Rubato should not interfere with the flow. Why are so many pianists tempted into playing the Mazurkas in such a mannered manner? Is it to distinguish them from walzes?
@mossfitz A Mazurka is NOT necessarily supposed to flow, you ignorant numbskull. Obviously you never heard the two reported instances of famous musicians feeling that Chopin played his Mazurkas with four whole beats in many bars. Try doing some research before making such idiotically misguided criticisms...
Can you really imagine your making your comment in such an ill-mannered fashion during a face to face public conversation.
Good rubato can, of course, involve long lacunas, interruptions and even silences. Jerky breaks are quite another thing and simpy bad rubato - like someone who just can´t dance. The Mazurka is a dance and though Chopin´s are not intended to be danced to physically, they are different than, say, a ballade which is more about story-telling and drama.
@mossfitz Could anything be more "ill-mannered" than rudely criticising a performer based on ignorance and a lack knowledge? A mazruak is not supposed to "flow". It is SUPPOSED to sound jerky, you ill-informed numbskull. Personally I should like to hear more freedoms still. To write this is off based on excess freedoms would be plain ignorance. No doubt you'd also have had a go at Chopin- in the playing of whom Meyerbeer heard more 4/4 bars than 3/4 ones...
@wayneredhart In this instance, its a question of taste not knowledge. I play many of the Mazurkas and, yes, i´ve read about them too. I find the timing here awkward - mannered, as i said - Perhaps awkwardness appeals to you? That would be the taste of a troll wouldn´t it? - well why not. Enjoy!
@mossfitz Well, perhaps you ought to do a little more research into both Chopin and the Mazurka? You clearly haven't done enough. Maybe,instead of criticisizing others on false grounds, you could then set about learning to play them better for yourself? If this is too "awkward" for you (and you would criticise it on such idiotic grounds and not having enough "flow" and being too "jerky"), you simply have not even begun to understand the Mazurka. Go and listen to Friedman.
@mossfitz PS. It didn't seem to about your personal taste when you said: "Rubato should not interfere with the flow. Why are so many pianists tempted into playing the Mazurkas in such a mannered manner?" However, if someone criticises such a misguided criticism, they ought to just acknowledge your different taste? Perhaps you should remember that next time you are making foolish criticisms that stem from your own naivety...
I have been playing it for a long time now, and still haven't figured out how to play this well. My teacher said my playing sounded too "metronomic" due to my left hand's playing.
THis is a wonderful interpretation! I will learn from this video and strive to play this piece as well as you do (but I probably won't). Thank you for sharing this performance!
Thanks for the honest and thoughtful observation! If I play straighter, it's deemed 'clinical.' I know I can't please everyone, so I try to please myself.
This has been flagged as spam show
my sister is playing this :)
TheBornthisway11 2 months ago
my sister is playin this :)
TheBornthisway11 2 months ago
Stacking!!
caltempature98 2 months ago
I play it too :) I really like it
kitttyke 4 months ago
Comment removed
kitttyke 4 months ago
大家好 彈的好棒 好棒的演奏 我是愛彈鋼琴的臺灣姑娘 請大家跟我做好友 我的頻論區見 請大家來流覽我台灣姑娘 tgwirl1 的網站 我有唱很多歌 我有彈現代 古典 再次謝謝大家 謝謝
twgirl1 8 months ago
thats a huge grand....
Kret0s 8 months ago in playlist Mus. CHOPIN Mazurkas
...That's not a "song" since theres no singing...
QcMori7 9 months ago
Comment removed
612curtis 9 months ago
Stacking :D What a fantastic game
RandleScandal 9 months ago
Comment removed
jupham42 5 months ago
Comment removed
jupham42 5 months ago
woow this is played professionally :D it's such a difficult part to play!
