Added: 5 years ago
From: badboybaddog
Views: 148,075
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:
see all

All Comments (345)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • Starting listening from 7:30, when she sings "in time" it's her 2003 voice, but when she goes to "you'll find the way... and then a hero comes along" it's her 90s voice. Then it makes a harsh and noticeable shift back to her 2003 voice "with the strength to carry on"

  • Don't get me wrong, I'm a huge Mariah fan, and all my friends know that fact. But because I'm such a huge fan, and I know everything there is to know about her, and I'm obsessed with the smallest details about her--I can say that she switched between live vocals and lip-synced in Hero and also lip synced all of the climax of my saving grace. If you listen closely to 7:40 for example, it's her 90s voice then it switches back to live.

  • @RebelXSi i pretty sure that its not lip synched

    

  • Simply spectacular !!!!

  • I Love her voice more than any other singers voice on this entire Planet... and YES SHE DId so fantastic on hero, way better than she recorded it.. Thats one amazing reason y i love her soo much, She can do something better than what she recorded it.. CRT forever.. And always and Forever #1 in my heart. CRT forever

  • Although her voice was a lil shaky... She still managed to give a gr8 performance of MSG and Hero!!! I love Mariah :)

  • I Love you forever and always CRT forever---The best singer on the entire Planet.. i love you more than any other singer on this entire Planet.. and I really mean that from my heart.. So much more than you than you know.. Thank you for always being the best singer ever...CRT forever

  • The best singer on the entire Planet.. CRT forever.. the best version of hero.. in that year, i like this better than she recorded it.. SHE KILLED IT!!!!!! The originai is Amazing also!!!! The best singer on tne entire Planet... CRT forever my hero 4ever and always crt forever

  • Mariah Carey Is a Godess Vocalist.. her voice is so fantastic. Thats why she is so popular cause her voice is unique and 100000050000022% real.. So I dont care what you say she is The best to me.. 4ever and always.. and if you disagree good.. Cause I dont.. ha ha.. Leave thank you..

  • this is not lipped u moron

  • Reason it sounds like the cd is because she doesnt do much editing to her music in the studio !

  • Y cant people accept tht she is sining live clearly she was in a good vocal condition 2day just coz she sounds like the CD dosent mean its lypsinc a lot people sound like the CD version and r still live thts just how amazing she is and her voice is, so wots the point in watching her vids if u hate her just get a life

  • Oh you know he was gonna cry but he was trying to keep a straight face haha

  • Can someone tell me the name of the first song she sings when she's wearing the wizard dress?

  • Parts of hero were lip-synced, I recognized her 90s voice taking on the harder parts and then switching back to live

  • @RebelXSi Yes, part if hero was lipped, and my saving grace too

  • @RebelXSi no its all 100% her she's never lipped hero y cant u just accept she can still sing ur all just jealous if ur only gunna watch her vids just to criticize then wots the point

  • i don't know how much of the hero performance is live but i think the first one was 99% live and same with the second one! really proud of her here!!!!! <333

  • Her boob game is sick !

  • nice one

  • i loved 2003 best yr for me thanks to mc ofcourse

  • that is really what passion means. mariah really has it when singing.

  • How come nobody said the whistle is lipped :)))) This performance is entirely LIVE!

  • @lukituchi yh defo all three are live

  • yea lol.... he really did look at her booty.... lol... she did great though

  • It;s so strange that she can sing such a high pitched song "my saving grace" but she can't sing hero or we belong together well....

  • @fuckinghotday it depends on the condition of her voice that day.

  • @fuckinghotday its the center part of her range that is damaged. she has no problem with the whistles register.

  • @fuckinghotday ...do you know...the high note part is lipsync...so thats way you said that lol...hero and WBT the truly live

  • sooooooooooooooooooo hot

  • MC D GREATEST!LOVE HER

  • lol. work jersey dress!! lmao. she dont play.

  • what's the title of this song?

  • @ninomeshi89 the first song is "boy" the second is "my saving grace" and the final is her song "hero"

  • Love during "My Saving Grace" when she sings "hope when I.." as a high note

  • i luv the blue dress....and her curvy body...she's very sexy here...

  • oh my god!! she very beautiful!! shes the BEST!!

