I only had a 10 gallon tank and no room for anything bigger so I just kept my BGK until I felt like he was beginning to get too big then found him a new home with the help of the people I got him from. I miss him but hope I will be able to have a larger tank one of these days and get another. They are so cool to watch!
they always say that about everything and 80% of the time they are qrong tha fish stays small not a baby but gets to 12-15inches if not less
and we post videos because we want to not to have people like that try to put us down they sound as they have nothing better to do than critisize people because they are jealouse if not doing way worse
Should the turtle have something he can prop up on? To get him out of the water when he wants" Ive seen those turtles Resting on logs in lakes - looks like thats what he needs...
Also - just picked up a "Mastacembelus armatus" today..Poor guys scared as hell. I have nice fish though, hopfully he'll warm up to his home quickly..
Ryanpretzel2311, like chieftx said the fishes outsides stop growing and the inside continues to grow. That's why it won't grow to 19 in. in a smaller tank. The people at your fish store seem more concerned about costing you money than they do about telling you the truth about the fish. In my opinion it would be a waste of money to buy a fish that will die if your tank is too small. Some fish cost $20-50 and thats a lot to flush down the toilet.
anyways just switch out the cylinder for something a bit more cave like and bigger and you'll be fine, but keep in mind if you dont soon your black ghost could die from stress (due to too much direct light exposure) or even from starvation. hope all goes well for you though ;)
i know how that is. try to find a tank setup that works for you will take a lot of time, iv had my for almost 6 years now and still havnt once been happy with it lol (bit of a perfectionist) - read next comment
that black ghost was really struggling to get out of that glass cylinder, now unlike the other talking about "oh it gets to 19" im going to cry waah!" - read next comment!
Awesome tank the whole set up is really cool :)!! I have two turtles with a tire track eel in a 55 gallon tank. I was wondering where did you get that BGK and is it a good fish?
Dude, I feel bad for that turtle. Turtles breathe air, he needs a place to sit or something. Have you wondered why he is constantly treading for his life at the top of the tank. Imagine being stuck in the ocean for the rest of your life, your safe and have plenty of food but you can never rest otherwise you will drown and die.
@emostars71 They're doing good together. I guess it's because my turtle doesn't eat fishes like normal turtle does. Actually my eel doesn't eat fishes either.
but arent u suppose to have rocks that reach up to the surface for the turtle...in case if he doesnt wanna swim all day all the time? (if anyone knows PLEASE answer because i want a turtle in my tank soon!)
Seriously thats not a good idea to keep a turtle in with any land that means he's living in water 24/7 and you really need to get a bigger tank for all them fish you should do some resourch before you decide to stick fish in.
What do you have to do to make it grow that much? I just got one and the guy in the store told me he eats normal fish food, however...they are carnivore...Whats the best food for then?
i read all your comments and i started my bgk in a 10 gallon tank and now he is 17 inches and 4 years old in my 55 gallon tank... nice tank cool fish...check out the vid of my bgk...5 stars from me
@toysoilder846 wrong - depends on your turtle and no I'm not retarded. I started with cheap feeders to see how the turtle reacts and go from there. Some turtles eats fishes and some don't. You need to do more homework before making comments like that. Not everyone is the same including animals etc. For example some people are negative like you and good people are positive.
hey, does a zig zag eel nned small narrow caves like the snowflake freshwater eel (i know its not really an eel)? i am getting one and i want to know how to set up the tank :)
A better solution would be to have a turtle/goldfish tank and a separate tropical tank.
A> the goldfish will grow fast and produce too much waste at a high temp.
B> the turtle NEEDS a rock/log base to climp completely out of the water to regulate its body temperature correctly
So, if you separate them, and keep the BGK and spiny eel in a dimly lit covered tank with more hiding places they should fare well. And Yes, 55G is enough for a BGK to reach its potential 20inches.
most of them grow to about 20-25cm in an aquarium. I have kept 1 in a 2footer and it was around 30cm when i sold it to someone with a bigger tank :)
ps your turtle will eventually eat all your fish. my little penny turtle killed all my fish including bristlenose and an oscar 4x the size of the penny. Turtle will hunt at night when the fish are sleeping and it will eat their guts. Thats what it did to my fish :(
I can't help but notice. You have a plant in your tank that is not truly aquatic. The variegated plant is has the scientific name Draceana Sanderiana. It is actually a plant that grows in swamps.
ignore that person cos i got like a really small BGK in a smaller tank n people at mi fish place said its fine just eventually u may need bigger tank if they grow 19'' but its unlikey, anyway nice tank!!
unfortunately chieftx is right about the ultimate size of the fish. Lucky for you the BGKs grow very slowly, so it should be fine in there for a while. Now for the bad news. The tiretrack eel you have in there gets to be about three feet long, and mine got to be that size in only about a year and a half. so that really wont work since your tank is barely three feet long. Sorry for the bad news.
