WARNING ON BILAL PHILIPS

[dawah100]

i dont get it what is that we should beware of about bilal?

[asalafi]

The 'Ulamah and the Students of Knowledge have warned Bilal Philips and have tried to give him sincere advice about his erroneous ways but he has not heeded their continuous da'wah. This is why the Ulamah have warned against him.

An example of this is that in his book The Fundamentals of Tawheed : Islamic Monotheism, on page 25ish, he calls to Tawheedul Hakimiyyah about which Shaykh Ibnul-'Uthaimeen (and other then him) said, whoever calls to Tawheedul-Hakimiyyah is an innovator.

[asalafi]

And this is not a small matter rather it is the way of a sect who came out in the time of the companions of the prophet (peace be upon him) and not only that they also fought against the companions too Until 4th Kalifa Ali ibn abi Talib fought and killed most of them. Along side to this he encourages suicide booming (I seen the vid its on TY) and he works with the people of bidah which again should not be taken lightly.

[Hurk01]

@dawah100 whoever enjoys listening to Bilal Philips is one of two: jahil(ignoramus) or person of desire and innovation.

FOr verily, he doesn't address the issue of warning the muslims from Jamaat like Jammat Tabligh,Ikhwaan al Muslimeen, Sooriyah, and the like. He sits with the people of innovation without addressing the innovation. THus he is a person of innovation due to his actions and statement. May Allah guide him or break his back.For indeed his misguiding the people away from the PATH.

[easyonetwothree]

Abdullaah bin al-Imaam Ahmad said, “Abu Turaab an-Nakhshabee came to my father who began to say, ‘So and so is da’eef (weak) and so and so is thiqah (reliable)’. So Abu Turaab said, ‘O Shaikh, do not backbite the Ulamaa’. So my father turned to him and said, ‘Woe be to you, this is naseehah (advice), this is not backbiting’.” (al-Kifaayah, 92 and Sharh Ilal at-Tirmidhi 1/350)

[ibinyamin]

why? does it hurt?

[quruxley1]

Baraak Allahuu fiek for this.

[danishmukaty]

May the La'nah of Allah be upon Neo-Salafis

[asalafi]

That is why Bilal has been warned against... becz he is with foolish people like you!!

[choorijamadar]

LOOOLZZ!!!u noe bro i actually heard Bilal Philips with my own ears say that he dosnt like seperate or like speak against Tablighi Jamat...he said that he dosnt refute them or anything and they just have a tiiinsy bit of rongneess in couple of things here and there & SITS WITH THEM...thas wat popped into my head wen i heard bout all the bid3a and stuff that the tablighis do and that were to stay away frm them and not to sit with them..SUBHANALLAH!!

[ryukenb2k]

Salam malikum brother ramadhaan murbarek, I hate all bid'ah and I dont understand how tasbeeh has survived this long whilst in other religions they have the same thing e.g. christians/hindus/buddhists, then people use excuse its easy to to count. I find tasbeeh sickening what next we going to use bells and horns to call to prayer

[aboewaleed]

Jazak Allah ogair for this info brothers

[aboewaleed]

Baraak Allah fiek for the info brothers!

[thesalafi]

Shaikh ul-Islaam Ibn Taymiyyah- said: “And such as the People of Innovation among the people of the [innovated] sayings that oppose the Book and the Sunnah or the acts of worship opposing the Book and the Sunnah - for exposing their condition and warning the Ummah about them is obligatory by unanimous agreement of the Muslims - ...

[thesalafi]

...until it was said to Imaam Ahmad bin Hanbal: “Is it more loved to you that a man fasts, prays and peforms tawaaf or that he speaks about the People of Innovation [i.e. exposes them and warns about them]?” He replied: “When he stands, prays and performs tawaaf that is for himself but when he talks about the People of Innovation then that is for the Muslims and this is more excellent.

