Emile Autumn, Regina Spektor, Amanda Palmer are all different women with different stories to tell. The song they write are how they view the world and its past. Inspiration is what it has always been.
Palmer's voice is so rough deep, like a snotty old english woman or something. Regina sounds like a cute ditzy, easily distracted and playful littler girl. I've always wanted them to do a song together, becaues they sing so differently. And I mean a REAL duet, not that Uh-Merica song on youtube where Palmer sings like 4 notes for the whole song....
Regina and Amanda are two very different people with VERY different styles. Regina has this sweet, eloquent whisper to her music while Amanda is all about raw emotion and would rather a song move you then sound perfect. Both styles are fantastic but can't really be compared because they are so different. What's the point of a cover that just mimics the original?
If you actually knew more of amanda palmer, you would know that she's very different from emilie autumn. I love both of them and they are very different.
Was machst du, Regina? Die Alten, sie verstehen es nicht. Was denn, machst du, Regina? Die Falschen sind noch immer ???. Was machst, machst du, Regina? Die Kälte hat uns eingeschätzt (?). Was denn? Mach mal, Regina! Die ??? kommt, die Flut zerbricht (?)...
I'm pleasantly surprised by Amanda Palmer here. Her vocals tend to be more raw, but she really cleaned them up for this cover, reenforcing the fact that for her originals, she is making a conscious artistic choice, and is not merely limited in her vocal ability.
Great job Amanda. I wish there was a better quality audio for this.
When I first heard the original song by Regina, I immediately thought of Amanda and The Dresden Dolls. I'm new to Reginas music, but I think her voice suited this song more. Amandas version is still great though! They're both so great
did any one catch that first I what is this woman's vocal range. Anyhow I'm not sure she was singing the same poem but given I don't no Russian I wouldn't be able to tell if that's her accent anyway her version is very moving I Think that although the song came from Regina's mind it must of come at an odd moment because it's way darker than everything else I heard from her. The darkness of the song sutes this singer very well.
No, they weren't the same poem. The original was Boris Pasternak's Fevrale, or February. And this is something else, I think a personal note to Regina Spektor.
i feel weird how everyones criticizing her. you can still see the emotion through her singing, and she's not trying to beat regina or anything. it's more of a props.
She's certainly not Regina, but I kind of like her unique voice to this song. I think she makes it darker, and a little bit more her own. Of course, I still admire Regina's a bit more.
i really liked the piano but her voice just can't be matched to the equivalent of Regina's voice.Sorry Amanda, I'm just saying that her voice isn't right for the song but she does have a good voice
Amanda is a fantastic pianist, but I just don't like her voice. I won't say she's a bad singer because that's unfair to say, I just don't care for her voice. She has a very unique style though.
The last minute of the song... Is that a solo begining of Half Jack?
Well anyway i do like the cover a lot, she's always so passionnate that it makes me feel like crying. It's just amazing how she can make laugh and cry in the same show!
Emile Autumn, Regina Spektor, Amanda Palmer are all different women with different stories to tell. The song they write are how they view the world and its past. Inspiration is what it has always been.
zheldra1 4 days ago
Palmer's voice is so rough deep, like a snotty old english woman or something. Regina sounds like a cute ditzy, easily distracted and playful littler girl. I've always wanted them to do a song together, becaues they sing so differently. And I mean a REAL duet, not that Uh-Merica song on youtube where Palmer sings like 4 notes for the whole song....
ChuckHitler 3 months ago 4
the way she sings, i do become afraid of the lame and the old and the cold
akil3120 4 months ago
Regina and Amanda are two very different people with VERY different styles. Regina has this sweet, eloquent whisper to her music while Amanda is all about raw emotion and would rather a song move you then sound perfect. Both styles are fantastic but can't really be compared because they are so different. What's the point of a cover that just mimics the original?
DawnlessSkys 10 months ago 4
this made my day.
x0callisto0x 1 year ago
The German is:
What are you doing, Regina? (Was machst du, Regina?)
The old ones, they don't understand us. (Die Alten, sie verstehen uns nicht)
What are you doing, Regina? (Was denn machst du, Regina?)
The false ones are ever still right. (Die Falsche sind noch immer recht)
What are you doing, Regina?
The cold one has judged us. (Die Kalte hat uns eingeschätzt)
What does one do, Regina? (Was macht man, Regina?)
