Added: 5 years ago
From: lovemyhayley
Views: 606,913
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:
see all

All Comments (859)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • Its a shame that the percussion is so bad. Katherine done an amazing performance and some drummer ruined it! Surly Katherine can get any drummer she wanted!

  • The percussion doesn't fit the song at all.

  • Its funny when people hear some pretty blond sing, big blown up tits, tacky dress that has her pouring out, and a few pretty notes that we have found the new Messiah of the music world. They may as well put Susan Boyle on FOX's The Swan TV show and give her a make-over and open for Brittney Spears! I would still pay to see Britney Spears anytime over this plasti-polluted blond BIMBO! She SUCKS!

  • I like this, but it might be better if she sang it in a higher key? Because she has a low key here and her voice is so naturally ferocious here the high notes dont sound as high. Just giving my opinion, because as i am an opera singer and my voice is extremely low like hers is ive learnt this from singing it but i like this version all the same x

  • The percussion is indeed peculiar. It's like someone was playing mp3's in the backstage. Completely out of place.

  • For an absolutely fabulous performance by Katherine Jenkins, check out YouTube "Katherine Jenkins Quello Che Faro" (Everything I Do - in Italian)

    The song fits her voice and style perfectly and the production is beautiful.

    One of the most MAGNIFICENT videos on YouTube IMHO

  • i love her voice but nothing like celine dion.. she is amazing!

  • Ok... Not Better then Celine. I'm mean Great. But her voice is huskey in the low end. She's singing with an operatic empasis. This woman has a great voice, but she needs to stop doing it "right" and just bust out. Sing like the Devil is on her heels and that voice is the only thing keeping him back!!! That's not what I'm hearing

  • Different from Celene's. Celene's is Etherial and Idealistic. This lady is LOVE.

  • I sang this for choir, and we got first place in our competition. I still remember all the words. She sings it better than celene (I don't know how to spell her name) though

  • Comment removed

  • @misscaz95 Sorry a find Kathrines track a hell of  lot better than celine or is it just me

  • EL TEMA ES PRECIOSO , SIN DUDA, LA VOZ DE LA INTERPRETE MUY BELLA, FELICIDADES POR ESTE TEMA Y POR LA INTERPRETACION QUE LE DA VIDA AL TEMA.

  • @BlackLionFilms i agree with you

  • wow.... this actualy sounds realy good!

  • KATHERINE JENKINS! Simply beautiful voice! No need to compare her to anyone!

    Her voice is simply georgeous!!

  • @misscaz95 I agree - this is not a competition, cuz Celine would win, hands down. Firstly, I Love Kat, but she is not an opera singer. Secondly, I am not a Celine Dion fan, but I must say no one does this song better than she, not even La Brightman, whom I absolutely love. Celine infuses an emotion, which no one else replicates, into this song. Everyone else just sings it. Thirdly, the drummer should be shot. Every singer has their bad moments. This was another one of La Jenkins'.

  • @amusedbygod The theme music throughout Titanic was sung by Sissel, the beautiful Norwegian singer. Check her website!

  • @nicoalphalpha I know that.

  • I won't comment on the music, but she sure is a lovely lady.

  • what an amazing woman!!!

  • i love you katherine

  • hooorrible arrangement...for such an amazing singer and the biggest song ever...such a shame

  • @filigrant I agree with you there

  • which year ?!

  • shes gorgeos women

  • REMMBER I LOVE YOU KATHERINE!!!!!!!!!!!

  • SING MY SWEET ANGEL , THE HEAVENS ARE LISTENING TO YOU !!!!!!!

  • I don't like any one that are able to find bad things about her ......

  • @54321thebeatles What? The fact that she sucks! I only came on this page because someone questioned my comment when I heard it the first time. Before that I had never heard of her and to be honest I wouldn't care to. Her of tone quality is false, she is as empty in the head as she is in the heart, and just plain aweful. You are easlity deceived of good classical singing is and obviously fooled by her bubblegum crap. Expand your horizons a little will you! Renee Flemming maybe?

  • i feel the spirit of god go thru me

  • Beautiful voice...percussion sucks. Really uncalled for.

  • @MissRandi101 The percussion is just fine, how about that voice? She SUCKS!!!!!!!!!!

  • @MOZ1175 Is that sarcasm? lol. The percussion is terrible and does not suit the classical style. Katherine's voice is amazing.