The gold fish/ feeder fish are fishes my kids won in the fair, not worried about those. I'm sure the black ghost will be fine in my 55G. I doubt it will grow to 19" because of my tank size. Plus I feed them every other day.
You sound like you know a lot, why don't you trying giving advise instead of being so negative.
look sorry about this, but that thing that petstore employees tell you about how fish grow to your tank size is dreadfully false. the fact is that when you stop a fish from growing by keeping it in a small space, it will begin to grow sick, unhappy, and possibly violent. this is called stunting, it is infact painful. giving him a larger tank or rehomeing him would be the best option.
I hate to be negative but your the one hurting the fish.
Thanks for the reply. I'll research stunting, this is the first time I've heard of that term. Learning as I go. I can't get a bigger tank so I'll find him a new home when he gets bigger. I'll enjoy while I can.
oh and also its not "stunting" its "stunning" it's a condition which states that in small tanks, the growth of the fish to its actual size will be stopped or really slowed. this is a myth. it might slow the growth a little bit but they will grow to the adult size anyway
Actually stunting isn't a term. His growth WILL get stunted a little bit but I don't think that causes them to die. To my knowledge if an animal lives in a smaller or more crowded habitat he will grow slower. But if anything I imagine this would lengthen their lifespan since they'd eat less and metabolize slower (age slower).
I hope this isn't true because I keep my black ghost in a 55G. A lady I know at a petstore told me she had hers for years in a 55G tank and he only grew a couple inches
actually it wasnt that negative he was trying to tell you what would happen because the bgk gets so big and if he outgrows the tank it would eventually become stunted
Fish never stop growing. People think that a fish will grow to the tank size, they are wrong. I work as a marine biologist and bacteria slows the growth of fish in small tanks. The fish is still growing but not nearly as fast as it normally would in a larger tank.. It will be fine, 55 is plenty big for him.
@speedfanatics i believe it might grow to be 19 inches but dont wrry abt it, a 55 is still fine for him :) btw, cant believe thts a 55, it looks huge :P
They don't get to 19" in captivity. They normally grow to 14" in captivity. I have a 3 year old black ghost in a 30gallon with a Gar, a Fire Mouth Cichlid, and a Placo(who is 5 years old).
I only had a 10 gallon tank and no room for anything bigger so I just kept my BGK until I felt like he was beginning to get too big then found him a new home with the help of the people I got him from. I miss him but hope I will be able to have a larger tank one of these days and get another. They are so cool to watch!
indianacowgirl07 1 year ago
for real i doubt it will get the full 19inches
they always say that about everything and 80% of the time they are qrong tha fish stays small not a baby but gets to 12-15inches if not less
and we post videos because we want to not to have people like that try to put us down they sound as they have nothing better to do than critisize people because they are jealouse if not doing way worse
tiny19000 1 year ago
Oh - And Ive had my Goldfish for Over 3-1/2 years, and hes as healthy as they come. He lives with Cichlids that have lived with him for over a Year.
Cichlids and Goldfish share a Happy Medium temperature of 75'f...All of my fish look and act extremely healthy and happy...
xtraflo 1 year ago
Should the turtle have something he can prop up on? To get him out of the water when he wants" Ive seen those turtles Resting on logs in lakes - looks like thats what he needs...
Also - just picked up a "Mastacembelus armatus" today..Poor guys scared as hell. I have nice fish though, hopfully he'll warm up to his home quickly..
Pretty tank BTW - very spacious.
xtraflo 1 year ago
plz guys tell me what the kind of this sands ..
DRAKULA888 1 year ago
You turtle could be an Olympic swimmer!
spineosaur 1 year ago
Nice :)
Has the turtle got somewhere to sit where he can breathe? Because it looks like he's trying to get some air.
