Added: 4 years ago
From: hopesfires
Views: 88,359
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (291)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • I swear, she can sing anything and still have it sound amazing!! 

  • oh, never mind ^.^'

  • what CD is this from?

  • @demon41096 Anywhere But Home

  • Korn fucking rocks. Amy Lee is an amazing singer. the end.

  • lol here face at 1:47 is epic derp!!

  • for some reason this is the 1st song ive heard amy cuss o3o

  • i do like this version much better but thats just me

  • i dyed my hair black because Amy Lee's my idol!

  • the korn version was goin through my mind when i was beatin the shit out of my little sisters boyfriend

  • This is very soft. It has a fairly and very smooth going of both softnesses and violent, pounding instruments soon after. Korn's version possibly was the original, if I remember correctly. Korn's version almost goes straight into the rough guitars and all that hardcore music. Amy has a very wonderful voice, godly even. But Johnathan has a fairly good voice as well, atleast for the music he and Korn does. So I would say that I like both versions fairly evenly.

  • O.O

  • I will admit i like KoRn a little more than Evanescence and overall i like korns version of thoughtless more but they do it differently Amy sings a little faster but also sounds like a fucking angel. But KoRn does sound amazing and idk how great the piano fits in with this song.....i mean it does sound good but overall i think KoRn does this song a little better. Thumbs up if you agree with me. :)

  • I am offended by some of the words in this song.

  • this is listenable, once or twice but Korn owns this shit!

  • Am I the only one who thinks its both funny, shocking and awesome when she curses? truthfully I didnt expect her to.

  • I love Amy Lee's voice its so perfect , unlike that whore Gaga . Who the hell likes that bitch anyway? I also love this song but I cant find it in normal version not live I havent known of Evanescence long I only found this band like a month ago and so far I love every song I here and thats weird for me to say cause I only like everything from Disturbed . Can anyone help me find the normal version of this song I love getting caught in the music , I could sit for hours listening to this singer :)

  • @TERRORTROOPER4 Both Amy Lee and Lady Gaga are amazing in different ways. Keep your own tastes to yourself. They both have amazing voices and both have different images. You can be a fan of both without being a bigot.

  • @TERRORTROOPER4 Im a fan of hat 'bitch' and she isnt a whore nor a bitch LMFAO.

    I love some of the mixes people have made using Evanescence an GaGa...They should make a song together it would sound so cool.

    Love this song!! And I also enjoy this one a lot more than Korn's

  • I love Amy Lee's voice its so perfect , unlike that whore Gaga . Who the hell likes that bitch anyway? I also love this song but I cant find it in normal version not live I havent known of Evanescence long I only found this band like a month ago and so far I love every song I here and thats weird for me to say cause I only like everything from Disturbed . Can anyone help me find the normal version of this song I love getting caught in the music , I could sit for hours listening to this singer :)

  • @TERRORTROOPER4 there IS no normal version, this is the one thats on the album. i like how it sounds this way anyways

  • I love this song! It made me feel alot better when I was in a crappy mood. :D Thx for putting this song up!

  • Why are people hating on KoRn? Both versions are good

  • I wish I could sing all the pain the way she does it..so unique

  • I love this! But Korn is good aswell! :)

  • 1:52 is the most gorgeous picture of our dear Amy ive ever seen.

    This is the best video ive found with this song :3

    and Amy, youre AMAZING.

    Both of the versions are awesome \m/

  • @xXAuthorAngelXx

    Every picture of Amy Lee I see makes me speechless. I can totally find her personality the innocence and the decency (even if her eyes are covered with black darkness) which Gaga the Lame* Monster and others can never have. I respect them but Amy Lee is just jaw dropping.

  • @AmySixx666 Oh yes, Amy is completely breathtaking. Truly, shes like an angel. Ive never seen (or heard) anything/ anyone that i thought was more beautiful.

  • @xXAuthorAngelXx Agreed :)

  • @AmySixx666 Yes but i kinda like Gaga i love metal and screamo but i can go a little bit with pop i would rather say Britney spears now shes the bitch shes fake and lip sinks but yes amy could take over the music world if she wanted to XD

  • She brought so much more to this song than korn ever could

  • GO AMY!!! Evanescence ftw^^

  • I like sally's song she is talking about how she loves someone but is afriaid to ask if he does to

  • @SourBlueGummieBear She actually covered that song from The Nightmare Before Christmas. Amy did not write that song.

  • @Roleplayer008 She covered it from Korn not some fucking soundtrack

  • @SamanthaJooBroo I was not talking about Thoughtless, I was replying to their comment where SourBlue here must have simply been mistaken and thought that Amy wrote Sally's song. I do know that Amy covered Thoughtless from Korn and I love her version. Sorry if I offended you to the point of cussing.

