She uses the same progressions over and over. It's the same progression a lot of pop punk bands use, but with power chords instead of fingerplucking. Either she designed her songs to be infectiously familiar, or she can't/doesn't want to write complex melodies.
I love Advisory Committe and You Think it's Like This but Really It's like That or whatever the fuck it's called.
Are you people serious? Anyone who is honestly a fan of her music wouldn't mind if she hasn't sat down and learned a particular song especially when she is producing such beautiful music. People who expect an exact set don't know what indie music is about, they don't understand flow and experimentation.
"Proof" is in 1:34 of footage consisting of little more than tuning a guitar?? C'mon kid, grow up. The fact that you're intimidated by talented women shouldn't also prevent you from thinking.
Kid? You little twirp fool. I should spank you. I just had the wife listen & asked her what she noticed most & she said "The Mistakes." Just like all the other comments saying the same thing. I didn't even have to cue her. Vindication is mine! Now go outside and swing or something.
LOL "twirp"? "the wife"?? Hmmm...a woman-hater who can't spell. But hey, there are a lot of you on youtube, so run off and circle-jerk with your pals, okay? This page is for thinkers.
HAHA. That is the most moronic thing I have ever heard. This page is where I go to slum w/ the stupid. It's people like you who have dropped it down to the point where it is.
And who the hell would want to see her sit & "tune a guitar?" C'mon. Do that shit backstage. Or on stage so you don't have to actually play your instrument. That's it. I have it figured out now.
Reading all your comments on your page show me what you are. You can go away now.
If you really need to ask that question, it won't make a difference one way or another.
As regards your faint-praise insult, I presented an argument here some months ago. You make great claims for yourself as arbiter of brilliance, originality and construction, yet your own argument hasn't appeared. So take all the time you need.
It does make a difference, it either means you are being completely irrelevant, or you like character based attacks instead of valid arguments.
I don't care about your past argument, my argument has appeared, blatantly, my argument is that you use age as an insult and that you shouldn't.
You should be thanking me for helping with your arguing skills, but instead you are just proving them worse by repeating THE SAME character based attack. Sad.
Sorry kid, nothing sad going on hear except your invincible stupidity. An empty and petulant admonition is no argument. You remain the one who jumped in apropos of nothing while ignoring the previous exchange. Learn to wait your turn and bring something tangible to the table the next time you think about approaching adults.
Hey little jaw-stabber, there's nothing wrong with slagging a video. But this guy went a lot further than that: It's not a difficult song to play. Talentless.
...which thoroughly deserves a "post-or-shut-up" response. So stab away.
i understand that there is nothing wrong with giving your opinion on a video. (I'm A master at that) It's the fact that you said "Post your own stuff and prove your better" and whatever else you said. I don't care if you've insulted the video, I'm merely stating that it
s almost irritating when people say that. Not everyone is trying to say they can do better. That was all I was saying
This girl has talent as a singer, but not very much as a guitarist. The most shocking thing is that anyone would perform something that they haven't yet learned. There simply is no excuse for not being prepared before perfoming publicly. Yes, mistakes will happen, but this is a case of simply "not knowing" the material.
omg people! this is a REALLY old song and someone probably requested that she play it for them and she probably hadn't played it in a very long time and was trying to remember how to play it because that's how mirah works. She tries to play songs you request!
so what she messed up! she's human, it happens. I bet you wouldn't even have the guts to go up there. Her voice was amazing.. she's amazing live. Kudos to her.
i'm sorry to say this dommiel, but i have to say your an idiot. not everyone sounds naturally good in public. plus, i believe these mistakes where intentional. to me it sounds like a person who is expressing there feelings to someone for the first time, which would seem awkward and shaky. i think the mistakes are beautiful. plus, it's the imperfections that makes something special.
She shouldn't aim so high if her skill level as a musician is lacking so much. She needs more practice for live performances and should probably look into getting a more skilled guitarist to work with her. I've heard a few of her songs, but this video was the first performance I've seen, and I must say I'm very disappointed in her, even though what I heard I didn't think much of.
i don't think she was high. i think she made mistakes cause she had to concentrate on the chord progression of the song; she basically had her eyes on the fretboard the whole time. you can't blame her. a lot of the chords were high up on the fretboard, she also was fingerpicking.
