O brother...it seriously looks blatent that you are attacking the hanafi fiqh channel & its scholars...ur intemtions may be to tell the truth but u havent looked deeply into this
subhaan Allah.. my response seems like an attack to u and what do u think about their lies and forgeries in the name of defending their sect? may i know ur point of view brother?
Its not a hanafi fiqh channel, its a deobandi fiqh or deobandi sect channel which attributes false stories to imam abu hanifa rahimahullah. Imam Abu Hanifa rahimahullah was free from what they attribute to him and they can hardly prove any thing from abu hanifa rahimahullah with correct chain of narration.
Imam Shafiee (ra) says that they should be placed above the navel but below the chest. Imam Nawawi (ra) discusses this in his commentary of Muslim saying, 'This is the better known ruling of our Madhab.' He also says in Sharh al Muhaddhab, 'He should place them below his chest and above his navel. This is the correct and clear ruling (of our school).'
MashaAllah. I like you brother for the sake of Allaah. Keep up with these videos of yours! Let the people see and know what the way of the salaf (the way of prophet muhammad pbuh, the rightly guided caliphs and their companions who follow them) is. May Allaah reward you greatly in this world and in the next for all your effort. Ameen, :)
Your video description is very funny. U say that the Deobandi were founded by the British. Do U ever heard about the Reshmi Rumal Tehreek or the anything about the struggle by Haji Imdadullah, Shaykh Gangohi, Shaykh Nanotwi etc against the British? Besides, the followers of the 4 mazhabs dont consider each other to be wrong. But when they try to protect ppl from your foolish arguments, then u accuse them of causing disunity. Please use your brain before using your mouth.
the biggest rejectors of the 4 imams are deobandis. Wait for my other videos and u will know. Rejectors of Sunnah, Opposers of Ahlul Haqq, opposers of Sahaba and opposers of Rasool Allah pbuh.. These are the things which Deobandis teach Deobandi audience but the audience dont realise the snake in the sleeve. Wait for my other videos and u will learn alot InshaAllah.
brother he does not mention any where that Imam Shafee held the opinion of placing hands on the chest. He only makes mention of Shaf'ees using the hadeeth of placing the hands on chest at 7:45 only to deny it via presenting a referenece which only shows the other opinion of Shaf'ees.
For teraweeh, again the majority clearly pray 20 - from the time of the Sahaabas, including the 4 Imaams and Saudi. I feel comfortable following the majority of the scholars on issues where there is Ijma. But I think it's best to respect every view, because at the end of the day we are all relying on scholars that we feel we can trust - unless of course we think we are qualified. As knowledge isn't just in books but passed on from generation to generation via the Ulema.
Brother if u read the article i sent you, surely it will help you increase your information on taraweeh because there is No ijma at all that Taraweeh is 20 Rakaah. Read the Article i sent and Insha Allah then if u comment it will be helpful for me and us all to discussion based on Proof. There is no Ijma on 20 rakaah at all. And yes it is best to respect evry view which is based on Quran and Sunnah. Alhamdulillah, may Allah unite us on Quran and Sunnah,Ameen.
Firstly, it is not about following the majority, but about following what is Right.
Allah (swt) Says in the Quran:
"And if you obey most of those on the earth, they will mislead you far away from Allah's Path. They follow nothing but conjectures, and they do nothing but lie."
( سورة الأنعام , Al-Anaam, Chapter #6, Verse #116)
Secondly, the prophet (saw) ordered that the night prayer is to be read in two's. and ended with 01 Witr. So we can read as much as we like.
As for the prophet (saw) himself, he always prayed 08 rakahs in the night prayer. But that number was never "ordered" for everyone. However, reading 1 chapter of the Quran in 8 rakah gets to be difficult for a lot of people.
But we should never limit the number to 20. Like in Haram (Makkah), they pray 20 rakahs for 20 days, and in the last 10 days they pray 30 rakahs. And also note that one Imam only leads the people in 10 rakahs, and then the other imam leads in the remaining 10.
the point I was trying to make was that the majority (4 Imams & Imams of Haram) don't have hand on their chest per se. Yes I know you mentioned that 'Sadr' can mean anything below the neck...but why do 'Ahle hadith' have it on the chest specifically?