Thats a lot of food :P
Inflames2k8 1 year ago
Ryanpretzel2311, like chieftx said the fishes outsides stop growing and the inside continues to grow. That's why it won't grow to 19 in. in a smaller tank. The people at your fish store seem more concerned about costing you money than they do about telling you the truth about the fish. In my opinion it would be a waste of money to buy a fish that will die if your tank is too small. Some fish cost $20-50 and thats a lot to flush down the toilet.
mynameisrichardgilmo 1 year ago
anyways just switch out the cylinder for something a bit more cave like and bigger and you'll be fine, but keep in mind if you dont soon your black ghost could die from stress (due to too much direct light exposure) or even from starvation. hope all goes well for you though ;)
voku2006 1 year ago
i know how that is. try to find a tank setup that works for you will take a lot of time, iv had my for almost 6 years now and still havnt once been happy with it lol (bit of a perfectionist) - read next comment
voku2006 1 year ago
that black ghost was really struggling to get out of that glass cylinder, now unlike the other talking about "oh it gets to 19" im going to cry waah!" - read next comment!
voku2006 1 year ago
Why is your turtles head tucked in? is
that normal?...
STERNOTH 2 years ago
Awesome tank the whole set up is really cool :)!! I have two turtles with a tire track eel in a 55 gallon tank. I was wondering where did you get that BGK and is it a good fish?
1kaitlyn123 2 years ago
Dude, I feel bad for that turtle. Turtles breathe air, he needs a place to sit or something. Have you wondered why he is constantly treading for his life at the top of the tank. Imagine being stuck in the ocean for the rest of your life, your safe and have plenty of food but you can never rest otherwise you will drown and die.
loganis1337 2 years ago
@loganis1337 He has a log to rest on.
speedfanatics 1 year ago
nice tank and fish, I got an eel too and so tempted to get a ghost knife if it wasn't for few small fish in my tank.
I think the minimum tank size for a full grown BGK is 75g and turtle should have access to land like a floating log.
f2warbound 2 years ago
Who cares about a gold fish, they cost like 12 cents.
ShyneClanDeath 2 years ago
Nice set up how are the turtle eel and fish doing? I just bought an peacock eel yesterday
emostars71 2 years ago
@emostars71 They're doing good together. I guess it's because my turtle doesn't eat fishes like normal turtle does. Actually my eel doesn't eat fishes either.
speedfanatics 1 year ago
this tank is AWESOMEEEEE!!!
=]
but arent u suppose to have rocks that reach up to the surface for the turtle...in case if he doesnt wanna swim all day all the time? (if anyone knows PLEASE answer because i want a turtle in my tank soon!)
QueenDominiRican 2 years ago
@QueenDominiRican You can't see it but there is a log he rest on.
speedfanatics 1 year ago
Seriously thats not a good idea to keep a turtle in with any land that means he's living in water 24/7 and you really need to get a bigger tank for all them fish you should do some resourch before you decide to stick fish in.
callumDCFC1 2 years ago
What do you have to do to make it grow that much? I just got one and the guy in the store told me he eats normal fish food, however...they are carnivore...Whats the best food for then?
TheRachel33 2 years ago
Beautiful tank, its nice to see your bond with your pets!
icephoenyx 2 years ago
YOU CAN PUT A TURTLE IN THERE??!
RonaldButlerJr 2 years ago
i read all your comments and i started my bgk in a 10 gallon tank and now he is 17 inches and 4 years old in my 55 gallon tank... nice tank cool fish...check out the vid of my bgk...5 stars from me
mattc950 2 years ago
you have a beautiful large tank. i think the fishes in there would be not just fine but very happy to live in there.
Koilover101 2 years ago
You should feed them twice a day but it seems like your not having any problems so whatever. Very nice knife fish.
xcwa8900 2 years ago
hey correct me if im wrong but i think ur eel is actually a tire track. BTW nice tank
bverman123 2 years ago
@bverman123 Yes it's a tire track. You know your fishes =).
speedfanatics 1 year ago
My advise would be get another bgk and watch how they come alive, moving a lot and hunting togather!
VampAro600 2 years ago
so does the turtle not eat that black fish?? cuz my turtle will eat anything that moves no matter how big. he will just rip them apart.
fallentoturtle 2 years ago
i had my bgk for 3 years and never got to big for my 55 g
thugdora 2 years ago
Nice setup, although I'm surprised you were able to mix in your turtles with the fish! How is his attitude towards them?
shiftykey 2 years ago
@shiftykey They get along fine. My turtle loves chasing your finger but scared of anything else or just don't care. Lol.
speedfanatics 1 year ago
nice tank with some cool fishes ! I have at home a Asian Shark Catfish I love that little bastard it eats everything and its active
Soldierfromhungary 2 years ago
u really dont have a clue
ZombeeXTC 2 years ago
@ZombeeXTC and you do? LOL.