I think it is soooo cute how she seems to lose it for a second. Performing is hard and everyone(even the greatest like Mirah) are bound to make a mistake. She carries through with it well. If anything, the fact that she fumbles a little makes it better to watch live. I don't want to listen to anyone so superior to everyone else that they don't mess up a little.
this is a super embarassing video of her. they sould take this off. nothing against her or anything. i think she has written some of them prettest songs ever.
she's wonderful, her mistakes followed by a little smirk is so genuine.
Elizabomb 9 months ago 2
i love this version!
Torn2Bitz 10 months ago
Wow, someone obviously didn't practice... Beautiful song, but still. PRACTICE!
jollysuck 1 year ago
saw her three nights ago. she got off stage and danced with us at the end. she is so lovely.
teafountains 1 year ago 6
Haha she played that on my birthday(:
I love this song.
xmikywayx 1 year ago
I love this song.. Sure, this version has a few mistakes in it, but its a fantastic song and her voice is amazingly tranquil. Cheers.
Himannv 2 years ago
Disappointing.
BlackJacketJones 2 years ago
Like her way of singing :D
batalisto 2 years ago
argh, she is perfect.
essjane 2 years ago 2
asaturn thats like the nicest thing anyone has done for anyone on the interweb.
belovedmakesmusic 2 years ago
i like your song and your voice is sweet
irlandescarrete 2 years ago
what guitar is that? fucking amazing
Giblets12 2 years ago
ok.....dont burst a vein child.........
EQUUSREIN 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
BLAHBLAHDA HBAHSHDAS D ITS TOO FUCKING LATE !!! AHHH nigger
Giblets12 2 years ago
seriously, do u even kno what nigger means u ass
EQUUSREIN 2 years ago
ouuh..
puppii95 2 years ago
ummm no
XDMissPringleXD 2 years ago
seems nervous. still plays it better than most anyone else could.
asaturn 2 years ago
you guys are being mean even if it is in the defense of this amazing women. just chillax
holdmiester 2 years ago
aw shes adorable
twilightfan531 2 years ago 2
maybe practise before u give a gig
rafl sad one
haubsen 2 years ago
What a let down.
lilcarmelskin8 2 years ago
She was great live. She's so cute and giggly!
akaPastel 2 years ago
all giggly and what not i like how she didnt stop
wtfeezey 2 years ago
soldtodying clearly said it the best.
vickorya0822 3 years ago
cute!
babizinha 3 years ago
Comment removed
kgtwin2 3 years ago
Did you notice Its a complex song to play on guitar? You have no sense of music.
Graaaainy 3 years ago
faggot you try playing that and tell me it's easy
mMusiCc12 2 years ago
aaaah its MIRAH!!
weetzybat 3 years ago
i love her flaws, her genuine spirit. It makes her more real, it makes her such an amazing artist.
rxqueen22 3 years ago 13
um hmm. My thoughts exactly. :)
Tigerlilym2 2 years ago
she's so honest in her music.
i find the mistakes make it all the more endearing.
soldtodying 3 years ago 20
Her mistakes are totally understandable. This performance was probably a while after she wrote this song; some artists forget even their own work.
It's cute, really, and the crowd even helps her out a bit.
So, quite bitching and enjoy the music. =]
BENJI127 3 years ago 3
She uses the same progressions over and over. It's the same progression a lot of pop punk bands use, but with power chords instead of fingerplucking. Either she designed her songs to be infectiously familiar, or she can't/doesn't want to write complex melodies.
I love Advisory Committe and You Think it's Like This but Really It's like That or whatever the fuck it's called.
idkmybffjv 3 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
is that her? the same gurl that sings the garden? i pictured her um thinner.........
pinkrox606 3 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
and some how slightly more gothicish... O-o
Ambee630 3 years ago
whats that matter?
listen to the music.
superficial fuck.
npoc 3 years ago 5
Or don't. It kinda blows.
Pike25x99 3 years ago
well, either or.
npoc 3 years ago
yeah me too when you here her sing she sounds really preety but no =[
STEPHENBIGBUTTN 3 years ago
Don't tell me you discovered her music becuase of So You Think You Can Dance.
telephonewirecalls 3 years ago
Well, I did. And I don't even watch the show. Just got lucky and caught the one episode. Very glad I'm did, because I find I really like her.
MrsNezbit 3 years ago
Are you people serious? Anyone who is honestly a fan of her music wouldn't mind if she hasn't sat down and learned a particular song especially when she is producing such beautiful music. People who expect an exact set don't know what indie music is about, they don't understand flow and experimentation.