  • @mjhart123 No its not, and of you think it is I am very sorry. Try listening to Renee Flemming performing You'll Never Walk Alone if you want a great singer doing something a little on the cheesy side. Katherine may be a nice person (I have no clue who she is actually now do I wish to) but she sings like a complete airhead with a nice instrument. Like Sarah Brightman, (what a complete let down) Katherine hasn't a clue how to use it to its fullest potential. Not even close.

  • @MOZ1175 I don't like Sarah at all, her voice is terrible. Katherine is much better. Katherine is a Classical Pop star and she is a lot better than the credit you give her. I have seen her live, and if you was to see her live I am sure you would be impressed. She is 30 now which is the best age for the voice, she has improved greatly since this performance and has a truly amazing voice. I think you need to know her a bit better to make comments like that.

  • NOT GOOD SORRY..SHE IS BEAUTIFUL AND AGREAT OPERA SINGER SHE SHOULD STICK WITH THAT..CELINE IS MUCH BETTER

  • CELINE DION always !!!

  • I did not know women could sing such low notes....

  • I agree with most all of the comments, the percussion is just this side of abominable, really embarrassing for a professional arrangement of music. Still a great song though, it reminds me of watching Leonardo DiCaprio drown!

  • I love her Music of the Night rendition. Without a doubt her voice is God-given and i just wonder what it must be like to wake up one day and realize that you can sing like that?

  • @jennyp0101 You're not born with it, it's goddamn hard work to get there ;)

  • angelic

  • Oh my...those percussions.. so awful arrangement! It ruins everything, such a pity.

  • Classic music was reborn by Katherine

  • Im a drummer, but in this song drums arent required, in fact, they ruin it:s

  • YOU ALL MUST SEE MY ACCOUNT

  • percussion ruined all this!!!!

  • @MargaretSwann No one could put it better. Right you are!

  • I Love The Way she sings. Someday I wish That I may Sing like her.

  • I'd love to smash her back doors in!

  • I am going to be controversial here and say that Katherine should have been chosen to sing this song for the soundtrack of the movie! That's how much I love her voice!

  • @misscaz95 To be fair, most of Celine's biggest hits were cover songs. Not only that, but Celine also never wrote anything herself either. She's got great songwriters writing things for her. That is the way it works for most female singers whose main strength lies in their voices. I love Celine's voice, but if anything, James Horner was inspired by the Norwegian soprano Sissel when he wrote the soundtrack to Titanic, but in the end she wasn't "pop" enough to make the song a radio hit.

  • На фоне всего услышанного понимаешь что лучше Сары  Брайтман пока что никого нет:)

  • click my name for katherine jenkings dcoctor who christmas special download link also availible

  • I love Katherine, love Celine Dion, love Brittany Mruczek, love Lisa Kelly, Méav Ní Mhaolchatha and Orla Fallon. I also love Chloe Agnew, Melanie Safka, Judy Collins and Jewel. I love that band called the Corrs and I have to say I love Annie Haslam, Keri Leigh, Karen Matheson, Ola Szomańska, Sarah McLachlan and a talented young lady I met just a couple of weeks ago, Ashley Nicole Monical. I love the female voice and the variety they bring. I do not compare them as each is wonderfully unique.

  • very gooooooooooood so much better than the Original

  • @MrMoePacino

    Not even close to the original ... she's singing with zero emotion lX_x!

    She's not feeling it at all.

  • the drums ruin this. whoever's idea that was was awful.

    i <3 Katherine Jenkins

  • Get over the BS and jealosy.....she is a beautiful woman and has an amazing voice. She doesn't have to compete with anyone but herself. Her voice is so pure and her beauty is

    actually stunning. She also has a strong belief in God and family which even makes me respect her more...and more. The world should be so lucky to have someone like this on our lives.

  • All of you who believe Katherine's going flat, she's not. She's just got MUCH better vowels than Celine Dion, therefore her tone is warmer. It's still in tune.

    I honestly don't like how bright Dion's voice is anyway, so to me, this is a kind adjustment.

    Loooove from America, Katherine.

  • I think celine is much better, can't compare. But i like this cover/version too. This girl is so good, cantora lírica (portuguese), but celine dion's voice, normal singer, cantora do diafragma, is better!

  • this is well cheesy lol. I like wen she sings high voice instead

  • Inappropriate use of vibrato - use for emphasis - not on every note. This is a pop song, nothing else. Is that the drummer Donna Summer used for disco in the 70s?

