Carlos Santana ft Alex Band-Why Don't You And I

[shainjoseph]

@dominumtuss dont speak spanish but the first line says how can i compare him to Cobain. that much can figure out. also ur Cobain is a god and is genious/ creatuve and Ben is just a boy. i was not comparing careers, impact, style, creativity just looks. hello blonde hair baggy clothes!! i know they are two very different guys. oh just the last part: the world still recognizes or he still influntial ten yrs after his death, n something about three years n Ben. how did i do???

[miguel72598]

As i listen to the singers, Alex voice is cooler and he looks better than Chad

[Graniterock1000]

Regardless of who sings it better, Santana is a musical genius.

[AnnyC2007]

This is what mean to make a song yours take any song an make it unique no matter who else sing the song no one could sing it like you and Chad and Alex make exactly that to amaizing versions of one amaizing song

[AURORA18000]

It is cool .... B-) 

[SimoHudsonBerto]

Chad kroeger is a great singer and i like very much nickelback but.. Alex Band is fuckin' awesome and i prefer this version than other!

[TearsForLosers]

ALEX BAND ROCKS!

[rheinne12]

im still having my wet dreams with alex band on my mind..lol

[rheinne12]

im still having my we dreams with alex band on my mind..lol

[rrio97]

its better chad kroeger version

[nohbudy]

Is it me, or does this sound like a japanese band singing in english?

[PJsthehobo]

this version is better. at least i think so

[mrpenumpela]

alex looks lol

[SakuraSyaoranTC]

chad for the win!!!!!!

[chickadee411bonehead]

What does the dude have aids??? What's with all the prancing about?

[777ransom]

This is gay Chad's soon much better

[1991GothicSoul666]

I prefur Chads ver.

[nrouse22]

I personally perfer Chad Kroeger's version better. As for him not deserving to sing this song, he is the one who wrote it. Not re recorded it. Both are good artist and opinions may vary.

[gutterflower24]

Nice voice!!!!

[MojitoWithASmile]

I love Bryant Park, the atmosphere is magical.

[jadenpaigeshow]

I would DIE for this song, best song ever!, I love it, I have been listening to it for 6 years now!, and so far, this is the one video i have viewed the absolute most, thank you SO much for posting this, I really really really would die without this song!, I love it so so so so so so so so MUCH! :) ♥

[surfergirrl66]

Sexy young man!

[playzoey]

okay if you dont like it, then go away and dont comment bashing him down. let those of us who like it enjoy it without your annoying comments

[FabricadoNoBrasil]

What a piece of shit faggot!!!!!

Fucking poser!

[showtime3321]

fuck chad kroeger...he doesnt deserve to sing this song ever

[666MetalHeads]

Chad is more old more mature more rocking its is impossible that alex can be better, its like justin bieber with micheal jackson :S

[gutterflower24]

@666MetalHeads Alex has better voice, it doesn't mind the mature. And that's not a rock song, it doesn't mind who's more rocking.

[shadow707three]

he looks like somebody like nobody would like, but dude, he's got a KICK ASS voice!

[maximusz10]

more trout that version is a crap hold the original version of chad, alex band sucks and the singer is re fucking for me that a song aga own and not imitate chad because alex is a fucking shit!

[kathyguthrie39]

Great love love love it , i love chad kroeger but on this song alex is better

[itskimianne]

i love chads version, i love this version. the thing is, its a good SONG regardless of which guys singing it.

[MarianitaDisney]

@itskimianne ikr. besides, they both have kinda the same voice

[SmileyGirlXO]

this is a good song. lol its cute how he jumps around the stage sorta.

lol did anyone notice the girl with the pony tails playin dah tambourine? :D

[zingla1000]

i like both versions ...i dont think one is better than the other

[luckydhel29]

green represents alex and the red one's are chad's now keep voting!!! wonden who win because chad's need to keep up....a lot!!!

[rbabhi]

chad kroeger is much better in my opinion.

[crazyhorseisdead]

good singer but sounds like eddie vedder, chriss cornell, scott stap, and crash test dummies wtf?

[shermanmi]

I like this version better!

[szunmate]

Chad Kroeger's version is better, than this.

[ijc1687]

@szunmate i agree, but i like this one as well

[TuxedoAllure]

@szunmate AGREED. I am still wondering why there were 2 versions of this song. I heard the Chad Kroeger version first, then they pulled it, and started airing this one.

