Raw Video: Russian Bridge Sways in the Wind

[cnkhwuidhd]

Banana Bridge !

[classysassy3]

This is fake. Look closely everyone.

[sparkygl0s]

@classysassy3

It was covered by several news agencies. Its real.

[kwldude]

The dramatically visible, rhythmic twisting that resulted in the 1940 collapse of "Galloping Gertie," the original Tacoma Narrows Bridge, has sometimes been characterized in physics textbooks as a classical example of resonance. However, this description is misleading. The catastrophic vibrations that destroyed the bridge were not due to simple mechanical resonance, but to a more complicated interaction between the bridge and the winds passing through it - phenomenon known as aeroelastic flutter

[kwldude]

@kint909 tacoma narrows bridge is only fixed to the ground at certain points. the majority of the bridge is held up by strong steel wires there isn't much to stop it swaying, where as this bridge is fixed to the ground all the way across if you pause at 0:35 you can see how the size of the concrete is big on one point and small on another if anyone can explain how concrete and metal can bend without losing shape or breaking i will accept this as a possibility.

[MrAshLC]

@kwldude search up a standing wave. This bridge is doing the same thing. Both are form of resonant harmonic motion.

And concrete and steel can bend, if they didnt the bridge would break. Same as how an Aircraft wing needs to flex.. otherwise it would just snap off.

[kwldude]

@MrAshLC the waves are different because it's structure is freely moveable. this is a hard structure. steel can bend however traditional concrete can't it will only take so much pressure before it cracks and in this video the concrete appears to shrink and expand in certain parts any concrete that cracked would of eventually collapsed this bridge or show signs of collapsing

[promolessstructure]

@kint909 I'm still thinking it's not possible

tacoma narrows was a suspension bridge and it could happens

in case of russian bridge which is normal type with many support below it's sick fake - look on the concrete on the side - look how its look with tacoma and then look on the russian

sorry but takoma looks autentic and in case of russian it's impossible - every bridge engineer will tell you

be more realistic people - do not believe in everything

[ccraig412]

Ya fake. The concrete on the bottom support doesn't expand and then go to a compact size in 2 seconds. -.-

[TheInkGalleryNYC]

that bridge needs stiffer suspension.. lol

[promolessstructure]

fake as hell...

[kint909]

@promolessstructure Well, look up Tacoma Narrows for something closer to you...

[kwldude]

that really does look fake it looks like the stone used to build the bridge is bending and morphing and wind does not blow upwards or downwards unless caused by some sort of hurricane or tornado if a bridge were to sway i'm sure it would be horizontally. it just looks like everything used in the construction of this bridge has had its shape morphed

[kint909]

@kwldude Well, look up Tacoma Narrows for something closer to you...

[tadatube2]

OMFG masturbating bridge!!!

[youngdones]

Russian engineering doesn't have a very good track record.

[djaktube]

FAKE

[chevelle1258]

@djaktube wrong, it happens. Something just matched the bridges resonance frequency.

[CrankUpProductions]

I want to ride my bike over that.....

[LongKimi]

Мост действительно раскачивался. Я это видел. Амплитуда колебаний составляла 1m. Между опорами моста 154m.

PS "the Soviet Russia" doesn't exist.

[sunkadam]

In Soviet Russia the wind doesn't blow it sucks..

[trifio5242]

concrete bridges don't sway)))) nice fake)) especially the noises!! cool))

[lynxcrasy]

@trifio5242 its not concrete btw, and this video is release from the offical russian gov media so science ftw ;]

[TubeVRN]

Это не фейк (NOT fake). Как будто у вас в америке, где дохрена подвесных мостов, не слышали о подобных случаях.

Многие мыслят слишком стандартно, чтобы поверить в подобные вещи

[ToastedAndy]

its like being on acid

[OMFGitsJeffX]

It's not fake you idiots go to school and learn for the love of science.

[HNickProg]

not fake, search for Takoma Narrows bridge, it wouldn't be the first one that collapse

[romanianlover123]

ok then... I guess this bridge is made of jello :P

[qviotkee]

FAKE

[TheXCrunchyX]

It's resonnance

[chapulin4216]

fukin F X

[InvincibleSamuri]

Bet its fake

[PlatinumGamez]

FAKE!!!!!!!!!!!!!

[clubpenguinsdfgdfgf]

In Soviet Russia, bridge sways you.

[DollieWepons]

...Physics!

[RufusTehThird]

Im not trying to say anything, but to me this looked really fake... You can see the pixels on the trees moving up and down with the bridge....

Or it might be real I dont know

[Ligalizitnow]

@RufusTehThird itis not fake they were shown on national news

[HKG36G3]

see, this is why you dont make bridges out of duct tape.

[dario0807]

russian quality

[RomanZzzzzzzzz]

@dario0807

The bridge of bad quality would have just collapsed. Russian quality is the best.