  • i like both versions

  • does anyone know where i can get the piano sheet music for this song? ~amy lee~ <33

  • DONT READ THIS CAUSE IT ACTUALLY WORKS. YOU WILL GET KISSED ON THE NEAREST POSSIBLE FRIDAY BY THE LOVE OF YOUR LIFE.TOMMOROW WILL BE THE BEST AY OF YOUR LIFE. HOWEVER IF YOU DO NOT POST THIS TO AT LEAST THREE VIDEOS YOU WILL DIE WITHIN 2 DAYS.NOW UV STARTED READING THIS DONT STOP.THIS IS SO SCARY.PUT THIS ON AT LEAST 5 VIDEOS IN 143 MINUTES WHEN UR DONE PRESS F6 AND UR LOVERS NAME WILL APPEAR ON THE SCREEN IN BIG LETTERS.THIS IS SO SCARY CAUSE IT ACTUALY WORK

  • @Jak3210 GASP! HOW THOUGHTLESS OF YOU!!!

  • The guitars sound amazing!!! :O

  • I love Korn but I'm not a big fan of Evanesence however I love the way she sings this song

  • I like both versions tbh! This one is slower, and softer... Whereas Korns is heavy and loud.. they are both so unique yet amazing. Why bother saying which is better...everyone has different taste...(:

  • @3dgemogirl Indeed ^^> I really like how she fits the piano into this version, I still prefer korn, though. I'd love to see'em make a duet like in Freak on a leash, 'twould be nice to see that, their combined singing is awesome ^^)

  • I like this version better because I love Amy's vocals <3

  • i love this song i think it way better then kron

  • I love the piano :D

  • so amazing.she is awesome live

  • O_o Uhmm....She's married

  • I like this one better than korn's

  • not saying its not good its nice

  • this is live! but still it's good as hell!!XD

  • *sigh* now that's what I call singing with emotion! Tried listening to WRTF and felt like punching someone for the lack of feeling in the songs.

  • KoRn is my fav band so im very critical about covering them but this song WOW i really love it, it isnt better than the original but its great amy is so badass:D

  • I love her corsets... I wish I had a corset that fit me... I do appreciate this band doing thoughtless though ha

  • vocals are about the same for both bands...awesome but the band itself i would go with korn

  • THUMBS UP IF YOUR DREAM IS A WILD SEX NIGHT WITH AMY LEE

  • THUMBS UP IF YOUR DREAM IS A WILD SEX NIGHT WIH AMY LEE

  • @rapcoremanx not for a girl lol my dream is to sing like her <3

  • WTF 1:47 XD

  • @TheWorldRoxz LOL

  • I love this cover. I think out of all the covers this band has done, this is prlly the best. It sounds more haunting, disorted psychotic. (with the lyrical singing in the beginning)

  • AMY LEE IS MARRIED.o.O

  • @AmyTheJawsTerminator

    why do u need 3 replys for 1 comment >.>

  • i love both versions but b4 i even knew that Evanscence coverred this song i thought amy lee would do goood to the song :)

  • I'm confused. Was Korn the original singer or Evanescence? :/

  • @pompapartygal Korn is, Evanescence did a cover of their song during their "Anywhere but Home" tour. Right before beginning the opening line, she said they were going to do a song by a band everyone knows. That she wasn't going to even say the name, the audience oughtta know what it is. I just listened to it on my iPod so I still have that in my memory. Hope that helps :)

  • I prefer this version over KoRn. It might be because I'm just not a big fan of KoRn in the first place, but I just love it when Amy Lee sings it :)

  • this sucks, korn is king

  • @VanillaSkyPoet u suck! don't watch the video!

  • @Sinara6 Lol i thought it be good. I love Evanescence but this song is awful.

    My opinion BROSKI.

  • @VanillaSkyPoet lmao epic I'm jus kiddin this IS youtube we r entitled 2 our own opinion

  • idk what all you are on about on both the KoRn and Evanescence versions, they are both amazing songs and both show anger, but different types, raw violent anger in the case of KoRn, or darker anger in this version, i love them both!

  • 1:50 LOL

  • Hell Yeah,, This sounds fkn beautiful.

  • i would go lesbian for Amy Lee!

  • @kiddelmoandtgrouch She's married.

  • @kiddelmoandtgrouch I'd go straight for Amy Lee.

  • @kiddelmoandtgrouch im with you on that one haha she is so effin' hot

  • @kiddelmoandtgrouch I'd get a sex-change so I could go lesbian for Amy Lee.

  • @kiddelmoandtgrouch  Me Too!!!

