Added: 5 years ago
From: nycrainbowbrite
Views: 165,017
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (218)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • wow they are not that good without the studio polish O_o

  • wow, studio production...

  • elle est défoncée la meuf ? En tout cas elle est bonnasse, elle a un style de ouf !!

  • Yeah, sorry, but this isen't good. The guy can't sing at all, so false...

  • Oh joy, another poor quality video made on some crap weasles cell phone. Oh Boy. Why waste your time puttin this on YouTube?

  • awfull

  • The crowd singing along is breath taking, they must feel awesome performing.

  • Amo esta canción!!! yo la escucho con mi novia <3 jeje

    Me encantan sus cabellos :DDDDDDDD

  • Comment removed

  • seriously.. where is the other singer...

  • i saw them now with sisley

    and they suck 1 not the same

  • i luv this song!!

    i think the lyrics mean sumthin sensual...?

    lolXD

  • all i know this was a great band dont know y yall hoes are winning about it god song

  • Poor performance.

  • I don't know why everyone has to freak out HARDCORE when someone leaves a band, they get a new member, or a band member goes on to do something different. If you don't like Sisely then stfu and don't listen to their music. Sisely and Carah are both great and STG sounds good with either one of them!

  • because a singer is the VOICE of a band, and depending on how modifyed their voice is in the studio from the live versions..well..It just means a lot. Carah was sooo much better. But I don't freak out.

  • ya i agree.. and its not like carah was kicked out.. she was 2 thousand miles away from home and went back to europe and started a new thing... if you like her go check it out ..---versant----

  • I dont think people are arguing that Sisely is a bad singer, she isn't. But they aren't the same band without Carah.

  • damn calm down. Carahs better.

  • You're watching this on youtube, most 'live' things on youtube sound bad!! So stFu!!

  • she is great at singing

  • whoa this is really nice quality! what did you use to record this? like the make and model?

  • get out.

  • wow , i despise you

  • LOL get the fuck out my internets

  • PFFTTT....i dont even now what to say, but i could list the ways to kill u for saying that...i could choke, knife u, gun u, or just do it with my bare hands...id rather use my hands..

  • DIS SONGZ SOOOO AWSOME!! :D

    i like da part wen she starts counting an shtuff ^____^

  • she sings great live not like other artists!!lots of love for mason - melissa musso

  • id really like u to come bak cause they are nothin any longer without u ...pleassss!!

  • this song rocks i have on my zune

  • they didnt kicked her out...

  • and what do you know?

    they say she left because she got marries but she says she didnt have a choice and she was asked to leave.

  • the question goes back to you

    "what do you know?"

    those are most likely rumors but i would say 50% of them are true...

    She wanted to start her own band!

    Sisley Treasure was suppose to be the main SHINY TOY GUNS vocals anyways, so there happy and now Carah is too..

  • ha...umm i know sisley was a first choice but couldnt be in the band due to her last contract...but i messaged shiny toy guns on myspace, and whoever they have reply to their messages said it was because she was moving out of the country with her new husband...i trust that more than you saying it was so she could start a band

  • Uhmm ok but they didnt kick her out....

    this is like the whole reason why I started the conversation...

    and there are ALOT of REASONS WHY SHE LEFT!

    noticed how i said left the band... instead of them kicking them out.

  • Kicking *her* out

  • Baha...lets just stop. whatever one of us says the other will disagree with it somehow...sooo Carah isnt in the band anymore and thats is lol YAY

  • lmao ahah yeah i was about to say that too x0D

  • they messaged me back the same thing

  • Whatever. It doesn't matter. Versant is going to be better than the new STG, so.... Yay :)

  • UGH FUCK STG FOR GETTING RID OF CARAH.

  • best song ever. it goes so well with heiki sorsas snowboard part in follow me around. check that out. itl make u happy :D

  • Whatever happened to Carah? D: i miss her..the new CD doesn't sound right without her ):

  • gibson firebird ;o nice guitar

  • I love watching chad play guitar, he fully gets into it! :D

  • cool song...just saw em in San Diego with Delta Fiasco...so tight

  • yea i saw them back in october, Delta fiasco is amazing

  • they are so good id die in ecstasy

  • carah's beautiful :)

  • ♥ on cd they are better...but great song =) ♥

  • Shit, for some reason I like this distorted version a lot now.

  • she always wears that shirt.

  • because she's effing hawt in it

  • indeed, they add 2 much extentions to the original lyrics and it makes it sound really really bad...

  • yeah pretty true, and idk vocals sound weird

  • Songs always sounds so awful when people record them on video cameras (cell phone?)at concerts. I bet it sounded awesome there, but damn, this sounds like shit!