10freekie2 10 months ago
Think im starting to like the mazurkas more than the nocturnes :O
ancientsolar 11 months ago 2
@ancientsolar They're pretty good but the nocturnes still have my vote lol
612curtis 9 months ago
Isn't this for four hands?
camioneroh69 1 year ago
my dad can play this very well and a little bit faster than this I always thought it was by Joplin because he plays a lot of Joplin too
reedrichards82 1 year ago
@reedrichards82
Choplin
PPJens 1 year ago
its easy to play, but it looks like as it is hard. thats the best thing about this nice song. love to play it xD
Maddin1929 1 year ago
@Maddin1929 Same thing with the Op.68 No.2 Mazurka!
daytonmlivingston 11 months ago
time wrong
Stefolina89 1 year ago
same!!!
qy2m 1 year ago
Playing this song for my piano recital...
AizaJustmint 1 year ago
This is horrible, she lost the feeling of the piece.
bsd300d 1 year ago
VERY WELL DONE
dongjiangbo 1 year ago
Would you guys stop calling it a "song" ? it's a Piece!
nivtal20 1 year ago
@nivtal20 whats the difference
llllShArPllll 1 year ago
nice piece very lively
qy2m 1 year ago
I'm playing this song too.
pianopam1 1 year ago
me too!!
thepianistfyr 1 year ago
is this piece hard to play?
i ask this because i found a music book which i have, which categorised this piece under grade 4.
RDU1388 1 year ago
@RDU1388 Well, I played this for my grade 7 last yr....its not that hard but its just cos u need to stretch ur finger a little
musiclover2141 1 year ago
Comment removed
OriginalBasaliskos 1 year ago
is something in 2:06 ?
bb1996818 1 year ago
@bb1996818 I noticed that too.
Archangel777Catholic 9 months ago
mazurka durka durka!
willgudmundsson 2 years ago
so many mazurkas so little time ;-)
mike480000 2 years ago 2
@mike480000
it's very difficult :S
derdereuchzihtx100 2 years ago
Rubato should not interfere with the flow. Why are so many pianists tempted into playing the Mazurkas in such a mannered manner? Is it to distinguish them from walzes?
mossfitz 2 years ago
@mossfitz A Mazurka is NOT necessarily supposed to flow, you ignorant numbskull. Obviously you never heard the two reported instances of famous musicians feeling that Chopin played his Mazurkas with four whole beats in many bars. Try doing some research before making such idiotically misguided criticisms...
wayneredhart 1 year ago
@wayneredhart
Troll!
Can you really imagine your making your comment in such an ill-mannered fashion during a face to face public conversation.
Good rubato can, of course, involve long lacunas, interruptions and even silences. Jerky breaks are quite another thing and simpy bad rubato - like someone who just can´t dance. The Mazurka is a dance and though Chopin´s are not intended to be danced to physically, they are different than, say, a ballade which is more about story-telling and drama.
mossfitz 1 year ago
@mossfitz Could anything be more "ill-mannered" than rudely criticising a performer based on ignorance and a lack knowledge? A mazruak is not supposed to "flow". It is SUPPOSED to sound jerky, you ill-informed numbskull. Personally I should like to hear more freedoms still. To write this is off based on excess freedoms would be plain ignorance. No doubt you'd also have had a go at Chopin- in the playing of whom Meyerbeer heard more 4/4 bars than 3/4 ones...
wayneredhart 1 year ago
@wayneredhart In this instance, its a question of taste not knowledge. I play many of the Mazurkas and, yes, i´ve read about them too. I find the timing here awkward - mannered, as i said - Perhaps awkwardness appeals to you? That would be the taste of a troll wouldn´t it? - well why not. Enjoy!
mossfitz 1 year ago
@mossfitz Well, perhaps you ought to do a little more research into both Chopin and the Mazurka? You clearly haven't done enough. Maybe,instead of criticisizing others on false grounds, you could then set about learning to play them better for yourself? If this is too "awkward" for you (and you would criticise it on such idiotic grounds and not having enough "flow" and being too "jerky"), you simply have not even begun to understand the Mazurka. Go and listen to Friedman.
wayneredhart 1 year ago
I found the Friedman version. I have to say, I quite like it. Have you heard Biret play?