[GalesCatnip]

His voice is so amazing and inimitable!

Listened to the song at his concert in Cologne two days ago and I still can´t get this wonderful music out of my mind. Just need to close my eyes and I here it.

Wonderful!

So do the same; join an Alex Max Band-concert. I promise, you won´t regret it!

[femalearcher]

@GalesCatnip

you are so damn right...Cologne was a blast

[BBW1973]

good cover, but have to admit I do prefer the Santana/Chad Kroeger version

[shainjoseph]

he looks like Kurt Cobain, but not depressed

y does he keep smiling so much??

[dominumtuss]

@shainjoseph COMO TE ATREVES A COMPARARLO CON KURT??? EL ES UN DIOS, ALEX BANG SOLO ES UN NIÑO BONITO PERO SIN GENIO CREATIVO, SI NO DIME QUE ES DE EL HOY EN DIA??? NADA. TODO EL MUNDO RECUERDA A KURT A MAS DE 10 AÑOS DE SU MUERTE PERO NADIE RECUERDA ALEX NI A TRES AÑOS DE HABER SACADO SU DISCO, LO SIENTO PERO S ES LA VERDAD

[mithan2010]

@shainjoseph

i guess he was just enjoying himself ;)

[shermanmi]

he's a happy musician. is that bad?

[DonCalnare]

Santana looks like a homeless...everytime I see him on stage...yet he kicks ass with his guitar skill, feeling and sound. Alex Band completes it with his perfectly fitting voice: Terrific.

[kharizma06]

Alex Band. is. just. so. freaking. good.

Those smiles can just totally melt me away~~~ :))

LOL at Santana. :)) Such a passionate and enthusiastic man! :D \m/

[kardzfn21]

Let's get this whole Chad vs. Alex thing sorted out those of U who don't know their's this thing called STYLE! STYLE is the type of music which your personally prefer-Everybody still w/me? Personally I like Alex band more w/this song but do I like Nickelback's stuff-YOU BET! There an AWESOME band, I think the radio wears there stuff out sometimes which pisses me off b/c I think there such a GREAT band & the radio SHOULDN'T do that but they do! Those of U who wanna say F U DON'T waste your time!

[kardzfn21]

Their are some guys like oh..... Mick Jagger who need to "hang it up" BUT Santana this guy still has it he isn't wanting to recreate the 60's or 70's like Jagger he knows what CHANGE is! If you disagree that's cool know why? This is America! FREE SPEECH baby!

[hvirag]

i dont know, i personally prefer the chad kröger one.. bad this one isnt that bad either.

[RebelMusicInc]

This is our favorite version. Come on... People: Alex's Voice. wow The guy is amazing.

[StaversonAnaysis1]

i think that Alex's version and Chad's version are both amazing, but i like watching Alex better because he's better looking. :)

[ksu63y]

@StaversonAnaysis1 haha true!

[Traveller1612]

....does this guys mom know he's not in school?

[liWmAssss]

@Traveller1612 h dikia sou to 3erei???

[littleredcar]

who the hell is alex band. before this video i never even seen him

[loenly14]

@littleredcar alex band is the leadsinger of "the calling" don't u know?

[littleredcar]

@loenly14 nope :D

[Roodsteam]

Nice voice there bit of Kurt and chad kroeger

[buhonil]

This song suits Alex voice better than Chad...I know he wrote it, and i'm a big fan, but someone that sings "I like your pantas around your feet..." can't be singing this lyrics...too romantic for Chad's voice XD

[12prinsen]

i think that the chad kroeger version is better

[LOQU3NDOX]

santana is very big

[3PSRACING]

DEANNIS CHAMBERS YEAAAAAAA!!!!

[coloradodafronteira]

Alex = Cameron Diaz

[cvbjhqweb]

alex sing good but i chad is better ^^

[martinraiden85]

@cvbjhqweb I'd say that Alex is doing a better job at this perticular song, since it's about being happy and in love.. His voice sounds more like exactly that, where Chad's is more dark. Just my opinion :P

[brionito77]

great voice..alex is great..

[PrizZillaR]

I like Alex's cheerful performance and nice voice. He looks so enjoy with the song and make me feel it too. and sound is very good.

sucha woderful performance!

[athlete333333]

Chad is way Better

[sunniluvart]

I like both versions, Chad AND Alex. And Alex is kinda cute, too! I love how he's so full of energy, jumping around the stage, he looks like he's really having fun!!

