Bob Dylan "Desolation Row" live in Paris 2011

[lmOnlySleeping]

I remember about 5 years ago I liked Bob Dylan, but was not a huge fan. I was 13 and remember hearing Bob live and couldnt believe thought it sounded horrible. Well fast forward to today and now im a HUGE Dylan fan, and i think this still sounds fantastic. I guess once you truly appreciate the man and the music its impossible for it to sound bad. I think his voice is still great, it still has the same soul and emotion it had 50 years ago.

[aristocraterocks]

his voice is ''gone'' for sure, but it's one of coolest ''gone voice'' ever!

[kerrykostas1]

Terrible.......... Id have been gutted to have paid even 2 euros to watch this in concert........



[MsAnnestube]

keep on rocking Bob

[pedroqueiroz1000]

4:21...love you BOB

[inverterville]

i know his voice is gone but the musical rearrangement is fabulous and of course the lyrics there is always the lyrics ....

[idiosyncrazy1980]

@inverterville "and of course the lyrics there is always the lyrics"

I understand, and I myself love Bob Dylan's lyrics, but what can possibly "Rhhhhooaarrrhhhhhnnnn thhrrrmmmoiiifff wrrrriiiisshhhttmmrrroouuuh" mean ?

[inverterville]

@idiosyncrazy1980 its japanese for calvin kline 

[novastarbart]

classic/fantastic!!!!

[DShaw42011]

Hes great on that keyboard

[dablueman21]

ah his voice is going. I hate to say it but it's a fact, the smoking and stuff from the 60s got to him. I like the instruments though...and of course the classic words.

[niknilbob]

Hi, pet. Thanks for email. Regarding "RIP" comment......I have a feeling that whatever age any of us are, despite all his cigs, he'll outlive us all. And deservedly so. 4EVER YOUNG!

[GeoffWilde]

@niknilbob Well obviously, Bob Dylan can't die, ever, like Jesus.

[niknilbob]

Hi, pet, thanks for email. Re: "RIP," I have a feeing that even with all the cigs, no matter what age we are, he will outlive us all. And deservedly so...

[LUCIFERIO51400]

j'y étais une légende vivante avec une voie comme jamais . c plus bob mais god dylan !!!

[drummerhere]

Fucking beautiful, regardless of his voice...

[aaqaaqaaqaaqaaqaaqaa]

@drummerhere sorry, but the gargling gravel sound does ruin the tune.

[pet456bike]

I love my Bob, have done since I was 13, when my step father sent me down to the record store to buy THE TIMES THEY ARE A CHANGING..I listened in my bedroom, when they went out I listened to him again and again, he changed my life ( for the better). OK i guess his voice is over... God bless him, and what he gave to us all. xxxxxx Almost want to say RIP Bob!

[kofireyrock619]

@pet456bike RIp? disrespectful and he sounds amazing still.  No other artist is like Bob.

[Marseille5]

@pet456bike Sorry you feel this way, but I think you missed a point.

[massinization]

No longer fit to sing coz Your throat Expired whisky and women Influenced the musical style

[pedroqueiroz1000]

ahahah....i love at 4:20 when he puts his hand on the back and starts playing with the other...PRICELESSSSSSSSSSS

[1fairportconvention]

Beautiful music arrangement.

[niknilbob]

Look at his left hand and his smile at audience at 3;41. Funniest, coolest guy who has ever lived in the entire world since the beginning of mankind.

[niknilbob]

Sorry, svenjiock, but I stay the same as far as what I said. I know that you can't play an instrument, you can't sing, you don't support yourself financially, you have not been into Dylan long, and you are not familar with his stuff. I can't convince you that what you said is idiotic, you'll have to see that for yourself one day.

