIKA"

  • a Former NASA Designer. I have invented engines that could one day make the Dr. Story Real. by GottaSaveTheWorldcom

  • your videos are the best on youtube. just saying!!!!

  • :'( <3

  • It's the only video on youtube that has ever made me cry! It's just amazing, and it just makes me remember how much I loved The Doctor and Rose more than him and his other companions. I couldn't stop crying, especially at the part when she tells him she loves him<3 Seriously, it's amazing! x

  • i end up crying when he says 'her name was Rose' :'( in my opinion, the best dw video on youtube.

  • this made me cry. best DW video on youtube. 

  • That is totally awesome! o.O

  • beautiful video - i started crying - excellent sequence and clip selection :D

    i wish they'd bring rose back into it, somehow...i hope the doctor never moves completely on

    and hopefully they bring the doctor's daughter into it somehow lol! anybody remember jenny?

  • i think Matt Smith does still have memires of rose

  • i love doctor who its like the best show ever

  • Oh my goodness, this video made me cry, it was so emotionally strong! It's when I watch amazing videos like yours that I actually forget the Doctor and Rose aren't real, and my heart breaks for their sad ending every time! Awesome, awesome, awesome job on this :)

  • yours was the first Doctor Who video I ever watched and the one that made me watch the series...thanks so much!

    I love Doctor Who now!

    :D

    I've watched up to Season 5 but not Season 5 yet...

    lol

    this video is my favorite DW video and I will ship Rose and the Doctor forever because of this! :D

    also this is the first video in my DW playlist...yeah this video was alot of firsts for me. :D

  • @bluesalad Thank you so much for letting me know your story regarding this video. it's wonderful to know how it has actually effected people, whether it be encouraging them to watch the show or simply shipping these great characters. Again, thank you. :) x

  • @seduff do you mind if I use this video in a vlog I'm doing talking about how I got into watching DW? I'd link your channel and video etc; but I'd like to credit you in the video and use your music video as an example of how I got hooked on the show

  • @bluesalad Of course you can. I would be honoured. ;) x

  • @seduff thanks! thank you for introducing me to this series. probably best series I found via the internet.

  • @bluesalad thanks for the recommendation!!!! :D

  • @bluesalad Thanks for the recommendation!!!!! :D

  • dude...i love it absolutely love it, so beautiful and touching i swear I cried

  • crying ='[ this is so painful watch...but so brilliantly done

  • Big Big crushing home run on this video. Its just great. You are very talented.

  • Holy Frak!!!! I usually hate tribute videos but this one was amazing! The best tribute video I have ever seen! And great use of Mika too. Love that song.

  • brilliunt

  • so...thanks to your video that I watched a couple of years ago, I've finally watched Doctor Who! Fell in love with him and Rose! :) this video is just so perfect I've come back to watch it again now that I know where its coming from etc; thanks so much for matching up the music with the series.

  • This was great. I agree with your thoughts about how the song inspires a mix of emotions. And the editing was superb as usual. I can't think of a better way to spend my time while waiting for my video editor to import all my media than to work my way through your channel.

  • You just rejuvenated my love for Doctor Who and David Tennant! Thanks so much :) Just shows you can't always take away passionate emotion and replace it with madness (in Matt Smith's case- even though he is a very good actor!)

  • I LOVE THIS SO MUCH!<3

    oh i cried!

  • I hold you and this video personally responsible for getting me obsessed with both Mika and Doctor Who!

    It's pretty tragic, but whenever I listen to this song I actually hear in my head the little bits of dialogue that you have put in, THAT'S how many times I've watched it!

    I may have commented on this before but, oh well...

  • seduff, u aussie? the logo in the corner is ABC

  • I cried when he lost Rose! so emotional!!

  • OMGGGGGGGG seduff you are sooo brilliant!!! That was beautifullllll!!!!!! Although.... I am simply suggesting you make a David Tennant FanVid to this song, obviously because he IS a "bitter, bitter man" for leaving Doctor Who without a reason. You make the BEST Doctor Who FanVids.... PLEASE? PLEASE? PLEASSSE???? <3

  • He did have a valid claim. 3 years and a few specials is a while, and he is an amazing actor. He wanted to try different things, I'd bet. Not bitter, just open for new things. :)

  • Oh God...

    one second i'm grinning like The Master, the next i'm practically sobbing.

  • Its Soo sweet :L

  • wow never have i wanted to watch Doctor who but it really does look like a great show. ^^

    awesome job on the vid!