The Ice Age comes, the flood shattered. (Die Eiszeit kommt, die Flut zerbrach)
MrNotkewl 1 year ago 11
Can anybody translate the german part?
SaveYoshi 1 year ago
Two of my favorite artists!
SaveYoshi 1 year ago
she has a nice voice but she isn't suited for this song. This song is very gentle compare to her hardcore cover
Madinkin 1 year ago
What the fuck? She sings like she's on crack or something.
bonocox1 1 year ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
she like a emilie autumn wunnabe
funnyfacerful 1 year ago
@funnyfacerful
If you actually knew more of amanda palmer, you would know that she's very different from emilie autumn. I love both of them and they are very different.
Naessly 1 year ago
@funnyfacerful Emilie Autumn wishes she could be Amanda Palmer..
artnerd18 1 year ago
@funnyfacerful I don't get what you're saying when Amanda has been around since 1989 whereas Emilie has been performing since 2000.
anonymiss666 1 year ago
Was machst du, Regina? Die Alten, sie verstehen es nicht. Was denn, machst du, Regina? Die Falschen sind noch immer ???. Was machst, machst du, Regina? Die Kälte hat uns eingeschätzt (?). Was denn? Mach mal, Regina! Die ??? kommt, die Flut zerbricht (?)...
xEveMoon 1 year ago
Instead of Russian part she sings something in German, something about art of Regina :)
kknev 1 year ago
She is emotional and she replaced Russian part with German.
iitarasova 1 year ago
I'm pleasantly surprised by Amanda Palmer here. Her vocals tend to be more raw, but she really cleaned them up for this cover, reenforcing the fact that for her originals, she is making a conscious artistic choice, and is not merely limited in her vocal ability.
Great job Amanda. I wish there was a better quality audio for this.
rockerdancsi 1 year ago 3
both amanda and regina give it a special "something" to it. i love it.
neyann 1 year ago
I have to say, this is probably the best attempt at a Regina Spektor cover. I like it.
PanicInMyCloset 2 years ago
is that the chick with the hairy pits in that music video ???
soulfoodmonkey 2 years ago
no way, both my total FAVOURITE female musicians, i nearly jizzed when i saw this!
IFUCKINLOVETEA 2 years ago 34
@IFUCKINLOVETEA CAN I GET A AMEN ! HELL YEAH ! I DID TOO !
OnexSilentxTear 11 months ago
oh man this is the first i've heard from this lady and i'm noooot feeling it ):
leave it to regina!
ADreamAsLovely 2 years ago 3
Listen to her solo material, or The Dresden Dolls.
EffinPiss 2 years ago
@ADreamAsLovely Don't give up on Amanda. She's fucking amazing. Look up some of her original songs :)
HaysoosLovesYou 2 years ago
Hmmm I think Regina does it better live :/ still an amazing song though...
jharsika 2 years ago 3
I love her power in this. Regina and Amanda are both wonderful musicians~
MaliceMizerMuffins 2 years ago 4
This has been flagged as spam show
less lingerie, more original talent please!
ryko26 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
What exactly would be the point of doing a cover of this? SO VERY MUCH LESS IMPRESSIVE than the original!
Like listening to a heifer, absolute butchering this song.
1 star!
ryko26 2 years ago
i love how i find Amanda Palmer... [love her to death] covers another artist [Regina spektor] that i love to death :D
MissCullenxx 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
this fucking sucks its not regina
spitballz 2 years ago
No shit. It's Amanda Fucking Palmer.
What'd you expect when you clicked "AMANDA PALMER- APRES MOI"?
MaliceMizerMuffins 2 years ago
i'm stating that it's not regina so therefore it isn't good
chill the fuck out
spitballz 2 years ago
i like how amanda plays the piano D:
but this song doesn't fit to her :)
feliponsh 2 years ago
I agree with singingcarrots she is flat. Regina is much much better!
valinda76 2 years ago 3
Nobody gives a fuck.
EffinPiss 2 years ago
Obviously you do since you HAD to post it
valinda76 2 years ago
You got me, feel better?