TehPwnererJr 3 years ago 3
I love when they make little mistakes, it's so endearing. I like her a lot.
Jimdaniels1 3 years ago
I like musicians that practice. It's not a difficult song to play. Talentless.
Pike25x99 3 years ago
actually Pike, she's a very talented songwriter. Put up some of your own songs before you call anyone talent-free and I'll watch, I promise.
Brianjonestown 3 years ago
She may be a talented songwriter, she just can't play live obviously. Just a fact. Proof is in the video.
Pike25x99 3 years ago
"Proof" is in 1:34 of footage consisting of little more than tuning a guitar?? C'mon kid, grow up. The fact that you're intimidated by talented women shouldn't also prevent you from thinking.
Brianjonestown 3 years ago
Kid? You little twirp fool. I should spank you. I just had the wife listen & asked her what she noticed most & she said "The Mistakes." Just like all the other comments saying the same thing. I didn't even have to cue her. Vindication is mine! Now go outside and swing or something.
Pike25x99 3 years ago
LOL "twirp"? "the wife"?? Hmmm...a woman-hater who can't spell. But hey, there are a lot of you on youtube, so run off and circle-jerk with your pals, okay? This page is for thinkers.
Brianjonestown 3 years ago
HAHA. That is the most moronic thing I have ever heard. This page is where I go to slum w/ the stupid. It's people like you who have dropped it down to the point where it is.
rationalresponders.c o m is for the thinkers.
Pike25x99 3 years ago
You still here, kid?
Brianjonestown 3 years ago
And who the hell would want to see her sit & "tune a guitar?" C'mon. Do that shit backstage. Or on stage so you don't have to actually play your instrument. That's it. I have it figured out now.
Reading all your comments on your page show me what you are. You can go away now.
Pike25x99 3 years ago
Stop using "kid" as an insult.
A "kid" would have brains enough to get a better argument, thanks.
Seedr0 3 years ago
"A "kid" would have brains enough to get a better argument, thanks."
Well, if that's true then it's not an insult, is it? This would make it a term of respect.
Perhaps next time you could try thinking a little more before you post, kiddo.
Brianjonestown 3 years ago
Are you saying you aren't using kid as an insult?
Oh, and once again nice job with the brilliant, original and well formed argument.
Seedr0 3 years ago
If you really need to ask that question, it won't make a difference one way or another.
As regards your faint-praise insult, I presented an argument here some months ago. You make great claims for yourself as arbiter of brilliance, originality and construction, yet your own argument hasn't appeared. So take all the time you need.
Brianjonestown 3 years ago
It does make a difference, it either means you are being completely irrelevant, or you like character based attacks instead of valid arguments.
I don't care about your past argument, my argument has appeared, blatantly, my argument is that you use age as an insult and that you shouldn't.
You should be thanking me for helping with your arguing skills, but instead you are just proving them worse by repeating THE SAME character based attack. Sad.
Seedr0 3 years ago
Sorry kid, nothing sad going on hear except your invincible stupidity. An empty and petulant admonition is no argument. You remain the one who jumped in apropos of nothing while ignoring the previous exchange. Learn to wait your turn and bring something tangible to the table the next time you think about approaching adults.
Brianjonestown 3 years ago
i will stab the next person in the jaw to say " post your own stuff and prove your better"
WHEN PEOPLE INSULT A VIDEO< THEYRE NOT ALWAYS SAYING THEY CAN DO BETTER
UnholyProductions666 3 years ago
Hey little jaw-stabber, there's nothing wrong with slagging a video. But this guy went a lot further than that: It's not a difficult song to play. Talentless.
...which thoroughly deserves a "post-or-shut-up" response. So stab away.
Brianjonestown 3 years ago
i understand that there is nothing wrong with giving your opinion on a video. (I'm A master at that) It's the fact that you said "Post your own stuff and prove your better" and whatever else you said. I don't care if you've insulted the video, I'm merely stating that it
s almost irritating when people say that. Not everyone is trying to say they can do better. That was all I was saying
UnholyProductions666 3 years ago
Please do.
Pike25x99 3 years ago
Exactly
kgtwin2 2 years ago
This girl has talent as a singer, but not very much as a guitarist. The most shocking thing is that anyone would perform something that they haven't yet learned. There simply is no excuse for not being prepared before perfoming publicly. Yes, mistakes will happen, but this is a case of simply "not knowing" the material.