  • @kiddelmoandtgrouch Me too! You know...if it weren't for the whole penis thing T_T

  • @JamesKravenwolf Hahahahahaha Nice :p

  • Amy Lee's version is a hell of a lot better than KoRn's.

  • @summerwhitla no its not. Evanescence it awesome but KoRn is EPIC!!!

  • @summerwhitla thats debatable :/

  • @summerwhitla thats debatable :/ personally i dont think she sounds angry enough

  • @summerwhitla Thats debatable....very, very debatable

  • @WeaponXSigma not at all.... korn smashes on amy lee. korns been around longer and will be around longer. period.

  • @extracredit100 While its true that KoRn has been around longer than evanescence has, the reason why i believe its debatable that Amy's version is better than KoRn's is that I find both versions equally awesome.

  • @summerwhitla uhhh Amy Lee did a great job at covering this song but no where better than the original.

  • @summerwhitla no it is fucking not

  • @summerwhitla No, its impossible. Amy made it darker and sweeter, but the original is forever the best.

    If you don't like nu metal, go fucking listen to it. Its awesome, I love KoRn and Evanescence, but the original is fucking beast.

  • @summerwhitla fails hard korns is better its more there type of music

  • @summerwhitla well, Korn wrote the actual song and inspired Amy Lee to do a cover. So ya gotta give them props for that :)

  • @summerwhitla well thats your opinion i respect that but in my opinion Korns is better but both of them are good :b

  • @summerwhitla bullshit

  • Comment removed

  • korn > eva

  • Fucking good!!!

  • @VicePower lol yea we are and yes i am :D

  • @VicePower yea i know, but my problem is that i'm lazy :D lol

  • @VicePower well i'm 18 and i'm in this progam thing that's a high school/college program, this is my last year there and we have to take certain courses to graduate so they pick the classes for us.

  • @VicePower well idt i have the grades for it though. my gpa is 1.7 something. it's not that i'm stupid or anything i'm just lazy as hell lol

  • @VicePower oh o.k i just hope u stay safe. well i'm really not sure yet, i was thinking about something with animals, not a vet though. maybe i'l lwork at a zoo lol

  • @VicePower it would be cool to do something like that but i honestly don't think it'l lever happen, mostly becuz i don't have the skills and i don't have the guts. i'm trying to down myself or nuthin like that it's just reality. what r u wanting to do?

  • @VicePower well i don't think that's ever happening for me lol with church choir i'm not singing by myself and the attention isn't focused on me lol what r u wanting to do then?

  • I think Amy Lee and Evanescence did a great job on their cover of a classic Korn song. I still prefer the original Korn version, but they really can't be compaired. Korn and Evanescence took the song in two completely different directions and made it their own. Either way, they both rock.

  • @VicePower oh that's a good song. the only time i sang in front of people was in choir at church and i sang papa roach- last resort on rock band with my friends but that was it. but yea i don't think i'll ever get past stage fright, i had a public speaking class and that didn't go over too well

  • @VicePower i have stagefright also but i probably have it worse...maybe lol but yea killstwitch engage is awesome, it actually took me a while to figure out the singer was black cuz i don't tend to look at videos much. but anyhoo u probably have nuthin to be shy about

  • @VicePower lol well go ahead and give it to me anyway....that's what she said haha

  • @VicePower i haven't gotten to wear i can sing for a long time with growling, i can do it but i guess my throat isn't that strong to do it for a long time. and it's kinda funny becuz people wouldn't expect from me cuz i'm a typical blonde with blue eyes and i guess i'm one of those people who could pull off the preppy look and the "rockish" look lol so yea i freak everyone out when i do it. but nah u don't have to look like a metal fan to be one, fuck that shit lol

  • @VicePower oh i like arch enemy also :D i can actually growl and it freaks everyone out since i'm a girl and all lol

  • @VicePower well i think her and JD are good friends and she had his permission. amy portrayed more of a hurt anger than a rage anger i nthis song, so she did do good with the emotions of it, and plus covers aren't really supposed to sound like the original, they're supposed to have some of your own flair to it. but yes lacuna coil is pretty good, do you know within temptation? btw lacuna coil did a cover of depeche's mode song "enjoy the silence" and it sounds different from the original

  • @VicePower yeah. sorry. i wouldnt rlly know cuz i dont listen to Korn so i dont know how Jon's voice is. but Freak On A Leash was awesome =)

  • How can anyone sing this good live :O :D

  • no duh this isnt Ev. i just dont like hearing Amy cuss in songs, covers or not.

  • i love the way she sings this, i wish her and j.d will do a duet with this song

  • I picture mythological Gods and Godesses fighting whenever I hear this song...Huh.

    This is beyond words, by the way.

