wow, me deja una sensacion de inmensa felicidad y a la vez una profunda tristeza, inigualable interpretacion, eres grande entre los grandes. INCREIBLE!!!!!!
puede ser que la mejor sea la de luciano p..sin embargo el si no me equivoco nunca la represento en un teatro de manera completa...creo que domingo es un grande ,lo vi en vivo...la diferencia entre ellos dos es solo su personalidad .-
Ya lo dijo Pavarotti: "Si algún día, por agradarme, ponéis una grabación mía, de seguro me iré. Si lo que queréis es que me quede, ponedme una de Plácido". Bravíssimo Domingo.
I agree with barou80 Pavarotti's Italian pronunciation is more natural and he has a certain timbre in his voice that is uniquely pleasant and soulful.
I can't stand Pavarotti. the worst role I saw him in was as a starving student in La Boheme. Can't stand his face, his mouth, his tongue always sticking out.
Placido Domingo, Jose Carreras, Jose Cura and Richard Leech all sing this aria better than Pavarotti. Too him not holding the high not, Domingo sang what is in the score, which is that the B is almost the grace note and the resounding note 'the A' should be the held note.
The note (B) shouldn't be hold, look at Puccini's partiture!!! The world has decided, maybe, but since when the world is known for wise decisions? Pavarotti had a beautiful voice, but he was maybe the worst interpreter of operas: he didn't sing the author's opera, but his own personal version. This is, over all, wrong. There's no more to be said.
i prefer pavarotti just for one thing, his italian doesn't sound weird like carreras or domingo, but maybe only the italian can understand this..anyway fantastic
Two things: first, Domingo was originally a baritone, so the anything beyond the A above the Middle C would be at least somewhat tenuous for him. Second, Domingo was not physically well at that time, and that probably affected his performance. Nonetheless, Calaf is a role for the heldentenors(tenors with a baritonal sound,especially lower and mid range),and Domingo is a heldentenor.
Franco Corelli, one of the greatest Calaf's was not really a heldentenor...domingo scoops and swoops hiw way through this aria, with only modest passion, and little beauty in my opinion...still better than most today...
I was first catagorized as a Dramatic Soprano. Since my vocal coach moved away, I have a new coach and she has catagorized me a mezzo-soprano. The thing I was hoping that you would help me with, I have a problem with switching from chest voice to head voice. I have terrible allergies, I've gone to the doctor. Have had things prescribed to me, and I know for a fact that allergies is the culprit to my problem. Is there anything that you suggest?
This is the best version on YouTube. Listen to them all back-to-back-to-back and you'll quickly see why Pavarotti and Domingo are head and shoulders above everyone else. Some might say that Domingo's last note is a problem here, but there are lots of other notes in this aria too, and most tenors tend to forget about them and wait for the finale to get serious. Domingo's, from first to last, is best.
ehm...the contrary is true: Puccini wrote this aria for a voice exactly like Placido's, not Pavarotti nor Carreras as neither have/had the heft that the role requires. Also, this is a live performance...I doubt Carreras could ever do better than Domingo in the opera house,so you must be thinking of a studio recording.Apples and oranges. Also, while this aria has come to be identified with Pavarotti, he sang it mostly in concerts, in front of a mike.It's a hell of a different ball game!:~)
Well I don't think people wrote for voices like Pavarotti's, he has a very unique tone. The vocal qualities of Pavarotti and Carreras may have been better than Domingo when they were in their prime, but they were short lived times.
I think Domingo does a terrific job, wonderful vocal line, nice full projection, great phrasing.
It's not bad but this does not come close to Pavarotti's version. Also Carreras' one is better. this kind of aria just is not written for a voice like Placido's
Neither Pavarotti nor Carerras, both lyric tenors, had the vocal heft to do justice to the part of Calaf (Pav's admitted this in public before himself). Domingo is more appropriate for the role and Corelli, who had a much bigger and heavier, dramatic voice than Pav or Carreras, was perhaps the best of all.
Gorgeous vocalism although Mr. Domingo doesn't always know what to do with his arms. The tenor reaches the high B natural at the end but it is not the best I have heard.