  • @jamiemh76 She's an opera singer. Vibrato is usually used constantly in opera; she's just trying to adapt her own voice to the song.

  • They should make reality show "Opera Star to Popstar" for opera singers who think they are are good at pop. Long live Celine. God help Charlotte Church

  • music sounds a little happy for what shes singing but it does help to seperate it from the original (personally i prefer jenkins) still good singing.

    "stand your ground, that others may see you and be encouraged to stand also"

  • well i actually like this... Im a HUGE sarah brightman fan, and i prefer KJ than other stupid singers that really don't know how to sing ANYTHING.

  • No dead people are just that, dead people. Memories may live forever but people die, just like every other living thing. You can't live unless you can die.

  • If you are blind and deaf you cannot appreciate Katherine Jenkins, I myself say that she is the perfect female in every way.

    Her looks charm the eyes , her voice fills the ears, and the way she combines the two captivates the soul . Thank you Katherine for your gift .

  • when you are an opera singer, you must sing in all of these languages...so what Katherine does here, singing in three different languages at the same concert it's not unusual for her or for any other opera singers. Sometimes, you must sing today a whole role in russian, tomorrow in italian, germain, french, romanian...and even if you don't know these languages at the perfection, you must study very hard to know by heart all of these languages and of course to know word by word the translation..

  • iN ONE CONCERT SHE SINGS IN iTALIAN, welsh, and English. Think about it. 

  • Although, I am not an Opera fan, I would pay to listen to Katherine Jenkins

  • Beautiful Katherine sings as beautiful as she is. 

  • hyeavan must be heartbroken that one of the most beautiful angles is missing .

    She is stunningly beautiful and her voice is absolutely perfect . She could sing the phone book and shopping list and be stunning and sound absolutely stunning. .

  • I'd like to know who all those who claim Jenkins is not a good singer do consider talented artists...

  • the notes she hits aren't nice :/ they seem out of key and flat... :/ still a good singer though 

  • @pdawwwg96 She is actually staying on pitch very well, considering this is a live performance. She does go flat on a couple of her sustains, probably as a result of running out of air.

  • If she didn't have bimbo looks, she'd never get a look in. This is dreadful.

  • @countbobby01 Bimbo? Huh? Blonde she may be, bimbo she is not. She's very attractive - not quite in a Barbie doll way, but more "doll-like" than you'd expect? - with a voice to match, is clearly classically trained and while her singing may not be up to everyone's taste, she is interpreting the song with the technique of an opera singer. I guess having said that, it is difficult to listen to this after having heard Celine's version so many times (and she is the queen of this song after all!)

  • She's not a bad singer, far from it but her voice lacks emotion.

  • This is nice, but as everybody knows Celine OWNS this song!

  • wow. beautiful and wonderful voice.

  • I like her a ton but I have to agree with some people her style (Mezzosoprano opera) of singing does not really match the solid emotional power of the song.

  • love her voice

    but the drumming in this version is horrible!!!!

    

  • If you like Celine , fine I myself would rather listen to Katherine .She has a beautiful voice and a beautiful everything else .

  • If you like Celine , fine I personnly would rather listen to Katherine .She has a beautiful voice and a beautiful everything else .

  • Yeah, i dont like this either, shes missing emotion in the song. and i hate where they pick the tempo up as well. bad version. and she is putting too much into it.

  • @blakenesbit1995 I thought the same. She always put too much into simple songs..it's frustrating!

  • wow haha opera

  • Great vocal perform, bad version. I miss something in this song.

  • Definitely do not like the arrangement at all!!! Don't have a clue what james horner, magnificent composer/arranger!!!, was thinking when he did this, except maybe it's got to be "hollywood", but I agree, doesn't come off! Not appealilng in the least. But, one cannot fault her voice It's magnificent!!! I wonder with Celine's arrangement & Katherine's voice, if Katherine sung it first what we would think. I would still HAVE to go w/ Celine. Seems to put more of her soul into the entire piece.

  • No Offence, her voice is manly, and this version is an insult to the real version. and NOTE I don't want replies like "Man you suck, she's awesome, Get a music taste and blah blah blah" because I really am not talking to you folks. I am just sharing my feelings. Kay thanks. =)

  • Drum need to be included... It's better. You'll never beat celine. I'm Celine's big fan!! I sort of like it. Not that much.

  • @celinevote1 Who says she's competing with Dion?