Who was the scholar that actually preferred to have it on the chest specifically?
Plus if the Imams of Haramayn are 'Ahle hadith' then howcomw they pray 20 rakaat teraweeh when 8 is more closer to Sunnah? I thought the Imams of haram were Hambali?
Very good questions mash Allah. Dear brother just as Sadr have 2 meanings, one is specifically Chest and Second the area beneath the throat right upto to the tummy..Similarly there are Ahlul hadith that place their hands specifially on their chest as well as any where above the navel and below the throat and the practical examples are the Imaams of haram and i also mentioned that i myself place it in Midchest area above the Navel and majority ahlul hadeeth that ive seen they do that.
So when it is said to be Sadr then it means both either specifically chest or any where below the throat upto the tummy. It depends on what you choose. Second Question is Why Imams of haram pray 20 when 8 is the closer Sunnah... I will email u an article regarding taraweeh which i have written Alhamdulillah and for me its the best possible and unbiased article that any 1 has written over the internet and all ive done is collected scholarly works and put them in one article.
In short, 8 + 3 is the minimum requirement for the sunnah to be fulfilled because it was the act of the prophet pbuh himself, but the prophet pbuh allowed as much as one can pray. Thats why the Imaams of kaaba not only pray 20 but also pray 30 Plus in the last 10 days of ramadhan. The intention is to extend the prayer and spend the night in prayer as much as possible in the last 10 days of ramadhan.
3ree type hath chest k nechay or navel say oper , hath chor k mean latka kar , or hath naaf k nechay band k,, but most attentic below chest and obove navel , ....but all type is right .... or hath latka kar b thek hai .. this is no issue ..all type is right..it is optional
@awaismalik80 aapka sawaal boht acha hai bhai, pehli baat tu yeh ki Usooli muamlaat, aqeeda etc per meri videos jald arahi hain insha Allah, specially on taqleed e shakhsi waghera. Jaha tak faroori muamlaat ka sawal hai tu bhai Mujhe koi farq nahi parhta agar koi naaf ke neechay ya uper haath baandhay lekin jab koi naam nihad Aalim apna masla saabit karne ke liye jhoot bolay aur bila wajah keechar uchhaalay tu mera nahi khayaal ki musalmaan ko chup rehna chahye..
@awaismalik80 Agar koi bhai apna moaqqaf paish kare aur bus wahi tak rehne de tu humain koi harj nahi.. lekin masla uss waqt kharab hota hai jab moo per jhoot bola jaye aur awaam ko bewaqoof banaya jaye. Na janay kitne bhai aisay hain jinho ne kaha hai hum tu yeh samajh rahe thay ki hum ghalat namaz parh rahe hain lekin meri videos dekh ker unki aankhain khul gayi, tu Alhamdulillah jo mei kar raha hoon woh Allah behtar janta hai ki kis liye kar raha hoon, Aur Allah qabool kare.
Walykum Assalaam warahmatullah wabarakatuh, brother if u watch the video from begining to end, u will have the answers. The word 'Sadr' does not just mean chest but it means the area beneath the throat upto the tummy, so whether its below the chest or above the navel, it is the Sadr and we Ahlul hadeeth tie our hands in that region And Alhamdulillah the imaams of the kaaba and masjid nabwi are all ahlul hadeeth and the they do this practical perfectly daily 5 times a day.
Second purpose was to show that the Imams of the 2 most holiest of places on earth place their hands on their Sadr. As far as Ibn Al Qayyim Rahimahullah is concerned then he has his view which we respect. When the hanafis quote Ibn Al Qayyim saying that its makrooh there women should be the first one to stop placing their hands on the chest. And remember that in hanafi fiqh, Makrooh means Makrooh tehreemi 'Second to haraam' and its a sin.