  • ella es super alta, y con tacon debe serlo aun mas xD aun asi michael jordan es capaz de hacerla lucir pequeña! xD debe ser un gigante en persona

    GO FOR MIMI!!!!!!!!!!!!!

  • Comment removed

  • she is the only woman i have seen that can wear a basketball jersey as a dress lmao

  • mariah is full of surpirses lol its her voice or her cd or its just playback :D thats why we love her she good at hiding it :D

  • its actually both..shes singing along with a backing track

  • the instrumental at the endd where mariah is introuducing micheal jordan is what brandy used in her intro for her human tour , does any one know where is it is from??

  • the best

  • This amazing woman gives me the chills...she is the only one that can do that to me. Keep it up Mariah. I'm your true fan!

  • miss u, Michael Jordan, the GOD.

  • boy i need u is so good y want it a #1 single?

  • she always be the best in my heart.thanks for her voice.GO MIMI!

  • Mariah Carey sings for Michael Jordan, that's the ultimate tribute...! A moment for eternity....!!!

  • are her boobs real?

  • well , i'm sure her nose isn't

  • her nose is real u idiot...its photoshop..

  • pretty sure she bought them! check out the fantasy music video... almost flat

  • D I V A ! ! !

  • what an amazing performance from mariah carey. do it girl.

  • Excellent Performances, I Love Mimi!!!

  • Her voice was ON in these performances. As I said before, 2003 was a great year for her. If she could deliver performances like these in 2009, I would be very happy.

    PS...Did anyone else notice Michael checking out her booty on the way out?

  • yes her voice was in perfect conditon on this performance.....WOW she blew me away!!

  • yeah retard

  • what an incredible voice...AMAZING...

  • coz she is amriah carey....people loves her.

  • this was a wonderful performance by Mariah; i can see Miachael was a little teary eyed

  • This has to be one of her best performances... i just can't believe the audience was so.. um quiet? haha

  • Considering this is a NBA crowd, and she didn't get boo'd like most other performance, I think that says ALOT lol. She even got a positve response, which also says alot lol

    In general, most performers get boo'd by NBA crowds, let alone get a positive response.

    Mariah's voice sounded to be in really good shape here.

  • sports fans are always pretty quiet when stars come out to perform. they usually just give a good round of applause cause they are more into sport. plus this was during the NBA allstar which means most peeps there were corporate big shot sponsors and celebrities and they are to good to cheer lol.

  • i think they had the crowd noice turned down . .

    thats what someone told me lol because iw as going crazy wondering why the audience didnt get so loud

  • The audience did SUCK. They should have been clapping their asses off for Mariah. Audience.... piece of shit....

  • @GlitterPH they were speechless that MC can sing like in studio XD

  • is it just me or did the adudience FUCKIN SUCK ?

  • well it might of just been the recording...they could have edited their yelling out...

  • also her voice was so powerful and deep in hero. i love her

  • nah, its her voice, the things is that she is singing with a backing track, sometimes its her microphone, sometimes its her cd playing haha

  • mariah blew everyone away. But am i right in think the backing (NOT her) was lipped because that was her voice.

  • amazingggg!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

  • i luv her low whistle notes in charm bracelet album... like the first one she hit in "boy i need you"... they sound so sweet and angelic

  • she was great

  • the last chorus after the bridge was definately not live cause you could hear the difference and i bet on it that they played her cd vocals.

  • so what f she lipped it do you ever exist??

  • Good god! 6:00 when she whistled the lyrics!! AWESOME

  • during millenium...so far, the best performance of her vocal is in charmbracelet era 2002-2004...LoL

  • mariah and her famouse hand waving,lol,i love her

  • At 7:34-8:00 she sounded just like she use to when she was younger with the curly hair when she use to sing that song hero. That was scary lol. My favorite was when she sung my saving grace, remarkable.

  • I liked when she was introducing Michael Jordan it looked like she was about to sing, that'd be funny if she was like "MICHAEL JORDAN" in whistle. haha

  • O

    M

    G

    6:00 THAT WAS AMAZING

    singing so sweet

  • lol. no1 was like yelling/cheering when her name was said.

  • dont you think it would be difficult to lip some part then blow your mind to some high and low part of the song you will sing...so i think this is live...