  • DRUMS?????????????? LOL! WTF?!?!?!?!?!

  • God..without a doubt that is the most gorgeous singer ever...and with an angels voice

  • WTF..Drums? :|

  • the drumming flounces any orchestral flow -_-

  • man the drumbeat in this rendition is annoying, shes not too bad, you cant beat Celine though

  • semplicemente stupendaaaa!!....bellissimo anche questo arrangiamentooooo!!

  • goosepumps :-o

    she's amazing !

  • Just because she doesn't huff & Puff & warble like Celine Dion, does not make her a bad singer.

    Saw Celine in Vegas & the singing was OK but all the banal chatter to amuse the mainly American audience was infuriating. Katherine Jenkins however was absolutely superb in concert.

  • omg she can sing other songs better but this? NO ONE CAN COUVER THIS SONG!

  • i want see sarah brightman sing this...

  • @alexaadap she has, it's called "Il Mio Cuore Va", it's the same song but with the lyrics translated to Italian.

  • she doesn't have the voice for this song. Celine Dion is a lot better then she is.

  • @Akikofuma

    Ok first off Katherine Jenkins can sing anything! secondly she would make 10 of celeion Dion in a singing competition so gather facs before you say that mybe that's you'r oppinion but really!

  • @Akikofuma you'r talking fuckin bullshit

  • @MrFrankcharles19991

    oh very intellegent. If you disagree, then just say so, or at least give a reason why you think I'm wrong. Throwing around with insults isn't very mature or smart. So you don't bother me at all. I like her. I just like Celine Dion more when she sings this song.

    Don't like it? Then be fair and say you disagree or shut your mouth. If you don't have anything smart to say, then don't say anything at all. How old are you, 14?

  • ich finde das es keiner sogut kann wie Celine Dion ! sry

  • she is an amazing singer. The power of her voice and range can't compare with Celine Dion. She's a trained opera singer.

    Two different genres. I prefer Celine's version however!

  • wow.speechless

  • She is cute =)

  • guys....if she copies celine or other singers everyone says...she's nothing....she's only coping other musicans....but if she covers songs and sings them in a new version everyone compares her with the real singer....!!! she's a great singer with a great voice and she makes her things!

  • @19ladys94 Absolutly , well said

  • yeah the original song is much better than this. but she has a great voice

  • OMG great......

  • takes alot of guts to cover a Celine Dion for a celebrity this could of killed her career lol the drums are terrible! in this lol. i expected better really

  • Erm, love the song and love the singer but this combo just plain out doesn't work

  • no song needs this much vibrato!

    but she has a good range

    but, personally her voice is a little too nasily for my liking

  • such a lovely tribute this song means a lot to me, its lovely Katherine my grandma would have loved thsi is she were alive

  • God God this is dreadful

  • i agree with some of the people on here..katherine has a beautiful voice for an opera singer.this song shouldn't be sung as an opera kind of way..i know she can change her style of singing but at least change the rhythm to pop..

  • @chauhpham God forbid!!

  • why does she keep taking other peoples songs!!!!

  • @Miss907Princess Because she's a recitalist. She rearranges other people's songs and sings her own rendition of it. People like her voice anyway, so it doesn't matter if she does or doesn't.

  • @Miss907Princess Maybe because she has not got musical composition skills, or maybe because she enjoys singing them, and its hardly taking them as she need to ask the composer and celine to cover this !

  • hermosa me encanta es presiosa su vos y todo

  • This lady could sign names from the phone book and the music would still be awesome! OMG.

  • Celine es mejor lejos, y la bateria la caga mal...

  • okay i would like to see you people sing an opera in front of thousands of people. Yes, I know the song's not an opera but Katherine sings in opera, that's her voice. You have no idea how many times i get the "the songs she sings isn't opera." Well she sings opera and turns classics into opera. Guess the twenty first century isn't ready for her gift. Fuckin morons.

  • @omgthazjulie Yes she can turn pop songs into operatic arias ,and then the next song is an absolute new version of some pop song .I agree Katherine is amazing .

    I do not know if it is Katherines good looks that annoy some people .

    Some times they are truly horrid about her.

  • wow! i just performed this song today at my music school's recital! i hoped katherine had a cover of this song that i could study but didn't find it until today! Her voice is awesome on this! i'd love to sing this with her one day!

  • this woman just takes the piss, she sings looks gorgeous and is intelligent, if she was also from alabama i would just have to shoot mesel! but i don't think her opera voice suites this song

  • oh! i love her!

