Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:
see all

All Comments (229)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • God bless you, Neda. This is a true sacrifice, and i know you're in heaven now, you deserve it

  • Its so sad she lost her life for a cause that here in America some take for granted. A butterfly who still flying forever.

  • fake??? are your crazy?! theories and theories...

  • So glad I'm not a muslim. Lover of life, not a lover of death.

  • wow how sad...this makes me think this world is hell

  • The sacrafice she made will resonate forever.

  • Comment removed

  • Comment removed

  • for some Iranians like me,it's hard to ever be completely happy again with the memories of people like Neda and many others who people in the west don't know about. RIP dear Neda.

  • unfortunately, this is price we pay for freedom - bloodshed... as the motherland says.. give me blood and i shall give u freedom.... all countries did this at sometime.. to win freedom. the americans.. the indians.. from oppressors.. now its the time of the iranians! go ... we all support you guys in the world

  • Rest in Peace Neda.... Rest in Peace. This is really sad.... really, really, sad. =-(

  • thats sad.. r.i.p :(

  • typical middle east

  • what goes round comes around...Justice is a strange thing sometimes.....

  • stupid y killed women, prophet said even during war cannot killing women and childs . poor this lady.may allah bless her. 

  • at 49 seconds watch her left, hand she pours fake bood on herself......its fake.

  • @smellyasss you are fake

  • ...I think I peed my pants when she looked at the camera

  • Neda you are one of the Bravest woman I ever know.........RIP

  • RIP dear Neda <3

  • It's so terrifying how she gazes wide-eyed into the camera and she follows it around as she's DYING.

  • Rest in peace, Neda. <3

  • The promised land for the Iranian nation is to taste justice, freedom to express their views without fear, freedom to choose their destiny, a society that the good overcomes evil,

    The society that decent and just government respects the basic human rights and human dignity.

    "I have been to the mountain top and I have seen the promised land"

  • Rest in Peace

  • Rest In Peace

  • R.I.P !! 4 Eva

  • RIP Nada

  • that wasn't really her father by her side, it was actually her music teacher who was accompanying her along her friend to the protest against the results of the Irani elections.

  • the killers name is Abbas Kargar Javid he will be judged RIP NEDA

  • So, why can't the western world plan their presidents assassination? We can send men to the moon, build weapons that can kill everyone but we can't assassinate one man who is killing innocent people and is building nukes in secret? U.K, U.S, France, Germany better come together and figure something out!! This man could easily bring another world war. He loves russia, and hates the west....go figure!

  • I can´t believe I can´t believe I can´t believe I can´t believe I can´t believe I can´t believe I can´t believe I can´t believe I can´t believe I can´t believe I can´t believe I can´t believe I can´t believe I can´t believe I can´t believe I can´t believe ...This is so.. Awfull

  • this happened in 2009, just one year ago. How can something as ghastly as that happen in our time? Where is the power of the UN? where are the human rights? persecution of protesters, censorship of the media, disappearances havent this happened before? say, late 1930s in Germany? Hmmmmmm.

  • @leoleony1 human rights lol ? we think we free we realy not

  • @leoleony1 The Islamic Republic of Iran thinks they are above the UN or any humanitarian groups; they do NOT care what anybody thinks they will do what they want to do because they believe their Sharia Islamic law is above all else and this is how they rule their country.

  • man this is fucked up. putting a person on dying. as if there secure private life isnt bad enough being shot, some jerk puts a dying person on here. jesus. outa be laws against this. let the dying die in peace.

  • @oterotularosa It wasn't a private death or a private moment. In life, she was just another college student, in death she becomes a icon.

  • @oterotularosa She most certainly was not dying in peace. She had been shot in the daylight in the middle of a group of protesters. Not privately, nor peacefully.

  • Thats sad. I'm very sorry for the woman. This is not how things should be.

  • monsters from hell

    poor beautiful neda

  • look at her eyes. she wants to tell us something

  • i am so heart broke seeing this, my sister my sister my sister...... may Allah raise you with the martyres you have paid the ultimate price for freedom, we will carry the flag from now on and we wont let your blood dry in vain oh my sister peace be on you and all the ummah from Turkey.