  • Who knows Mariah's songs, knows that this is totally live!!!

  • I love her high note in hero. It's so beautiful..

  • i love the part were she's like, "givn' me hope when i", but in whistle. So magnificent.

  • @cjboybaby1993 Yesssssssssssss...... ugh. INSANITY. She is seriously... perfect.

  • this isnt lipped

  • good voice horrible dress

  • alot of the hero song is pre recorded, but whatever. if you listen closely you can hear whispering along with it. 7:19,7:25,7:09.

    but i just pray that my saving grace is fully live because its sooo beautiful!

  • thats so not true, if she would have wanted to lipsync hero, she definately wouldnt have done it in such a low register, but the regular high one

  • benj0924: I'm also a singer and I don't think this is lipped at all. Either she is phenomenal at lip-syncing or the entire thing is live or the entire thing is lipped. It is extremely hard to just grab the right note out of thin air and most professionals cannot do that. She would be forced to do that if she were stopping in the middle of a phrase and it would be harder to lip that way than to just sing the song.

  • it's fucking live

  • oddly, her voice was much better in 2004, better than it had been in years.

  • this is the example that it's partly lipped...listen to 7:33-7:49. the line..."in time" is live then she lipped the "you'll find the way" till " and then the hero comes along" and " with the strength to carry on" is back to live... take a closer attention how her voice changed in the lines i mentioned. I know her style. cause i am also a singer and i know if a singer sings live or not...in adiiton to that, i am her big fan, so i know her voice. i have her cd's. i love mariah no matter what!

  • I dont think its lipped. i dont see why she would lip just that bit but o well

  • also mariah is very bad at miming and you would be able to tell very easily

  • I agree with you. not too mention its always obvious when she lipped cos she always hold the mic so close to her mouth.. technically when you hit a big note you do the opposite. (see mariah circa 1990-98).

  • mariah carey is just simply amazing! i love her voice and i think it's beautiful! the most amazing and beautiful singer in history!

  • OKAY. I AM MARIAHS LIKE NUMBER FKN 1 FAN!... BUT

    I have like 1000 dollar bose speakers connected to my computer........anddddd im high.....but i just hear songs more clearly that way.....but anway...

    telll me why... IT SOUNDED LIKE THERE WERE tWO DIFFERENT FKN PEOPLE SINGING HERO?!?!?!? IT SOUNDED LIKE A SPANISH WOMAN AT THE HIGH BELTING POINTS!. BACKROUND SINGER???/ Before downputting this, just listen, look at my faves, i love mariah. mwah! -lilheir

  • She had a great day!!!her voice changes as she moves it´s all live never doubt mariah´s gift!!!!!

  • OMG; This performance of hero was amazing, gooooosebumps, mariah is the best

  • MARIAH NOTHONG COMPARES TO YOU!!!!

  • haters fall back!!!

    NUMBER 1!! LOVE YOU MARIAH!

  • Is she the one who did G#6 in this video? or was it a backup singer

  • her..

  • Beautiful.... I love You Always Mariah Carey

    LOVE CHARLES

  • where can i buy the dress she bought or at least sumthin close to it?

  • her dress is cute its a throwback but its long

  • Mariah Carey Is The Best Singer In The whole world.... Charles Loves you Mariah Carey..

  • Her voice gives me goosebumps. Everytime.

  • She just needs rest, Thank you twinnie93, She still has it, She just doesnt get any rest at all....Love you mariah

  • she looks so skinny omg love both of those inspirational songs!!!

  • it's totally live and make Michael Jordan Crying....... i always listening every day this song compilation Hero........

    Yes. if we listening sentences "THEN A HERO COMES ALONG" like Voice whitney

  • because certain parts of the song were being lipped, u can tell by listening real closely, mariah doesnt fool her loyal fans

  • is totally live..the diffrence is very ovbious!!

  • Love this one My Saving Grace was really nice, Its good to see her do Boy - you don't see her do that song too often

  • tiddies was looking right

  • she sounds amazing with the powerful mid range voice. she should use it more often.

  • OMg i love her fuckin posture when she stands, lol. The way her legs are perfectly crossed and her back is straight all the while she's singing. I only say that b/c I have very bad posture, I hate it. Im practice on it.