  • This is my favorite song from them!!!

    THEY ROCK!

  • The whole thing with Paris Hilton was just a rumor

  • Love her voice...

  • oh yeah, what was that deal about carah doing samples of paris hilton songs and you could hear her voice in some tracks?

  • It wasn't true...or at least that's what Carah said. She said that she studied Paris's cd like crazy to see if she could hear her own voice in there anywhere as well as listening to the lyrics to see if she recognized any of her own and nope...NOTHING...

    She says the rumors started because before Carah joined STG she submitted some of her own songs to the Paris's same label and apparently Paris's people were looking at Carahs' stuff and "considering it" but never used it...

  • so what if she wore the outfit more than just once, geez? people are so vain. Maybe she really likes that outfit, maybe it's comfy, maybe it's her lucky outfit? who knows. And she looks pretty clean. She's cool, she's not like other singers who eventually sell out by dressing how they want.

  • i love shiny toy guns. since i was 13 and i love them so much! although her voice isn't that great live... they're better as a studio band.

  • all electronic bands are. more effects

  • when i saw them live, they sounded awesome

  • AIDS!!

  • wait..huh? lol

  • is it just me or does she wear that shirt a lot

  • she's punk...it's cool to be dirty

    id still hit it

  • nice

  • good song, but live.. hmm she can't hold the air, her voice's kind of tired..

  • y are people saying that they r abd live, i prefer them live , when i first heard carah i couldnt believe that voice was real, how she hti those notes..now i see it live, so u all h8as fuck off

    this band is legendary

  • i agree she does have a good voice and i love this song hey at least dont lip it like most artists and plus they have a unique sound

  • People don't always have great shows...the give them a break they probably played 10 songs arguement doesn't work though. Bands play a hell of alot more then that when they have multiple cds. It could be the recording since it's obviously not the best sound quality, I personally don't see how she sounds bad but to each his own. Don't be so quick to judge someone as talentless though based off one video shot in low quality.

  • she really isnt that bad....

  • not very good live, but an incredible actual song...

  • not very good live, but an incredible actual song...

  • wow they are horible live....

  • theyre actually not. videos make ppl sound really bad or they were just really bad this time. but when i saw them they were AWESOME

  • theyre actually not. videos make ppl sound really bad or they were just really bad this time. but when i saw them they were AWESOME

  • really? I think they sound pretty good. there is some feedback that sounds bad, but I thought overall it sounds fine?

  • Carah sounds like she chonged a fat hit from da bong. She sounds like crap! I don't care how many songs you sing, there are many great performers who sound great live after singing 5 songs in a row...that's what makes you a rock star. She needs to mix in some cardio with the tequila.

  • lmao! u wish u could sing like that she beats your arse any day

  • You know what Imma give her credit, for their concerts. They start out singing, "Starts with One." "Jackie Will Save Me" "Chemistry of a Car Crash" "Le Disko" then this song...and I'm sure her voice is hella tired out by the time she sings and that they are touring all the time. She has to hit alot of high pitches, especially in "Jackie Will Save Me" The band kickass ass...so lol.

  • but... that's what people who sing do. they sing. even when they sing... wow! five songs! must be exhausting.

  • his guitar is sexi but hes sexier! lol

  • ehhh

    they dont sound all that great live

    the girl sounds different

  • The're awesome!

    One of my fav. :)

  • Compared to the singer from The Blow, she's freakin' fantastic.

  • Of all the videos of her singing this song. I love this one the most. I like her voice when it cracks a little. And they are cool as hell too, not all stuck up and shit.

  • not to mention that they prob been singing like 10 songs already. sooo. imeaan come on give them a brake

  • dude what the hell you talking about?!

    they rock and if you think they suck then go fuck yourself and waste your time doing something else.

    dumbfucks.

  • yeah for real huh, shit i can't sing like that not to mention thats pretty high to sing lol

  • they're still great>:l

  • I love the band but i rather have the girl sing because the guy makes the CD to me boring:( but amazing band<3

  • how the hell is she still in the band!!! I cant even stand to listen to her for a second!!!

  • Oh fuck off.

  • hehehe yeah some bands so like you wanna punch your ear dreams out ! there not toooo bad (:

  • ugh i rather listen to them in cd than live...anyway i love the girl's voice (idk her name lol)

  • i don't think the guy look good w/long hair at all he looks way better w/short hair

  • haha i totally agree but hte concert i went to he had short hair and a full bierd didnt look to good but it wasa good concert coheed and cambria was there!!!

  • what venu was this?