[nadoeloiskat]

These fucking truthers believes that 911 was an inside job but wont believe that this is real.

[randomgraduate]

its a video effect, i mean come on, concrete and steel will never bend just like that.

[samednakhla]

@randomgraduate

Its basically smaller pieces of concrete made that way .. if not some other materials might be used, I think its quite possible, but difficult and expensive ! In japan building's bases are just like this, because of the many earthquakes they have over there !

[tdaneri]

@randomgraduate look  this... play he wikipeida video of tacoma bridge 1940 you will be amazed

[randomblob117]

OMFG @ 0:10 - 0:18  id drive that :D

[williamcerniuk]

It is an example of natural harmonics. Do a search for "Tacoma Narrows", a video lesson every physics major should take.

[Dremennn]

@williamcerniuk

yeah just saw that video about Tacoma Narrows in physics today and learned why this happend and stuff

first time physics were exciting

[strangeman509]

@williamcerniuk

Just FYI, the Tacoma Narrows collapse was not due to harmonics as originally thought, but flutter caused by the wind.

[HelloIdiotsWhatsUp]

@williamcerniuk Actually, it's not natural harmonics that caused the Tacoma collapse (or this swaying, I'd assume), though that's a common misconception. It's an example of aeroelastic flutter. Pretty interesting stuff, you should look into it if you're a physics major.

[Koldness99]

ITS FUCKING FAKE YOU IDIOTS

ITS A VIDEO EFFECT

[mrrafaelsuazo]

@Koldness99 fuck are u talking about?

[effyochicken]

@Koldness99 Well you're a sad excuse for a human being. Piss off.

[hkscott12345]

@Koldness99 this is the official Associated Press video feed. I'd say its pretty legitimate numbnuts.

[tdaneri]

@Koldness99 look this... look for tacoma bridge video in wikipedia

[mateuszkaa]

Most może wpaść w drgania ale na tym filmiku jest to wyostrzone i dodane są inne efekty (wygięcia)! Bez przesady, nie aż tak!

[mib0220]

YYY ludzie wiecie co to REZONANS ??????????? nie? to do kurwy nedzy poczytajcie sobie troche o tym i sie dowiecie czemu ten most sie tak bujal!!!

[PiMp3k44]

Ludzie kurwa to nie możliwe, żeby asfalt nie pęknął, a beton nie pokruszył się przy takim zginaniu, no bez przesady.

[pucio00]

fakink fejk



[OstryRuchacz]

WHAT THE FUCK LOL ? SERIOUSLY WHO IS SO FUCKING RETARDED TO MAKE SO SHIT FAKE VIDEO !!?!!?!?! SERIOUSLY ?!?!?!

[Travmapunk]

@OstryRuchacz no

[puczinek]

ten filmik jest prawdziwy

takie kolysanie wynika z czestotliwosci (predkosci) wiatru, ktory synchronizuje sie z czestotliwoscia mostu(wiem ze to dziwnie brzmi ale takie cos instnieje :)

to sprawia ze most wpada w wibracje

[OstryRuchacz]

@puczinek udowodnij

[DarkArchon1992]

@OstryRuchacz most Golden Gate San Francisco dokładnie to samo tylko że siła była około 30 razy większa, a i przeczytaj sobie dlaczego żołnierze przechodząc przez most nie utrzymują żołnierskiego tępa (lewa,prawa)

[OSZKI]

fake

[borkos111]

fake.

[ZioUoch]

to jest nie możliwe 0:34 żeby ta warstwa podstawy kurcyzła się i rozszerzała ;/

fake.

[CherryByBack]

Photoshop, fake

[efclicos]

FAke, photoshop



[anusial7ka]

jak to mozliwe??moze mieli trzesienie ziemi

[MrQTAX]

It's just the effect of resonance vibration of the bridge and the wind:) Also happens in USA :P

[denelson83]

The Russian Galloping Gertie.

[tawreon]

Who thinks that this video is fake are so dumbass....

[MrEastern69]

Russian engineering at its best that bridge was built to do that without the wind ahhahahh

[kernel246]

last time i checked americans dont make rubber bridges thank god

[0hmyfuckinggod]

Those were normal conditions, no wind. Russian engineering fail.

[jukingeo]

You think designers would learn after the Tacoma Narrows collapse, huh?

[jojoyomamaface101]

Take some acid and watch that bridge gooo hahaha

[ChaseThatTornado67]

omg that is sooo dangerous! fuck 0:13

[ami2evil]

...nice

[MikeBorchers]

in Soviet Russia bridge sways wind

[MrOpamop]

@MikeBorchers

It's a fake. no any soviet Russia,just Russia, learn bloody history - make an effort.

By the way learn about bridges too a bit.