[olympia1968]

thats wierd. i thought it was a grown man singing

[Doog0AD]

Personally I find Chad Kroeger's voice far too gruff for Carlos. I think this version with Alex Band fits a lot better with Alex's slightly less gruff voice, while still retaining that rocky feel that Carlos was going for in the original label. I don't see what everyone's problem with Alex Band is :P

[Dolllaaarrr]

his demeanor and movements do make him look gay dont they. is he?

[Dolllaaarrr]

i adore alex's voice

[icanteverdecide]

i like this version way better than the chad kroeger one, but i still laugh every time i see alex band, he looks so boy-bandish yet has that cool growly voice

[BabyChiiCa16]

@icanteverdecide i love alex band just because of these facts :D:D:D

[zaco21]

@icanteverdecide

Chad Kroeger has a more suitable voice then this guy for this song!

[dprester333]

@icanteverdecide soooo not true, hes singing like lil girl. He is trying to sing like a man, like Chad and ill give him that but this is a FAIL ppl. All who respect music will agree this singing isnt any better than any other boy-band singing thumbs up^^(tho i dint expect to get any)

[charmedfover]

Chad Kroeger was the original Singer but RoadRunnerRecords Did not allow them to release the song because Nickelback was doing a cd around the same time and they feared it would mess with the Hype, so Chad Decided to put this Fag of a singer instead of him

[CastilloOJ]

nice voice and guitar...

[ceruleanemeraldheart]

It really doesn't matter who holds the microphone at a Santana show; there's only one attraction on that stage and his name is Carlos. Carlos is the master artist, everyone else is just the canvas.

[RakStaRyan]

chad wrote the song and originally sung it , his label didnt want him associated with it cause nickelback had a big album coming out , so they put alex band on too sing for the radio version , end of story ,

[flatlined95]

Funny, the version with Chad, people say this version is better and on this video everyone is saying Chad's is better XD

[sussyshg]

@flatlined95

hehe.. i noticed that too.. hehe..

[leondelai]

can the vocal be anymore gay?? fucking shit man.......

[kylglly1]

santana's strap is fuckin boss

[Katgirl1331]

Chad sounds better........ For a second I thought that was Aaaron Carter LOL!

[cachanillasoy]

santana legend  VIVA MEXICO

[Galigon525]

the one with chad hroeger is better

[l0kl0k0202]

thats a fucking cover lyrics are fron chad kroeger

[Doog0AD]

Actually, RRR just believed that a single like this would damage the sales of Nickelback's The Long Road, so Kroeger recommended Alex Band.

Personally I think this voice sounds a lot better than Chad Kroeger's. Fits Carlos' style a lot better.

[BrainBlader]

i agree with you.. if Kroeger selected Band personally there has to be an actual good reason for that

[mattxhardyxlove]

I agree. :) Alex rocks this.

[adam12brody]

The singer looks like Jesse McCartney i thought he wpuld have a tiny whinny voice lol... great voice actually

[munkyosuh]

i loooove this version...

[zdfighter]

This dude can't sing. Comparing this to Chad Kroeger is just stupid.

[lalasitah]

Lets talk about Santana!

[kocakondaedd]

amazing!!

[tsms710]

You say Jonas Brothers-I say NICKELBACK

You say Taylor Swift-I say fuck me please taylor

You say Kate Perry-I say NICKELBACK

You say Miley Cyrus-I say NICKELBACK

You say Shakira-I say NICKELBACK

You say pop-I say ROCK!!!.....ROCK=NICKELBACK

KEEP ROCK ALIVE

[lonbilly]

Nickelback isn't that great. If you're gonna post one of these, at least make it reasonable. You act like Nickelback are some "Gods".

[tsms710]

lol u tell me whats good then >>

[canine2k5]

ur rite nickelback is good but not that great... there r much better artists then nickelback. the new generation rock is nothing compared to the 60's - 80's

[Doog0AD]

^ Word.

[1911NiCkElBaCk]

You say Jonas Brothers-I say NICKELBACK

You say Taylor Swift-I say NICKELBACK

You say Kate Perry-I say NICKELBACK

You say Miley Cyrus-I say NICKELBACK

You say Shakira-I say NICKELBACK

You say pop-I say ROCK!!!.....ROCK=NICKELBACK

KEEP ROCK ALIVE

[footballmunki]

I love Nickelback.... but I also love the Jonas Brothers.

