the timing was off in some portions of the song, not strong in sound in switching tunes of the overture. surely this is not the same ppl who did the studio version. :/
and yet the auditorium may had had some echo? hmmmm.. but still think they could had done better for a live video recording..... ;/
@kimicansyn I don't think they could've done much better than this. All orchestral instruments were recorded in separate tracks by Rudess on the keyboard, in studio.
the orchestra doesn't like dream theater........ you can tell, I want over blown trumpets and everything. Muted flute, at 4:30 would sound great :) But I had to write for those instruments in my life :/
the orchestra doesn't like dream theater........ you can tell, I want over blown trumpets and everything. But I had to write for those instruments in my life :/
Would love to see a rerecording of this with the Metropool Orkest. Probably the only ochestra/big band that can manage such stuff (and hey, they also could manage Stevie Vay, and Zappa-related stuff)
@ROBINAMK5 Correct me if I'm wrong, but this is in a Dream Theater concert. They do the entire Overture in Six Degrees and acompany them in songs like Octavarium and Metropolis.
I feel like if they had a more prominent percussion section in the orchestra , it would have sounded so much better. But you gotta give them credit, they not only learned this entire piece but other complex songs like Octavarium and Metropolis too, just think of all the time they had to put into getting used to all those key and time signature changes.
@KDawgAtsu I don't know if the stuff they are playing here is more complex than a lot of classical pieces. Mind you they are professionals... Add to that their ability to read sheet music like normal people read ordinary text and I think it was just "another day at the office" for the orchestra.
Though they usually don't get to play songs that are as good as these. :)
@KDawgAtsu I doubt that, the speed would have been a difficulty but classical music, which in my opinion is the base of progressive metal because of its long pieces and musical freedom, also has a lot of different timesignatures. One of the reasons they have a conductor.
@KDawgAtsu Who needs a percussion section when you have Mike Portnoy? I'm sure they knew that with him playing drums a full percussion section wouldn't be necessary to spend money on.
@willschoeff man portnoy is so fuckin overrated, c'mon he's solid as fuck but he's not really that impressive. Grant Collins...check that motherfucker out!!!! Drum portnoy under the table with one arm the lad!!
@danymann let's see you try to remember a 42 minute song and then play a whole bunch of other long ass songs so get back to me when you master all of it
@GentalaMaya well, the original piece wasn't rock at all, was ( sort of ) classical.. and the sad thing is it sounded much better with digital instruments. I just wish an orchestra transposition could add something to the piece, not make it worst. See you.
@thealphasystem I like your comment. I think they couldnt hire the best orchestra, not like Metallica and their S&M. They might not be that familiar with classical piece either. Hope they would progress.
i really wish this didn't remind me so much of my high school orchestra. Maybe they got bored of the piece and didn't really get into it.
8radicalraym8 3 weeks ago
Being a string player myself for over 13 years. This was downright sloppy.
MAW9 2 months ago
@ 2:53, let the timpani power begin
Jmast3r6046 3 months ago
the orchestra has to be bigger! but it's nice that the band does not perform in the ouverture.
lulalely 3 months ago
dream theater is every one of these people playing in the orchestra and even more than then!!! the best!
scorpiones103 5 months ago 2
the timing was off in some portions of the song, not strong in sound in switching tunes of the overture. surely this is not the same ppl who did the studio version. :/
and yet the auditorium may had had some echo? hmmmm.. but still think they could had done better for a live video recording..... ;/
kimicansyn 5 months ago
@kimicansyn I don't think they could've done much better than this. All orchestral instruments were recorded in separate tracks by Rudess on the keyboard, in studio.
ErikJonssonMusic 5 months ago in playlist Fler videoklipp från iiBR4ND0N
@kimicansyn The Studio version is not played by orchestra... it's all Rudess' job! :-P (for what I know, but I'm pretty sure about it)
AndrewRBX 1 month ago
This is so Ballsy for a rock band to orchestrate their midi patches.......
maestroanth 6 months ago
the orchestra doesn't like dream theater........ you can tell, I want over blown trumpets and everything. Muted flute, at 4:30 would sound great :) But I had to write for those instruments in my life :/
maestroanth 6 months ago
the orchestra doesn't like dream theater........ you can tell, I want over blown trumpets and everything. But I had to write for those instruments in my life :/
maestroanth 6 months ago
the orchestra doesn't like dream theater........ you can tell, I want over blown trumpets and everything.
maestroanth 6 months ago
love the whole song
NoSurprisesPlease0 6 months ago in playlist Six Degrees of Inner Turbulance
wasn't this when Dream Theater played with the Octavarium orchestra?
loveforleggy 7 months ago
Would love to see a rerecording of this with the Metropool Orkest. Probably the only ochestra/big band that can manage such stuff (and hey, they also could manage Stevie Vay, and Zappa-related stuff)
JosBrouwer1 7 months ago
Does anyone know where one could find sheet music from Overture?
emmyellaleo 7 months ago
Amazing
emmyellaleo 7 months ago
Comment removed
TheXanadu88 8 months ago
Comment removed
TheXanadu88 8 months ago
why were there drums on this part?