[pet456bike]

@niknilbob I absolutely agree with you. You can take a horse to water, but you cant make it drink eh?????? To be a Dylananite is something else, we were at the right time and place and by God did it blow us away.. Still does...... Guess that in time all great voices will go,, but Hey, his WORDS WILL LIVE ON LONG AFTER HES GONE POET AND MASTER.XXX

[niknilbob]

"HIS VIOICE IS GONE AND HIS ORGAN PLAYING ARE HORRIBLY BAD?" I guarantee the jerk who wrote this 1) can't play an instrument 2) can't sing

c) is probably bald or something else that makes him obviously so f'in pompous and is 4) a snob who lives off his parents. You are a total, disgusting, musically ignorant pompius piece of shit, if someone gave me a picture of 10,000 people I guarantee I could pick you out, you are a moron a stupid pathetic moron. What a jerk, I hate you!!! I really do!!!

[brainysod]

@niknilbob I would say...that was probably a bit harsh. Its just an opinion, and as you have demonstrated, we are all entitled to them.

[pet456bike]

@niknilbob fuckin right on!!!!!

[Pmitsou123]

@niknilbob Ha ha ha !

[stillilllife]

@niknilbob It's his opinion? Why not just respect that? He's as entitled to his as you are to yours, no matter how much you two disagree with each other.

[Trealawking]

@niknilbob brilliant, I couldn't have put it better myself!!!

[Trealawking]

@niknilbob - Well said

[Music100Quality]

@niknilbob AMEN i love you! i am sick of people hating on dylans voice. its obnoxious.

[svenjick]

Just went to his concert. It's sad: his voice is gone, and his harmonica & organ playing are horribly bad.

[tosa275]

So sad..He has started raping his own nice songs.....As if somebody is slicing his throat...

[aquinshire]

@tosa275 he's just changing it up. you try playing the same song for 40+ years.

[aquinshire]

@tosa275 faggot.

[stillilllife]

@aquinshire Why are you calling him that? Because he doesn't share your opinion? Why are you acting childish and seemingly don't respect him for having a different opinion than yours. He's as entitled to his as you are to yours.

[HerRoyalKateness]

to the bitter end, bob dylan has ALWAYS been a ladies man. :)

[MrBurneSwin]

3:40

[MarianoJurda]

@MrBurneSwin fuck yea

[Cwray27]

@MrBurneSwin I wonder what 1986 dylan would of thought of that dance

[ohmercy]

WOWZA!!!!!!!!!!

Not just the coolest cat on the planet--- the sexiest too!

Thanks MeloYello0- wonderful

[jinal007]

brilliant! thanks for sharing

[HerRoyalKateness]

and meloyellow0, i think i have kissed u b4. good job, keep dodging those security bullets in the form of some polynesian karate chop!

that hand on the back hip shot is PRICELESSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSS­SSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSS­SSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSS­SSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSS­SSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSS­SSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSS­SSSSSSSSSS, excuse me while i faint........

[ohmercy]

@HerRoyalKateness I'd catch you- but I'm right behind you fainting too.

[HerRoyalKateness]

stockmack its not bobby, its ur ears honey. something is blocking them from hearing perfection. check it outttttttttttttt.

[HerRoyalKateness]

wowwwwww i love that beat he is tapping out on the keyboard high in the mix! sound crews is finally getting it! we want 2 hear the two notes bob dylan plays 2 the rhythm of hs soul than the perfect musician sound of the rest of the crew. in fact it would be ok with me if u turned them all down, 2 hear him from across that lonesome ocean. i want him 2 come home fast! this footage happens 2 to be esp sweet.."iknowhereyesrfixedd uponnnnnnn...." ah so kewl, i love him! ooooo la la! go paris!

[CAVIARZIDANE]

La voix merdique et inaudible de Bob DYlan , suis parti au bout de 30 mn , il s'est foutu de notre gueule avec une sono minable .Par contre fantastique et du GRAND MARK KNOPFLER

[songmule]

Bob could 'fart' this song and it'd still be great.

[blueglasses4you]

fabulous ! thanks for posting !

[gicbd]

THis sounds as fabulous as the version played in Bournemouth. Wouldn't it be wonderful if Columbia were secretly filming all these shows and decided to put out a DVD of, well, at least some of the performances. A dream, maybe ... but some dreams do come true!

[SamuConf]

painting the passports brown....