Sweeper5 3 years ago
Mistakes made it painful.
Pike25x99 3 years ago
this is really good despite the mistake.
gorramdoll 3 years ago
lol hahahaha... sounds sweet!;)
McGuyvers 3 years ago
it just looks like she hasn't played it in awhile. not a big deal. i've seen bigger named artists have the same trouble, so who cares.
melissery 3 years ago
omg people! this is a REALLY old song and someone probably requested that she play it for them and she probably hadn't played it in a very long time and was trying to remember how to play it because that's how mirah works. She tries to play songs you request!
amykasio 3 years ago 4
The problem with it is this -
The mistakes she makes are incredibly distracting, which ruins the flow of her music.
Artists like her (acoustic type people) are generally listened to because of their flow. After the video, all I remember are the mistakes.
bweedly 3 years ago
Can anyone tab this for me? haha
kmacattack3 3 years ago
so what she messed up! she's human, it happens. I bet you wouldn't even have the guts to go up there. Her voice was amazing.. she's amazing live. Kudos to her.
kmacattack3 3 years ago 2
also you should notice how she begins to pick up in the end.
deadwithindark 3 years ago
i'm sorry to say this dommiel, but i have to say your an idiot. not everyone sounds naturally good in public. plus, i believe these mistakes where intentional. to me it sounds like a person who is expressing there feelings to someone for the first time, which would seem awkward and shaky. i think the mistakes are beautiful. plus, it's the imperfections that makes something special.
deadwithindark 3 years ago
She shouldn't aim so high if her skill level as a musician is lacking so much. She needs more practice for live performances and should probably look into getting a more skilled guitarist to work with her. I've heard a few of her songs, but this video was the first performance I've seen, and I must say I'm very disappointed in her, even though what I heard I didn't think much of.
Dommiel 3 years ago
god she sucks so much...freaking screwing up all over the place
jjjjkkkk
that's actually some pretty intricate guitarwork she can screw up all she wants...i'll still love her.
Drewb18c1 3 years ago
she is old but hot
girlboy18 3 years ago
hahaha-fantastic comment
jvoigt82 3 years ago 2
You are an idiot.
rlburns666 3 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
mirah is fat
jeanniefd 3 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
she's a pig
adelebea 3 years ago
love her
seeing her next mo in chicago
teafountains 3 years ago
Where is she playing in chicago??
MichaelBradus 3 years ago
dude...google it
Drewb18c1 3 years ago
she is adorable.
fratsdomino 3 years ago
mon chien
joue de la guitare mieux
que mirah hahaha
luciaxfixia 4 years ago
et quelle chansons joue ton chien?
vullita 4 years ago
je ne me
rappelle
pas
luciaxfixia 3 years ago
i don't think she was high. i think she made mistakes cause she had to concentrate on the chord progression of the song; she basically had her eyes on the fretboard the whole time. you can't blame her. a lot of the chords were high up on the fretboard, she also was fingerpicking.
dogsmusic 4 years ago
the mistakes add character...and she's real high? It's all around dope.
kemstarporvida 4 years ago
Iron Horse is in SAcramento!!!!
gumdroplou 4 years ago
esta mina canta como una gallina jejeje
luciaxfixia 4 years ago
yay human beings! and the triumph of beauty in humanity rather than production perfection.
icountyoureyelashes 4 years ago 2
I feel sorry for those who think this is flawed.
Those mistakes are artistically perfect.
Seedr0 4 years ago 4
I've never seen her messed up live. Is she high or something?
sk8wnec 4 years ago
I think her mistake at the start makes the whole performance more charming.
callom 4 years ago
I think it is soooo cute how she seems to lose it for a second. Performing is hard and everyone(even the greatest like Mirah) are bound to make a mistake. She carries through with it well. If anything, the fact that she fumbles a little makes it better to watch live. I don't want to listen to anyone so superior to everyone else that they don't mess up a little.
miriamleaman 4 years ago
this is a super embarassing video of her. they sould take this off. nothing against her or anything. i think she has written some of them prettest songs ever.
diosmio22 4 years ago
i don't care as long as she still writing such a beautiful song like this. mirah is one of the best female artists out there
buddude420 4 years ago
is she alright?
garythetramp 4 years ago
Hopefully one day i will get to enjoy Mirah live.
kaceycash 4 years ago 2