Muy buena pero sinceramente no me emociona como cuando la canta Pavarotti
nekro23 1 year ago
wow, me deja una sensacion de inmensa felicidad y a la vez una profunda tristeza, inigualable interpretacion, eres grande entre los grandes. INCREIBLE!!!!!!
acamen 1 year ago
Awesome :O
Matuxo15 1 year ago
puede ser que la mejor sea la de luciano p..sin embargo el si no me equivoco nunca la represento en un teatro de manera completa...creo que domingo es un grande ,lo vi en vivo...la diferencia entre ellos dos es solo su personalidad .-
musilvaleo 2 years ago
no cabe duda de la maestria de domingo, peeeroo!!
NADIE PUEDE NEGAR QUE ESTA CANCION, LA MEJOR INTERPRETACION FUE Y SERA SIEMPRE LA DE PAVAROTTI!!!
R.I.P MAESTRO!!
FROM PERU!
tkmddysias 2 years ago
the last high note is edited. He did not souded like that.
nicevidbro 2 years ago
bravo placido...
luoperat 4 years ago 6
Que bonita canción..... me fascína más en la voz de Sarah Brightman aunque a ella casi no se le entiende en Italiano..... ¡Bellizimo!
quikepiaf 4 years ago
igual no es una cancion para sara ni para otra, es para un tenor !!!HOMBRE!
egisellem 4 years ago 4
Ya lo dijo Pavarotti: "Si algún día, por agradarme, ponéis una grabación mía, de seguro me iré. Si lo que queréis es que me quede, ponedme una de Plácido". Bravíssimo Domingo.
infielesno 4 years ago 7
Domingo's voice has a pinched quality to it here...and he just barely made that high B. Simply put, he does not sing this as well as Pavarotti!
Operafiend22 4 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
MELOFOLLO
Burdell22000 4 years ago
I agree with barou80 Pavarotti's Italian pronunciation is more natural and he has a certain timbre in his voice that is uniquely pleasant and soulful.
lorilee32 4 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
I can't stand Pavarotti. the worst role I saw him in was as a starving student in La Boheme. Can't stand his face, his mouth, his tongue always sticking out.
jonedelleman 4 years ago
Pavarotti is a god. Perhaps you should spend less time with *your* tongue sticking out. And flapping.
jillgivler 4 years ago
After all, he IS Italian. Haaa.
dannyboythegreat 3 years ago
its werid it seems to make every 1 quiver and shake these songs!!
elmbrent 4 years ago
Agreed with bondal...Placido Domingo owns Pavaroti...
shadowtreader 4 years ago
Sí.
tahtitieteilija 4 years ago
uh! =)
Anaisnon 4 years ago
...
tahtitieteilija 4 years ago
Muy bello... :)
Anaisnon 4 years ago
just great. i love this one. it quivers me.
kimisip 4 years ago
simplemente espléndido!
carolinaha 4 years ago
Placido Domingo, Jose Carreras, Jose Cura and Richard Leech all sing this aria better than Pavarotti. Too him not holding the high not, Domingo sang what is in the score, which is that the B is almost the grace note and the resounding note 'the A' should be the held note.
bondal 4 years ago
Jose Carreras and Jose Cura....i must say hohohoho...you must be a deaf guy.
angusmark80 4 years ago
Another outstanding performance of perhaps the most beloved music in opera.
smokeythefurball 4 years ago
Totally with you Bladiyo.
kuepandan 4 years ago
i Think this is the performance ever made of nessum dorma, pavarotti is excelent, but he never transmit feelings as Placido here, he is great here
bladiyo 4 years ago
Sounds great, but this is Pavarotti's piece, period. You can argue all you want, but it's very simple, the world has decided it. End of story.
Domingo didn't even hold the high note.
