Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (134)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • I saw this in Chicago with Nathan Lane.....WAY, WAY BETTER!

  • Just horrible. Original cast is so much better.

    

  • @Cffirst Horrible is an unnessisary word when you are talking The Addams Family. What I see is not the best cast. They have their hits, and their misses. In the end, they were good, but I will agree the original is the best.

  • i saw this show on broad way, it was awesome!

  • The original cast was better.........

  • I saw this one tour and even though I expected more, it was still good

  • I'm not the kind of guy who does "reviews" on youtube but thanks God I saw the play with the original cast. Simply can´t compare, especially Krysta, she is completely amazing. Bebe and Nathan are awesome individually and even better together. Well, of course that´s just my opinion, but I feel lucky to saw that live with the other Addams!

  • I just didn't see Brooke Shields as Morticia. Bebe just felt more natural.

  • I saw this with Brooke and she is a MUCH better singer than Bebe listening to the soundtrack. Rachel is a much better singer and a good actress but Krysta stole it with acting.

  • @actingirlri

    Brooks voice just doesn't fit the character....

  • Why would Wednesday like to go to Disneyland?

  • @everlefreak the haunted mansion?

  • @everlefreak ummm shes changing! yeah duh....its sorta in the song "pulled in a new direction" so yeaaah

  • i disliked Wesley Taylor in the role of Lucas Beineke, I thought he was too WINEY!!!!!! It kind of annoyed me....

  • Well I'm just going to say to everyone out there,,i think Rachel is AMAZING!! All the other Wednesdays were good but Rachel definitely plays Wednesday perfectly for the context of this musical!! She is an Amazing singer and actress and i think everyone needs to stop saying bad things about Rachel and the other people in the addams family! they are all phenomenal! If you don't like it! then simply don't watch the video!!

  • I think the Chicago version is overall so much better. The sword fight between Gomez and Morticia may have been unrelated to the plot, but it was fantastic nonetheless. Uncool.

  • Rachel Potter keeps making me think I'm watching Tessa Netting.

  • roger rees sucks he could be her grandpa

  • Thank God this bomb gets extinguished this week. And losing a TON of money. That's what happens when you make the #1` mistake with a musical...hire a composer with NO talent.

  • she is very good (:

  • brooke shields is no way near as good as bebe neuworth. sorry. she just is too happy!

  • I SAW THIS YESTERDAY!!!! IT WAS SO GOOOODDD

  • I say both the versions are good in their own ways; it's just that the Original Cast is always remembered more, because it's a new thing! I'm not saying I have anything against these actors and actresses- I think they're all awesome!- but it's just that not many people remember the second or the third; just the first.

  • Brooke Shields would have done better with Nathan Lane...

  • OH HELL NO! brooke sheilds can't replace Bebe Neuwirth and whoever that is can't replace Nathan Lane! this version *suuuuckkks*

  • Rachel surprised me! I thought "A disney girl playing the role!?" but gladly I was 100% Wrong! She was INCREDIBLE as Wensday all the actors were amazing! GO SEE THIS MUSICAL! IT KICKS ASS!

  • ...Why is Gomez 100 years old?

  • I'm sad they never showed any of Heidi's performance. I loved her in [tos] and was thrilled to see her perform live, but even the rest of my class thought she was the best part

  • Everywhere there is debate about whose better, look you cannot blame anyone for wanting to put there spin on the character, everyone is saying the original is the best, that's because it is hard to match the original for anything, your also used to seeing the original cast and aren't used to seeing the new one you can't determine whose better unless they are both doing the same thing as each other but they r not, I love both versions of the cast and screw you to anyone who disagrees

  • Can someone in the entertainment industry please have an original thought and stop Musical-ifying all the old shows? Please?

  • I can't love any Gomez other than Nathan Lane :/

  • :)

  • Roger Rees was great as Gomez

  • Krysta kills it as Wednesday, shes spastic and freakish while Rachel has a sweet little girl voice- i don't feel Wednesday at ALL.