DustinShaneYounce 8 months ago
@DustinShaneYounce I mean "NO" drums?
DustinShaneYounce 8 months ago
The only problem is, how does one mosh to an orchestra? =P
missymoosical 8 months ago
Comment removed
lmSeXy 8 months ago
dream theater takes the complex of tthe music and show us how beautifull is it to play, 'n listen, with songs with a start .. a midle and an end...
dream theater is simply funtastic!
joaoabn1 9 months ago
anyone else get reminded of Ludibrium from Maplestory? xD
TheWilderMusic 10 months ago
OMG
jonickk 10 months ago
Is an incredibe effort! its not an easy peace to play.. dont be mad
Pancho1988 1 year ago
i wish dream theater would hear this version and they will be proud that the orchestra had a really good effort
ROBINAMK5 1 year ago
@ROBINAMK5 Correct me if I'm wrong, but this is in a Dream Theater concert. They do the entire Overture in Six Degrees and acompany them in songs like Octavarium and Metropolis.
freetrader0000 1 year ago
@ROBINAMK5 They actually did hear this version. Watch part 2 to see what I mean.
ChippyYYZ 1 year ago
in the album, this piece has an compainment of the band this is only orchestra :/
CrissCoverdrive 1 year ago
@CrissCoverdrive so?
TheWilderMusic 10 months ago
I feel like if they had a more prominent percussion section in the orchestra , it would have sounded so much better. But you gotta give them credit, they not only learned this entire piece but other complex songs like Octavarium and Metropolis too, just think of all the time they had to put into getting used to all those key and time signature changes.
KDawgAtsu 1 year ago 27
@KDawgAtsu I don't know if the stuff they are playing here is more complex than a lot of classical pieces. Mind you they are professionals... Add to that their ability to read sheet music like normal people read ordinary text and I think it was just "another day at the office" for the orchestra.
Though they usually don't get to play songs that are as good as these. :)
BoardgameBaker 1 year ago 2
@KDawgAtsu They need a more prominent percussion. Really? With four timpanis AND Mike Portnoy?
missymoosical 8 months ago
@KDawgAtsu I doubt that, the speed would have been a difficulty but classical music, which in my opinion is the base of progressive metal because of its long pieces and musical freedom, also has a lot of different timesignatures. One of the reasons they have a conductor.
DrummerRF 7 months ago
@KDawgAtsu Personally i dont find the time signatures not a real problem, it feels really natural to me.
LeapingDodo 6 months ago
@KDawgAtsu Who needs a percussion section when you have Mike Portnoy? I'm sure they knew that with him playing drums a full percussion section wouldn't be necessary to spend money on.
willschoeff 1 month ago
@willschoeff man portnoy is so fuckin overrated, c'mon he's solid as fuck but he's not really that impressive. Grant Collins...check that motherfucker out!!!! Drum portnoy under the table with one arm the lad!!
lhall84 1 month ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Never heard a worse Orchestra!!!! They are really funny...trying to play...so cute
danymann 1 year ago
@danymann let's see you try to remember a 42 minute song and then play a whole bunch of other long ass songs so get back to me when you master all of it
srryforowningu 1 year ago 4
@danymann Obvious troll.
freetrader0000 1 year ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
how bad arrangement, sounds so flat...
thealphasystem 2 years ago
think how wonderful a rock song has become a classical piece mr the alphasystem. flat it is but it is a mega effort
GentalaMaya 1 year ago
@GentalaMaya well, the original piece wasn't rock at all, was ( sort of ) classical.. and the sad thing is it sounded much better with digital instruments. I just wish an orchestra transposition could add something to the piece, not make it worst. See you.
thealphasystem 1 year ago
@thealphasystem I like your comment. I think they couldnt hire the best orchestra, not like Metallica and their S&M. They might not be that familiar with classical piece either. Hope they would progress.
GentalaMaya 1 year ago
epic
SubaUba 2 years ago 24