And not to forget that All 4 imaams have the view of placing their hands in the Sadr whether its on the chest as hanafi women do, below the chest or above the navel as all the remaining 3 have said. And the difference of opinion is obviously there and this shouldnt be made an issue at all. My video response is for the fanatics of this Ummah that split this ummah on such minor issues. i hope that answers the concern.
yes InshaAllah.It takes alot of study and time to make these responses. Th 6 points of salafis is really filled wth tons of lies just as the video "Who was Nasiruddin Albani?", i may just make a short video and leave the link to the detailed answers in the description. Lets see Insha Allah. The best way to answer those 6 points is to go and meet a salafi himself and check these 6 points :), truth will be clear by it self.
seriously brothers sisters i don't know what to believe anymore but i'm gettting sick of this topic place on chest or navel or below navel. Some say fake Hanafi but i say Salafi and Wahabism are the fake and the one's started this. And theres big scholars that place on navel. I think you should mind ur business and let the people pray and stop playing with people minds. As long they pray 5 times do there Sucud and Ruku properly and its up to Allah swt to decide and judge.
If you watched the video then you wouldnt have made such a comment. When did we say you cannot pray with your hands below the navel? Right in the very begining of the video and the description of the video i have mentioned that this matter is an issue in which scholars have differed and we should respect both as both are established. It is the Deobandi fake hanafis who initiated this Dirt of disunity on such issues and say NO NO only below navel is sunnah.
@LifewithAllah brother you have got ur facts wrong about Deobandis......we deobandis dont have any issue if any1 places his hand above the navel....we believe in the validity of all four school of thoughts. Deobandis fought the british empire. The deobandi madrassah was founded by the people who fought the bitish empire. Bother you have got ur facts wrong. The Barelvis and Ahle Hadith of India gave Fatwa in support of the british empire in India
Brother, we can see the facts and the deobandis so called acceptance of the four schools of thought and let me tell you, there were 5 schools of thought and not four. The Fourth was was the school of thought of the Sahaba and the other name for this was and is Ahlul hadeeth. And I will ignore your baseless allegations that the ahlul hadeeth supported the british empire and in response i'll give u proof that the Deobandis were the ones that were the production of british.
If the deobandis hadnt got any issues with such minor issues like Placing hands above or below navel then you should condemn the hanafi fiqh channel for its actions and for misrepresenting Deobandis. You dont need rocket science intellect to see that the differences of opinions doesnt go down their throat.
Watch this talk for proofs that deobandis are the production of britishers and served them, its in urdu:
And its wrong for you to blame us despite us having a neuteral approach to the matters of disagreement in which scholars have differed from the very begining. And ask the deobandis to mind their business and stop lying to people on matters of disagreement. Coz if they continue to lie then we will continue to respond. Its not a hanafi channel its a Deobandi Anti Ahlul hadeeth channel and we will respond to the lies propogated their whether people like or not. InshaAllah
Watched it full this time and i apologise for responding quick because honestly i got sick of this topic, but its even Zakir Naik student doing this to and other groups that follow sheik Albani to or think Abdul Wahab is a good person... Peace Esselam aleykum and thanks for the video May Allah swt blessyou.
lol, your evidence is based on where the qaris from makkah place their hands, well they pray 20 raka'ats tarawih too, so why dont u follow them on that???
My evidence were the Imams of the holiest places of Islam on earth is much stronger than a Person from a sect whcih is named After a Village of Hindustan.Your question is that in Makah they pray 20 so why dont we follow that? I wish go bck to the recordings of Makkah and check, you'll Never ever see just 1 Imaam leading 20 rakaah. The Imaams leads 10 rakaah, and then another comes and he leads the other 10, further more in the last 10 days the number goes upto 30
So Alhamdulillah the taraweeh are as much as one wants but the fulfilment of the Sunnah is 8+3 and thats why you have 2 imaams and each of them leads 10, 10 and then the witr. And in the last 10 days the numbers increase to 30 or 31 or 33.
for an irrefutable article of mine on taraweeh you can refer to:
youtube.com/watch?v=oEqCV_siG-M
Check the article in the description of that video.
So When did any of us say that hanafi women pray with their hands below the navel? :) We know they pray with their hands on the chest but according to Abdur raheem limbada its not sunnah so they shouldnt place their hands on the chest.