[thesalafi]

Muhammad bin Bandaar al-Sabbaak al-Jurjaani said, “I said to Ahmad bin Hanbal, ‘I find it very difficult to force myself to say, ‘So and so is da’eef’ and ‘So and so is a liar (kadhdhaab)’’. So Ahmad said, ‘When you remain silent and I remain silent, who will inform the ignorant one about that which is authentic (saheeh) from that which is problematic (saqeem)’.” (Majmoo al-Fataawaa 28/231 and al-Kifaayah, 92)

[thesalafi]

Abdullaah bin al-Imaam Ahmad said, “Abu Turaab an-Nakhshabee came to my father who began to say, ‘So and so is da’eef (weak) and so and so is thiqah (reliable)’. So Abu Turaab said, ‘O Shaikh, do not backbite the Ulamaa’. So my father turned to him and said, ‘Woe be to you, this is naseehah (advice), this is not backbiting’.” (al-Kifaayah, 92 and Sharh Ilal at-Tirmidhi 1/350)

[thesalafi]

Abu Zaid al-Ansaari an-Nahawi said, ''Shu’bah came to us on a rainy day and said, 'Today is not a day for hadeeth, today is a day of backbiting. Let us come together and backbite the liars' .'' (al-Kifaayah of al-Baghdaadee, no. 91).

[thesalafi]

Sufyaan Ibn Uyainah said, ''Shu’bah used to say, 'Let us come together so that we can backbite for the sake of Allaah, the Mighty and Majestic'.'' (al-Laalikaa’ee 1/140).

[asalafi]

From Mu'aawiyah ibn Abi Sufyan, the Prophet said, "Whoever Allah wishes good for, he grants them Fiqh (understading) of the Deen."

May Allaah bless you with the undestanding of ad-Dawah Salafiyyah for indeed the madhab of the salaf is nothing but the HAQQ...Aameen

[loverofhuq]

can i remind you all that this is still classified as backbiting! may Allah guide you all

ameen

[asalafi]

Refuting the innovators and the errors of authors is not backbiting rather is a form of jihaad in defending the religion from falsehood.

There are six occasions where the scholars have reminded us about. Other than these occasions then it is forbidden.

[asalafi]

These six exception are taken from Imam Nawawi in his explanation of Saheeh Muslim :

1 Oppression

2 Help in changing the evil and bring the sinner to the right path

[asalafi]

3 Seeking a fatwa or religious ruling

This is allowed due to the hadeeth of Hind and her saying, ‘Abu Sufyaan is a miserly(stingy) man and he doesn’t give me what is sufficient for me and my son except if I take it from him without him knowing.’ The Prophet said to her ‘Take what will be sufficient for you and your son with righteousness,’

4 Warning the Muslims from evil

[asalafi]

There are different types of warnings. From it is to criticise the one who is deserving of that such as mentioning the faults of narrators, witnesses and authors. This is allowed by the consensus of Muslims, rather it is obligatory to preserve the religion. It also includes describing faults (about a person, for a serious reason such as business, marriage, etc.),

[asalafi]

From it is to speak up if you see someone buying faulty goods or a person that is stealing or smoking/drinking or committing fornication, or similar to that then you mention about them. This is by way of sincere advice not with the intention of harming or to bring about corruption.

[asalafi]

Also if you see a man going to a sinner or Innovator taking knowledge from him and you fear that he will be harmed then you must advise him explaining the situation to him seeking only sincere advice

5 Those who are open with their sins and Innovations

6 Description

end of Imam Nawawi’s six points.

[loverofhuq]

the prophet (saw) said that the best form of jihad is speaking out against a tyrant ruler, if this is what he did then he is not wrong, may Allah swt guide us all,

[asalafi]

yes... read the full hadeeth..in private NOT in PUBLIC!!

That (speaking out against the Tyant rulers) is the way of the Kawarij NOT the way of the people of sunnah.

[asalafi]

Stated Imaam Barbahaaree in Sharh us-Sunnah:

"If you find a man making supplication against the ruler, know that he is a person of innovation. If you find a person making supplication for the ruler to be upright, know that he is a person of the Sunnah, if Allaah wills.