[54spiritedwill54]

I love Alex so bad!!his voice is driving me crazy..

[erickondio]

AMAZING LIVE VERSION!!!

[BiZinatChos]

Chad Kroegers version is so much better.

[wantah89]

I still love alex band after all these years :)

[JGIncorporation]

the blonde hair guy has a rly good voice but i like nickelbacks version better and dont say kroegers voice sucks just because some people dont like the raspy... its a rare and unique voice thats hard to come by... people need to listen to the rock bands from the 60's 70's and 80's u remember all the crazy unique voices.... tehres very little variety with voices nowadays it gets old hearing the same crap over and over again... this kids rlly good just kinda unoriginal

[JGIncorporation]

santannas easily one of the best guitarists to ever live.... what band does the origina;l version of this song??

[conor2479]

this guys voice is better then krogers but chads works better for this song

[2k11angel]

i like the recorded video better...

santana still rocks though ;)

[rpblc30]

alex band is soooo cute...i'm shaking n hyperventilanting right now!!n his voice is freaking sexyyhh..

[skrib31]

this guy is shit lol chad kroeger shits on this guy

[blinkyboy86]

stupid comment. just because you like chad kroeger better doesnt make this guy shit he still has a good voice

[Cloudff231]

damn you bitch, alex band is great, try to sing like that if u can, ur a bitch just like ur bitch of a mother

[tsms710]

hey i didnt say alex isnt good lol i listen to this version than the chad kroger one cause , chads voice in this song, makes him sound constipated , well hes a tenor soo : S

[CuLlEnBoYsRoKmYsOx]

I love Chad and Nickelback, but I like Alex's version of this song better. Still love Chad tho=) But the originl is way better. No offence to everyone, but your wrong;-)

Lol. jk!

[beerbong151]

this sucks shit. chad is way better.

[rofc102886]

Alex Band is kinda Boyband while Chad is definitely A Rockstar!!! Chad is better than alex. the version of alex sucks.

[HoTKayliffeVoX]

I was wondering why Chad isn't performing this Live when it's him who sang the part and not Alex..I think Chad deserves this performance onstage. He sounds more like a rocker to me compared to Alex, although both are good vocalists.

[Shana4t5]

Not that I hate him, but I think he sounded a alittle breathless in some parts

[Mrazmerize]

I don't know,i think Alex has more stage presence than Chad, but i think Chad deserves more credit

[LoveeFan1]

I loveee alex baand!!! he is soooooooo hot and cutee <33 love his voice too :D

[incadilu]

That rocks!!!!!!!!!!!!

[cboadicea]

Santana can't sell out for shit. Look at the size of the crowd, even for free hardly anyone would come see this has been. Only reason why he's still around is because he relys on popular artists to keep his career, otherwise he'd be dirt poor right now. Sad really, if he attempted to do an album with only the people in his band, he'd flop. Santana's a joke.

[CuLlEnBoYsRoKmYsOx]

Santana rocks. Hes way better at guitar than a lot of other artist!  Not that I can play... but you gotta give him credit for that. He's amazing at guitar! He's not a joke.

[mjk125]

SANTANA + ALEX + CHAD = ROCKS!

[airsqua11]

santana sucks!!..he let two artists to sing this song..that's why there's a comparison between chad and alex..santana sucks!!

[JagHeterAlexandra]

Even if I'm a HUGH and I mean HUUUUGH fan of Alex Band...Chad Krouger sings this better and that was the version I heard first...so...maybe that's why

[iainh1970]

chad better on vocalls but still good

[rafaelmacintosh]

ALEX + SANTANA > CHAD + SANTANA

[billy8877]

Why do u have to comment which version's better?I mean, u can choose what u like and that's it.End of story. ALEX...he ROCKS!

[jecca3]

both versions are great

[pinkreid11]

Chad kroger singing this is so better. also listen to Into the night santana ft. chad kroger

[s0ySaucE]

chad koreger verison was way better

[alexmaxfan]

I love Alex so bad!!his voice is driving me crazy..

[imkouklos]

wooow. . . .fantastic voice

[nashman2]

stigmatized... could it be any harder, watch and listen to those acoustic versions on youtube... enough said

[HplusG]

Stop hating. If you like Chad's version, thats cool. But some of us like Alex's version better.

this song ROCKS!! Phenomenal live performance!