LifewithAllah, you have the best channel on youtube MashAllah. Its sad how much bidaah and kufr the ummat is involved in. In the defense of the deobandis the majority (99%) are not involved in wahd-at-ul-wujud or tawassul. I've noticed those with the right aeqedah such as ahl hadith only criticize and complain about the negatives instead of providing or implementing practical solutions. A simple question sums it all up; in our day jobs do our companies hire complainers or problem solvers?
you are right brother and these are the masoom people. I dont even call them deobandis though they may label them selves as one. And believe me... 99% of these people have been told that they are deobandis and hence they label them selves as deobandis. Even i was told 7 or 8 years back that i was a deobandi but Alhamdulillah i was a normal muslim and 99% of the public are normal muslims that can even die for Quran and Sunnah but unfortunately they are being mislead.
I have in my hand Vol2 of ibn Qudamah's al-Mughni (page 22)... "The narrations have differed where to place then hands... And then there's the saying/narration of Sa'eed ibn Jubayr and Shaf'i;"I saw the Prophet SAW praying, and he placed his hands on HIS CHEST"... It uses the word SADR... This man is misleading people by telling them that no imam said SADR, as al mughni is the biggest hanbali fiqh book...
I find it funny that I actually bought this book from some Debandi bros!
Akhi they are like that, they mislead the innocent brothers and sisters who dont have knowledge. And believe me.. the same innocent brothers and sisters can die for the Deen of islam and they want to live a life according to Quran and Sunnah.. but people like Abdur raheem limbada and alot of other deobandis hide knowledge from them and mislead them DELIBERATELY. And i say deliberately because of the practical experiences ive had with deoband. May Allah guide them and us all, ameen.
O brother...it seriously looks blatent that you are attacking the hanafi fiqh channel & its scholars...ur intemtions may be to tell the truth but u havent looked deeply into this
saeem7 1 week ago
@saeem7
subhaan Allah.. my response seems like an attack to u and what do u think about their lies and forgeries in the name of defending their sect? may i know ur point of view brother?
Its not a hanafi fiqh channel, its a deobandi fiqh or deobandi sect channel which attributes false stories to imam abu hanifa rahimahullah. Imam Abu Hanifa rahimahullah was free from what they attribute to him and they can hardly prove any thing from abu hanifa rahimahullah with correct chain of narration.
LifewithAllah 1 week ago
Imam Shafiee (ra) says that they should be placed above the navel but below the chest. Imam Nawawi (ra) discusses this in his commentary of Muslim saying, 'This is the better known ruling of our Madhab.' He also says in Sharh al Muhaddhab, 'He should place them below his chest and above his navel. This is the correct and clear ruling (of our school).'
TheAbdullah1430 1 week ago
@TheAbdullah1430
Jazak Allah khair brother.
LifewithAllah 1 week ago
MashaAllah. I like you brother for the sake of Allaah. Keep up with these videos of yours! Let the people see and know what the way of the salaf (the way of prophet muhammad pbuh, the rightly guided caliphs and their companions who follow them) is. May Allaah reward you greatly in this world and in the next for all your effort. Ameen, :)
TearsOfProphets 1 week ago
Your video description is very funny. U say that the Deobandi were founded by the British. Do U ever heard about the Reshmi Rumal Tehreek or the anything about the struggle by Haji Imdadullah, Shaykh Gangohi, Shaykh Nanotwi etc against the British? Besides, the followers of the 4 mazhabs dont consider each other to be wrong. But when they try to protect ppl from your foolish arguments, then u accuse them of causing disunity. Please use your brain before using your mouth.
sjn58 1 month ago
@sjn58
the biggest rejectors of the 4 imams are deobandis. Wait for my other videos and u will know. Rejectors of Sunnah, Opposers of Ahlul Haqq, opposers of Sahaba and opposers of Rasool Allah pbuh.. These are the things which Deobandis teach Deobandi audience but the audience dont realise the snake in the sleeve. Wait for my other videos and u will learn alot InshaAllah.
