nightwish- wishmaster live in lowlands 2008 (with anette)

[nightwish22893]

Looking back at this now, i can't believe that Youtube used to be such a bad quality video... first time im watching this since the upload ;)

[maxadrienne2]

Ignoring the horrible voice and always singing out of tune...

Marco + Anette + prerecorded vocals cannot reach the power of Tarja when singing.

Anette's vocal energy is so low that the whole band must sing quietly to let her be heard.

[Chevymonster203]

@maxadrienne2 Well you can also state that Tarja's voice is no where near as good as Liv Kristine. Now she can sing.

[maxadrienne2]

@Chevymonster203

Friend, are you deaf or just replying for spite?

Tarja and Liv are friends since the 90's, did duets many times and also did a tour together.

Liv is a big fan and admirer of Tarja's.

Of course Liv has a good voice, but to compare her with Tarja is funny.

.

Hear them here where they are dueting. The best way to make a comparison.

/watch?v=_32x2exb01c

If you still don't hear the difference, I rest my case.

[maxadrienne2]

@Chevymonster203

Pay special attention after 3:00, where Tarja is singing both lowest and highest voice in the duet.

Skill, power, finesse. And what a naturally beautiful voice and sensibility.

Can't imagine how you or anyone else may hear a performance like this and be able to continue talking bullshit.

[zukarocks]

In my opinion!!! This fucking thing sucks!!! >.<

[tetetutu]

wtf??? Tarja Fever!

[bridgetxrose]

im sorry anette, nut dont sing tarjas songs. its not your style.

[GrammarTrolll]

As an Anette fan, she sang this chorus good with Marco. But this is definitely not Anette's style. The Imaginaerum album is more of her area.

[AvetOvDnaEvol]

Both versions, by Tarja and Anette, give me goosebumps.

[jdarkhell1]

o my god...ts seams like her had been a potato in your mouth........kkkkkkkkkkkkkk he's is very bad!!

[klausxxx92]

Listen Wishmaster from end of an era and tell me once more that anette is better than tarja.

[MrThenova25]

this is one of my fav songs i love the guitar rift! 

[TheMariko35]

OMG TARJA LEFT ON HER OWN MOTHER FUCKING FREE WILL SO EVERYONE SHUT UP!!!!!! THAT WAS YEARS AGO!!!!!! AND IF U JUST WANNA SAY ALL THIS CRAP ABOUT ANETTE THEN U ALL HAVE NO DAMN LIFE'S AT ALL!!!!!! SO WHAT SHE IS NOT AN OPERA SINGER!!!!! SHE CAN STILL SING VERY WELL!!!!!!!

[appriltwister]

lamparaa!!!............ 

[Micanchepe]

Tarja volvéeeee D:

[umbrellamx0307]

Despues de leer todo esto resumo en que nadie puede superar el trauma de hace un poco mas de 4 años... Por mas que hagan drama Tarja nunca va a regresar, lo que me deja tranquilo es que a Tuomas no le importa lo que piensen.

[edgarmexfut]

That Edward Scissorhands is incredible!

[maxirata7]

A ver...no entiendo por q se critica tanto a Annette. Ella no tiene la culpa de que los miembros de la banda la hayan elegido como vocalista. Los que se equivocaron fueron ellos al seleccionar una vocalista que no tiene ni el registro ni el estilo de Tarja. Hace lo mejor que puede. De mi punto de vista no la canta mal, lo q pasa es q le cambia mucho el estilo al tema. Pero insisto en que en todo caso la culpa es de los demás...

[itzaramaja]

@maxirata7 Anette tiene un registro altísimo, por Dios, yo soy cantante y la escucho y me admiro. Lo que pasa es que tienen estilos de cantar muy distintos. Tarja era cantante de ópera. Anette canta con estilo contemporáneo. Aparte, Tarja ni en sueños podría cantar las canciones contemporáneas que Anette sí puede, se escucharía raro. Y en general, saca a Tarja de su ópera y la música clásica y no te funciona; Anette como cantante funciona para estilos musicales más versátiles.

[diegonwfed]

@itzaramaja si podria.. solo se escucharia diferente, como es el caso de esta cancion y muchas otras canciones, seria basicamente lo mismo q a estas alturas, oyeramos a Tarja cantando Amaranth por ejemplo...