  • love the way she works the crowd, yet again another great performance! love her! thanks for posting this! :)

  • This its totally live, if do not believe it, listen the cd version.

  • how can she lip the climax of MSG? Cant you here the whistle part that was not originally in the recorded version? Mariah could do this!

  • i just don't hear whitney i just think mariah just sung it a bit deeper

  • the part of hero that sound a bit like whitney in the singing sentence "then a hero COMES ALONG"....it was in lower keys....my opinion....or my ear opinion...lol

  • HERO is LIVE in lower keys than the original version....which made some parts of the song hero sound like whitney!

  • some parts of "hero" was in powerful mid range and it sounded very like whitney!.....thats wierd....no disriespect!....mariah is awsome!....check it!

  • that is not lip synching all of you stupid!!!!!....she is always been like that, her voice is like that...

  • the climax of saving grace was lipped, and certain parts of hero was lipped.

  • yeah..maybe..but she can do de whole thing live on OPRAH...my saving grace n through the rain..

  • No it wasn't, she did those notes nefore and she can do them now!

  • yup at all the hard parts she is lipsynching

  • so tru

  • she really is the best!!! go mimi..

  • MJ almost cried, i saw that! hahhaha hes so hot

  • She looks so yummy in that first outfit. I've had a crush on her ever since she first sang at an NBA game. I forget what game it was.

  • she isn't lipsynching! Those are called Harmonies

  • i don't care old she gets, she is always going to stay fly,no lie

  • she scared of the crowd at 01.47 a bit. who doesnt? they might pull her skirt off! XD

  • nicevidro look with your eyes and you will see that she don't lipsing! haha she is one of more popular singer and she have a big voice she don't have need to lipsing!

  • WOW that's my team right there i was born in Chicago and Michael is the WORLDS BEST BASKETBALL PLAYER AND MARIAH IS THE WORLDS BEST SINGER FOR SURE!!! :)

  • WOW now that's my team right there the Chicago Bulls i was born in chicago and Michaelis the W

  • so deep ! jordan cry is so emotional, mariah lord is with you

  • She only covers her face during the high notes when she's really singing.

  • shes always perfrmd grace LIVE and well! at oprah too

  • HOW AMAZING IS MARIAH CAREY?? OMG! What a freaken talented woman! She is and always will be the most amazing singer ever! I can never get enough of her voice.. I get the chills from her! God Bless her!! <3333

  • No this one is live. look at her neck. Yo can tell she's singing live. This was to beautiful. She was the Diva paying respect to the King of Sport. Its like a Royal Event. SO Beautiful. Michael Jordan is the friggin King.

  • my one comment had to be spread over 3 and now 4 sorry :)

  • at the grammys "together" at the end the note wasnt held the same, when she sings live its live when its lipped the whole thing is lipped dont be silly.

  • If that was so, then she would always do it and you would never hear songs were she does a lower key like make it happen , why doesnt she cheat live on that one aswell, im sure she would lip all the song if she didnt want to hit the bigger notes, people have said that she cheats on the end of we belong together cos it always sounds the same at the end, hello , its ment to sound the same plus if you listen hard at the very last line "we" is in diff key on many of the live ones, and

  • she looks so cute here i love mariah i cant wait for her new album she is the best artist around

  • mariah is the best singer ever! she has been singing her brains out for over 20 years...obviously her voice is gonna change a bit but even on her worst days she is better then most.

  • Thank god for backup singers

  • Hero sounds excellent when she belts the notes a few keys lower. I sure wish she'd sing it like this always.

  • Please!

    Her live performance is the best!

    If see stop doing that --> it's loosing her charm.

    May be she can reduce it but not quit it!

  • wicked! altho in my saving grace some parts arent live

  • It really gets me angry when people say some parts arnt live, how can they just put a prerecorded line in.

  • heroes part is the best.. oo yes it does.. oh yes it does.. :)

  • She needs to stop singing live and preserve her voice, before she looses it!

  • what makes you think that stoping from singing would help... It could just make things worse! Practice makes perfect!!!

  • No if you watch Mariah uncut her doctor does say that when her vocal chords swell up after consistent singing it is always a danger.

  • yeah i agree with she shudnt stop singing becis vocal cors are muscles and they need a work out if ur a singer and if u stop singing it will fade