  • oh that was so lovely ^ ^

  • best romantic song eva, its so sad, im almost cryin :'( lol

  • i consider it one of the greatest love stories of all time.

  • oh wow. I'm tearing up :( But it's really good :)

  • your vid are the best !! i dón't watch any others know!!!

  • This Song was sampled in a HipHop Beat I heard ...

    I was interessted in the Original

  • This reminds me of The Stars

  • yayy another masterpiece by seduff!! <3

    seduff u know yr vids are what i show to ppl when i want to get them into dr who!!!

  • DoctorDonna28L Oh that's wonderful. So glad i can be of some help in recruiting new who fans. =D xo

  • amence!<33

  • "Hi *big cheesy grins*"

    awesome vid!

  • Well... I'm about to cry now!

    This was art, just like everything else you do.

  • Hey, from what season is this? Thanks a lot!

  • season 2

  • and season 3

  • This is a brillient vid. Very well put together. I loved how you used the sound on the clips aswell.

    Five stars and fave.

  • Is this available for download anywhere? I really really would love to put this on my mp3 player!

  • The "say goodbye" part near the end when they waving at each each breaks me everytime I see it

  • SHHHHHH SPANISH

  • amazing

  • scotsmen

    the best bonds, Dr Whos, football managers

    tally ho

  • We miss you Seduff, come back soon! xx

  • I really like this lots... cannit believe david tenant is leaving :-( loved how it all worked out with clips :D

  • Makes me cry. I love it

  • RTD decided that they would have chemistry which was great. It happened so subtle ...he had just lost his entire race and met this girl who had the most pure heart of anyone he had ever met there was no way out of falling in love with her. She fell in love with the child in him but also the brilliant man who used his brilliance to save the world time and time again who needed no glory for doing so. One of the greatest doomed love stories of all time. I hope Matt Smith still has memories of Rose.

  • it was awesome as expected and the timing was great i loved it

  • the music has a well good effect with this, i cried :(:l

    i cant believe theres gunna be a new doctor in 2010. david tennant was amazing, he shouldnt of left!

  • :-O !!!! he left :''''''(

  • seduff i swear to god you are the best video maker ever but i have to tell you that someone called showapoolKwesi is stealing parts of this video and using it in their's its really not cool and you have to do somthing

  • AMAZING! 5/5

  • mika and doctor who what a fabulous combo :)

  • This is a really beautiful song. I'd never heard it before, but every time I do from now on I'll think of Doctor Who. Beautifully done, as all of your videos are. : )

  • I know i've already commented , but i had to say once again how brilliant this video is! the editing is amazing and the clips are matched perfectly with the song, thanks so much for this, this is my fave doctor who video i've found. :)

  • This is gorgeous, I loved it.

  • good job dude!

  • Beautiful video. Angsty and light at all the right moments. <3

  • great job! I cant stop watching it!

  • omfg!! yet again seduff, a video that has brought me to tears, your amazingg!! thankyouu for postingg! incredible! x

  • wow. i can't get over how amazing this is. i love this song and doctor who. amazing. thanks !!!

  • Mika + Doctor who = perfect video <3

    and Any other world is my favourite song.

    THANK YOUUU!!!!!!

  • I haven't had to chance yet to watch this series but I really want to. Your video is still my favorite Dr. Who video out there! :)

  • oh geez the end was so depressing like the last 3 secs, i loved the random clip where some one opens the door and dr &rose both go HI!

  • -sniffles-

    beautiful, as are all your other vids. This made me want to cry and smile at the same time. Favourited and 5 stars =D

  • that was absolutly amazing!

    well done..

    ..coz you made me cry =O

    well done again =]

  • SO B-E-A-U-TIFUL!!!!

  • T_T THAT WAS AMAZING! I LOVED IT!

    I CANT BELIEVE DAVID TENNANT IS LEAVING DOCTOR WHO!!!*wails*

    And what about rose??? i know she has the human doc but still! they both really did love eachother

    ROSE/TEN FOREVER!

  • waouh this was amazing one more time

    can't believe I had missed this one too (shame on me lol^^)

    anyway it's really brillant I so love it !

    and love this song as well great for the Doctor and Rose !!!

  • That was amazing, no joke! Best Doctor Who vid I've seen since the Scattered/Map of the Problematique one. Excellent job!

  • I only liked the dr who with david tennant and billie piper when she was crying when she thought she would never see him again I had to hold back my tears and love this song !