[dark7700]

@maxirata7 culpa de que? que hizo anette?

[dark7700]

no se pide que cante como tarja ;), lo hace a su estilo y es un buen tema cantado por nettie, la verdad me sorprende cada vez mas esta sexi mom nettie ;)

[NabilaScreaming]

anette sucks!!!!



[TheMetalHokie]

@NabilaScreaming she is fucking just fine, stop being a faggot of the past, things change get used to them

[TheMariko35]

@NabilaScreaming If u think that then stop watching the vids and stfu.... u jealous f*ck...

[antonsdefrancua]

She singed very well and I like her singing style!

If you don't like, why you ever come here?

[felipefgdp]

Ela tá dançado a dança do Carlton? Carlton's, of the Fresh Princen Dance?

[ruizquecandro]

sin tarja no son nada ¬¬

[Silferas]

Anette needs to be high fived. Into face. With a chair...

[antonsdefrancua]

@Silferas And you needed to put in jail!

[Silferas]

@antonsdefrancua what did I need to put there? I don't really recall any such a thing.

[manikmorta]

nooo.. deles pena.. Nigthwish???deberían cambiarse el nombre... les propongo nightmare !!!!

[TheScorpiB]

Anette cant sing like Tarja ..... just anette suck

[truermt]

why so many dislikes? tbh i like it

[DamageIncM]

And now watch this: watch?v=eJTlH521E6w

And this: watch?v=zVAnP2fHFys

pwnt

[DamageIncM]

Oh, and also, stop making close-ups of the Edward Scissorhands figure, it's cheap and we all know Tuomas wants to be Johnny Depp...

[DamageIncM]

What were they thinking hiring her?

I mean, their last album has awesome and great songs on them. (apart from the frickin' mastering-quality)

But did they even think about her singing the songs Tarja sang??

Now it sounds boring and you don't have that epic high voice anymore...

[ElAngelLucifer]

popmasterdance be the new nightwish song with the singer

[vivustemporis]

its not bad.. but its not nightwish.. but the version is still coool

[PunkConnieArmstrong]

i so want tarja back into band

[sepak17]

i wanna hear her orgams :D

[ilusionperdida]

It's hilarious how Tarja fans think it's horrible/awful. Obviously, Nightwish (and by that I mean the real/current members) thought she was good enough to sing their old stuff. Both of their vocals are completely different and both are great in their own way. Anette is Nightwish's voice now and all of you stuck in the past need to get over yourselves.

[AirlordRobin344]

Anette and Nightwish is just as good.

[AirlordRobin344]

Anyone think this is bad is just jealous Anette you can at least not so keep your mouth shut>: (.

[ElMetaleroManu]

IS A SHIT!!!

[ccffviifan1]

This is awfull.

[TheSaramond]

Anette can't spell all words and Tarja is monster :)

[TheSaramond]

Marco is the best singer

[TheStormtruper]

Its like this Tarja is like female Bruce Dickinson and Anette is like female Michael Bolton

[pavcon]

I'm not into the comparison thing.. But I like this song with Annete SOOOO MUCH BETTER than Tarja

[xroxanneX02]

Holly shit ths is disgusting... miss Tarja so muck

[dawoopbanana]

shes not really 'singing' this, she focasing more on actually saying the lyrics than letting her voice flow, its sounds nice when it flows :/

[ikariam007]

its doesnt matter who sing (: nightwish is the best band :D with annette or tarja...

[darkdragon7fisher]

Anette's voice is less boring and more energetic, it has that umfhh and is not looooooooong, super high and booooooooring like Tarja.

[geelicon]

@darkdragon7fisher What can we expect from someone who just "likes" the music and doesn't even know how to appreciate it

[rsimion3]

@darkdragon7fisher

There are guys that like ugly chicks, girls that like fat guys and so on.. I can understand that, I also understand people that like Anette.

But to say Tarja has a high long boring voice (wtf does this mean btw) ... dude you deserve the fat ugly chick :)

[AbbeyDraven]

fuck everybody, i like anette's performance

[azabache1525]

@AbbeyDraven yeah boy

[Surise]

Wow.. It's been almost 6 years already and still no matter what Nw video I happen to watch on Youtube, people are still having this Anette vs. Tarja thing going on. Well, makes me glad that at least I have a life.