[asalafi]

Stated Imaam Abu Bakr al-Aajuree (d.360H, rahimahullaah):

“It is not permissible for the one who sees the uprising of a khaarijee who has revolted against the leader, whether he is just or oppressive – so this person has revolted and gathered a group behind him, has pulled out his sword and has made lawful the killing of Muslims – it is not fitting for the one who sees this, that he becomes deceived by his recitation of the Qur’aan,

[asalafi]

...the length of his standing in prayer, nor his constant fasting, nor his good and excellent words in knowledge when it is clear to him that this person’s way and methodology is that of the Khawaarij.” Refer to ash-Sharee’ah (p. 28)

[naffe79]

can some tell me what Bilal did?? please...

[loverofhuq]

what he is accused of by these people is talking out against these rulers who don't rule in a accordance with the shariah, who sit,watch and even help the enemy as the muslim ummah is being slaughtered by these infidels, this is his crime! if this is the case may Allah keep him, ali tamimi and their likes firm on their noble beliefs!ISLAM!

[asalafi]

Yes!!

we follow the salaf of this ummah in all of the deen Insha-Allah.

Bilal Phillps and Ali Tammimi and the like went against the salafi understanding of Islaam, i.e that islaam that the Imaams of the past were upon.

[gojarus]

JazakAllahu khair.

Wallah, I did not know about this.

May Allah reward you brother.

[asirthesalafi]

May Allah reward our noble brother (asalafi) for uploading this video and clarifying this major issues for the muslims

For more videos clarifying Bilal Phillps deception, search "Deception of Bilal Phillps" by our brother (assalafee)

[asalafi]

May Allah reward you akhi, it is also on this video responces...

[Baller2dafullest]

May allah make it easy for us to be on the stright path... Ameen....

[asalafi]

"Keep to forgiveness, and enjoin kindness, and turn away from those who choose to remain ignorant" (Qur'an, 7:199).

[Lhaw06]

bad quality

[asalafi]

??///

[myzara2000]

May Allah reward you akhi, and grant you and I (and all of us) the strength to remain on the straight path. May Allah guide Bilaal Phillips and others like him to the Sunnah.

[hayow]

Subhnallah Allahu Akbar May Allah reward the brother asalafi finally we have a clarification regarding this man! Alhamdullah!!!!

[thesalafi]

What the scholars have said:

ON ATTENDING THE GATHERINGS OF THE INNOVATORS

Shaykh Ubayd al Jaabiree said:

''The third point is that he (i.e. Bilal Philips) mentioned that he attends their lectures, this is not from the manhaj of the salaf, The salaf stay away from the sittings of the innovators, They do not go to them.

They even warn against them (the innovators) and their harm.....

More on Bilal Phillips go to salafitalk(.)net

[thesalafi]

They even warn against them (the innovators) and their harm. Upon the one that comes to them and others. From this, Sufyaan ibn Uyaiynah or Thawree that he said regarding sitting with the innovators that the person who sits with them will not be free from any three things " Either he will be free from the misguidance, or he may fall into it, or others besides him will be deceived due to him (being with the innovator)." All of this is dangerous...

[thesalafi]

continued shaykh ubatd:

All of this is dangerous. Mus'ab ibn Sa'd rahimahullaah said "Do not sit with the Maftoon (the one who is tried) for he will not leave upon you except two things, either he puts you to trial and so you follow him, or he will harm you before you depart from him." ...

[thesalafi]

shaykh ubayd continued:

Mufaddal ibn Mahallal rahimahullaah "If the companion of the bid’ah were to speak to you about his bid'ah at the beginning of sitting with him then you would have kept away from him and left, but he will speak to you at the beginning with the Sunnah then he will put in you his bid’ah and your heart accepts it so when will it leave your heart?"...

[thesalafi]

shaykh ubayd continued:

So I say to this person who says that he calls to the salaf and Salafiyyah that he should be away from the innovators and make his rank clear from them. That his love and significance be with ahlu Sunnah, the Salafees.

