even after his voice changed- Josh didn't 'leave' Libera- he like many boys works behind the scenes teaching new boys, and in some songs they need mature/llower voices as well so he can still sing some backing parts on albums. I beleive he also recorded some other music on his own for fun for youtube.
Between Josh Madine and Tom Cully, my bet is Josh. But of course i like Tom Cully's voice. Both of them have very angelic voices. And it's so amazing for Josh to maintain such Angelic Voice. Plus, I love Japan which made me liked this video even more.
I love Libera, espessially Joshua Madine. How can stand for his smiling face and his lovely voice. Most of the boys have lovely voices. I admire them all.
Tom Cully is now a former Libera member. He confirmed it in his Myspace and other accounts. Although he is not in Libera anymore he will always remain a legend in the choir and to the rest of their supporters. KUDOS LIBERA! :)
I'm probably gonna be shot for saying this but i think Josh was cuter as a younger kid (don't get me wrong, he's still quite attractive), whereas Tom became even more attractive as he grew up...
They are actually still here in the philippines... they had a successful concert here. In Manila and Cebu. Joshua celebrated his birthday here. They just got back in manila from cebu this morning.
Tom Cully is still in Libera although his voice have changed. We might not see him as often, but that doesn't mean he left.
On the other hand, Josh is still very active in Libera. He is in the Philippines now for the upcoming concerts. Josh's voice is getting deeper but he can still sing "You Were There" as he sang beautifully in this video. Plus, he's turning 15 on Monday the 26th, so check out my new video for him? lol
I love tom and josh they are the best and also the cutest, wish that tom will still be a soloist cause he still is the only person in liberA THAT HAS SO MANY SOLOS
Tom was the original soloist,his verson is my favorite,but I have to accept other boys taking Tom's place.That's life.Stefan is the only newbie in this group that I have followed their singing,he is good!Perhaps he will take on more solos.This lad looks very serious,I hope he gets more relax and smiles more.I like him a lot!
I like Tom's version too but this is also my favorite version. I loved Josh's version of You Were There at the Crystal Cathedral concert. That was my absolute favorite :D
Either Liam was standing on a box, or he's been caught up in a growth spurt!
I think Tom does this better than Josh; not that Josh is poor, that is.
I wonder if things might be better if he opened his mouth a little more? I don't mean in the grossly exaggerated way that cathedral choirboys sing, but just a tad more open.
Yes! Josh and Sam are the oldest ones in this clip. I agree with you that it's pretty incredible for Josh to maintain his soloist position in Libera at this point of his life :D
It's official. Tom Cully's voice has now changed and he sings TENOR in the St. Phillips choir. He no longer sings with Libera. Look for Tom Cully at school video here on youtube to here his changed speaking voice.
this is so good! i think the reason Tom wasnt singing in it is becuase he didnt go on the Japan trip becuase of school commitments. Josh looks so different here! but he did a good job at singing the song
Josh's voice was so clean! And stable! Wow! And he managed to kill the audience with his charming eyes!
BTW, what happened to the hosts in the middle? =_=
danderomy 1 week ago
GO JOSH!!!!!!!!!!!! XD
coffeefreak22 2 months ago
even after his voice changed- Josh didn't 'leave' Libera- he like many boys works behind the scenes teaching new boys, and in some songs they need mature/llower voices as well so he can still sing some backing parts on albums. I beleive he also recorded some other music on his own for fun for youtube.
4FabBEATLES 3 months ago
Beautifully done, Josh.
Irishthunderhead 5 months ago
Josh Madine is my favorite among them...charm!!!!!
j93178 7 months ago
Tommmm <3
90dicitklose 8 months ago
fantastic!!!
thesongstud27 9 months ago
I love joshu!
His voice is lovely and beautiful !!!
mc04jb18noon202 10 months ago
Between Josh Madine and Tom Cully, my bet is Josh. But of course i like Tom Cully's voice. Both of them have very angelic voices. And it's so amazing for Josh to maintain such Angelic Voice. Plus, I love Japan which made me liked this video even more.
BoA2ne1 10 months ago
watching this makes me sad :(
By any chance can I listen to just one more live solo by Josh?
I have been crazy about him for 3 years :(
joshmadinerules 11 months ago 2
Thank you Thank you I love Libera and the Madine's
coolsweetgroovy 1 year ago
i LOVE JOSH MADiNE ... HIS VOICE IS SO ANGELIC
XxXNiNkOrOXxX 1 year ago
love this song..
shanaishyr 1 year ago
Josh's eyes damn right captivate me. *o*
weheartdough 1 year ago 7
Look Zach and Liam! Their head move together xD Love Libera! I love You Were There by both Tom and Josh :)) x
jshiny27 1 year ago 3
Josh sang really beautifully :)
I love both Tom's version and Josh's version~
Very touching and amazing !!!!
Josh sang beautiful high notes~~~~~
anniechanYK 1 year ago
I love Libera, espessially Joshua Madine. How can stand for his smiling face and his lovely voice. Most of the boys have lovely voices. I admire them all.
