Brothers (English Version)

[topsecret770]

this song reminds me of my sister... I feel a lot of guilt for what I did, she may forgive me, but it still stings the fact of all I did to her.

[Sallosapaladin]

playing both this and the non english version at the same time sounds pretty good

[fullmetalkitty48021]

It must be vic mignonga singing ://D

[gokufan122198]

@fullmetalkitty48021 Vic is singing this :)

[MrCocyMan]

excelent!!!i LOVE fma!!

[pinochetgeffrard]

is that Edward elric singing

[gokufan122198]

@pinochetgeffrard No, it's his voice actor though...Vic...I forgot who to spell his last name ^_^;

[linkLoverAG]

@gokufan122198 Mignogna 

[gokufan122198]

@linkLoverAG Thank you :) I always forget Vic's last name for some reason :/

[linkLoverAG]

@gokufan122198 its harder to spell with the gnogna XDD

[gokufan122198]

@linkLoverAG Yeah! XDD

[iluvchrishalliwell]

Didn't read the description of my fav song from this anime.

Heard Ed's voice.

Then I died. <3

[Cherrytheninja]

@iluvchrishalliwell Same here lol

[TheTreaniebeanie]

If anything happened to any of my siblings I dont think that I would be able to stand it. We may fight and scrap but I know that they will always be there for me and have my back. I am sorry for everyones losses... I am sad to say that I cannot truly sympathize.

[ChibiRavenPrincess]

This is actually Ed's voice. Dub version of course and I think he also sung another song for fma called Nothing I won't give... it's another song from Ed to his brother.

[lordofallpokemonchaz]

This vid is fuckin amazing and fma brotherhood cansuck my ballz the original fma is better

[MischievousHeart]

Wow. Now that I know the words and meaning, it's even more sad!

[hiYaLen]

russian version way-way better!

[Cherrytheninja]

@hiYaLen Well you could atleast say something nice about it ya know? Not trying to argue or anything.

[Skypatter]

i have a question. How come they didn't use this in the dub ? since usually they like to translate everything

[Chikorita2Chante]

@Skypatter They didn't get the right for the music after a looong time.

[IamtheSHINeeGirl]

@BeyondBemazing He has ruined yet another good song.

[lordofallpokemonchaz]

Holy fuckin shot this vid is fuckin amazing

[IamtheSHINeeGirl]

Goddammit. Is this Vic Mangina?

[BeyondBemazing]

@IamtheSHINeeGirl YES!

[1RedDash]

Do you have a download link?

[HayateTheHedgehog]

@1RedDash use snipmp3.com

[1RedDash]

@HayateTheHedgehog Thank you I found one, but this will be helpful for other things. (:

[ButterANDBuiscuits2]

EDWARDS VOICE? :D :D :D

[Tadsapon]

@ButterANDBuiscuits2 Yes,i prefer >_< i have watched english,thai and japanese ver.

[kledder2]

I tend to give thumbs down but that's just because the original is so much better. The english version is decent. But hey, at least now I know what they're singing about ;).

[Tygeress20]

A beautiful song to begin with, but the fact that that this is the English voice actor for Ed singing makes it incredibly touching.

[LeaveItToErik]

*Tear* beautiful

[mara2073394]

Love this song its so beutiful

[projectshadowx1]

ed is singing

[DrSamanthasaurus]

This makes me cry.

[omgshesdead]

This song is so beautiful <3

[Darkdrago909]

my god want a brother T^T

[Darkdrago909]

@Darkdrago909 i want"

[nomnomnomrawr95]

i friggin love Vic

[Annishappy]

I'm italian and i watched FMA in english only because i loved Vic's voice!

[uuuuuuu30]

@Nevientpas friendship.

[Nevientpas]

Magic... 

[masonlyngen]

this song is very melancholy if tabbed slowly on a guitar.