  • Worst Live Band EVER!

    Love them in studio.. hate.. i mean.. HATE their live stuff. I feel like I am being forced to listen to wailing cats that are in heat.

    Now.. mind you its mainly the girl... everyone else actually play their instruments correctly/sing well. You can definitely tell there was a TON of work done on her voice.

  • apparently you've only seen one band live then, cause there are so many bands that are worse live than them.

  • It's called studio magic.

    And no, they're not the worst live band ever. There is much, much worse.

  • Of Course there's going to be differences between album and Live, there's not to many bands that do sound the same. They're definitely not a studio band, i've seen them twice in concert...twice because they didn't sound horrible the first time. Holy jesus this a video that has BAD sound quality obviously taken from a Digital camera.

  • i like his guitar

  • they have amazing voices

  • OMFG. My favorite band evaah! XD God I love them.

  • she has such an amazing voice

  • really. i wish they made a version where she sang it like that, now i listen to this song and its not the same.

  • they're are all so talented.

    am I the only one who likes what the girl is wearing =D lol

  • woo I went to one of their concerts, the girl is so cool but the lead singer guy is an ass. Either he's an ass or he was really really stoned. Probably stoned.

  • &hearts;

  • :O i was there!! :O

    nah just joking but i wish i was!

    this is THE BEST band ever!

    XD

  • They are really goood live I saw them last night in Philadelphia :]

  • wow ther great live

  • the girl singer looks like Karen O of the yeah yeah yeahs...STG are fresh...5/5 ^^

  • viva LA 'NO GOOD' SNOWBOARD VIDEO :D BEST !

  • Its not that they sound worse, its just not in a nice quiet recording studio. Its a much larger room.

  • most bands sounds worst live than cd

  • i met shiny toy guns mikey the drummer asked one of my gloves :)

  • ah stfu you cant even spell notified

  • love this song, they need to make a vid for this song =]

  • i was at that concert they were awsome

  • the lead singer, forgot her name but damn shes fine!

  • Carah Faye

  • yes i agree, Carah is sexy shit

  • dude who cares and second youtube bought rights to music being played on their site

  • Damn you guys are so lucky you saw them! shit, they were supposed to play at Milwaukee's Summerfest but they cancelled it because of some emergency, I'm so jealous!!! God, Carah look so damn sexy!!!!

  • I fucking LOVE shiny toy guns. I'm going to see them in november, hopefully at House of Blues. if not, at some ampitheatre in pampano.

    I'm so gonna be Carah when I grow up.

  • shinys are awesome live. i saw them at joiners and i have to say its the best gig ive ever been to. they have amazing stage presence and they are an amazing band

  • Iloverides - it's not "doorknob" it's "door, no"...

  • Ahh Shiny Toy Guns do pretty well live.

    As for Panic! at the Disco..not so much.

    But that's my opinion

  • Uhm. They do not suck live. They're actually pretty good. And regarding some comments below me....uh. Panic at the Disco has more songs than just that one, and those aren't really even the lyrics.

  • she squeaks. but ther still amazing

  • omg panic at the disco sucks live i cant beleive i wasted a day of my life to see them lol. no offense to panic at the disco fans plus their song doesnt make sense sometimes god damn doorknob? wtf????

  • I did not like this song live at first but it got better. They are definitely wayyy better recorded.

  • I SO AGREE WITH Amayra15

  • THEY DO NOT SUCK LIVE!! they are amazing!!!! :D

  • I don't know what you guys are saying but i think they are good

  • i have to say that i love their recorded music. but honestly, they suck majorly live.

  • hahaha I know right? So does Panic! at The Disco

  • They ROCK GOOD BAND there style is soo different but GOD THERE GOOD

  • there awesome live

  • its cute how she squeaked at the beginning lol

    :D

    i love this song!!!!!!! 6.6

  • OOoh I LOVE LOVE LOVE THIS SONG!!!!!!!!1

  • awesome

  • we need more cowbell!

  • too bad the audio isn't better... not much ya can do about that though....we don't all have professional recording equipment

  • i would love to meet them =)

    the bestttttttttt band ever =)

  • that guy has an awsome guitar!!!

    pretty good music to

  • i'm pretty sure it's a firebird with mini or reg humbuckers and yes it's freaking awesome custom paint job.

  • shes hot!

  • i dont know why but when i saw them there were alot of emo and goth people. But we were in the front section towards the cheap seats (haha) so maybe like i was just in a bad section.

  • omg, I really want to go see them in concert now!!!!!! damn!

  • love them so much great band and jeremy is soooooo hot !! catchy tunes mad music whats not to like!