    ;*****

  • Not her best perfomance.

  • hmm i think she should lose the drum beat :/

  • @xoxbethersxox yea the drums arent good for this :(

  • Comment removed

  • @saritsiribud you dont know what the heck you are talking about

  • @saritsiribud i agree with you .. celine dion rocked this song .

  • @saritsiribud

    I agree 100 %, this version has no emotions what so ever :(

  • @saritsiribud

    Celine Dion suck

  • @verbod I don't think any artists suck, I think they all have their own gifts and talents. All I tried to say was that I prefer Dion more in this song. Katherine is a good and talented singer, I love her as well, I listen to her songs and I buy her CDs.

  • this is a GOOD operatic rendition of this song:

    watch?v=WiRs_j7NDy8

    Katherine ruins it.

  • My intention is not to bother anyone, or even hurt anyone, but  honestly, when I listen her voice, it looks like Im listening a travesty singing.

  • 7 points...i don`t like it very much...

  • wwhy is this song coveed so much. it is a great song but celine is the artist and EVERY1 knows it. if an artist truly feels they want to interpret the song thats 1 thing but I think alot of people do it 2 comptte with celine.

  • the music is beatiful and so is the singer !! absolutely fantasic to listen to !!!!! bravooooooooo

  • o now. my ears. it's not good!!!

  • das original ist besser. obwohl katherine ne echt hammer stimme hat. aber an das original kommt niemand stimmlich ran..

  • hier hat sie keine besonders schöne stimme, klingt wie eine meckernde ziege :S

  • @pumapaule allerdings. grausig. weg damit.

  • the song is 4:16 sec but she sings very fast its 20 seconds less

  • she is the best singer ever <3

  • I've started to discover Katherine Jenkins, her version is very good though not as fantastic as Celine's. Dion owned the song. I also liked Sarah Brightman's version.

  • she has better covers! but not bad, in my opinion. but it's bit too fast and.. dunno, not this emotions like in Titanic, like from Celine Dion.

  • katherine opened harrods winter sale, even though she knows they still sell fur from tortured animals, LEONA LEWIS refused to open harrods because of this, she has morals unlike katherine who just took the money, look at 'CAFT' website to see katherine at harrods turning her back on anti fur supporters and the innocent animals, she has no back bone, LEONA LEWIS has real heart, she is a real star, katherine is a fake

  • @eastlondongeeezeeer "EastLondonGeezer" cries about animal fur. Haha. Wonder how all the other East London geezers would feel about that.

  • Ich bin echt die letzte die etwas gegen klassik sagt ... aber das was sie da singt hört sich echt grauenhaft an ... es hört sich so gedrückt an ... und nicht frei .. das ist echt schrecklich ... es gibt opernsänger die das wesentlich besser können

  • jap sie hätte etwas mehr gefühl mit einbringen können

    aber trotzdem is es wunderschön

  • i love you Katherine. would DIE for you

  • @tatman661 schwätz kein scheis huso

  • booooow the drums are bad -.-

  • Fehlt wirklich ein wenig die Emotion bei diesem Auftritt...das kann sie besser

  • Leute, man muss ja auch mal offen für neues sein! ;) Die Klassik ist stark im kommen (Gott sei Dank!!!!) Trotzdem finde ich auch, dass sie es noch etwas gefühlvoller hätte singen können und dass sie leider keine besonders lange Luft hat...

  • Comment removed

  • @Musicology4you Du hast offenbar keine ahnung von musik

  • Comment removed

  • mezzo soprano sings My Heart Will Go On. classic classic

  • i love the flute solo

    katherines voice is great but celines interpretation from this song is better

  • das schlagzeug ruiniert irgendwie die ganze emotion im song..und sorry...aber dieses lied ist definitiv nicht für sie gemacht zum nachsingen.... sie hat an sich eine hammer stimme..aber das ist nicht so gut gelungen meiner meinung nach^^

  • strentorian voice, beautiful, awesome

  • Amazing!

  • bei dem lied find ich geht nichts über celine dion..da kann das singen wer will ..

    und ansich hab ich nichts gegen coverversionen aber das lied.. sorry das gehört einfach CELINE DION..sie soll das singen und keine andere !!...achja und dieses dämliche schlagzeug machts echt kaputt..das zerstört total die stimmung.. -.-

  • she welsh baby the best vocals r from wales