LifewithAllah 1 week ago
BROOOO HE DID SAY IN THE VIDEO THAT SHAFIS USED THAT PROOF OF TIENG ON THE CHEST BUT IT DIDNT WORK OUT FOR THEM OR SOMETHING LIKE THAT
PathToAllah 1 month ago in playlist Uploaded videos
@PathToAllah
brother he does not mention any where that Imam Shafee held the opinion of placing hands on the chest. He only makes mention of Shaf'ees using the hadeeth of placing the hands on chest at 7:45 only to deny it via presenting a referenece which only shows the other opinion of Shaf'ees.
LifewithAllah 1 month ago
u make no sense bro u act like there is only one answer to everything may Allah guide you and put some mercy and compassion in ur heart
Nzifa 1 month ago
@Nzifa
ive allowed ur comment just to let people see what sort of mind set you people have.
LifewithAllah 1 month ago
For teraweeh, again the majority clearly pray 20 - from the time of the Sahaabas, including the 4 Imaams and Saudi. I feel comfortable following the majority of the scholars on issues where there is Ijma. But I think it's best to respect every view, because at the end of the day we are all relying on scholars that we feel we can trust - unless of course we think we are qualified. As knowledge isn't just in books but passed on from generation to generation via the Ulema.
Salaams.
Leroi531 1 month ago in playlist Responses to Hanafi fiqh Channel Blind followers
@Leroi531
Brother if u read the article i sent you, surely it will help you increase your information on taraweeh because there is No ijma at all that Taraweeh is 20 Rakaah. Read the Article i sent and Insha Allah then if u comment it will be helpful for me and us all to discussion based on Proof. There is no Ijma on 20 rakaah at all. And yes it is best to respect evry view which is based on Quran and Sunnah. Alhamdulillah, may Allah unite us on Quran and Sunnah,Ameen.
LifewithAllah 1 month ago
@Leroi531
Firstly, it is not about following the majority, but about following what is Right.
Allah (swt) Says in the Quran:
"And if you obey most of those on the earth, they will mislead you far away from Allah's Path. They follow nothing but conjectures, and they do nothing but lie."
( سورة الأنعام , Al-Anaam, Chapter #6, Verse #116)
Secondly, the prophet (saw) ordered that the night prayer is to be read in two's. and ended with 01 Witr. So we can read as much as we like.
amorus1 1 week ago
@Leroi531
As for the prophet (saw) himself, he always prayed 08 rakahs in the night prayer. But that number was never "ordered" for everyone. However, reading 1 chapter of the Quran in 8 rakah gets to be difficult for a lot of people.
But we should never limit the number to 20. Like in Haram (Makkah), they pray 20 rakahs for 20 days, and in the last 10 days they pray 30 rakahs. And also note that one Imam only leads the people in 10 rakahs, and then the other imam leads in the remaining 10.
amorus1 1 week ago
the point I was trying to make was that the majority (4 Imams & Imams of Haram) don't have hand on their chest per se. Yes I know you mentioned that 'Sadr' can mean anything below the neck...but why do 'Ahle hadith' have it on the chest specifically?
Who was the scholar that actually preferred to have it on the chest specifically?
Plus if the Imams of Haramayn are 'Ahle hadith' then howcomw they pray 20 rakaat teraweeh when 8 is more closer to Sunnah? I thought the Imams of haram were Hambali?
Leroi531 1 month ago
@Leroi531
Very good questions mash Allah. Dear brother just as Sadr have 2 meanings, one is specifically Chest and Second the area beneath the throat right upto to the tummy..Similarly there are Ahlul hadith that place their hands specifially on their chest as well as any where above the navel and below the throat and the practical examples are the Imaams of haram and i also mentioned that i myself place it in Midchest area above the Navel and majority ahlul hadeeth that ive seen they do that.
LifewithAllah 1 month ago
@Leroi531
So when it is said to be Sadr then it means both either specifically chest or any where below the throat upto the tummy. It depends on what you choose. Second Question is Why Imams of haram pray 20 when 8 is the closer Sunnah... I will email u an article regarding taraweeh which i have written Alhamdulillah and for me its the best possible and unbiased article that any 1 has written over the internet and all ive done is collected scholarly works and put them in one article.