[thesalafi]

shaykh ubayd continues:

And if an innovator attends his gathering, then he should close the path for them and not open the path of debating and arguing with them. For debating with them is not from the methodology of the Salaf. Imam Malik said "Is it that every time a man comes that is more eloquent in arguing than another man we leave that which Jibreel 'alayhi salaam brought to the Messenger sallallaahu 'alaihi wa sallam."

[thesalafi]

shaykh ubayd al jaabiree continues:

So this person must be with the Salafees and add to their ranks and strengthen their power, and for him to differentiate from the innovators and strives to show the Sunnah and warning against the innovations, then he will be upon the correct Salafi methodology. The methodology that differentiates and clarifies. ...

[thesalafi]

Shaykd Ubayd continued:

We may not tell him not to give them salaam and not give shake their hands, it some circumstances this may not be easy, but his love and his inclination must be for the Salafees and ahlu Sunnah. His inclination, love and advice should not be to the innovators amongst the tableeghis, ikhwaanis and other than them.

[thesalafi]

This will strengthen their power and weaken the ahlu Sunnah and others who are not equipped with knowledge and correct methodology will be deceived by his actions." End of quotes from Shaykh ‘Ubayd al-Jaabiree, by way of Abdul-Ilah Lahmami (Jeddah, Saudi Arabia). Taken from salafitalk(.)net

[amatullah4ever]

SubhanAllah, not Bilal Philips man!

What a blow this is, he's a decent speaker who explains things in simple manners and i have to put all his vids on private until i can be certain about this issue.

BarakAllahu feek 4 sharing it with us bruv/sis wa assalaamu 'alaykum wa rahmatullah

[TabeebAbiDawudMD]

Read my comments earlier in the comments regarding Bilal Philips ya ukht. He has had mistakes of declaring all of the Muslim rulers in the world to be Mushrikeen and he has called to hizbiyyah for decades now. I discuss these things in enough detail. We can not take from the people with such grave mistakes because they can lead people astray very easily. Most of what he says is correct, but what he says of incorrectness is far too detrimental to one's hereafter to overlook.

[TabeebAbiDawudMD]

His misguidance is not obvious and is only caught by the people of knowledge which makes him more harmful to the sincere Salafi than the kalaam (theological rhetoric) of some flaming Sufi with fire balls of kalaam flying out of his mouth, wa 'i adhoo bilah! Bilal Philips is like honey mixed with poison. His mistakes can turn someone into an innovator and outside of Salafiyyah.

[Acezizi]

i fully agree with you

[asalafi]

Bilal has many errors, many of which are still propagated – in the field of hajr, the ahl ul-bid’ah, ta’aawun, and we do not see any great clarity or the type of clarification from ones’ errors that are required when errors are made of this nature.

Remaining silent about this is a means of hiding the truth and earning the wrath of Allaah, by concealing these types of oppositions.

[asalafi]

Especially when the da’ee or person under question holds great sway over people - due to his popularity or whatever.

And all of this is from the angle of wishing clarity and safety for Bilal? And secondly, so that those who might be misled by the orientations Bilal puts across can be protected from his errors.

[truthJUSTICEfreedom]

this bilal phillips is nothing but a lying misled corrupted fool..! hate preacher with nooooo backing..!! as weak as abu sufyan!!

[asalafi]

truthJusticefreedon wat you say is ooooff the mark....

The point of this it not to call him name or make fun of him...

But to help him and our brothes and sister...and show them the Haqq by way of the scholers of the sunnah

[TabeebAbiDawudMD]

In his book The Fundamentals of Tawheed : Islamic Monotheism, on page 25 or 26, he calls to Tawheedul Hakimiyyah about which Shaykh Ibnul-'Uthaimeen said, whoever calls to Tawheedul-Hakimiyyah is an innovator. He states that whoever rules by other than what Allah has revealed has committed Shirk and has fallen outside of Islam. The reason why this is an innovated belief is because no where in the entire Qur'an, the Hadeeth or statements of Sahabah is this declared.