StovnerBaronen 1 year ago 3
Tom Cully is now a former Libera member. He confirmed it in his Myspace and other accounts. Although he is not in Libera anymore he will always remain a legend in the choir and to the rest of their supporters. KUDOS LIBERA! :)
ItSNoToVeR00 1 year ago
you can tell this is getting harder for him :(
TheBloodyLam 1 year ago
I'm probably gonna be shot for saying this but i think Josh was cuter as a younger kid (don't get me wrong, he's still quite attractive), whereas Tom became even more attractive as he grew up...
Killy1Leo 1 year ago
where is tom?
nvbailon 1 year ago
I reallu love the singers's voices
parcab1 2 years ago
I love watching Josh sing, because when he sings it looks like his eyes do too. It's great! :)
Jamie7466 2 years ago 5
My Gosh..!!! Fantabulous!!I really love JOsh madine and Tom As well.. Love u guys..
mixzaurell 2 years ago 3
magnifico. Adorei!!!!!
gylvandias 2 years ago
Love Josh!x
Snelling06 2 years ago 25
i hope someday God will give me a child the same feature as JOSH's face... he gives me a glimpse of how i want my future child will look like...
jojojoeful 2 years ago 3
They are actually still here in the philippines... they had a successful concert here. In Manila and Cebu. Joshua celebrated his birthday here. They just got back in manila from cebu this morning.
daleydeil 2 years ago 2
wow im in girls choir and i cant even hit those high notes!he rox!!!!!:-)
videogirl4571 2 years ago 3
Tom Cully is still in Libera although his voice have changed. We might not see him as often, but that doesn't mean he left.
On the other hand, Josh is still very active in Libera. He is in the Philippines now for the upcoming concerts. Josh's voice is getting deeper but he can still sing "You Were There" as he sang beautifully in this video. Plus, he's turning 15 on Monday the 26th, so check out my new video for him? lol
Now....
let's enjoy Libera as a whole group, please...
DearMadine 2 years ago 11
I love tom and josh they are the best and also the cutest, wish that tom will still be a soloist cause he still is the only person in liberA THAT HAS SO MANY SOLOS
kanrisanz 2 years ago 4
what? Tom's not in Libera anymore?! :(( well, at least Josh is still there :D
direknosled 2 years ago
Tom was the original soloist,his verson is my favorite,but I have to accept other boys taking Tom's place.That's life.Stefan is the only newbie in this group that I have followed their singing,he is good!Perhaps he will take on more solos.This lad looks very serious,I hope he gets more relax and smiles more.I like him a lot!
Fandago33 2 years ago 3
I like Tom's version too but this is also my favorite version. I loved Josh's version of You Were There at the Crystal Cathedral concert. That was my absolute favorite :D
DearMadine 2 years ago
@Fandago33 ralph is also good
thesupernovastar1234 1 month ago
Ouch,, I really like Edward with his longer hair.. But here its like exploded.. But even though I think is cute :)..
And I really like the song and LIBERA OFFCOURSE
SheaDG 2 years ago 3
Either Liam was standing on a box, or he's been caught up in a growth spurt!
I think Tom does this better than Josh; not that Josh is poor, that is.
I wonder if things might be better if he opened his mouth a little more? I don't mean in the grossly exaggerated way that cathedral choirboys sing, but just a tad more open.
Limpandtotheleft 2 years ago
JOSH IS INCREDIBLE i think he is almost the older of the lads and he can reach very high notes!
Scinfaxi1 2 years ago 13
Yes! Josh and Sam are the oldest ones in this clip. I agree with you that it's pretty incredible for Josh to maintain his soloist position in Libera at this point of his life :D
DearMadine 2 years ago 2
wers tom cully
tonygage95 2 years ago 2
It's official. Tom Cully's voice has now changed and he sings TENOR in the St. Phillips choir. He no longer sings with Libera. Look for Tom Cully at school video here on youtube to here his changed speaking voice.
Nashcountryboy 2 years ago 2
oh man, that kinda makes me sad! I love Tom
hastalapastayay 2 years ago
josh.. looks cuter when he was.. younger...
birdy12ph 2 years ago
everyone looks cuter when they were younger..--
liberailuv 2 years ago 3
I didn't think of.. it sorry.. because.. I'm not.. cute.. when I am younger... XD
birdy12ph 2 years ago
Isn't that true with all boys and girls. Alas, they ALL grow up.
Nashcountryboy 2 years ago 2
Hah? what do u mean? by dat?
birdy12ph 2 years ago
It means that they will all grow up to adults. Now just relax and enjoy the music :)
DearMadine 2 years ago
Don't forget that it was a live performance! So minor mistakes should be accepted.
Well Done Josh!!! :) Support you forever!
liberailuv 2 years ago 6
this is so good! i think the reason Tom wasnt singing in it is becuase he didnt go on the Japan trip becuase of school commitments. Josh looks so different here! but he did a good job at singing the song
Sibadibdoo2 2 years ago 5
lovely josh
megamix875 2 years ago 39