  • @adanali85 adanali your comment was very moving to me. I can't put my finger on why, but it was. It's the first time I have ever been moved by a cry from the heart of another religion, so it felt a little strange to me to feel that way when I read what you wrote. This may sound cheesy coming from me -- but may your God's peace be on you too. As well as Neda.

    -an ex-military, Republican American

  • thank you. the truth my christian friend is ignorance and evil prevail in this world this is another e.g of it with Neda... A believer whoever it may be who truly believes in the existence of the 1 true GOD can never be intolerant and kill, He who loves God- loves life and wouldnt even kill a scorpion. the honor of Islam has been put to shame by acts of such barbaric incidences such as this,

  • FUCKING MILITIA COWARDS!

    R.I.P NEDA

  • @WAQWAQSAHAB

    you sick fuck, really??

    It is undeniably the work of the Islamic Republic that committed this grisly murder

    Everything bad in iran currently is because of these arab dogs that are called mullahs, dont deny it

    THE END IS COMING SOON

  • she was killed by british MI6 and filmed by BBC for propaganda purposes. everybody knows whar the brits amis and shitraelis have done to iranian people since coup against the democraticaly elected government of dr. mossadegh!!!

    stop your lies read history you asshole zionist sympathizer!

  • @WAQWAQSAHAB hehe you don't even believe that yourself. fact is Iran president is a Tyran and will always be. fact is that goverment controls the people with violence and torture. fact is. that you killed a innocent girl demonstrating. scary but true no wonder Iran will Never be respected in the civilized world. I'm really proud of the courage of the iranian people who demonstrate against the evil tyrany. Respect. so fuck off about propaganda the only propaganda is from your goverment

  • @660eye

    filthy disguised zionist thug! :-)

  • Neda's Call - Free Iran!!!

  • neda,,in haven---ahmedinajad go to hell werry son

  • That moment when she looks into the camera just before she dies.... thats haunting.

    And to all the people arguing about wounds, and if its fake or staged, I think you really missed the point here. Is that all you get out of this video?

  • @shutemdwn i dont think she looking at the camera, but i know what u mean, its the face of death, its crazy, where and what happens when we die, hope its fuking cool as fuk

  • @shutemdwn she wasn't looking at the camera, she was dead.

  • @shutemdwn THIS IS NOT FAKE. This wasn't fair. It's just... So... Sad. ):

  • @seshaiti13

    Every knee shall bow and every tongue shall confess that Jesus is Lord.......

  • @seshaiti13 Every knee shall bow and every tongue shall confess that Jesus is Lord.....

  • @seshaiti13 dude your crazy lol

  • so sad... omg

  • fcuk baseej ! the freedom coming soon

  • GOd bless her

  • Iran people should do something!

    I live in Ciudad juarez mexico

    and its sad to se much people die...and to se people dont make something

  • hey asshole, i read all your gibberish and i just wanna ask you, do people who have a heart attack just drop dead or does it take a couple of minutes? getting shot in the heart is the same as having a heart attack because your heart stops. but it takes a few moments before everything shuts down and you die. THIS IS REAL SO SHUT THE FUCK UP AND GO TO HELL IM SO SICK OF RETARDS LIKE YOU

  • i am iranian and i love ameicans.jast ahmedi nejad hate ameicans.iranian love ameicans.fauk ahmedi nejad

  • im Canadian, and its cool to hear that. I personally know many marines and army who have served over seas. One marine in perticular, is the hottest girl i know. Weird. Anyway, i know that all those brave people are doing it for the riht reasons, and im glad to hear someone aknowlege that

  • @2reza2 American people yes, we like them but not thir government. remember Reza the Coup d'etat of 28th of Mordad in Iran which overthrew the legal and democratic government of Dr. Mossadegh and established Hegemony in our country for another 60 years was orchestrated by Americans!!!!

  • @2reza2 Ziyad khaye mali nakon, Havas kari mesle Iraq o Afghanestan biyan koonet bezaran va nanato jelo cheshmet bokonand,,

  • @2reza2

    i believe you. My best friend's father is from Iran. My friend was born in America, is not Muslim, and lives a life that is not what you would call "Middle Eastern".

    She is visiting Iran for the first time in her life right now and she says she is having a great time.