LifewithAllah 1 month ago
@Leroi531
In short, 8 + 3 is the minimum requirement for the sunnah to be fulfilled because it was the act of the prophet pbuh himself, but the prophet pbuh allowed as much as one can pray. Thats why the Imaams of kaaba not only pray 20 but also pray 30 Plus in the last 10 days of ramadhan. The intention is to extend the prayer and spend the night in prayer as much as possible in the last 10 days of ramadhan.
LifewithAllah 1 month ago
3ree type hath chest k nechay or navel say oper , hath chor k mean latka kar , or hath naaf k nechay band k,, but most attentic below chest and obove navel , ....but all type is right .... or hath latka kar b thek hai .. this is no issue ..all type is right..it is optional
Emran195 2 months ago
@konquest1453
Jazak Allah khair, remember me in ur duas.
LifewithAllah 2 months ago
@LifewithAllah
bhai aap nay aik farooi maslay par itni mehnat kar dali main nahi samajhta kay is ki eesi bhi koi zaroorat thi
aap agar yahi mehnat asooli muaamlaat maslan hakumat o khelafat wagheray kay baray main kartay to mujhay zayadah acha lagta
or main nay aap ki description bhi parhi hay aap aik taraf to kah rahay hoo kay ummat ko in chotay chotay masail nay disunite kar rakha hay
mera aap say question ye hay kay kia in farooi muamlat main ummat ka unit hona itna hi zaroori hay?
awaismalik80 2 months ago
@awaismalik80 aapka sawaal boht acha hai bhai, pehli baat tu yeh ki Usooli muamlaat, aqeeda etc per meri videos jald arahi hain insha Allah, specially on taqleed e shakhsi waghera. Jaha tak faroori muamlaat ka sawal hai tu bhai Mujhe koi farq nahi parhta agar koi naaf ke neechay ya uper haath baandhay lekin jab koi naam nihad Aalim apna masla saabit karne ke liye jhoot bolay aur bila wajah keechar uchhaalay tu mera nahi khayaal ki musalmaan ko chup rehna chahye..
LifewithAllah 2 months ago
@awaismalik80 Agar koi bhai apna moaqqaf paish kare aur bus wahi tak rehne de tu humain koi harj nahi.. lekin masla uss waqt kharab hota hai jab moo per jhoot bola jaye aur awaam ko bewaqoof banaya jaye. Na janay kitne bhai aisay hain jinho ne kaha hai hum tu yeh samajh rahe thay ki hum ghalat namaz parh rahe hain lekin meri videos dekh ker unki aankhain khul gayi, tu Alhamdulillah jo mei kar raha hoon woh Allah behtar janta hai ki kis liye kar raha hoon, Aur Allah qabool kare.
LifewithAllah 2 months ago
@LifewithAllah in this video there is an arabic vocals or natt plz tell me the name of its plz
waqasarain 2 months ago in playlist Uploaded videos
Salaam,
Erm....what was the main point of showing the Imams of the Haramayn? They had their hands BELOW the chest.
Also didn't Ibn Qayyum (RA) say it is Makrooh to put hands on the chest?
Leroi531 2 months ago
@Leroi531
Walykum Assalaam warahmatullah wabarakatuh, brother if u watch the video from begining to end, u will have the answers. The word 'Sadr' does not just mean chest but it means the area beneath the throat upto the tummy, so whether its below the chest or above the navel, it is the Sadr and we Ahlul hadeeth tie our hands in that region And Alhamdulillah the imaams of the kaaba and masjid nabwi are all ahlul hadeeth and the they do this practical perfectly daily 5 times a day.
LifewithAllah 2 months ago
@Leroi531
Second purpose was to show that the Imams of the 2 most holiest of places on earth place their hands on their Sadr. As far as Ibn Al Qayyim Rahimahullah is concerned then he has his view which we respect. When the hanafis quote Ibn Al Qayyim saying that its makrooh there women should be the first one to stop placing their hands on the chest. And remember that in hanafi fiqh, Makrooh means Makrooh tehreemi 'Second to haraam' and its a sin.