[wartiger120]

fake it is warps and sound fx

[ArtisanTony]

All of you saying this is fake google bridge + wind and you will plenty of old footage of when suspension bridges were first being built and see that this is very possible. A bridge can act like the wing of an airplane if not designed properly and create lift. This bridge should have been closed. Maybe it was.

[houseofbeauties]

@ArtisanTony

yeah but all the other vids you see look nothing like this.

its really looks fake.

[ArtisanTony]

@houseofbeauties All bridges are designed and built to move to a degree tobe able to accept loads from wind and seismic activity . I am in the construction industry and am familiar with this process. Just the other day I pulled over on a bridge to accept a phone call and I was bouncing up and down while cars went by. You have to understand a little bit about harmonics also to understand what happens in nature and bridges.

[ArtisanTony]

@houseofbeauties Certain vibrations from wind and earth can harmonize to a certain frequency to cause this type of thing with bridges. If you listen to nature you will hear and feel things. Just the other day my Dachshund, Max, caused our entire floor to bounce only with his little trot he does. I am a heavy guy and could not reproduce the harmonic vibration a 10 pound pouch did. It is all about frequency and harmonics of nature. I have just exposed you to sacred secrets, oops! :)

[SplurtaBeats]

This is real btw, it may look damn near impossible but that's physics for you

[SplurtaBeats]

Looks like the bridge is on an acid trip.

[slightvalentine]

fake

[Collinemycin]

After Effects->mesh warp+some sound FX -.-

[DanLFC8]

weird how metal can do that haha

[JesFeyenoord]

Scary

[Boisword]

WOW seriosly u guys this is fake n im serios look at those metal in the bridge they look like theyr sponges and if its b coz of wind i cant reli hear the sound of the wind in the vid n y dos the same noise keep looping

[TheGalvanize123]

thts so fake

[yeyekuye]

it is imposibble

[chilldude567]

thats some strong ass wind lmao

[Deviczon]

wooooooow :S

[aed78]

it is a failure of Russian engineering...

[makhairat]

@aed78 the bridge moved for minutes but it is still not only useable but there is not even a single damage.......so now i ask u is it a failuer ? it had happened in other countries i am sure it would have burried all the poor ppl was crossing at that time.

i am not russian but telling u the things u can see.

it shows thier engineering high quality.

[Damianek2121]

Widać że fotomontaż -.-

[PornOnThisChannel]

Это видео очень страшно и опасно

[GmasterRED]

In soviet Russia, bridge cross YOU

[gabe0083]

@deli067

oh shut up

[tacosfromearth]

WTF

[hilectro]

@deli067

/facepalm....



[naylah781]

We all can do it. Just have to get the right app on your Iphone. (this is not an ad)

[roselee0010]

omg .. i think this is true ..

[hilectro]

Can't believe all these people writing 'fake'. Clearly they're not engineers. If they were, they'd know that any piece of material / structure has its own 'harmonic frequency' - basically, if something effects it at this frequency (ie wind blowing by in this case), the structure can vibrate itself to pieces, depending on the amplitude of the force and the time in which it acts.

[SuperDrummerJoe]

@hilectro tarmac dont bend

[boyrichboy]

@SuperDrummerJoe you fucking idiot.. grow a brain.. watch Nat Geo's Megastructures episode of Bridges before you make a stupid comment like that...

[hilectro]

@SuperDrummerJoe

In actual fact, you'll find everything bends to a certain degree. Take glass for instance, it bends, just not much until it shatters.

Tarmac can take quite a bit of punishment, especially if warm, as the bitumen is very 'rubber like'.

Not only that, but the total bending per square metre is quite small, probably less than 1 or 2 degrees per metre. Well within limit. I suggest you refrain from posting until you grow a little smarter.

[zeropm1]

@SuperDrummerJoe yes it does

[JEDGUECOB]

It's not fake, physics can explain this... Plus it's not the first time for a bridge to sway like that. search tacoma narrows guys, they "almost" have the same condition and that bridge is ain't fake. It was examined by some architect and physicists.

[clubsfun]

that s fucking fake

[MaximumMaxime]

looked real at the beggining but the view over the road shows that this is definetely not real !

would be funny though

[DanceGenerationEGY]

who says its fake is idiot nothin fake all tv channels showed it nothing fuckin fake

[mraissam1997]

FAKE , FAIL

[Graptemiss]

I have seen many bridges "swaying", and this one sure looks fake. It's supposed to twist, not get bigger or smaller, nothing logical in that. And what, the cars and the people would still be going on such a bridge, if it truly was moving? Tsssss.

[ImaginativeBrowsing]

fake and gay

[Neo3050]

Theres an article about it in the Moscow Times

[imdumped]

another fake shit

[hneboori]

It's a standing wave, or a resonant wave. It has to do with the length of the bridge and the force of the wind/vibrations hitting the bridge. Eventually the amplitude of the standing wave will build up and the bridge will collapse. Something similar happened to a bridge called tacoma narrows in the 1940's ...