[mrGrolish]

Van canto cover is better than this :(

[TheDundolina]

chipmunk in jeans with mike :)

[efielXD]

please do new song and dont sing tarjas song the band have to do too many changes to fit the anette's voice to tarja's songs

[SabrinaSiren]

With Tarja they were gods...now they're meh and tarja alone is kinda mehh./:

at least i can still listen to their old stuff and go -> :D

[Issametal666]

Oh God! Anette sing horrible the old songs!! is much better if she sing only your songs.

[madshot101]

@Issametal666

Then people would whine about the band not playing the old songs anymore

[Issametal666]

@madshot101 but the new band don't should playing the old songs, because is so different the Anette's voice and Tarja's voice.

[madshot101]

@Issametal666

Yes, it sounds different, but its not any worse

If Nightwish played only their new songs, people at live concerts would not go there anymore

let them play, its the music, not the voice, that makes nightwish

[Issametal666]

@madshot101 You Know you're right but, look Anette don't have voice for sing this songs. so when she sing Tarja's songs, her voice it's false and the sound is ugly. The New nightwish is good but before were gods

[madshot101]

@Issametal666

Yes, i guess you're right, though i still think Annettes voice with the new songs makes them more special than the rest.

[Issametal666]

@madshot101 well... u can have that idea, my idea is that Tarja was better 4 Nightwish. but Anette is not bad singer.

[JaxxTheBlade]

I think she sounds like she's sort of yelling in this one. Don't get me wrong, I love Anette, as well as Tarja, but I really think Anette's voice doesn't fit a song like this.

[crashlove768]

I CANT EVEN RECOGNOISE THE SONG IN SOME PARTS

THIS IS DISGUSTING

[voytassss]

Of course there ain't no doubts about Tarja being the soul of this band, but still. Tarja filled her slot in Nightwish much better than Anette. That's all true, BUT! Let's not forget the fact, that Anette was still able to cover this song in her own, amazing way.

It sounds different and somehow strange indeed, but it still sounds great, tell me if it doesn't?

[zouru]

I don't know but it just feels like some chick singing karaoke with a live band...

[demonhoopa]

People stuck in the past please go find Tarja's crappy new videos and worship her. Nightwish and their fans, while grateful for the past, have moved on.

[theprophet113]

i like nightwish with tarja and anette,but i think that they are each good for certain songs only, i think anette needs to stick with their new songs instead...cause seriously i did not think this was good, and wishmaster is my second favorite song by nightwish (end of all hope being my first) anette just doesnt have the right voice for this song

[tatoskate18]

Nightwish is not the same without Tarja

[AriadneCS7]

-.-

[perkeleentyyppi]

Nightwish is nothing without Tarja! And this video proves it



[c1k4ml3kc3]

OMG WHAT A FAIL !!!

[broque14]

Tarja: DRESS

Anette: JEANS

no words...

[nightwish22893]

@broque14 I can remember the good ol' days, when Tarja came up to the stage with Rubber outfits.

[demonhoopa]

@broque14 Oh yes a cute girl in jeans. Shudder the thought! LOL

[TheMetalHokie]

@broque14 who cares?

[itzaramaja]

@broque14 Maybe Anette wears jeans cuz she's a fucking human being and she also wants to be comfortable once in a while????? I don't care what all haters say, Anette sounds amazing here, she doesn't need to be an opera singer or wear a fucking disguise to prove she's great, and I actually prefer the contemporary edge she gives to Nightwish songs. Tarja is great also, but she's no longer Nightwish vocalist, so get over it, haters.

[broque14]

ANNETTE MUST TO SING POP MUSIC!! just look how she dresses, how she dances, and how she sings!! there's NO F*CKING WAY!!

[lacrimaangelux]

oooo Tuomas eres tan hermoso *.*  Anette is sucks !!

[isai641]

le da un toque espesial la anette

[Keatszie]

Oh Tuomas , were you drunk ? ;(

[GouByu]

Oh no. Anette fucked with Wishmaster. It's like: "OOOOOOOOOOOOOO ELBEREEEEEEEEEE".

Oh, Nightwish, what are you without Tarja?