OriginalBasaliskos 1 year ago
@OriginalBasaliskos The Biret version is way better than this.
bsd300d 1 year ago
@bsd300d : D I agree. Her mazurkas have a sort of energy and liveliness that few others seem to put into their playing of Chopin's mazurkas.
OriginalBasaliskos 1 year ago
@OriginalBasaliskos Actually the best word to describe it for me is....bounce !....:)
dmcII 1 year ago
@mossfitz PS. It didn't seem to about your personal taste when you said: "Rubato should not interfere with the flow. Why are so many pianists tempted into playing the Mazurkas in such a mannered manner?" However, if someone criticises such a misguided criticism, they ought to just acknowledge your different taste? Perhaps you should remember that next time you are making foolish criticisms that stem from your own naivety...
wayneredhart 1 year ago
Very good... greetings from Peru...
jccalderonp 2 years ago
i just started playing it.... i suck...:(
rani265 2 years ago 6
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Just learned it, took me 5 minutes
aaabbbccc5 2 years ago
Comment removed
AidaTosca 2 years ago
@aaabbbccc5
u suck much rofl!
The2012Apocalyptos 1 year ago
I could´nt care less!
aaabbbccc5 1 year ago
Comment removed
xJulianax 2 years ago
I just started playing this song. You play it beautifully. Thank you!
harpandpianomusic 2 years ago
I love you!
brakiz 2 years ago
Comment removed
AidaTosca 2 years ago
great! and the timing enjoyed
Eyalel5 2 years ago
man she is hot
cydavid 2 years ago
Comment removed
AidaTosca 2 years ago
i'm playing this song!
KasKait19 2 years ago 16
ME TOO!
lipmann0128 2 years ago 21
@KasKait19 this is not a song.
kenneth2145 10 months ago
@KasKait19 this is not a song
kenneth2145 10 months ago 6
omg Check out "The Chestnut Tree." It's a little animation that uses Mazurka. It's really cute.
iSpeakKonglish 2 years ago
Very good!
I have been playing it for a long time now, and still haven't figured out how to play this well. My teacher said my playing sounded too "metronomic" due to my left hand's playing.
Love it! :)
pianomath 2 years ago
Great job
irondawson 2 years ago
great! im teaching this to myself- havent gotten past the first page though
brisingr380 2 years ago
Do you have the sheet music?
iSpeakKonglish 2 years ago
yeah i do
brisingr380 2 years ago
Can you post the link?
iSpeakKonglish 2 years ago
ME 2!
im 13 and im learnin how to play this!
very good btw
skeletonface95 2 years ago
very beautiful!!! i''m also playing this but i'm 13 years old...XD
Dattebayo13Girl 2 years ago
13 dont change a thing
RayTide9 2 years ago
THis is a wonderful interpretation! I will learn from this video and strive to play this piece as well as you do (but I probably won't). Thank you for sharing this performance!
silviezimmer 2 years ago
Wow... what a beautiful compliment!
AidaTosca 2 years ago
The technique and dynamics are excellent, but I can't help but feel the rubato was taken too far.
Progenerator 3 years ago
Thanks for the honest and thoughtful observation! If I play straighter, it's deemed 'clinical.' I know I can't please everyone, so I try to please myself.
I do appreciate your thoughts.
AidaTosca 3 years ago
Comment removed
thefutaisnow 3 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
aida tosca I checked your list and you could never be the beauty who is playing here probably you are a wanna be travestite
elquetocapiano 3 years ago
very good performance~!
MozartAppreciator 3 years ago
Very Good, I also play it like that.
Jumpmanmauro 3 years ago
I'm learning this.
( you played it better than my teacher, when he was showing me what it was supposed to sound like. )
beautiful. =D
emilypotter7 3 years ago
What a beautiful compliment...
Thank you very much!
-Kyung
AidaTosca 3 years ago
Nice.
I LOVE THE PIANO!
miguelchavez94 3 years ago
wonderful performance! very emotional!
Georgezhao123 3 years ago 3
Thanks, George!
I tried to portray 'charm' for the majority of the piece... Hopefully that came through.
-Kyung
AidaTosca 3 years ago