Mariah Carey butterfly live @ zdf wetten das, germany(rare video)

[TheMadjoB]

Lip sync!

[lloydylizard]

Back up singers sound shit ! keep it down, trying to listen to mariah !

[jaquen1977]

@lloydylizard The backup was the only thing live on this. Put on the CD if you wanna hear MC because this is all playback on her part.

[mcluver455]

Only time she ever sang this live was on her Butterfly Tour.

[for2pica]

of course that's live

[ZbmwM5]

In the normal/album version at 3:45, she would sing "spread your wings and fly-y-y" but she doesnt here. Hm.... I'm thinking this is live and she is just THAT good!  :)

[MCLambDahling3000]

i can't believe he just said that! "this is small, medium, and large."

[MariahCareyAngel1]

She's soo pretty in this video!!

Love this song!!

[Shazni1409]

it is live coz her neck does tht straining thing

[prozerfina]

even though its lipped its still her voice !

[lolqueto]

not not live.. faked...

[medeh28mariahcarey]

EvEn LypsyNc st!LL bEat!fuL LovE !T

anD sHes reaLLy bEat!fuL hEre

! LovE thE v!dEo .. ^_^

meLoDy

[NicholeGoodger]

Nah, she really is singing it- but she does have the recorded version playing along with it. maybe the weather was dry, and she knew she needed backup cuz she knew her voice might break up.

[nargiz01]

Mariah Carey is the Sence of my life

she follows my whole life

thats why because I love her soo much <3

[lantopher69]

not live! the back ups are live though :)

[jrr1234567890]

@lantopher69 shame on you mariah for making your back up singers do all the work

[toptimbot]

OMG LipSync

But Very Good I Like it

Love her

[medeh28mariahcarey]

@toptimbot fOr aLL whO sa!d L!psyNc

!f yOu wOuLd jUst hEre mar!aH s!Ng!ng L!vE

yOu w!LL reaLLy amAzEd w!th hEr bEaut!fuL, swEet, aMaz!ng anD pOwErfuL vO!cE

mar!aH fan t!LL dEath dO Us paRt

>meLoDy

[xandernorthstaar]

Yeah live. Some drops in pitch here and there, and the mic thing.

[TheKazenokizu]

lipsync

[xxxxjaneyvillexxxx]

IS THIS LIVE?

[caiojuniormc1]

I think that it is not live

but this beautiful

[manfromphil02]

for the effort to visit Germany 3*

[miguelmaui24]

God, she sang beautiful!

[initochanchan]

she looks incredibly beautiful in this video.