[markojudas]

I'm sorry but this sounds like a glorified local "garage" band. I do like Anette, I really do but this version should be ONLY sang by Tarja...as well as all the songs originally sang by Tarja. All the other songs they are great and perfect for Anette...but this version almost killed this song for me.

[TheGiraf2]

I think this version is great, I like the tarja version more, but this is still very good. I wish I would have a band with either Tarja or Anetta as singer :)

[jahabdank]

I really wonder why all the fans of nightwish say Anette is any good. It it obvious that the Nightwish is dead, and now it is just any band. People saying Anette is good, sound like a grandma saying to her grandchild that an awful drawing he made looks pretty. It is a pitiful convincing that something is great, which actually is not. It is ok, but there dozens of bands as good. But Nightwish + Taria was exceptional, like none other.

[jahabdank]

well, they downgraded themselves from an exceptionally great opera metal band to a good heavy band. It is a good song, and a good preformance ... but only good. not extraordinary ...

[darkroronoa]

oh god

[timosha21]

i just don't understand why they did not audition opera singers for singer of nightwish... just saying... it would have been cool to hear a male opera voice singing some of these songs or a different female opera voice on these songs...

[svensudhoven]

omg datz pure fail. Tarja ftw

[Paxke666]

OMG horribly this !!!! Nightwish should be ashamed doing this !!!!

Hail Tarja !!!

[lazarus8472]

While I like Nightwish with Anette she simply doesn't have the voice to do this song justice. I'm really unimpressed with her perfomances live.

[MaacTavish]

I give Anette credit, must of been hard to TRY and sing this song how Tarja did, but it just doesn't sound like it at all.

[diegotrn]

R.I.P Nightwish

[Digitbig]

What did you expect them to do after they replaced Tarja? Stop playing all the songs they recorded with her? You can't reasonably expect Anette to be able to sing exactly like Tarja. They're different people.

[SultanOfTheOrient]

WTF IS THIS!!?? THIS IS MADNESS!

[jahabdank]

@SultanOfTheOrient THIS IS SPARTA :)

[BloodErotica]

Taja own this song

[heavylord666]

Shit Anette, Tarja rulez

[TheBerny1996]

with Tarja its more epic xD

[lScarlettl]

She ruins this song and the whole band... :-<

[Juanjovolador]

I like both, so shut up : )

[MikeDaysOfGrace]

just watching Tarja's version, switched on this after...

Cant hear it more than 30 secs.

[vlodvek777]

She thinks she will be the next britney spears or smthing,nah man im just not convinced,doesnt sound the same.

[DumbThingsMakeSense]

2:22 DIE DAVY JONES !!!

[FRenchCore51]

@DumbThingsMakeSense +1,000 xD

[demonhoopa]

@szpiderman Wow. Well if you call what Annette does "screaming", I can't imagine what you'd say about the vocals of ACDC.

I must confess, when I hear Amaranth or The Poet and The Pendulum, I'm not reminded of The Plasmatics or Accept. Sorry, just don't see it. But maybe it's me, maybe Annette is shrieking all the way through Eva and I just don't realize it because of all the hearing damage from all the metal concerts I went to in the 80's. :)

[demonhoopa]

@szpiderman Annette does a great job on this song. I just watched the End of An Era version here on Youtube and actually, Tarja struggles quite a bit with it. Lots of gasping for breath. But we build things up in our minds and it sometimes clouds things.

[blackwOrldband]

I Wish Anette would try strengthening her voice at the Chorus part of this song

co'z it has a solid tone :)

[Maria1paz1]

este es un cover !jajajaja

[Maria1paz1]

esta es una payasada! 