LifewithAllah 2 months ago
@Leroi531
And not to forget that All 4 imaams have the view of placing their hands in the Sadr whether its on the chest as hanafi women do, below the chest or above the navel as all the remaining 3 have said. And the difference of opinion is obviously there and this shouldnt be made an issue at all. My video response is for the fanatics of this Ummah that split this ummah on such minor issues. i hope that answers the concern.
LifewithAllah 2 months ago
Salaam,
Erm....what was the main point of showing the Imams of the Haramayn? They had their hands BELOW the chest.
Also didn't Ibn Qayyum (RA) say it is Makrooh to put hands on the chest?
Leroi531 2 months ago
@LifewithAllah, do you plan on responding to Abdur Raheem's lecture: "Six points of Salafis"?
itcrowdfan92 2 months ago
@itcrowdfan92
yes InshaAllah.It takes alot of study and time to make these responses. Th 6 points of salafis is really filled wth tons of lies just as the video "Who was Nasiruddin Albani?", i may just make a short video and leave the link to the detailed answers in the description. Lets see Insha Allah. The best way to answer those 6 points is to go and meet a salafi himself and check these 6 points :), truth will be clear by it self.
LifewithAllah 2 months ago
Jazakallaah Khair........ I also wanted to know about keeping hands in Nimaz but after watching this Im impressed..............
sanaullahjanwery 2 months ago
What an amazing refutation akhi keep up the good work May Allah Reward You .
choudry1231 2 months ago in playlist Uploaded videos
MASHALLAH MASHALLAH Love To Know This May ALLAH Give You Jaza-E-Khair I am subscribing ur channel loved it :)
Former Deobandi Brother
Pakistan
better901 2 months ago
seriously brothers sisters i don't know what to believe anymore but i'm gettting sick of this topic place on chest or navel or below navel. Some say fake Hanafi but i say Salafi and Wahabism are the fake and the one's started this. And theres big scholars that place on navel. I think you should mind ur business and let the people pray and stop playing with people minds. As long they pray 5 times do there Sucud and Ruku properly and its up to Allah swt to decide and judge.
ubsorry27 2 months ago
@ubsorry27
If you watched the video then you wouldnt have made such a comment. When did we say you cannot pray with your hands below the navel? Right in the very begining of the video and the description of the video i have mentioned that this matter is an issue in which scholars have differed and we should respect both as both are established. It is the Deobandi fake hanafis who initiated this Dirt of disunity on such issues and say NO NO only below navel is sunnah.
LifewithAllah 2 months ago
@LifewithAllah brother you have got ur facts wrong about Deobandis......we deobandis dont have any issue if any1 places his hand above the navel....we believe in the validity of all four school of thoughts. Deobandis fought the british empire. The deobandi madrassah was founded by the people who fought the bitish empire. Bother you have got ur facts wrong. The Barelvis and Ahle Hadith of India gave Fatwa in support of the british empire in India
khaanster 2 months ago
@khaanster
Brother, we can see the facts and the deobandis so called acceptance of the four schools of thought and let me tell you, there were 5 schools of thought and not four. The Fourth was was the school of thought of the Sahaba and the other name for this was and is Ahlul hadeeth. And I will ignore your baseless allegations that the ahlul hadeeth supported the british empire and in response i'll give u proof that the Deobandis were the ones that were the production of british.
LifewithAllah 2 months ago
@khaanster
If the deobandis hadnt got any issues with such minor issues like Placing hands above or below navel then you should condemn the hanafi fiqh channel for its actions and for misrepresenting Deobandis. You dont need rocket science intellect to see that the differences of opinions doesnt go down their throat.
Watch this talk for proofs that deobandis are the production of britishers and served them, its in urdu:
youtube.com/watch?v=2qvc1nhJqus&hd=1
I hope this helps.