  • @MirandaH96 I agree

  • ....... I thought they changed the cast to make it better... not worse! I mean there all good but the old cast is wayyy better!

  • @ 3:51 LUV Wednesday's jacket!!

  • no more mean comments....they all have talent that's why they got the role in the first place:)

  • BEBE NEUWIRTH IS SO MUCH BETTER THAN BROOKE SHIELDS

  • I am very disappointed with Brooke, Rachel, and Roger. It's not their fault that they aren't right for the parts, but seriously, it's like whoever cast them is blind deaf and dumb. So glad that they aren't on the tour.

  • I really love the song Pulled but I hate that Rachel isn't on the cast recording :(

  • Rachel, to me, is a more preppy Wednesday. As opposed to Krysta who was more of the dark, classical Wednesday. But in context to the show, Wednesday is preppy and attempts to resist the brighter side but can't control her desires which I think Rachel does perfectly. But don't get me wrong, Krysta was an amazing Wednesday but Rachel, I think, is just a great fit!!!

  • @BroadwayMusicalFreak now THAT'S what i call a true fan

  • The musical is great, but the story line isn't the best!

  • Rachel is an incredible singer, as is Krysta, but I think Krysta had a more 'Wednesday' feel to her performance.

  • Comment removed

  • @defythewesternsky you couldn't be more wrong if you tried. i saw the original cast and met bebe. brooke is just kidding herself thinking she is anywhere near as good for this part or as good as bebe and the new wedenseday is just horrible...glad i saw this when i did...because this is just terrible

  • I like Krysta better, she is a better actor and she seems like she has much more fun on the stage. My opinion though, please don't mentally destroy me with your harsh comments.

  • I like Brooke :) 

  • Rachel is so much better than Krysta.

  • i just don't like that wednesday

  • I LOVE Rachel, but im not feeling Wednesday in her in this video. i dont know what it is, in pulled she could of gotten more in to it. i just dont see wednesday in her.

  • i've watch so many videos of broadway performances with comments saying that the cast member are over acting. i hate to break it to you but THAT'S THE WHOLE POINT OF BROADWAY.

  • Im sorry but she over acts it, Krysta is better

  • My chorus cast is going to see that tomorrow and next year we are seeing wicked

  • I only like Brooke sheilds kryara rodrequez is better

  • I just saw this 2 days ago - with this cast - and it was FANTASTIC!!!!!!! My whole family thought so too. I'd highly recommend going to see this.

  • the original broadway cast was soooooooooo much better!!!!

  • it was great! thw scenes with the grandmother wer the funiest!

  • Im not digging the GOmez.....he needs to go.... I like everyone else though

  • Very nice try...but I think there was some casting issues in the 2011 cast-it looks to me they tried to create the Bebe Morticia look on Brooke. The Gomez I am NOT a fan of...I think they could've done a little better this time around as far as casting.

  • Very nice try...but I think there was some casting issues in the 2011 cast-it looks to me they tried to create the Bebe Morticia look on Brooke. The Gomez I am NOT a fan of...I think they could've done a little better this time around as far as casting.

  • Hate the Wednesday and Gomez

  • One thing that I recognized with this new cast is that they seem to be singing the songs to fast and from the way they're talking it sounds like their trying to hard and it shows. Not putting down the actors/actresses or anything, but with them singing faster than the original cast the spooky charm was lost...

    And is it just me or does this Mrs. Benieke look like little orphan Annie???

    But I do love the video though...

  • I saw this play and I LOVED IT!!!!.....besides the fact I was starring at Wednesday (Or Rachel Potter as you may like to call her) almost the whole play...

  • I've seen it at Brodway , oh god it was sooooo good !

  • I actually think Roger Rees is really good in this role, very reminiscent of Raul Julia's take on the role....Rachel may be a tad better than Krysta but both are great, but don't get me started on how horrific Brooke Shields is.

  • Krysta's voice is so beautiful. Almost to be a Wednsday.

  • How come this got such nasty reviews? This looks like a really fun show!

  • i loved krysta!