[Fistler01]

353 thumbs down because tarja is out of band

[stevenjsmith87]

i love anette but i dont think she has this song down yet but i see it with time :)

[stevenjsmith87]

@Fistler01 Tarja wasnt really ment to be in the band as long as she was Tuomas just called her up to do a demo for him. Its true look it up and listen to alot of the interviews

[Turdman12]

@stevenjsmith87 Dude is REAL lucky she did that demo then....and as far as this song goes, Anette does fine, not her fault she doesn't sing in a soprano voice, not everyone can, holy hell. I actually like Sacrament of the Wilderness MORE with Anette, look for it live folks, Anette rocks that song good

[Turdman12]

@SamiosPythagoras Neither can you. Remove yourself from the internet and go find a cliff to swandive off with a microwave tied around your neck

[jacobvangoethem]

not hatting on Anette but i think that this song was done better by Tarja besides Anette has good songs that she has done

[Fistler01]

i see the sadness in the leadguitarist`s eyes because tarja must leave the band -.-

[saragetsi]

recordemos que la era de la sr. Turunen a terminado y todo tiene que cambiar, en lo particular me gusta el cambio pero sin olvidar de que cada una tiene su estilo aun asi sigue siendo nightwish y el maestro de la musica Thoumas.

[SpazMiss]

Socks and sandals... I just lost a bit of respect for Marco lol

On another note, I love this song, the music is amazing and the fact that Tuomas could adapt a song like Wishmaster to Anette voice speaks volumes about his talents. Live on Nightwish, I support you. 

[MegaWishmasterMario]

"I Love Nightwish with Tarja and with Anette". The true nightwish fans says This!!!!

[Budaguyeh]

@MegaWishmasterMario Very well said! A true Nightwish fan will support that statement as will say it on a daily basis.

[3LRusS1To]

@MegaWishmasterMario you should be kidding, isn't it? There is no Wishmaster without Tarja...

[MegaWishmasterMario]

@3LRusS1To Tarja is definitely higher. But I hate people who say that Nightwish is a band over. Better listen to the Nightwish with Anette, Tarja's solo instead

[3LRusS1To]

@MegaWishmasterMario ok I respect your opinion, but as everything in life it is just a like or dislike matter.

From my side, Nightwish (with Tarja) was one of my 3 favorites bands (you don't want to know the other 2 haha), probably that's the reason because I can't enjoy the current composition of the band with Anette.

[MegaWishmasterMario]

@3LRusS1To I do not pretend that everyone should listen to nightwish with anette. I only ask fans to tarja, to respect the band who so loved and respected us who love nightwish. that s all

[AllisonJohnny]

I like Anette too, but Tarja ownz

[jahabdank]

@MegaWishmasterMario unless you are a fan of opera metal, not necessarily Nightwish ;) There are other bands doing great music ... recently the best is Within Temptation

[PunkAnarq07]

@MegaWishmasterMario You need face the truth, dude.Anette hasn't tarja's talent.

It's like anette is 10 and tarja is 100, very large diference.

[IMPISSOFF]

@MegaWishmasterMario They really just say " I love Nightwish."

[cabopineda]

@MegaWishmasterMario Totally agree!

[killmasterin]

guys i think that we are all used to hear tarja's voice. So i find it extremly logical that none of us prefer annete than tarja. But that does not mean tha annete is not a good singer. Although i think some tarja's songs must not be touched (like this one) cause they are butchered. How the hell she expected to say wishmaster? I think nightwish must put a redline between past and future and start all over again forgeting all their previous songs.

[SpazMiss]

@killmasterin Why? Because they got a new front woman? That justifies having four men leave everything they've accomplished in the dust? Tarja still sings the old songs at her shows, but Nightwish, as a band, can't?

[3LRusS1To]

@SpazMiss I think they can, in fact they should, that's great, some fans just want lo listen to the "band".

but from my point of view, the singer is one of the most important part of the band, he/she (in this case) gives identity,

[3LRusS1To]

@SpazMiss so Nightwish as band can play the old songs that Tarja used to sing, but they never will sound as they did, in the other hand, Tarja with almost any good musicians will be able to play Nightwish songs quite similar as she did a few years ago, again it is just my point of view, but I do believe Tarja by her own is more Nightwish than Nightwish itself... weird hehe

[inutaisho94]

Nightwish just isn't the right band for Annette's voice...and Anette just shouldn't sing..xD

[legomand1000]

anette is better to the new songs and tarja the old

[samuraihax]

TARJA FOREVER !

[synyst3erivan]

Anette rules!!!... fucking diva tarja sucks!!!! >.<

[SerasxAlucard]

@synyst3erivan Yes. Thank you. TO HELL WITH ALL THE ANETTE HATERS!

NIGHTWISH RULES \m/!