[SharksKing1992]

@MsFuzzycaterpillar hahaha brothers get jealous of each other but you have to know that they love you deep inside...actually you are lucky that you have brothers and sisters...I have always wished to have one

ooooh give me one

[MrCALGORE]

that so awesome I can't belive it's english and Ed that makes it all the more beautfull! aswell as the litteral translations didnt match the song so I'm so happy I can finally sing the right words! thank you so much for uploading

[instantlight12]

screw this world id chose the anime world anyday

[1bessiedog]

Such a sad but meaningful song!!!

[MrSushi12312]

Killed a bear....

[kendraeball]

I love this song it's so beautiful !!!!!

[alicecullenrox1425]

i love it!

[warriorsjacobbramble]

this song is beautiful

[kei0kusanagi]

wow...........................­..anime songs in english usually SUCKS, but this one is pretty good, I won't lie. It's pretty calming and sad. I like it.

[Eorzat]

@kei0kusanagi This one is especially unique since it was originally in Russian.

[Chikorita2Chante]

@kei0kusanagi He made this without consent (just for fun). And after a while they got the rights for the music and then made it official ^^

[MsMandaish]

Vic is my favorite voice. he's in a real lot of anime's

[Okami1001]

what episode clip did you use in the beginning?

[christiancoleh]

Who is singing this song? It sounds like to voice actor for Edward Elrick.

[kasumimoon1961]

@christiancoleh it is!!! isnt he cute!! XD

[MangekouSharinganPro]

@christiancoleh

It is.

[christiancoleh]

@MangekouSharinganPro Cool! Thanks

[stuwieFF]

you couldn't find a better song to dedicate to your brother, this song is breathtaking, the english and japanese.

[PeteTheElit3]

My brother died last year of an unknown, undectable virus or genetic condition, no one knows. Every test that the best doctors in the state did and the millions spent could not save him. This song and FMA reminds me so much of what we all went through, first a coma, hundreds of thousands of seizures, should be dead but survives, only to be finally stuck down in the dying hours of night. I'm sorry we couldnt save you brother, but I'm glad I got to talk to you one last time.

[KalebDeanGrim13mm]

@PeteTheElit3 Im sorry about your brother man its rough losing someone that close to you I know all too well your pain my family seems to be droping like flies thats the only way i can describe it and now im joining the marine corps my mother must be a nervous wreak

[SuperPlayful07]

wow i love this.. does anyone know which is the second season. i never finshed watching them :/

[nekoninjaproductions]

@SuperPlayful07 u never finished watching FMA? well just go to Animefreak tv thts where i watched it :D

[SuperPlayful07]

@nekoninjaproductions no i never got the chance to . thanks i will :) i always loved it but i didnt have cabel or a computer and i can only watch it when no ones with me cuz they dont like it ..if only the knew wat it was about they dont give me chance but its ok cuz i dont need to be acepted by anyone even if that someone is my family :/ one day thayll understand :)

[sadlife567]

The moment the song started i was already crying. I wish i had a brother..i would sacrifice everything for him.

[00Stella000000]

@sadlife567 me too :) And if you have a brother it's like you told... I mean, I have 2 sisters and even if we get angry easily, we deeply love each other because I can't think they could dye.... I can far understand what Donutonsticks felt... That's because this anime had a lot of succes ( and it's my fav x) ) =)

[sadlife567]

@00Stella000000 i also have two sisters.I wouldnt be able to live without them.

[Rarodar]

Man.. i wish my brother was like Ed

[boubinou65]

the OST orginal that brothers has > that version but it's great song.

sorry for my bad english ^^

[Invaraeden]

Saw Vic sing this live at AX yesterday,,,,his voice is beautiful.

[ThePolkadotz12]

I had to stop listening to this or I wouldve cried... R.I.P Matt..

[meowth900]

I know how sad this anime is and I feel like hugging Edward to make him feel better after all the mistakes he made not knowing what would happen...its just that sad

[Niazuke]

Fullmetal Alchemist is truly one of the best animes a lot of sites voted best anime 2010 probably brotherhood fma

[Wolfieist]

TBH Vic can't sing well. He's decent but did they really have to make him the one to sing the English version? Just because he's Ed doesn't mean they should try and let him sing a song that was probbaly meant for a woman.

Granted I think the song is better off in Russian only.



[KyrinHasuko]

@Wolfieist Then why listen to this video in the first place?