  • I said I wouldn't add any more videos to this song to my favourites/playlist but this one was too good to not add. I recently found your videos and I think they're brilliant.

  • wow... that was fantastic.

  • amazing.

  • jaw dropping, that's all i can say. work of art darling.

  • Oh that was wonderful. simply beautiful.

  • OMG that is so beautiful! It's got me all choked up...It's going on my faves!

  • awesome song and awesome video!

  • 3 words......WORLDS BEST VIDEO!

  • i still can't believe they got rid of Rose... it was a good idea bringing in Catherine Tate thu

  • @Forcebearer51 That's true. I think Donna was someone the Doctor needed, a friend who wouldn't totally fall for him. Actually, Donna's goodbye was more heartbreaking to me. When the Doctor says bye, and she says "later," it kills me. :(

  • brilliant! what more can I say, all of your videos are brilliant. 5/5 for making me smile and rebreaking my heart all over again

  • God, you kill me. So, so, good. Can't wait to see what you do with s4.

  • Russel T Davies broke every Doctor/Rose shippers heart.

  • David Tennant is so good at being Doctor Who

    if there ever was a Doctor Who

    I would imagion him to be just like David Tennant

  • How amazing! Really sad but at the end u like captured all their great moments (especaially the 'Hii!' One lol its so cute!) N i loved it where the Doctor was looking and Rose kept turning around like he was there. I also love this song its so sad n goes perfectly with this vid! 5/5 xxxx

  • I can't watch this video after watching The Stolen Earth.

    I can't stop crying now. I love this video so much.

  • I'm pretty sure this is my favorite of all your videos, or perhaps tying with Rose's Story. It is just so emotional and heartbreaking to watch. I absolutely love it.

  • Thanks for all your lovely comments. :) I am so glad that you are enjoying my videos. *beams*. I think this song just creates such a mix of feelings, with happier moments and the sadness of being alone again. x

  • wow this is good.

    David Tennant is by far the best Doctor Who, although i have never seen the older ones. And i like the song (:

  • omg that is so good, its just so sad!! :(

  • This is so wonderful, thank you so much. This really had me tearing up, I could watch it forever. WOW.

    Incidentally, what program did you use to make this?

  • loved the last 20 seconds of this video. it was fantastic!

  • Absolutely beautiful.

  • brilliant- mika and dr who go so well together dont you think?

    well done.xx

  • this one always makes me cry

  • the bit where he is standing on that bridge with the water pooring down and he looks like he is in so much pain...god it gets me every time. great vid

  • that was beautiful... and so emotional

  • SOOO AMAZING made me almost cry :( i miss the old day when the doctor and rose would have crazy adventures together!!!!!

  • brilliant video - favouriting for repeat viewings!

  • really, really brilliant work! everything fitted perfectly... trying to write this through tears so you know you did good!

  • Okay so I know I must have seen this vid before but having watched it again it just got to me so much. A Doctor/Rose vid hasn't been able to do that in such a long while but I felt so depressed inside, it was terrible... and brilliant all at the same time! lol I think it was the colouring that did for me, not to mention the words are so haunting. *breaths* lol, You've made me wreck! I hope your happy with yourself! ;)

  • Sorry about that Soph. :) Hope you are feeling better now *passes tissue* . Considering this is one of my first vids i am so happy to see that it still provokes such an emotional response. My fav shot is at 1;04 when he looks at the empty tardis hearing the laughter of happier times. *sniff* Poor Doctor. :)

  • Oh tell me about it, that bit almost had me in tears! ;P lol

  • This really killed me. Honestly, it really did. I love this vid so much. <3

  • Whow, this is such an amazing video. The music is absolutely beautiful!

  • This video is excellent. I mean, I love all of your stuff, but I think this is particularly outstanding. If you intended to break my heart, it is a job well done. Seriously, though, brilliant video- the editing is excellent.

  • Awesome video..although i do love all of your stuff ^_^ can i ask...where is the clip from 1.14 from? x

  • Hi, the shot at 1;14 is from Runaway Bride series 3. Glad you enjoyed it :D x

  • thankyou for making that,

    it is the first time i realised just how much i missed Doctor Who,

    what a nerd, eh!

    but honestly,

    thankyou x

  • this made me cry, so it was amazing

  • I'd like to congratulate you on making a really great video. I've seen others, with the same song, but I really enjoyed your take on it. I've loved the new production of Dr.Who since the first season. The story of the Doctor and Rose is wonderfully conveyed here. I never quite got over it, and never quite liked Ms. Jones as much. I'm happy to hear Rose is coming back, even if she did annoy me at times.