    I wish you and your people happy lives <3

  • Breakingthescene: You are a plant! Soldiers and cops who have seen people die by gunshot will tell you that many peculiar things happen. Based on the poor quality video you have absolutely No grounds for writing your BS. Just for starters you do not have autopsy data to support any of your stupid allegations about the mechanics of death due to this victim's particular mortal injuries. P.S. death by violence is NOT like in the movies.

    The video is authentic and NOT staged...my opinion!

  • RIP USA

  • RIP USA and LONG LIVE AYATOLLAH AND THE MULLAH.

    DIE NEDA DIE!!!

    HIP HIP HOORAY!!!

    LONG LIVE SHARIAH!!!!

    Relax, of course i was being sarcatic.

    But anyway, they want the U.S and the Shah out of Iran and that's how they want to live and die under sharia. it's sad but true.

  • To breakingthescene:

    I dont think the shot was so mortal at first. She could be alive for some seconds terribly scared, high on adrenaline, and made that thing with her hand to not to fall.

    If the shot crossed the respiratory system or the digestive track, the blood will always run out from the mouth and nose.

    The blood in her eye, is just blood that flowed from the nose along the face.

    But of course I don't know for sure, I'm just expressing a different explanation.

  • how do you dare to give your opinion ,were you there? NO.

    I now enought of ballistics and arms to see this cannot be true

  • @ breakingthescene: and neither were you bitch! so how dare you give your opinion? run along now and go fuck your goat! and then go blow yourself up so you get some booty! cause your ugly ass can't get any otherwise!!!

    one more thing before i go, i shit on your quran everyday!

  • To breakingthescene:

    That thing on the eyes is not a consequence of dying but on getting unconscius. People can go back and forth into unconsciousness just for seconds.

    I dont think she was dragged to that place.

  • the man whos apparently her father is actually her music teacher, or a teacher. When she was shot she stood there staring at the woond in shock, and blood was spitting from the wound. Then the camera started rolling. What a terrifying and horrible way to die. She is a Hero.

  • @TomVu99

    Just by your comment i can tell you're one who doesn't think before they speak.

  • Even Americans hate Americans, they should all die too?

  • @WarriorMunk786 These Iranian protesters said: "death to america". Think about it.

  • @ TomVu99

    Alot of Americans are saying death to Obama too, they're burning his effigies. I can walk into any sports bar right now and if say yell "they suck" towards the home team i'll be lucky to walk out alive. And i'm talking about America buddy.

  • yeah monk you're right. but this is polictics and they are living by their own rules. the rules they are willing to protect and die for. Just like any other country. so what's the big deal with this video?

  • @TomVu99 you are so stupid!!!..maybe you should kill yourself when you wish other people's death..

  • Dude, relax. I was just being sarcastic. Of course Islam is a crime against humanity and there is the proof.

    Islam is failing.

  • Suprising how this can shock the world , we see worse things here in Juarez Mexico, the drug war has killed alot of innocent people including children,entire familys. Over 400 women raped and murderd and no one can help ......sad what the world has come to.

  • Cette jeune femme a donné sa vie pour défendre la liberté dans son pays, c'est un exemple de courage.

  • I am actually surprised and saddened that someone was taking a video even in the middle of such a tragedy

  • so who's going to write the history books if not those who immortalize remarkable moments like these. Your martyr would be nothing without a video picturing this insignificant person being shot through her head. Such a simple incident reaches disproportionate standards when monitoring through western mimeograph machine that has completely become alienated from the very basic features of human nature such as survival through bloodshed. Allegorically we're a power cord between USA and universe.

  • of course people take pictures when a drama is staged

  • what have we all become

  • RELIGION (learn to spell, theferranzzz) isn't the muderer, EXTREMISM is. There are millions of peaceful religious people around the world, but extremists for ANY cause (religious/political/whatever) are the ones who cause death & destruction.

  • hey...not all

  • ...USA killed million people "in the name of God" too..so ?

  • So let them kill under their own god

  • revoltante a forma com éla morreu, vi fotos e documentarios é éra uma jovem e bela mulher não merecia isso, tenho ódio destes países do oriente médio.

  • eu tambein

  • the one true answer is simple and does not lay with in one race, religion, or ideologie. the one and only truth to this evil act is universly known as.... human nature.. welcome to mankind.