[Wolfieist]

@KyrinHasuko: Because I want to hear for myself?

And comment on it? Hmm really now~

[sakura818]

@Wolfieist Even if the Russian version is obviously a hell of a lot better, this version seems to have more feeling to it Because is the one singing it.

[Wolfieist]

@sakura818: I disagree it has more feeling but whatever

opinions are opinions.

[sakura818]

@Wolfieist meh

[LordBrauner]

@Wolfieist I think it was a great idea to give the vocals to Ed. The song is about the bond between two brothers who bled a lot together. Just like the show. It's just Ed singing to Alphonse. Don't think too far into this, pal. Just enjoy it.

[Wolfieist]

@LordBrauner: lol I'm not "thinking way too far into this" I'm stating my opinion :/

Its a great idea to have a male singer but Vic isn't that strong of a singer its like he's saying the lyrics not singing them.

[LordBrauner]

@Wolfieist Nevertheless, I still prefer the Russian choir singing it. lol

[rainclawwarriorcat]

@Wolfieist Well that's just too bad for you then

[MochiccinoWuvsCoffee]

@Wolfieist Who is they? And "they" didn't make him sing anything. He did this for fun and it just happened to blow up over the internet.

[kasumimoon1961]

sooo coool i didnt know vic could sing so well <333

[maxmotives101]

writing while listening to this with the volume all the way up!! haha!

[sjoerdtoppi]

@TheIii000

Oke Thanks!^^

[eirik1234321]

@justinbieberlove2243 seriously. thats realy imature. i was trying to understand how someon can hate this. but then i saw your name. that alone makes it clear that you dont know what music is

[Kiha717]

@justinbieberlove2243 Sorry to say this, but so is the fag you're worshipping...He's (As raywilliamjohnson would say) FAKE AND Gay!!! Suck scum Justin Beiber

[757satosha]

Very Well done.. GReat.. i Appreciate you very much..!

[inuyasha276]

this is beautiful i loooooove it!!!!!!

[LastActionCowboy]

@justinbieberlove2243 you're a perfect example why some animals eat their young

[cody21706]

This is the best song ever, it's so sad and happy at the same time. I love it :)

[mydrkndheart]

awesome !!! A TRULY heart touching music....... !

[japaneseokamiadmirer]

no matter how many times i listen 2 this i always do the same thing.....

CRY! i have the song on disc and i listen 2 it evry night bc i dont think any1 beats vic mignogna... not in my eyes any way... i still think of my grandpa but now i dont cry as often as i used 2... After all i didnt wanna let him c me crying and i dont wanna cry knowing that he is watching... I still let it out somtimes but i am not the same crybaby as b4...

[TheNightmareReality]

Vic is all over the place in anime. Dragon Ball Z, DN Angel, One Piece, Soul Eater, Naruto Shippuden; but I think he's great for Ed. Plus, he's great at singing. This song is so pretty and heart-tugging, it's great.

[sjoerdtoppi]

@TheNightmareReality

who does he play in Naruto?

[TheNightmareReality]

@sjoerdtoppi

He's one of the three people in that arch that wasn't in the original manga.

The one with Sora, (who you don't see after it's over)

(Personally, I was waiting for it to END already. LET'S GET WITH THE AVENGING!!!)

I think he was the lady....Fuen or something...

[takeshiBANKAI]

@TheNightmareReality omg u forgot bleach, he plays ikkaku

[TheNightmareReality]

@takeshiBANKAI Well, bleach too then. O.o

See what I mean, though?

[takeshiBANKAI]

@TheNightmareReality hahahaha yep! :)

[kendraeball]

@TheNightmareReality who does he play 4 naruto shippuden and Dragon Ball Z ?

[TheNightmareReality]

@kendraeball Uhhh I forget who he is in Dragon Ball Z, (look him up on imdb.com), but he plays one of those extra bad guys in that story arc right before Shika's revenge. :/

He wasn't a big character, but he was in it nonetheless. It was the one with the zombies and the Sora guy (whom you never see again, so the whole thing was pointless), but whatever.