MackeyMackeyMouse 4 years ago
that Doming note was a yell
marcobaratta 4 years ago
The note (B) shouldn't be hold, look at Puccini's partiture!!! The world has decided, maybe, but since when the world is known for wise decisions? Pavarotti had a beautiful voice, but he was maybe the worst interpreter of operas: he didn't sing the author's opera, but his own personal version. This is, over all, wrong. There's no more to be said.
skyriver83 2 years ago
amazing.. incredible
TicoTorres 4 years ago
muy bueno, pero suena medio chica la voz no?? estaria medio enfermo....Igual excelente actuacion
martinzirolli 5 years ago
i prefer pavarotti just for one thing, his italian doesn't sound weird like carreras or domingo, but maybe only the italian can understand this..anyway fantastic
barou80 5 years ago
Two things: first, Domingo was originally a baritone, so the anything beyond the A above the Middle C would be at least somewhat tenuous for him. Second, Domingo was not physically well at that time, and that probably affected his performance. Nonetheless, Calaf is a role for the heldentenors(tenors with a baritonal sound,especially lower and mid range),and Domingo is a heldentenor.
PAZ0619 5 years ago
Franco Corelli, one of the greatest Calaf's was not really a heldentenor...domingo scoops and swoops hiw way through this aria, with only modest passion, and little beauty in my opinion...still better than most today...
fdomingu 4 years ago
Hi,
I practiced opera for almost a year.
I was first catagorized as a Dramatic Soprano. Since my vocal coach moved away, I have a new coach and she has catagorized me a mezzo-soprano. The thing I was hoping that you would help me with, I have a problem with switching from chest voice to head voice. I have terrible allergies, I've gone to the doctor. Have had things prescribed to me, and I know for a fact that allergies is the culprit to my problem. Is there anything that you suggest?
Lorene123 4 years ago
where is the break at? note wise
themusicman428 4 years ago
Great, this is his role. Pavarotti is not Lyric Tenor.
elex12001 5 years ago
This is the best version on YouTube. Listen to them all back-to-back-to-back and you'll quickly see why Pavarotti and Domingo are head and shoulders above everyone else. Some might say that Domingo's last note is a problem here, but there are lots of other notes in this aria too, and most tenors tend to forget about them and wait for the finale to get serious. Domingo's, from first to last, is best.
bradvn 5 years ago
ehm...the contrary is true: Puccini wrote this aria for a voice exactly like Placido's, not Pavarotti nor Carreras as neither have/had the heft that the role requires. Also, this is a live performance...I doubt Carreras could ever do better than Domingo in the opera house,so you must be thinking of a studio recording.Apples and oranges. Also, while this aria has come to be identified with Pavarotti, he sang it mostly in concerts, in front of a mike.It's a hell of a different ball game!:~)
sancarlo 5 years ago
Well I don't think people wrote for voices like Pavarotti's, he has a very unique tone. The vocal qualities of Pavarotti and Carreras may have been better than Domingo when they were in their prime, but they were short lived times.
I think Domingo does a terrific job, wonderful vocal line, nice full projection, great phrasing.
steainsy 5 years ago
It's not bad but this does not come close to Pavarotti's version. Also Carreras' one is better. this kind of aria just is not written for a voice like Placido's
koopatrizzle 5 years ago
balony
footballfever 5 years ago
yeah right...
koopatrizzle 5 years ago
Neither Pavarotti nor Carerras, both lyric tenors, had the vocal heft to do justice to the part of Calaf (Pav's admitted this in public before himself). Domingo is more appropriate for the role and Corelli, who had a much bigger and heavier, dramatic voice than Pav or Carreras, was perhaps the best of all.
rmm413 5 years ago
Pavarotti, to me, is pure effortless, wonderful power, while domingo, also to me, is pure suave and sensuality. And he can REALLY sing, too!
CHRYS1001 5 years ago
Placido is the greatest!
Jolantabuk 5 years ago
Bravo! Very nice indeed.
sutatscom 5 years ago
Gorgeous vocalism although Mr. Domingo doesn't always know what to do with his arms. The tenor reaches the high B natural at the end but it is not the best I have heard.
Samurai9 5 years ago
Oh, I love this song! It's one of my favorite songs ever! This man has a fabulous voice as well! :D
AngeDeMusique 5 years ago
singing the high A's sitting up! that is pretty hard. never get tired of this performance
jestinicasiano 5 years ago
it's not really that hard, it's just training...a good singer should be able to sing in any position...opera often demands it!
tenorrman 5 years ago
My favorite tenor aria. LVOE I
dcstudio 5 years ago