  • This is NOT a fake video. Show some respect to her!

  • this is 120% a fake video!!

    Bad a really bad one, how can you be so blind?

  • fake video..freeze frame at :044..look at the hands of the man..already blooded..0:49..look at that blood it doesn't look a squirt from her nose..the flow of the flood is poured from something..this is not the video...but i salute Neda for fighting for freedom!

  • The topic says "Woman Killed named Neda is now a martyr for Irans protest movement"

    We dont know if shes a martyr. Allahu 3alim.

  • I am going to pretend that I didn't read any of comments down below. They are more disturbing than the video. People who have lost touch as what is real or fake should start traveling to real places where plastic -world is not the way of life. Neda , you voice is heard loud and clear. Keep singing.

  • Dooroood bar Azadi, Doorood bar Azadikhah, Doorood bar supporter of Freedom, RIP Neda

  • give noble prize to mosavi , like his fucking partner Shirin ebadi

  • ندائی هست دائم بر مزار این ندا

  • @tomilia: I saw you are Swiss. I'n Dutch. Once an American told me "Yes I visited your country (the Netherlands), you have very high mountains."

    Mon Dieu!

  • @texdaddy123: "I", "I", "I".... You make a classical mistake by thinking that an attack on you is an attack on the USA and vice versa. This only proves how stupid you are. I never said a word about you. I did not need to. You sort of say it yourself over and over again.

    @tomilia: hear-hear!

  • ??????

  • @TexDaddy123: most Americans never gave a shit about politics or anything else that involves using your brain. Your statement about yourself is nice but it does nog change this statistical fact. And I can tell, as I travelled the USA and found out myself.

  • you see, what is ridiculous is that you put me in the same category as everyone else JUST because i'm american. i'm not out there trying to say we are better than everyone else. personally, i think bush was horrible and obama will now be the downfall of everything we remotely had after bush. but you people from other countries do nothing but judge. visiting the USA does NOT fill you in on the mindset of 300 million other people.

  • I am american, he dosent have to visit us, he probably knows already. We are idiots, fat, arrogant, ignorant, poorly educated, idiots. We consume, consume, consume. At the same time we are raping the environments so that we can, for a brief moment wring a few droplets of pleasure from this life. This life that we have taken for granted. Each day is a gift, not a given right. Each day we are protected behind american walls, where elsewhere life is as fleeting as a summer breeze. Don't be fooled.

  • you are just as ignorant as the people you mock. the fact that you make redundant comments to summarize a people as diverse as its landscape shows how immature and uneducated you are. i feel sorry for you. it must be incredibly boring and depressing walking through your life of cliches and stereotypes while viewing everyone from a superficial perspective. instead of posting frivolous comments to youtube, why dont you go read a book or do your homework. it would be a benefit to all involved.

  • I find that last statement of yours hypocritcal on your part, as i used spectacular word choice in that comment that is not generally seen on the internet. Look past your arrogant nationalism and see what we're doing to everyone else. Its time to finnaly stop picking sides.

  • I find it to be no suprise that someone like you trolls around in threads like this. All you do is post otiose prejudicial rhetoric for the purpose of self validation. There are many facets of American life and ideals that I do not agree with; however to paint its people with a single stroke of a stereotype simply exposes your convictions as well as your comprehensive intelligence. den eneste ideen jeg arrogant forkynne er for individualisme. hvis bare du var smart nok til å see.

  • És ezt mi a tökömért kell kamerázni?????

  • That was fucking bull shit...That day I was in Enqilab SQ.

  • the president of iran should be removed from power he is an animal......he calls america evil...he is worse than sadam and should be stoned to death...

  • america is in any case evil:):) fuck the USA

  • Comment removed

  • fuck you, i'm an american and we aren't all bad. the fact that you would generalize us and say we're all evil just makes you a dick. if you actually came here maybe you'd find that we aren't all sucking our govt's dick like everyone else around the world thinks. we're no different from you so don't generalize us based on where we live, asshole.

  • yes, yes, for sure!!

    You speak like all other americans therefore you are the same stupid shit like all the others!! I don`t see any difference between you and the rest of USA!!

    There is no good americans, point!

    I generalize like I want!!!

    Your empire is finished and you too!!!