[Hardcoregamer300]

@kendraeball He played Broly in Dragon Ball Z.

In Dragon Ball Z Kai, he's Burter.

In Naruto Shippuden, he's going to be the voices of Obito Uchiha, Nagato, and Fuen (Sora Arc).

[Hikarilastsolace]

@TheNightmareReality wait SOUL EATER!?!?!?!

[TheNightmareReality]

@Hikarilastsolace You never noticed how close to Ed-ranting Spirit-san gets when he gets excited or upset?

Like when he's screaming 'Maka!!!!'?

[Hikarilastsolace]

@TheNightmareReality no i dident notice lol!

[TheNightmareReality]

@Hikarilastsolace Rewatch any episode with him in it. :3

Pay special attention to when he's yelling. x3

[fullmetalkitty48021]

@TheNightmareReality their the same voice actor

[TheNightmareReality]

@fullmetalkitty48021 I know; I was pointing that out to another person.

[XemoXheartXbreakerX]

ahh Vic Mignogna ish completly amazing and i love his voice as eddo and he sings wonderfully tew..i could just listen tew this song over and over cuz its so sweet and perfect though it makes meh cry

[iluvKH4eva]

Vic Mignoga also sings the opening song in D.N. Angel.

[iluvKH4eva]

This has to be my utmost favourite track from this series alone..... Breathtaking.

[Pop77o7]

zomg I didn't know Vic could sing! :-D it's perfect!!

[Zeetermin]

This inspired me to read the manga since I've already seen both animes.

[phazon40]

OMG I LOVE YOU FOR POSTING THIS

Love to all my brothers out there.

We all live in this cruel twisted ugly life called Reality.

With each others strengths, we walk and keep walking.

Not letting life keep us down, we walk with our heads held high.

:) Thank you Fma<3

[ilovemovies007]

wow this song was very touching i thnk im gona get some tears.... :,( 'sigh' lov fma its awesome

[Puttedask]

Woah... this song pierced my heart like a arrow... especially as i am a FMA fan.. a huge fan.... but hearing Ed (well its Vic that voice acts ed but duh) sing about his life.... sing about the hard times etc.... It just so touching...

[pokegirlmary]

My friend said this song was sad, but when I was done listening, I was LEGIT CRYING!!!!!! "BROTHERLY LOVE FTW!!!"

[TheBlindCry]

Dude... im crying all over the keyboard... T.T no body look plz...

[DNAlchemist119]

love it love it love it!!! Vic is an incredible guy and thats why we love him!!

[PandahBurr]

VIC MIGNOGNA DID THIS?!! @_@ <3

[Yanimeluvfan]

WHOA!! This is Edward?! Wow...so cuuute!

[L3P4DUU]

This song is so touching ;< Love you Vic :3

[HamtaroYAY]

I knew it was Edward singing! :D I saw this on my phone, and I was like is that Ed...? It's so sweet.

[japaneseokamiadmirer]

I am so sorry 4 ur loss Donutonsticks idk if u still look at the comments 4 this video but either way i still feel bad and ik how u feel bc this reminds me of my grandpa more bc he knew this melody 4 this song idk how bc he died b4 vic sang this and he used 2 hum it he never sang it in words but i luv this song soooo much it makes me luv my grandpa so much..... RIP grandpa

[probetastar]

why does this tear me apart inside?

[megmmy]

great video ^^

[Donutonsticks]

My big brother just died because of cancer...he have a collection of an Anime DVD in his room..then I find FMA...I watch it and tears fall in my eyes because Edward reminds me of my brother and this song reminds me of our brotherhood

[11111ichigo]

@Donutonsticks That's so sad... I'm a big sister, and i have two little brothers. I wouldn't know what to do if they suddenly dissapeared...

[CamieBrelle]

@Donutonsticks that is so sad , i'm so sorry for your loss.. Seriously..

[Araverta]

@Donutonsticks I'm so sorry for your loss</3 i would understand this anime would be somewhat fitting, for what the Elric brother's went through. Again, so sorry...