  • I saw the Addams family with Bebe Neuwirth, Nathan Lane, krysta , jesse Swenson, and pugsleys understudy, logan Rowland. Krysta IS Wednesday. And I am convinced that morticia was made for Bebe Neuwirth. The cast I saw was better than what is currently on broadway. The cast currently on broadway is incredible but I personally like the cast I saw better.

  • Rachel's body language and acting is way too happy. Wensday is just turning to be a happy person and Rachel is already there. That's not how it goes, sorry

  • I feel like Krstya is a way more Wensday than Rachel. Rachel has an incredible voice, but Kyrsta is just...Wensday

  • Honestly, why I can't feel The Addams from this preview?

  • they're all too happy

  • i miss krysta

  • Krysta is just WEDNESDAY... Rachel's voice is a little to high pitched and whiney...

  • Wait is she the new wednesday or did Krysta replace her???

  • i think Rachel plays a very fine Wednesday (yes, she is NO Krysta) but in this one preformance......i dont know......her singing pulled in this video...she looks uncomfortable and awkward....i wish i could see her singing it a different time so i knew for sure, but just in this preformance alone, she doesnt pull off the song as well as Krysta.

  • I miss Krysta...

  • !!!SUGARPLUMS!!!

  • I saw this version in NY and it was AMAZING!!!

  • The Addams family should be creepy ,but they are not !!!

  • Comment removed

  • Rachel Potter is amazing as Wednesday!!!!!!!!!! Anyone that has not seen her live in the show needs to not put her down because she is incredible. Both her and Krysta are different so there is no need to compare :)

  • I would not see. it sucks...

  • I don't rate Brooke Shields in this preview, her singing voice is alright, but she has little stage prescence.

  • I recently saw this. Brooke was just not cut out for the job as Morticia. But Rachel OWNS Wednesday. She has some serious Broadway potential.

  • Rachel i think needs to be more into her song "Pulled". Seeing Krysta do it was amazing. She was so expressive and really into her staging. Rachel has a beautiful voice, she should just really be looking like she's being "pulled" instead of just going through the movements and have more spark in her eyes.

  • Rachel and Heidi stole the show!

  • I had no expectations from Brooke Shields, so I was impressed (some). Bebe Neuwirth was just perfect for the role. Rachel Potter is incredibly talented (sounds a bit like Annaleigh Ashford too!) but her movements seemed forced and not as natural as Krysta Rodriguez. I think that with a few more years she can become so much better and that she has an amazing career ahead of her! Roger Rees was good, but he lacks the enthusiasm and wild recklessness that is who Gomez is and Nathan Lane embodied!

  • I like Brooke and Rachel as Morticia and Wednesday, but Bebe and Krysta will always be the orginals, and rightfully hold their place. But Roger is a the perfect successor for Nathan. They are equals in their talent. My personal opinion only. I will say though, Without the originals, the show has lost a some of it's quirky charm, even though the new cast is great.

  • i saw the full original cast and it was spectacular. when i heard that bebe and nathan and krysta left i was so upset. brook cant do morticia the way bebe did and i feel super lucky to have seen them all together. also i'm sure rachel is good, but krysta's energy reeeeallly made that character for me, rachel doesn't seem to have any real creepiness goin' on here. but i haven't seen her so i probably shouldnt judge.

  • I love Krysta but this girl seems good too!

  • I didn't get to see Krysta play Wednesday, but I thought Rachel was absolutely fantastic and had a gorgeous voice. I can't compare her to Krysta, but I bet she was just as good.

  • Brooke certainly looks... interesting. I didn't know she could sing. I bet she's good. I think Bebe was better though.

  • i like it better with the new cast i saw it yesterday

  • I loved loved loved Krysta, but Rachel does do great. Rachel brings her own view as Wednesday and its something I have to get used to. BUT BEBE is the only one who can play the true Morticia. Brooke just is a little too over the top.