  • wow, i speak like all other americans just because i'm defending myself? i don't think you realize what people are really like over here. most of us don't agree with our government. most of us DO struggle for money. i think it's pretty sad for you as a person to generalize and hate people who probably work harder than yourself.

  • no it was because you said all of america is evil. i also suggest you learn some english so i can at least understand what the fuck you're saying. first off, we aren't "members" of the USA, second, i have nothing to do with my politicians. i hated bush and i sure as hell hate obama too. just because they're my leaders doesn't give you the right to call me arrogant. i work hard and go to school, i'm in the middle class probably just as yourself.

  • you're pretty immature for being like... 34. arrogant must be the only word you know.

  • all the same shit? what a hypocrite. so typical, you're exactly an example of what you hate about americans. if i say something against you its because im a "typical ignorant american". both of you swiss and dutch guys need to stop complaining about america and worry about your own damn countries.

  • I am speaking only about me, you and this video!This video is a fake! I am a journalist and sociologist and I have analised the two videos of this scene at the TV station where I work: this famous video is a fake!You americans are trying to do the same "pouch" in Iran (for Israel) like in Honduras, Chile, Nicaragua and more!P.S: Do you really think that if you are against Bush and Obama you are a good guy?I survived Genua in 2001 and I will fight all my life against the USA-UK Empire!

  • lol i am not a part of my country's politics, how many times do i must tell you? im a good person because of my actions, not who i support. im aware that this video is a possible fake. i do NOT support a war with iran, i didnt support one with iraq. why are you STILL trying to generalize me as "bad"? just because i LIVE here? i don't have the option of living elsewhere and if that bothers you then you're an asshole.

  • you're a journalist?

    prove it.

  • seriously its fake?!?! wut do u mean how is it fake? :S

    p.s i totaly support the last point about fighting against the US and UK empire

  • its not

  • our empire is finished?

    ur a european. Your empire was finished 60 years ago, and now your entire nation is gonna die a slow death b/c of all the muslims you let into your countries.

    I would bet my house that by the time i die (supposing i live to a ripe old age), the netherlands and france wont be democracies anymore

  • but if you canadians still have a queen living in the UK is this a democratic state?

    Are you against muslims? If yes also we can stop to write togheter!!

  • I dont know what on earth the queen as anything to do with what we're talking about. She has literally zero say on any aspect of the country.

    Am I against Muslims? I am against their takeover of the world. They seem to have this priority of spreading their sharia law over the entire world, and I think everyone should do everything in their power to keep liberty and freedom alive

  • empire=Queen/King

    takeover of the world???

    Sorry, but where do you live?? In Canada? Have you there problems with muslims?? By us in Switzerland there is no problems with them, we live togheter and nobody is killing each other! You are, in my opinion a little bit too much influenced from the USA-Israel media propaganda! Murdoch is not a jew?

    The Bush family was not one of the best friends of the Emir and King of Saudi Arabia?

    Sorry but the problem is not the religions but the politics.

  • lol you have no clue about the world's politics, do you. Forget about the fact that the Queen has no influence in Canada's parliament, she is also nothing more than a symbol in Britain itself.

    And i cant comment on switzerland, i dont know enough about that country. But there is no doubt about holland and france. My entire family is dutch, and all of my remaining relatives there constantly complain about the Islamic problem..pretending its not there only quickens the continent's demise..

  • holland and france are extreme cases (and I think you know it) and only 2 country of 28!! Spain,Germany, UK and Italy?

    Have you problems with muslims in Canada?

    Is your family still alive or the muslims have stolen all?

    Or better: do you have problems with people from indonesia or malaysia?:)

    Sorry but what do you write is in my opinion only a pregiudice and nothing more.

    In Switzerland we have a very bad community: the tibetan:) They are against China:)

    Please, tell me something interesting

  • Truth is, the same problem exists in the UK, and is starting to spread in Italy and Spain. Which then does make up a signficant majority of the continent.

    I dont really have a problem with Muslims in Canada. They generally dont pour acid on women, dont kill documentary authors who dare express their freedom of expression, and dont riot in the streets because of cartoons in obscure newspapers. ALthough, there was an honour killing of a 14 year old girl last year

  • I agree with every damn thing you are saying. Say it like it is, because its the damn truth and I am so tired of people sugar coating. Thank god someone isn't scared to express his or her own opinion.