[TabeebAbiDawudMD]

The Sahabah, the Salaf and thus true Ahlus-Sunnah states about the Muslim who rules by other than what Allah reveals is they have committed kufr duna kufr (disbelief less than disbelief). Meaning that person has committed an act of disbelief that does not take one outside the fold of Islam. In Tafsir Ibn Kathir, Ibn Kathir (rahimullah) states that this is the well noted opinion of many Sahabah such as Ibn 'Abbas (radi Allahu 'anhu) and other Salaf such as al-Hasan al-Basri regarding Verse 5:44.

[TabeebAbiDawudMD]

I heard Bilal Philips himself say here on a video I saw of him on YouTube that you can be a Salafi and still be involved in an "Islamic Organization (i.e. a Hizb)" that is not Salafi. Anyone who is not upon the 'Aqeedah (Beliefs/Creed) and Manhaaj (Methodology) of the Salaf is on something other than that, which means they have some, if not a lot, of innovations with them. It is the Ijmaa's (Consensus) from amongst the Scholars of the Salaf to abandon the People of Innovation.

[TabeebAbiDawudMD]

The Prophet (salAllahu 'alayhi wa sallam) said, "Whoever innovates or accomodates an innovator then upon him is the curse of Allah, His Angels and the whole of mankind." (Bukhari 12/41 and Muslim 9/140)

[TabeebAbiDawudMD]

The great Sahabi Ibn Abbas (radi Allahu 'anhu) said, "Indeed the most detestable of things to Allah are the innovations." (Bayhaqi's As-Sunan al-Kubra 4/316)

The student of the Sahabah and scholar Yahya Ibn Katheer (d 129 H) -rahimullah- said, "If you meet a person of innovation along the path, then take a path other than it"

[TabeebAbiDawudMD]

"You will not find any people who believe in Allâh and the Last Day, making friendship with those who oppose Allâh and His Messenger, even though they were their fathers, or their sons, or their brothers, or their kindred (peaople).---

[TabeebAbiDawudMD]

---For such He has written Faith in their hearts, and strengthened them with Rûh (light and guidance with the proofs) from Himself. And We will admit them to Gardens under which rivers flow, to dwell therein (forever). Allâh is pleased with them, and they with Him. They are the Party of Allâh. Verily, it is the Party of Allâh that will be the successful." (Quran 58:22)

[TabeebAbiDawudMD]

The translator is Abu Muhammad Ridwaan al-Maghribi (hafidhullah). I know him personally. I've been on Hajj with him and other students of Madinah Univ and he had more knowledge than they did. I was embarrassed sitting next to him when we were all talking because I felt I had not dedicated enough time to serious devoted Islamic Studying. He truly inspired me. He indeed has a great deal of knowledge, is very close to many of the 'Ulamah and is without doubt upon khair and straightness.

[choorijamadar]

but im confused.......bilal philips bacs everything he says with the Quran & sunnah..by the understanding of the salaf........doesnt he?

[SALAF18]

... he is a shaykh of Daarul Hadeeth, Dammaaj and also amongst the people who give khutbahs, go out for dawah, are teachers, and people of research. so sister if u are still in doubt u can get a detailed and clear analysis into the errors of bilal phillips if you go to salafitalk(dot)net type in the bilal philips and a number of links will be there which will demonstrate in the big errors that he has inshaallah

[choorijamadar]

so then instead of the scholors speaking out aginst him wouldnt it be better and nicer if they just corrected him?? sorry if wat im saying doesnt make any sence. LOL

[TabeebAbiDawudMD]

My dear and beloved sister, the 'Ulamah and the Students of Knowledge have warned Bilal Philips and have tried to give him sincere advice about his erreunious ways for almost three decades now. He has not heeded their continuous da'wah that have hailed from amongst the knowledgeable ones of our time and has continued to contradict the Salafus-Salih in various ways. Now it is incumbent upon the People of Knowledge to warn against his literature.

[majaiz]

yes brother.. in these case.. Bilal Philips is way off the mark.

And its not permissible to follow anyone blindly into/onto falsehood.

We accept the truth AND we reject the falsehood.

Thus we are advised to keep away from Bilal Phils until he comes back to the truth, inshallah.