  • I want the old weds back she had a stronger voice and played it well other than that its amazing

  • @olenarochelle143 I know  I wanted to see her not rachel

  • i more think that Krysta has the look and act to the character but rachel had the voice and i think that krysta had rachel's voice then that would be good. but personally i like rachel's voice better

  • Cant believe I have to wait until March 2013 to see this!!!!!!!!

  • @29leighbo Really?....it'll probably be closed by then!

  • @Piccolo13 haha no I have to wait til 2013 cause thats when its coming to Australia =)

  • I really likemost of this new cast (Rachel is fantastic) , but I don't think that Brooke is that good. Rest are great though x

  • new cast is awesome,SPECTACULAR! especially Gomez part,so much better!

  • how rachel potter can go from being the Glinda understudy on the tour and be the dark depressing Wednesday...that's pretty impressive

  • I personally think that Rachel owns the character, as opposed to Krysta.

  • @SHALAFI123 no way! krysta is so much more insane which when you think of the character wednesday is totally appropraite!! rachel looks a bit forced and fake, still good but krysta kicks assss!!

  • wow. wednesday is really a different person now. Ii discusts me. But she is still torturing pugsley with whatever she used in 2:32 through 2:35.

  • Not to hate, but im a sucker for the original cast ( :

  • Where is Heidi?!?!

  • Everyone seriously just chill. The new cast is definitely up to par with the original and Rachel is just as amazing as Krysta so just enjoy what they're bringing to Broadway and stop criticizing.

  • I actually enjoy this cast a lot more compared to the clips I've seen of the originals (mainly Nathan and Bebe as I haven't seen much of the other's originals), but I enjoy the voices a lot more. >.< Nathan Lane is good, but I don't know, something about Bebe's voice aggravates my ears...

  • to each is own. Brooke and the new cast seems to be doing the best they can. Any musical shows change actors till they finish their contracts. After Brooke there will be new casts again and again. so It will never be the same as the originals. But i know new casts always do great!

  • I absolutely ADORE Rachel Potter. I think she's fabulous. Her voice is lighter than Krysta's but I really like it!

  • Would everyone just chill! The new people may be different than the originals, but it's ok. Everyone protrays the characters in their own way. I actually think the cast is perfectly fine. You have to be grateful that there are people willing to fill the shoes of those who did end up leaving the show :) Just give them a chance, this is the beginning of their run.... they'll get better!!!

  • I hate brooke shields as morticia . she sucks. bring bebe back!

  • I love Rachel Potter in small doses, but Brooke Shields' voice isn't very melodic. She embodies the character of Morticia very well though.

  • I want to see Brooke in this!!!

  • Why did they removed "I studied with lurch?"

    I'm so happy I was lucky to see the old cast, I think that Bebe & Lane were much better.

    Cool musical, anyway!

  • I like Rachel Potter better than the old Wednesday!

  • The new cast is different. I think that Roger Rees performs and old and non-romantic Gomez. Brooke and Roger sing awful. I'm glad that Jacky perfomrs Grandma again.

  • I met Rachel Potter when she hosted the tony award party.....she told me she liked my dress and took a picture with me and she was just a sweet heart

  • Without the unmatched charisma and stage presence (and let's face it - utter talent) of Bebe Neuwirth and Nathan Lane, and Krysta Rodriguez, it seems to have lost it's... spooky and cooky charm. It's still a brilliant show, but I just miss their energy.

  • @margretteleigh yeah, not to mention the first wednesday was hot... and good.

  • Thank You very much, it's so Good to See and to Listen!

  • boooooo the new cast sucks!! i miss the old wednesday!!

  • Who is the girl playing Wednesday? She is AMAZING!!!

  • some of the happy/sad lyrics changed. hmmm. and what happend to "I studied with lurch?"

  • Comment removed

  • no Heidi...boo.

  • Rachel Potter's voice...wow!!

Loading...
Alert icon
0 / 00Unsaved Playlist Return to active list
    1. Your queue is empty. Add videos to your queue using this button:
      or sign in to load a different list.
    Loading...Loading...Saving...
    • Clear all videos from this list
    • Learn more