[MainOffenderKZ]

lolwut?

[TiptupJr]

This is motherfucking FAKE, you idiots.

[ferd9191]

Asphalt is flexible which is why the road isn't breaking apart. I'm not so sure how much strain is needed though to break everything else?

[InCastProductions]

lolwut?

[domokun5555]

I Want to take a car with bad shocks and drive 160mph across that thing,

and hope not to die...lol

[ALEj0O0]

wouldnt the concrete break?

[RacketDoctor]

IT LOOKS SO FAKE BUT THEN AGAIN I CAN'T HELP THINKING IT'S TRUE

[chatoz]

Thats a fucking joke. that bridge shouldnt do that lol

[snakeinabush123]

@chatoz Check a related video titled Tacoma Narrows Newsreel. That bridge went through the same thing, but collapsed. It's just one of the many design flaws of older bridges. They weren't designed to withstand really powerful winds.

[h00ntube]

i see the bridges in russia like to sway to and fro like their drunken comrades? lol

[dramagirl94x]

is this photo shopped?

[snakeinabush123]

@dramagirl94x No, I was actually watching Russian news on TV when they showed this. I'm pretty sure that they aren't dumb enough to talk about a photoshopped video. So to answer your question, no it likely isn't.

[h00ntube]

weeble wobble goes the bridge.

[danceaddict321]

how is the road not breaking?

[corvettefan96]

looks like the tacoma narrows bridge

[stone1792]

me da lo mismo que seas ruso imbecil como te hago entender que no te creo ni nadie tampoco soy de chile y hubo un terrepomo,tonto, y si vieras noticias quedo la embarrada y fue de 8.8 y ese puente se mueve koo su fuera de 20 y nadie te cree que ese puente alla seguido en pie despues de ese movimiento...aparte de que con ese viento un poco de oleaje deve haber RUSO IMBECIL!

[coldfu00]

Props to the bridge builders. not many bridges could handle that kind of oscillation and not crumble.

[Knightmareninja]

@coldfu00 lmao that's one way to look at it. But if it was me i rather have a sturdy bridge that doesn't sway in the wind.

[dograt666]

So fake and So gay!!!

[Roughneck8]

What's the problem here? That bridge is totally safe.

[l1998]

FAKE shit just like russians lol

[fatbastard135]

So many people on the internet are dumb asses, of course this is real

[stone1792]

este video es falsisimo por ke kon elv iento se tendria ke mover el agua por lomenos un oleaje y mas ensima por lomenos deveria kaerse un tendido electrico con ese moviemiento jajajaem dan risaa pero mucha risa mediocres me mierda me da risa ke nisikiera una grieta en el cemento alla dejado este movimiento... yo soy de chile y le digo ke aka si se movio la tierra y dejo la embarra y kn ese movimiento ubiera dejao el puente en el suelo! ciiao mediocres ociosos!

[phantomsnare]

I didn't know BP built bridges!

[nikkatak]

@phantomsnare um no...

[fixingtheproblem]

holy fuck

[ultmobrian]

fake much?

[crakermouth]

In soviet Russia, the bridge sways the wind ;D

[EBsoccer12]

in soviet Russia Bridge shake you!!

[elpelaYonoveNtAyDos]

FAKE AND GAY!

[ps2freak6678]

only in Russia

[ltrage]

that dude at 0:13 is badass, it's just a regular day for him in russia

[ReVoKeR210]

LOOKS FUN!

[Roofius2]

idiots its not fake

its real

[crazyozzyking]

its not a ghost bridge just bad russian safety policies.

[MrSultanwind]

no possible

[clubsfun]

haunted bridge lol

[lebourg973]

pffff un montage et pis c'est tout !!!

[88anas88]

Ce pont est un pont sur piliers, la résonance est à éloigner. Tacoma était un pont suspendu sans piliers.

En plus faites une petite recherche sur ggle. Trouvez-vous une source assez crédible ?

C'est un montage !

Enfin ceci reste mon avis.

[romain7591]

Non ce n'est pas un trucage !! c'est un phénomene en physique qu'on appelle "résonnance" ! Tapez "pont de tacoma" il s'est passé la meme chose !

C'est dur a croire mais c'est la vérité !

[romain7591]

@romain7591 sauf que malheuresement le pont de tacoma lui n'a pas tenu !!

[ameliaL53]

La vache o.O On nous prend vraiment pour des cons O.o

[LeBronjames63720]

FAKE !!

[Tsaye]

Yahoo raconte vraiment mais que de la merde ... people ou fake, c'est abusé.

[manulemalin21]

45'' : a strange light appears in the middle of the screen near the black point on the road, it looks like a little flash of lighting ! it comes from the top to the right bottom... is that really Chuck Norris ? Maybe Aftereffects ?