speedfanatics 1 year ago
are you retarded your never supposed to put a fish and a turtle in the same tank obviosly they dont get along
toysoilder846 2 years ago
@toysoilder846 wrong - depends on your turtle and no I'm not retarded. I started with cheap feeders to see how the turtle reacts and go from there. Some turtles eats fishes and some don't. You need to do more homework before making comments like that. Not everyone is the same including animals etc. For example some people are negative like you and good people are positive.
speedfanatics 1 year ago
hey, does a zig zag eel nned small narrow caves like the snowflake freshwater eel (i know its not really an eel)? i am getting one and i want to know how to set up the tank :)
mcdonaldjosh7 2 years ago
hahah. what the flipp isup with the turtle.
that cracks me upp.
:D cute fish!!
KreamVanillaShow 2 years ago
A better solution would be to have a turtle/goldfish tank and a separate tropical tank.
A> the goldfish will grow fast and produce too much waste at a high temp.
B> the turtle NEEDS a rock/log base to climp completely out of the water to regulate its body temperature correctly
So, if you separate them, and keep the BGK and spiny eel in a dimly lit covered tank with more hiding places they should fare well. And Yes, 55G is enough for a BGK to reach its potential 20inches.
objectofdesire 3 years ago
@objectofdesire Good tip - Thanks.
speedfanatics 1 year ago
does the turtle has access to a dry zone? cuz they need or they will perish in only water aquaria
VanSneiwder 3 years ago
what are u feeding them?
cottoncandyisyummy 3 years ago
Oh wow you can feed an eel, don't you feel awesome.....NOT!
SpitRhymaAgain 3 years ago
i ave the blsk ghost knife but ot bad i dies ...MISS IT !!! TOT
KanemiX3 3 years ago
how did u get such a big zig zag?! that's fuckin HUUUUUUUGE! I've seen fire eels that big and bigger but not zig zags. Zig zags are TINY!
WTF?!
SpitRhyma 3 years ago
turtle will eventually eat all your fish.
giannizboy 3 years ago
@giannizboy I'm still waiting for my turtle to eat anything alive.
speedfanatics 1 year ago
most of them grow to about 20-25cm in an aquarium. I have kept 1 in a 2footer and it was around 30cm when i sold it to someone with a bigger tank :)
ps your turtle will eventually eat all your fish. my little penny turtle killed all my fish including bristlenose and an oscar 4x the size of the penny. Turtle will hunt at night when the fish are sleeping and it will eat their guts. Thats what it did to my fish :(
giannizboy 3 years ago
@giannizboy I've had my turtle for 10 years and has never ate anything alive.
speedfanatics 1 year ago
VERY nice tank!
pranicmegan 3 years ago
Yo, the turtle.. is gonna die.. turtles cant live in that deep of water... Also u need like a plantform for it to sun tan and stuff..
FairRaizen 3 years ago
I can't help but notice. You have a plant in your tank that is not truly aquatic. The variegated plant is has the scientific name Draceana Sanderiana. It is actually a plant that grows in swamps.
greendruid87 3 years ago
what turtle is that because i thought you couldnt keep them with fish?
ryanpretzel2311 3 years ago
what turtle is that and dont u have to have a UV light
ryanpretzel2311 3 years ago
how big do they get?
redandbluebeater 3 years ago
does that turtle try to bite the other fish? my sisters is only 5 months old and it bites any other thing thats in there.
redandbluebeater 3 years ago
where did you get that see through tube for your BGK? you get it from a pet shop or something also are they expensive?
ryanpretzel2311 3 years ago
@ryanpretzel2311 There was a glass shop in my town. You can get them at ebay.
speedfanatics 1 year ago
nice tank, that looks like tire track eel? if you dim lights in your tank the ghost knife will be active all day and night like mine is.
Jcashrulez 3 years ago
@Jcashrulez - I have blue dim led lights. I know what you mean =).
speedfanatics 1 year ago
hey how long is ur tank? in feet
cairnsghettonigz 3 years ago
@cairnsghettonigz I'm not sure but it's your standard 55gal.
speedfanatics 1 year ago
ignore that person cos i got like a really small BGK in a smaller tank n people at mi fish place said its fine just eventually u may need bigger tank if they grow 19'' but its unlikey, anyway nice tank!!
ryanpretzel2311 3 years ago 4
.....they grow to be 21" no matter how small the tank is...
zaracki92 3 years ago
They grow 3 feet in nature. They grow to the maximum size that your set-up allows them to.