  • you edited it well thanks

  • i just hate to hear her curse in her songs, even covers. it's such a cheap tactic. its like "oh i cant think of a good lyric, so i'll cuss" i mean come on. her lyrics are so amazing and meaningful, but this is just cussing and stuff. she totally rocked the cover aspect, but i just dont like the whole cussing tactic

  • O.o I was replying to a comment to a lyric video I did of this song - then saw your 'cd version' here... Then I started comparing both of them, playing some of this then some of mine--- Sounds exacccctly the same to me :/ So bs to your description saying everyone elses was crappy audio

  • I like it! :)

  • Lol at 1:49

  • F U it*s not CD

  • @5693252

    Yes it is xD

    Its from the CD Anywhere But Home. You idiot. -.-

  • Yeah i was hoping that this would be the recorded version. But i like korns version a little bit more better.

  • For all you people who dont think this is the CD version, IT IS!! Lots of CD have one song on them that was recorded live, and lot's of times it's the final song on the album. There is no better version, now stop whining because this song is awesome!

  • LMAO. cd version my ass xD

  • best cover ever

  • I soooo LOVE that u edited all the background noise & screaming fans!!!!!

  • in my opinoin korn's version is more depressive and angrier. and this is kind of cold and sad i think, but i also like it

  • Kocham Evanescence;-** A ta nuta jest zajebiaszcza;-)

  • @Dresden1065 No need for language like that. While you are entitled to an opinion, keep it to yourself next time.

  • Aww... I used to have this CD, but i have no idea where it went! :(

  • I love this version a lot better anyway... in the studio it would just take away from their energy.

  • good song but if its a cd version then why can i hear people in the background

  • @hattenifnatten because they had a LIVE CD... called 'Anywhere but Home'... there is no studio version... but this is technically the cd version that they made from live recording at their concert in france.

  • @NYspitfire hehe yeah i know i was just trying to be sacastisk on the title, but still an awsome song, when anywhere but home came in store i travelt half around the world just to get i 4 mouths before it came in my own contry, brogt it with a dvd back then.X3

  • @hattenifnatten youre a hard core chick, i tip my hat to you ! (=

  • @NYspitfire thank \m/

  • both versions are nice but personally I prefer amy lee's version

  • Both versions are brilliant!

  • I feel both versions are amazing and good for different moods.

  • I Really like that they use Piano in this song, and amy's voice is great as ever, but still, i like KoRn's version more, just more hate, anger and desperation

  • GOtta fuckin agree wit you potheads

  • When did Amy lee start cussing lol

  • I havent heard the orginal? But i rele like this alot!

  • Original is by Korn. It's good, but I honestly like this one better. :)

  • Amy lee is fucking HOT!!!!!!!!!!

  • @potheads8994 Yes, yes she is

  • @potheads8994 She's married

  • I perfer the original version better. It suites johnathan's voice better. Amy sings it well though.

  • i love it when amy lee cuss!

  • lol I dont agree with the "the way thoughtless is actually supposed to sound like" the original sounds like its supposed to sound.. :P this is a cover

  • this is an intense song

  • A great version of the song... different.

    but I still prefer the korn-version cause JDs singing is just so great and I don't think that there is anyone who could do it better(but Amy is also great)

  • That's not really singing, it's screaming. :)

  • korn is better..

    this is just a cover..

    if anyone says this is nice, bcoz this is a nice COVER..

  • 4:26-4:30 Love the highlights and makeup!

  • Love this version way better! Korn is...not hard core enough for me....Evanescence really brings out my feelings,and I can totally relate...I will be doing this cover too...but what do I say instead pf using profanity?

  • Instead of a** you can say.. well you cqn just say I want you crying in front of me. And for fu** you can say What on earth you think your doing to me.

  • What the f...

    sorry, but i disagree

    This truely is a great version of this song, but I like the KoRn version more.

    And come on. KoRn not hardcore?

    Just listen to Right Now by them and say it's not hardcore ^^

  • @Psychopathensau koRn are not hardcore... they're EPICORE!

  • even the CD version is their live performance? any versions that don't have the fans in the background?

  • @Psychopathensau ._. I don't like Right Now. Even thought I am a big KoRn fan.. I just dislike that song. Just sayin. :P

  • @Psychopathensau I think korn is nu metal, a "heavy" one, but it is XD

    PS: I like korn

  • ha.. haha..hahaha... what Korn have you been listening to the new stuff... go back to their earlier stuff the were the creators of Nu Metal along side of Marilyn Manson, Slipknot, And System Of A Down... are you like a thrasher or somthing?

  • i like them equally much, thoughtless is a big song in my life because i was made fun of a lot but both versions are special in their own way... and im a bit biased towards korn but i love this version....

  • Hot!