LifewithAllah 2 months ago
@ubsorry27
And its wrong for you to blame us despite us having a neuteral approach to the matters of disagreement in which scholars have differed from the very begining. And ask the deobandis to mind their business and stop lying to people on matters of disagreement. Coz if they continue to lie then we will continue to respond. Its not a hanafi channel its a Deobandi Anti Ahlul hadeeth channel and we will respond to the lies propogated their whether people like or not. InshaAllah
LifewithAllah 2 months ago
@LifewithAllah
Watched it full this time and i apologise for responding quick because honestly i got sick of this topic, but its even Zakir Naik student doing this to and other groups that follow sheik Albani to or think Abdul Wahab is a good person... Peace Esselam aleykum and thanks for the video May Allah swt blessyou.
ubsorry27 2 months ago
@ubsorry27
No problem. And jazak Allah khair. :) really the ummah shouldnt be disuniting on such issues.
LifewithAllah 2 months ago
lol, your evidence is based on where the qaris from makkah place their hands, well they pray 20 raka'ats tarawih too, so why dont u follow them on that???
kareemabdullah 2 months ago in playlist Responses to Blind followers
@kareemabdullah
My evidence were the Imams of the holiest places of Islam on earth is much stronger than a Person from a sect whcih is named After a Village of Hindustan.Your question is that in Makah they pray 20 so why dont we follow that? I wish go bck to the recordings of Makkah and check, you'll Never ever see just 1 Imaam leading 20 rakaah. The Imaams leads 10 rakaah, and then another comes and he leads the other 10, further more in the last 10 days the number goes upto 30
LifewithAllah 2 months ago
@kareemabdullah
So Alhamdulillah the taraweeh are as much as one wants but the fulfilment of the Sunnah is 8+3 and thats why you have 2 imaams and each of them leads 10, 10 and then the witr. And in the last 10 days the numbers increase to 30 or 31 or 33.
for an irrefutable article of mine on taraweeh you can refer to:
youtube.com/watch?v=oEqCV_siG-M
Check the article in the description of that video.
LifewithAllah 2 months ago
actually,hanafi women pray with their hands on their chest
kareemabdullah 2 months ago in playlist Responses to Blind followers
@kareemabdullah
So When did any of us say that hanafi women pray with their hands below the navel? :) We know they pray with their hands on the chest but according to Abdur raheem limbada its not sunnah so they shouldnt place their hands on the chest.
LifewithAllah 2 months ago
LifewithAllah, you have the best channel on youtube MashAllah. Its sad how much bidaah and kufr the ummat is involved in. In the defense of the deobandis the majority (99%) are not involved in wahd-at-ul-wujud or tawassul. I've noticed those with the right aeqedah such as ahl hadith only criticize and complain about the negatives instead of providing or implementing practical solutions. A simple question sums it all up; in our day jobs do our companies hire complainers or problem solvers?
gkflyhigh 2 months ago
@gkflyhigh
you are right brother and these are the masoom people. I dont even call them deobandis though they may label them selves as one. And believe me... 99% of these people have been told that they are deobandis and hence they label them selves as deobandis. Even i was told 7 or 8 years back that i was a deobandi but Alhamdulillah i was a normal muslim and 99% of the public are normal muslims that can even die for Quran and Sunnah but unfortunately they are being mislead.
LifewithAllah 2 months ago
@gkflyhigh
And Jazak Allah khair for ur wonderful comment about my Channel. Just pray that Allah accepts these littlest of efforts.
LifewithAllah 2 months ago
8:14 What a joker!
I have in my hand Vol2 of ibn Qudamah's al-Mughni (page 22)... "The narrations have differed where to place then hands... And then there's the saying/narration of Sa'eed ibn Jubayr and Shaf'i;"I saw the Prophet SAW praying, and he placed his hands on HIS CHEST"... It uses the word SADR... This man is misleading people by telling them that no imam said SADR, as al mughni is the biggest hanbali fiqh book...
I find it funny that I actually bought this book from some Debandi bros!
Hamza120994 2 months ago
@Hamza120994
Akhi they are like that, they mislead the innocent brothers and sisters who dont have knowledge. And believe me.. the same innocent brothers and sisters can die for the Deen of islam and they want to live a life according to Quran and Sunnah.. but people like Abdur raheem limbada and alot of other deobandis hide knowledge from them and mislead them DELIBERATELY. And i say deliberately because of the practical experiences ive had with deoband. May Allah guide them and us all, ameen.
LifewithAllah 2 months ago
@LifewithAllah ameen
Hamza120994 2 months ago