You should keep it in a LONG tank but they generally find a place to hang out and stay there so I don't see the point of anything longer than 48"
Mine is in a 55G and LOVES his peice of wood ;)
Check my 55G tank prior to adding the BGK in my videos. He now resides in the wood on the right (2nd from the right) with the onions growing on it.
He's funny
SpitRhyma 3 years ago
They don't grow to 19", it is 12-16"
1992pattrow 2 years ago
unfortunately chieftx is right about the ultimate size of the fish. Lucky for you the BGKs grow very slowly, so it should be fine in there for a while. Now for the bad news. The tiretrack eel you have in there gets to be about three feet long, and mine got to be that size in only about a year and a half. so that really wont work since your tank is barely three feet long. Sorry for the bad news.
plutopersephane 3 years ago
well thats great!
I acctually really wanted one for my 55 gallon but I heard about it on this very good fish forum you oughtta join us.
on Badmanstropicalfish(dot)com.
they have some awesome info there and they will be glad to help ya out.
glad to help out. :)
chieftx 3 years ago
Oh this is bad.
first off: gold fish are cold water fish period! its insides will outgrow its skin in tropical temps.
second: a black ghost gets to 19 inches, and they will stunt and die in a tank that small.
chieftx 3 years ago
The gold fish/ feeder fish are fishes my kids won in the fair, not worried about those. I'm sure the black ghost will be fine in my 55G. I doubt it will grow to 19" because of my tank size. Plus I feed them every other day.
You sound like you know a lot, why don't you trying giving advise instead of being so negative.
speedfanatics 3 years ago 5
OK its understandable about the goldfish.
look sorry about this, but that thing that petstore employees tell you about how fish grow to your tank size is dreadfully false. the fact is that when you stop a fish from growing by keeping it in a small space, it will begin to grow sick, unhappy, and possibly violent. this is called stunting, it is infact painful. giving him a larger tank or rehomeing him would be the best option.
I hate to be negative but your the one hurting the fish.
chieftx 3 years ago
Thanks for the reply. I'll research stunting, this is the first time I've heard of that term. Learning as I go. I can't get a bigger tank so I'll find him a new home when he gets bigger. I'll enjoy while I can.
speedfanatics 3 years ago
thats the best thing u can do :) gud luck, they are very beautiful fish :)
zaracki92 3 years ago
oh and also its not "stunting" its "stunning" it's a condition which states that in small tanks, the growth of the fish to its actual size will be stopped or really slowed. this is a myth. it might slow the growth a little bit but they will grow to the adult size anyway
zaracki92 3 years ago
Actually stunting isn't a term. His growth WILL get stunted a little bit but I don't think that causes them to die. To my knowledge if an animal lives in a smaller or more crowded habitat he will grow slower. But if anything I imagine this would lengthen their lifespan since they'd eat less and metabolize slower (age slower).
I hope this isn't true because I keep my black ghost in a 55G. A lady I know at a petstore told me she had hers for years in a 55G tank and he only grew a couple inches
SpitRhyma 3 years ago
actually it wasnt that negative he was trying to tell you what would happen because the bgk gets so big and if he outgrows the tank it would eventually become stunted
Thiswarisours56212 2 years ago
Fish never stop growing. People think that a fish will grow to the tank size, they are wrong. I work as a marine biologist and bacteria slows the growth of fish in small tanks. The fish is still growing but not nearly as fast as it normally would in a larger tank.. It will be fine, 55 is plenty big for him.
1992pattrow 2 years ago
@speedfanatics whats the difference between the average tiretrack and zigzag eel?
finalman25 1 year ago
@finalman25 - They are the same eel. I guess different scientific names. Lol.
speedfanatics 1 year ago
@speedfanatics i believe it might grow to be 19 inches but dont wrry abt it, a 55 is still fine for him :) btw, cant believe thts a 55, it looks huge :P
zaracki92 1 year ago
lol 19 inch bgk would be a monster, try 12 inch MAX and in a 55g thats fine
shmico 3 years ago
To say that they will outgrow their skin is one of the more idiotic things I have heard in my life.
Their SCALES will regrow and accommodate the body of the goldfish.
mrdansoko 2 years ago
They don't get to 19" in captivity. They normally grow to 14" in captivity. I have a 3 year old black ghost in a 30gallon with a Gar, a Fire Mouth Cichlid, and a Placo(who is 5 years old).
1992pattrow 2 years ago
@chieftx no, they're fine in heated tanks.
spineosaur 1 year ago