EffinPiss 2 years ago
this cover is an insult to the song. she's extremely flat, and she's not half the pianist regina is.
singingcarrots 2 years ago 3
what did she says in the Russian parts, it's not the original isn't it?
simsplumbob 2 years ago
yes, absolutely no russian words)
at least, i can't understand it but I'm Russian ;)
A424R 2 years ago
Amanda Speaks German I'm pretty sure ;)
lachie777 2 years ago
hahaha, thats quite funny, good, interesting
brusegab 2 years ago
amandas cover is cool.. but i like reginas version better russian part just gives me goosebumps...
atatski1 2 years ago 3
it's so cool to see two vocalists with such different styles play this song, which is amazing.
Clairamel1 2 years ago 2
Haha this is so cool! I mean, this song doesn't really suit Amanda raw voice.. but it's nice anyway.. Amanda is cool (-:
0neTrickPony 2 years ago
When I first heard the original song by Regina, I immediately thought of Amanda and The Dresden Dolls. I'm new to Reginas music, but I think her voice suited this song more. Amandas version is still great though! They're both so great
Zenlutra 2 years ago 3
Very, very stoked on Amanda's Regina covers. They're awesome.
Vanuch 2 years ago 3
i think she says something about regina spektor in german?
aethlewine 2 years ago
the only part I caught clearly was the 'was machst du Regina?'. It's pretty much 'What do you do, Regina?'
littleblackduress 2 years ago
did any one catch that first I what is this woman's vocal range. Anyhow I'm not sure she was singing the same poem but given I don't no Russian I wouldn't be able to tell if that's her accent anyway her version is very moving I Think that although the song came from Regina's mind it must of come at an odd moment because it's way darker than everything else I heard from her. The darkness of the song sutes this singer very well.
rath60 2 years ago
No, they weren't the same poem. The original was Boris Pasternak's Fevrale, or February. And this is something else, I think a personal note to Regina Spektor.
Garten260 2 years ago
Was machst du, Regina? ;)
kandelila 2 years ago
it's awesome that Amanda Palmer covered Regina Spektor
i love both of them so much<3
but no one can sing a Regina with the same effect
christineasphyxiate 2 years ago 5
I love amanda and the dresden dolls, but Regina did it way better.
immyfan25 2 years ago 2
...and i just came...
tabiberkey 2 years ago
one of the best singers in the world covering the other. oh. my. GOD!!!!! im going to explode!!!!!
ifshitisbliss 2 years ago 3
I was just about to say that! xD
PinkBanana2u 2 years ago
Ho-ly. Shit.
Okay so Amanda Palmer was my first girlfriend and then Regina Spektor.
So this video is just orgasmic for me.
My hands have all kinds of bite marks.
:D
Henshitsusha 2 years ago
I loved it
Febrais 2 years ago
is the "russian part" in this cover even russian? it kind of sounds like german...
BloodBound093 3 years ago 2
definitely not the same thing as regina's version (i.e. Pasternak's poem)
merdufer 2 years ago
I love regina and amanda palmer, this makes me so happy =3
Muzikafreak92 3 years ago 6
Yeah. She shouldn't have sung that.
Valvakvlam 3 years ago
People can try to cover Regina Spektor, but it will never be the same standard or better.
Photographlife 3 years ago
her voice really doesn't flow with this song. its almost dark and weird. idk how to explain
tallchick16 3 years ago 2
Amanda Palmer covering Regina Spector (this must be what heaven sounds like). I love Amanda Palmer's approach to the song.
theRealCrazyOne 3 years ago 3
*agrees*
waaikiej 3 years ago 4
i feel weird how everyones criticizing her. you can still see the emotion through her singing, and she's not trying to beat regina or anything. it's more of a props.
celerycoloredcarrots 3 years ago 23
This comment has received too many negative votes show
I hate her voice...
myashess 3 years ago
ouch.. the sound quality of the video Dx
neat performance though :3
MrFairygodmother 3 years ago 2
Crazy! Amazing!
MrFairygodmother 3 years ago
She's certainly not Regina, but I kind of like her unique voice to this song. I think she makes it darker, and a little bit more her own. Of course, I still admire Regina's a bit more.
turokdarkstar 3 years ago 3
i really liked the piano but her voice just can't be matched to the equivalent of Regina's voice.Sorry Amanda, I'm just saying that her voice isn't right for the song but she does have a good voice
vegangirlx1 3 years ago
I agree...