  • Aqueoua:

    You have a very similar take on the new series to myself.

    I have really enjoyed the re-incarnation of the series. The pairing of the Dr and Rose was wonderful. i have warmed to Martha, and hope to make a video of her soon (but it definitely took a while) So glad you enjoyed this video, as it is a very popular song for The Doctor. x Sarah

  • this is an amazin vid i was wondering where u got the first bit from where he was saying sumthing like: if you talk to rose just tell her tell her oh shell no

  • The voice clip "If You Talk To Rose"... is from Satan's Pit Series 2 - When The Doctor is about to fall. x So glad you enjoyed it. :)

  • This video was amazing! and the song fit the Doctor soo well i loved it!

    Im so happy that Rose is coming back in the 4the season i just hope the doctor and rose get to meet each other! i think i would cry if they didnt let them see each other.

  • InstantJommyFan: Thanks.... It will be great to have her back, but i am sure we will all be devastated if they don't meet. :) Have to wait and see...

  • i lvoe this vidoe ti so cute and sweet

  • Hey! This looks like a REALLY good movie! Is there any way Americans can order this?

  • It actually a great British TV Series "Dr Who" :D... It's a great mix of fun, love and adventure. x

  • Oh yeah! I remember that when I was a little girl! They only had it on really late at night. I would sometimes sneak out to watch it without my mother knowing. This looks much better & not as scary.

  • I must admit the new production is truly wonderful. :D x Even i was surprised. I was like you, would sneak a peak as a child, but this is very, very watchable. :)

  • It looks really good. I wish there was a way that Americans could watch this. :( I'm feeling deprived.

  • I am pretty sure it is shown on the Sci Fi channel. I know quite a few american You Tuber's who make Dr Who fan videos. :D But renting the DVD's or downloading might be easier. :) x

  • Thanks! Yeah, I'll have to check out the rentals. I don't get the Sci-Fi Channel but I know you can rent just about anything. :)

  • I think this vid was damned great! Wonderful cuttings to a very suitable song! And I love this Doctor/ Rose story :-)

    5/5*

  • Can anyone give me a summary of this series?

  • What would you like to know? :) x

  • Well, just the main story that you based your video on.

  • i luv this vid so much!! i luv all ur stuff seduff!! great song choice. luvit.

  • AHhh. I can never stop watching this. I have watched it a trillion times already, I think. haha.

  • This makes me want to cry. I loved Rose. Glad she's coming back!

  • What movie is this?

  • It is from a serie called Doctor Who :) Glad to see you decided to watch this vid, thanks!

  • I'm not familiar with this series, but didn't he play in one of the Harry Potter movies, as Brty Crouch?

  • David Tennant? Yup, you got it.

  • i do think that they would off stayed togther as a good cuople but oh well i wonder how well and who the assistant will be

    mikas music rocks

  • lovely video - and I think Mika's music is great!

  • Hey Sheila! Good to see that you decided to watch it :)

  • Thanks so much for sending this to me! It was so neat and sad. I have never even watched this series! lol :) But it looks interesting.

  • Whaha, you are crazy XD Thanks for your sweet commment ^-^

  • My goodness! I've fallen in love with the serie because of this video :p (I only saw one episode hehe LOL) Faves for me, it is great, and this song is simply bewitching. The audio in the beginning worked so well. I loved the fastclipschanging around 1.30. This one will be send around ^-^!

  • Wow, thanks so much for sending it around! Series 2 was just BRILLIANT. The new series looks like it might be good too. Fingers Crossed! xx :D

  • hehe you are welcome! :) I shall search for it once!

  • OMG I LUV THIS VID!!!! gr8 work keep it up by the way when the doctor is talking at the beginning what episode is that from?? please get back to me x

  • That audio is from 'The Satan Pit' Series 2. When he is about to fall. Glad you like it. :D xx

  • OOHH YEHHH!!! fankzz x

  • hey seduff! it's me again... you're really good at making videos... and i commend your taste in songs. this is another great video... but now i HAVE to find season 2 & 3!... your videos make great advertisement-- they got my attention definitely!

  • You see..... These ARE great advertisements for the series. I have had quite a few say they want to purchase the DVD's now. :D As i have said before, i