[UmbreonFromTheShadow]

@Donutonsticks Sorry for what happened, I feel the same about my father whom also died about a year ago. This song is great however for providing a soothing yet comfortable view of death so we ourselves can continue and live.

[nekoninjaproductions]

@Donutonsticks Im sorry about your brother...it must be hard ): i dont rly understand what its like to have a brother or lose one so i tell u i feel ur pain.But i give u my respects u must be very strong to lose someone so close to you. :)

[blackstar764]

Donutonsticks i'm very sorry that u lost your brother i am truly sorry

[kei0kusanagi]

@Donutonsticks May your brother rest in peace. You have another brotherhood, US FMA FANS =)

[alicecullenrox1425]

@Donutonsticks im sorry. i hope you feel better.

[Digmer]

@Donutonsticks I almost lost my sister 3 years ago for the same disease...is heart breaking even remember that but she is still here and I can´t imagine your suffering. I´m truly sorry for your lost...I hope that you and your family are in the way of finding peace with it...good luck and wish you well from Chile.

[Survivorgroup1]

@Donutonsticks i'm sorry for your loss, i too know the love of a brother, although he was jy half brother we had a relationship, dare i say, stronger then blood brothers.we both had problems, he did drugs and got drunk all the time, i had two heart surgeries, am bound to get more, and like Ed think it was my fault he did those things. he just got out of that stuff and had to move. before he moved i sang this and we both cried... the more and more i think about it the more and more we sound elric

[rockyroad024]

@Donutonsticks I feel you bro and never lose HOPE... Me and my little brother loves anime so much...I inspired him of watching Naruto, Bleach, and FMA. I gave him a keychain of edward's head in FMA....he love it and hang it in his pencil case...He didnt die but HE ALMOST die...when we are in the hospital...i told him everything i wanna tell him....I hope you did the same...I didnt become a good brother...I know you did so dont lose hope...

[bluelove1999]

@Donutonsticks

Awww. :( My dad died of cancer a few months ago, I'm only 12 years old. </3 You're not alone so don't worry. 

[Koopiac]

I did not know he could sing

[flyliketails]

@Koopiac He does :)

He also sings the theme for DB: Kai

[LilvRizzle]

i want to like this a couple hunred more times than once

[KuroNeko1615]

doro esta canción ya sea en ruso, en inglés da igual sig siendo bonita

=)

[FunklinkMusic]

@justinbieberlove2243 You're an idiot.

[mastery910]

@FunklinkMusic Stop feeding the troll...

[LisannaSakurai]

...... Haters gon hate but.

This song is horrible in english.

[darkgryffon]

@LisannaSakurai really? -_- the lyrics are exactly the same only difference is the person singing it, sooo...ya wow.....

[MasterKaios]

@darkgryffon Well I'd say they'd have to change them a bit to keep them in rhyme but having the same meaning. Just like with any dub.

Speaking of which, they did a fantastic job on that. I'd say this song is even more powerful in English. Possibly helped by the fact that it's a solo vocal, as if it were just Ed speaking to his brother alone...

[x0xmidamix0x]

the 1 person who disliked this only has a sister.

[Tomyytomx3]

Everytime i listen to this song, I think Edward is singing like, in front of me.

Thank you Vic! :DD

[MasterKaios]

@Tomyytomx3 Everyone seems to think that, but I associate that voice with Phantom Dark first, Vic himself second, and Edward Elric third. <=/

[JiinxxHoar]

I am just hitting the repeat button over and over and over...

[Smartboy7]

@JiinxxHoar Just put "replay" before "youtube.com" in the url!

[DX662]

woow

[DX662]

والله فضيييعه

[jet2ski2]

*Tear*

I always thought this song was beautiful, and now that I understand the lyrics I think it even more so.

[cancerbero777]

IT SUCKS IN ENGLISH

[SultanaKidStudios]

@cancerbero777 i think its more fitting really

[nyccamaro396]

He sounds like Ed from the show.

[SMGxSeshaBeowulf]

@nyccamaro396 It is Ed from the show.

[IsmailMarina]

PERFECT!!!! THIS SOUNDS BETTER THAN MY BROTHERS SINGING!!!!