Liza's At The Palace - If You Hadn't, But You Did

[kittystolemycookie94]

I've noticed many negative comments about Liza and her performance. We have to remember that she is older and her voice is a lot deeper and huskier than it used to be. Also, she had brain encephalitis and the doctors said she would never sing again, and she was able to sing again. Like a previous comment said, she has been through a lot in her life and being able to recover from brain encephalitis is pretty amazing.

[broadwaymike92]

"You asked for it! You asked for it!" (GUNSHOT) LOL

[askania60]

@stavinchain As sad as this might be to say but I have to agree with you. I was a great admirer, but to see this is a sad performance to me too. This is a really hard song to sing and to perform but Minelli seems to have a frog in her throat.

[16fonzie]

@stavinchain true kristin does this so much better but liza is stil an amazing performer and she will always be loved, plus she still sell out so she must be doing something right

[lillmango]

ultimately its about entertainment, and in my perspective: both kristin and liza are both amazing entertainers! they're different but i get as much pleasure listening to liza and watching her perform as i do with kristen...

[PyroDefysGravity]

I feel like from a vocal standpoint, Kristen was better, but Liza's acting is most definitely superior. She's hysterical! I never realized how great this song was until I heard this version.

[aluem10]

liza is legend she only just turned 65 she been thru alot, and shouldnt have retired when her mother died she was very young when judy died

[ScenexxxPunk]

kristin's better. end of story. my little sister idolizes this woman and her mother and sister lorna.....i understand why judy kind of..but why liza? really? she ruined this song. kristen did such an amazing job on this song and i watched and was horrified. she was better as a kid and should have ended a long time ago. sorry liza at least your pretty

[stavinchain]

Sorry....this is a wonderful song, and an almost-adequate performance...but Liza should not have continued performing to such an old age...she should have retired gracefully around the time her mother's career ended, because she has turned herself into only a sad joke as a reflection of her family's talent. Kristin Chenoweth's versions are only better because of her more youthful voice...but my favorite performance of this (still unavailable?) is Carol Channing's on the Flip Wilson show (1972?)

[AntinousIsGod1]

@stavinchain How dare you, Liza is not a joke and the only reason Judy's career ended was because she died! Get your facts straight

[mrss0l3]

única!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

[mtmorrispk]

she sings this character song from the vantage point of a mature woman who has lived...i love it!

[PurpleGnomesOfOz]

Liza has always been gold, and will always be gold. Kristin's recently become gold, and most likely will be gold forever, just like Liza.

[GavinRoskamp]

Um... what? Sorry, but that "style" of singing requires no talent at all. Want to hear this song sung well and correctly? Kristin Chenoweth.

[AntinousIsGod1]

@GavinRoskamp Liza was a star long before Kristin was. Liza is the bigger idol and always will be. I love Kristin too, but Liza is the Queen.

[yougottagetagimmick]

@GavinRoskamp She's in her mid-sixties. Her vocal cords aren't what they were, she knows that. And they weren't that much to begin with. So she has to act her songs as best she can, and she does. I mean...well, check out her Oscar-winning performance if you aren't convinced by this.

Kristin Chenoweth - like Minnelli's contemporary Barbra Streisand - has a perfect voice and gorgeous vocal skill. So, she really doesn't have to act. And she doesn't, much. At least not with this song.

[ScenexxxPunk]

@yougottagetagimmick i feel kristin did act well with this song in her "nights at the pops" video to it. she was beating and dragging around the body of the man

[adamnoviello]

Liza will never go out of style!!! Can still sing a song and play comedy! Love you work Liza never leave us xoxo

[arzeN3]

It's so funny. I enjoy it very much. :DD

[AntinousIsGod1]

I loved it! Liza is awesome :)

[twinnumber3]

Ha :D If you had done that with the mic, I'd buy it :P Thanks for posting more great music :) ♥♥♥ to the Grandest Duke

[AntinousIsGod1]

Haha aww thanks babe :D <3