En otro video Miriam Makeba explica que los colonizadores de su país, llamaron a esta canción "La Canción del Click", simplemente porque no podían pronunciar su nombre en la lenguaje Xhosa además dice que es una pieza que se canta en las bodas, así que que para Debora mis felicitaciones por enriquecer la cultura universal trayendo esta canción a los hispanoparlantes.
I commend her for trying this song, realizing how difficult it is for other people not from our land to pronounce some of our words in IsiXhosa. Hope she finds someone who speaks isiXhosa, siNdebele or isiZulu to help her out with the clicks and then properly redo it. The song has no meaning without the proper pronunciation of the clicks. Its painful to listen to. Good try though, and beautiful voice too. I give her credit for trying.
Everywhere i look, i see kindness in African people. You have proven this again today. Even though she pronounced isiZulu wrong, you looked past that. Miriam Makeba, your voice and music will forever live on! even in the white people hahahahah
I love this arrangement of the song, but I find it difficult to enjoy as a whole due to the mispronunciation of nearly every word. She does, however, have a good voice.
im not gonna lie i read your post before i saw the video... and i was thinking damn you prolly right, but after the video i started to notice they were using a instrument to mimick the clicking for her which was smart on her part.... all in all she has a beautiful voice.. compared to many proffessional attempts she did pretty good even with xhosa.
En otro video Miriam Makeba explica que los colonizadores de su país, llamaron a esta canción "La Canción del Click", simplemente porque no podían pronunciar su nombre en la lenguaje Xhosa además dice que es una pieza que se canta en las bodas, así que que para Debora mis felicitaciones por enriquecer la cultura universal trayendo esta canción a los hispanoparlantes.
Pax
chekelitoCIL 6 months ago
Por cierto, tampoco es Zulu, es Xhosa.
sarnahorn 10 months ago
Tal vez el experimento hubiera resultado mejor con el pata pata, los clics del pata pata son un poco más sencillos
sarnahorn 10 months ago
Tal vez el experimento hubiera resultado mejor con el pata pata, los clics del pata pata son un poco más sencillos
sarnahorn 10 months ago
ken lee, tu libu dibu douchoo
dastechnoviking 1 year ago
dont expect her to be able to do it.....im South African myself i cant do the Nguni clicks ie Zulu,Xhosa, Ndebele and Swazi
445678999ful 1 year ago
Awful!
Fatou83 2 years ago 3
nxa ukhuluma uyakhuluma let it go lady i do not know what you are saying therefore no meaning thina singamaXhosa siyazi ingoma le stick to your taal
raggatasn 2 years ago
why do people make it a point to mess up our language? This lady should contact me for some lessons. She might do it better. :) Good try though
buhle78 2 years ago
Hi buhle78
So, can you help me with the pronuntiation???
thanks!!!!! a lot!!!!
:)
marbathory 2 years ago
E vabbè, sei Sudafricano, capisci che per uno stranieronon è facile pronunciare il Q, X, C.
jeansihn 2 years ago
Beautiful..good job
oladapo007 2 years ago
Hmmm...a click song without any clicks...just like nike without air = possible, but...it sucks. lol
She tried to do it...(I don't know if that was a good idea...)
MissYassa 2 years ago 2
LMAO!! I agree
stacynewyork 2 years ago
nkonkowanee hahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahhahaha Mhaneeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeee
Huuuuuuuuuuuuu hahane or malume
Satafrika 3 years ago
I commend her for trying this song, realizing how difficult it is for other people not from our land to pronounce some of our words in IsiXhosa. Hope she finds someone who speaks isiXhosa, siNdebele or isiZulu to help her out with the clicks and then properly redo it. The song has no meaning without the proper pronunciation of the clicks. Its painful to listen to. Good try though, and beautiful voice too. I give her credit for trying.
toobit7 3 years ago 10
@toobit7
Everywhere i look, i see kindness in African people. You have proven this again today. Even though she pronounced isiZulu wrong, you looked past that. Miriam Makeba, your voice and music will forever live on! even in the white people hahahahah
TheAfricanSoul 11 months ago
I love this arrangement of the song, but I find it difficult to enjoy as a whole due to the mispronunciation of nearly every word. She does, however, have a good voice.
ummacles 3 years ago
it,s sweet, nice try!!
chamunda35 3 years ago 2
Great voice but she cannot pronounce the Xhosa words that are crucial to the music... so it's really awful
bluedrew612 3 years ago
im not gonna lie i read your post before i saw the video... and i was thinking damn you prolly right, but after the video i started to notice they were using a instrument to mimick the clicking for her which was smart on her part.... all in all she has a beautiful voice.. compared to many proffessional attempts she did pretty good even with xhosa.
Awful i think is a lil unfair.
bjahava 3 years ago 5
she is good
jacobson00 3 years ago
excelente voz,excelente interpretación.
Y ademas tienes muy buena energia, y eres la mas linda de la debora.
morbidser 3 years ago
estas como rica, eres muy buena..., persona
sebitasdeoro 3 years ago
Maria Angelica Makeba.... que hago?????????? FELICITACIONES!!!!!!!!!!! 10000000000000000 øø VECES!!
QUE DIOS TE GUARDE POR SIEMPRE!!!!!!!
shacoota 3 years ago