I also don't think she has the technique that Regina has, as far as the piano playing. I like her, but she Regina are just... different. :]
almostspotless53 3 years ago 3
thank you for agreeing with me :)
vegangirlx1 3 years ago
Amanda is a fantastic pianist, but I just don't like her voice. I won't say she's a bad singer because that's unfair to say, I just don't care for her voice. She has a very unique style though.
ScarletsBeautifulLie 3 years ago
The last minute of the song... Is that a solo begining of Half Jack?
Well anyway i do like the cover a lot, she's always so passionnate that it makes me feel like crying. It's just amazing how she can make laugh and cry in the same show!
yuritogoth 3 years ago 2
very very very cool.
bigpuffyjunebug 3 years ago
this is the english translation, as far as i did understand the german part she sings:
what are you doing, regina? the old souls don't understand
what are you doing, regina? the disposers still are right-wing
what are you doing, regina? the cold has surrounded us
what are you doing, regina? the ice age nears, the flood will burst
SgtAndrewLueck 3 years ago 2
What does she say in german?
PinkBanana2u 2 years ago
ahh i saw her last yr and huged her hehe woot love u amandaaaaaaaa
krakmunky666 3 years ago
Holy f****** s***.
This is the most amazing thing I have ever seen in my entire life, ever.
GlindasBubble 3 years ago 2
Good girl
bumbeez 3 years ago
someone translate that..cuz its awesome
its obviousely a praise to regina cuz i hear the german equivalent of "regina....you are the sh*t" ha
amanda's awesome.
regina's awesomer.
jenny lewis is awesomest(!?) but thats another story.
the end.
ExecutionOfAllThings 3 years ago
Dude.. yes.. I agree. Those three ladies are amazing. I've met Jenny, now I just have to meet the other two, and my life will be complete.
Oh wait, and Zooey Deschanel. :) <3
Eubulondus 3 years ago
it's not russian; it's german... but i can't decipher it
vivling99 3 years ago
Nice cover. What is she singing instead of the Russian part Regina usually sings?
cfitz387 3 years ago
That's what I was wondering - hopefully someone speaks Russian and can translate.
flickeringwasteland 3 years ago
it's really german, she sings something with "die flut" -> "the flood", but it's hard to understand everything :/
i belive it's just a translation from the russian part to german. amanda speaks german, regina speaks russian- makes sense, doesn't it?
MissTeenSouthSeyde 3 years ago
@flickeringwasteland I speak fluent Russian..
WTF IS SHE DOING? O_O
STOPtheHORROR 1 year ago
@STOPtheHORROR
She's singing in German!!
3Annika7 1 year ago
@3Annika7 No shit sherlock?
STOPtheHORROR 1 year ago
@STOPtheHORROR
No shit. I'm german.
3Annika7 1 year ago
@3Annika7 And?
STOPtheHORROR 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@flickeringwasteland Using the powers of GCSE German:
What are you doing, Regina? The old souls don't understand
What are you doing, Regina? The disposers are still right-wing (not sure about this one)
What are you doing, Regina? The cold has surrounded us
What are you doing, Regina? The ice age nears, the flood will burst
doswillrule 1 year ago
@flickeringwasteland Google is your best friend
Ashabarala 1 year ago
@flickeringwasteland
Read the comments below, insted of the usual russian part, she sings in German
Sokaanon 1 year ago
@flickeringwasteland it's german
artpjf 1 year ago
@flickeringwasteland she replaces the russian part with german
artpjf 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@flickeringwasteland she replaces the russian part with german
artpjf 1 year ago
it's german, not russian... i can't decipher it totally.
vivling99 3 years ago
Fevrale dostat chernil i plakat,
Pisat O Fevrale navsnryd,
Poka grohochushaya slyakot
Vesnoyu charnoyu gorit.
Here's the rough English translation:
February. Get ink, shed tears.
Write of it, sob your heart out, sing,
While torrential slush that roars
Burns in the blackness of the spring.
edgarg310 3 years ago
well that was regina's version. i didn't realize she was singing something different. wasn't all the way through watching =p
edgarg310 3 years ago
Wicked! I recorded this too but my focud was off and I was peaking through heads ... glad you nabbed this.
dislodge 3 years ago
freakin' awesome <333
Sarix35 3 years ago
Now that's an awesome cover done by an amazing artist!
bongomar 3 years ago