[vchancu]

SOUND LIKE ROXETTE :))

[rentao89]

@synyst3erivan u are idiots u know that

this is veryyyyyyyyyyyyyy badddddddddd

[synyst3erivan]

@rentao89 jajajajaja take it easy, you idiot, it's just a singer get a life dude.... jajajaj o crees q tarja te va a compensar por defenderla?? jajjaajajaja

[Tallytinhathy]

BoOm.....e adoro a Tarja,mas gente,nós temos que nos conformar com a Anette...

ou vocês pensam que criticando a anette,a tarja vai voltar??Hello....não....

então vamos dár uma chance pra ela né.....e ela ñ canta  mal....

by.....

[lilithvampire20]

THIS IS A SHIT! TARJA RULES! \m/

[xerxesmv]

I don't have anything against Anette, but this sounds like a cover

[jeatjeatjeat]

STUPID BASTARDS !! U DNT KNOW HOW TO ANALYZE !! ALL U CAN DO IS TO THORW STUPID COMMENTS!! TARJA= OPERA VOICE, ANETTE=POP TYPE. NOWADAYS OPERA VOICE CANNOT COMPETE ON POPS THATS WHY THEY ADDED ANNETTE TO HAVE SOME POP-ROCK INGREDIENT TO NIGHTWISH!! STUPID DUMBASSSESSS!!

[acht71]

I never understood all you Tarja lovers. I agree she can sing oprea but the dynamic in her voice often does not fit the songs, and since she only sings oprea it oftens does not sound very good. Check put ReVamp, their vocalist can sing both opera and rock, a great combination. What makes Nightwish a special band is not Tarja or Anette, but the creative force in their productions whoever that might be.

[ChaosVonGin]

@acht71 That would be Toumas, the guy playing the Keyboard.

[agnosticforce]

@acht71 kudos to you for making a great point.

on another note

I personally like the verses sung by anette on this song. but thats just my opinion.

[minotauro43]

Ohhhhhh, i miss you Tarjaaaaaaaaaa

[relledom]

I think people must first understand that Tarja was unique in what she did and second that people must get used to Anette's Voice and stop comparing her interpretations with Tarja's. NIGHTWISH!! =)

[Jaryslayer]

no me gutó esta version :( pero igual xD

[SerasxAlucard]

BOO TO ALL THE ANETTE HATERS!

Go Nightwish!

[KaddyRox]

I love her Voice.. she's great.. and the whole band, too! If you all realy love nightwish, you should accept her as the new singer..!!

[Surise]

I don't really get what these Tarja fans would've liked Tuomas to do? Get another opera singer even though Tarja could not be surpassed? Make Marco the singer and practically stop playing old songs altogether? Keep Tarja even though they hadn't talked for two years and didn't get along at all and with time make all of them depressed and the music soulless 'cause there's no fire to continue together? End the band because of one person even though the fire to continue is still there? Geez.

[marilena6]

@Surise Actually the way Tuomas chose to fire her by giving her a lousy letter, instead of confronting her was just coward and pathetic. People who claim to be friends since their childhood don't act this way.He should tell her face to face but he didn't have the guts.And Tarja was devestated from this act.But anyway, between the choices you gave above, since I'm a "tarja fan" i choose the first one: GET ANOTHER OPERA SINGER!!! al least tuomas would keep alive the band's style this way!

[Surise]

@marilena6 I'm not defending the way Tuomas fired Tarja, I thought it was immature as well. But I don't see the point in getting another opera singer. Tarja did that so incredibly well, she's not surpassable. Since when has there been a rule that a band must stick in with one style? Compare Angels Fall First with Once and tell me their style hasn't changed ever since. I'm not in a position of deciding what the REAL Nightwish sounds like. I respect whatever Tuomas decides to do with HIS music.

[andrewizz]

They should had found another singer, opera style, she just cannot sing most of their songs, sorry but she doesn't fit in the band, that was a terrible mistake i think

[winny1900]

nothing against Anette, but i think she shouldn't sing Nightwish's old songs, cuz she is not Tarja....she has a good voice, but not for the songs of Tarja...

[SerasxAlucard]

@winny1900 Then the same for Tarja, she as a solo artist now shouldn't sing Nightwish songs.

[heisenmanFC]

@SerasxAlucard Yes, she should, it's not illegal or anything.