[berk1983]

Yeah man u right.and everybody say nickelback is good but I dont think so.Nickelback is nor origanl grup their style like Nirvana.But they arent a Nirvana.

[JonathonCalligeros]

@berk1983 just so you know. Chad wrote the bloody song so don't put shit on the guy who gave you this great song. just cos he has a gruff voice and they sing rock music Nickelback is trying to be like Nirvana? thats just a stupid comment.

[squall823]

dios mio este video es femonenal q lastima q las personas dañen la pag poniendo comntarios como q con nickelback es buena q alex apesta y eso xd en vez d criticar ddknse a disfrutar lo buena q es la kncion alex rock

[Diva907]

The one with nickelback was better, he had a better voice

[berk1983]

But this song is orginal voice's alex.And I dont see nickelback.Nickelback want looks like nirvana.They aren not orginal gruop.And ı fuck their ass.Motherfuckerss....

[EpiCPerCepTion]

@berk1983 How is Nickelback like Nirvana now ? :S confusing muchly

[lovebloodriver]

@berk1983

yo...berk dont bark about something like this

you have this sight of seeing the other their sight of seeing

everybody has different taste

what does matter is the love to music not which band played it better...

and its inmature if u compare bands with other bands u know

they are all different.it could be that nickelback resembles nirvana a little....(i dont know and i dont care)

but as long as i live i never heard that nirvana made those kind of lovesongs like them.to be true

[chongwong]

i dunno, personally i prefer this one, and if yuor veiw is right, then why did santana put the alex band version on his ultimate santana album

[edisonmexico]

hey guys, is a reason why Santana decided for alex band and not Nickelback at the final part, but Nickelback is good too

[xj10a1g7x]

even though nickelback rock this version is way better

[undivided21]

nickleback didnt play this song

[mjk125]

yes he did

[undivided21]

no they didnt, nickleback is the band, Chad Kreoger sang it for Carlos Santana however his record company did really want him doin it so they swapped him for alex band

[inferniousX]

When nickelback and carlos santana did this it sounded 10000000000X's better

[geraldlee81]

nickelback should stick to song writing, he sounds like a someone with lung cancer.

[alexmaxfan]

LMAO!!

[xj10a1g7x]

omg as if you compare alex to aaron carter and jesse mccartney

alex has an amazing voice and is way talented

alex rocks!!!

[billy8877]

Oh,GOSH...Alex sounds fantastic live.And I can't belive someone said Chad's version is better!No way.

[kittybabyforever7]

not even. i went to a nickelback concert this feburary. chad sounds so much better then this. i cant even put it into words. nobody can beat chads voice. this guy reminds me of aaron carter. this song is a very sad excuse of the other one

[billy8877]

Okay...That's your point of view and I respect that.I like Nickelback A LOT(as a matter of fact:-)

[Tinkerbaby94]

you guys are aware that little children are reading the things you are typing. Could you please type those sort of things in private messages. I sure don't want my little siblings reading these comments, and why you may not like this song a lot of other people do. I understand that you have your own opinion and I respect that, but could you please watch your language. Please and thanks.

[berk1983]

thankx tinkerbaby94.Somepeople can be unreasoning.They dont never understand good songs.Carlos is a prefect guitarist for my mine.

[Tinkerbaby94]

No problem, i was just thinking about what would happen if my little sister or brother came on here and read some of these comments. I mean I really don't wanna explain those words to an eight year old.

[berk1983]

You're speak like a young woman.Very nice thing for you.I hope alot of people like you.see you later little girl.

[Tinkerbaby94]

Why thank you, nice that someone notices. Bye!

[millwoodpark]

maybe he will have jesse mccartney faggot singing with the band next time, lately carlos has been into this little white boy with blond hair trip,think that has anything to do with carlos being molested as a child

[ref1ex]

If I said I didn't like it, then you know I lied :)

[berk1983]

thankx for you love this song.

[xbrooksxonxguitarx]

think hes the guy from the calling.. maybe the band changed their name

[nicko32001]

i love this song

[xBastionx]

The lead singer looks vaguely familiar...like someone I've seen on TV or in a Movie recently...

[bergs14]

he reminds me of that little jesse mcartney faggot

[marcusilluminous]

You remind me of the little Andy Dick faggot