  • my general point is that Muslims and democracy are mutually exclusive...Unless they completely integrate into whatever country they emigrate to, they dont fit in with democratic society. In fact, they end up becoming a threat to democracy. I only hope that Canada and America never have to experience the hopelessness that Holland feels its in regarding its future prospects as a liberal, modern democratic country.

  • muslims are a brutal force that knows no limitations. Here in Canada they are nothing less than destructive, disruptive and satisfied with nothing less than violence, murder, oppression, and hatred....they lie, kill, bomb, deceive, disrupt and sow discontent and misery...islam must be wiped from the face of the world for all that is decent, right and just....Neda is just one more notch in the belts of devout muslims around the world....her death is their pride...this must not stand!!!

  • "Is your family still alive or the muslims have stolen all"...

    Funny you mentioned that, whenever I go to visit my relatives in Holland and Germany, they dont let me walk around with a kippah anymore (im jewish) b/c theyre scared i'll be attacked.

    The new synagogue in Munich was built with no windows, and all stone, b/c the congregants there are scared they'll be shot at...I saw it with my own eyes.

    As i said before, if you think the islamic problem doesnt exist in Europe, you're nuts

  • First of all, where are you getting all this stuff? Second of all, we will never understand the media or who is behind it so its about time we stop stereotyping and making generalizations. The point is Islamic propaganda, sharia law, dogma threaten liberty and individuality. Lets talk about that, and not about US and the Israel, nothing is certain. However, we are certain about the threat that sharia poses

  • I absolutely agree. There is a difference between allowing people to believe what they want to be believe and a difference between allowing their dogma "sharia law" in western society. It is very dangerous and threatens everything we have built up. I feel sorry for Neda and thousands of others who have died for this cause.

  • shut the fuck up!! you say all these things about the USA but atleast people arent dying for basics rights here not the same as other countries! talk about ignorence

  • really?

    Are you sure?

    Iraq,Afganistan, Chile, Nicaragua,Honduras,Venezuela??

    Do you want to re-write the history? Or better: do you want to talk with me about ignorance?

    PLEASE...PLEASE

  • When the powers that be fuck up..boy do they fuck up! Neda / how appropriate to be translated into "the calling"

    Americans..stand up and take note how change happens by energy when one force returns and equal and opposing force. The Iranian government royally f'd this one up. Don't they know..people will not tolerate their voice not heard? You can only do this for so long.

    The universe has a funny way of balancing itself out..let that be a lesson to power mongerers of the planet.

  • i know that this is one death out of thousands world wide, but, it is so moving. that look in her eyes pulls you into her death. she should be a martyr for the entire planet to change how we ALL live.

  • Thousands of people all over the world die from crimes like these. It was just an opportunity for some criminal to put his name on a bullet that killed this young woman. use politics as an excuse if you may.

  • how do you know so much? why is this not a government bullet? why try to distance the government?

  • well now we know why some fools created the sect shia....only to gain power!!!like the BASTARD khomeiny......he teaches the shia's that there is only 12imams and the last one's mehdi(well he was killed by some one only to gain power) but today khomeiny's an imam??!! fuck him hell bleed in hell

  • wow..all these americaleedn hypocrates are bleeding their hearts over here, but not a tear for millions americans have killed in Vietnam, Iraq directly, or in latin america supporting the tyrants...thousands have women been raped by yankee troops and children slaughtered...we all know..but not a shed of tear for that bloodbath...and look at the hypocrates.. i guess it is just a liberal fad, for the intellectul yanks to talk on dates and later get drunk and scew each other

  • exactly!!!

  • I wish the price of FREEDOM was not so expensive! Dear Neda you will always live in our hearts. Roohat shad!

  • All the same how often I see it, reads, I hears cry to cry about the too young student the NEDA. WHY?????? Why do innocent have to die? STOPT IT FINITE. HEARS ON THEREBY. Enough humans died

  • The people of the world need to take a step back and look at the kind of societies we've created.

    Instead of arguing about it on youtube, shouldn't we all - including myself - be thinking about what we can do about it?

  • oraroai piaporo makinai miriki macakai no doin