Many people have sung this song before, some are very good too. But Ivana Wong's voice, diction and singing skills have certain qualities that are heart-melting, make you indulged! Great artist!
i'm not saying her (the woman covering the song) voice isn't lovely. its angelic actually. bt as a tori fan i think there are just some tori songs that are sacred and should never be covered... this song, winter and me and a gun come to mind. i don't know but these song are just so personal...
Ivana's beautiful singing of 'Silent All These Years' brings me 'goose-flesh' because I am so moved! Her voice is soft and warm, her diction is very clear! She gives this song a new mystic-beauty feel that touched every heart! Excellent, Ivana!!
700,000,000 is not a small market, and her talent can go beyond the meaningless borders of HK; Radiohead give away their latest album for free too; it will be the concerts, which mostly only true fans will go, that will pay for her livelihood
700,000,000 is not a small market, and her talent can go beyond the meaningless borders of HK; Radiohead give away their latest album for free too; it will be the concerts, which mostly only true fans will go, that will pay for her livelihood
sorry for the double reply, and the population of HK should be closer to 7,000,000 than 700,000,000; otherwise, we will be in big trouble,
ps, would love to see Ivana play both acoustic and electronic guitars more frequently, jamming melodies with other true musicians, but not entertainers, in HK; and i will start a petition soon if i still see those clowns (aka idols) call themselves artists; thank you for patiently letting me to finish my comments, and it is your turn now
True. But Faye has got years of experience more than Ivana. Its obvious that Faye will always be the greatest (to me, at least, haha). I don't really get the deal with people always making comparisons between singers. Music should be what you like and not like, not who is better than whom. Comparisons are unavoidable, but we should always respect singers for their craft.
Wow! She sounds amazing! Next to "Winter," this is my other favourite song by Tori Amos. I hope Ivana will record her own version of "Winter" as well. I'd really like to see how she would sing it. GO IVANA GO!
想不到她的聲線可以如此多變.....
jasonpolaris 2 months ago
She is awesome!!
MrKubbo 4 months ago
樓上說比tori amos好..也太誇張了吧..地球上沒有人演譯這歌會比tori amos好。
但王苑之有唱出一些感覺,她是很有才能,很有個性,可惜...在香港,這些都不是'紅'的必需條件。
hydrablue888 1 year ago 8
This has been flagged as spam show
@hydrablue888 說地球上沒有人演譯這歌會比tori amos也太誇張了...
bluebird1117 9 months ago
很東方的Silent all these years
cwm0902 1 year ago
hk does has good singers!!!!
vvvip 1 year ago
wow this really needs to surprise me on one of the next anime's I watch... this is beautiful
echosaisis 1 year ago
omg, a voice from angel
chin19841 1 year ago
很輕描淡寫的感覺...
卻帶有很深的感情...
再把自己的唱腔帶進去歌曲裡...
剛開始有點不穩!
到後面就整個很自然了
a3592122 1 year ago 10
好厲害
非常不好唱的歌
p25912197 1 year ago 9
prefer her to tori amos. beautiful
WiccanThorn26 1 year ago
i can still many words sound like mandarin.... not too bad though...
kogepansanx 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
this doesn't sound that good..
stefanie sounds better
and of course.. no comparison to tori..
iMPERiOUS 2 years ago
Amazing!
It seems to me that she sings much better in English.
gogogo789789 2 years ago 6
marvelous,,,
kungfugroup 2 years ago 6
wow she can play the piano without looking. she's soo good!
jenniferkayan 2 years ago 15
這是她出道前嗎?
pokia801209 2 years ago
That what a singer should do that putting music as her first life.
kachun610 2 years ago 2
it's how a singer should be
lovindots 2 years ago 13
This has been flagged as spam show
但佢在香港都係紅唔到,要紅就要有無後台,好似雞容甘,出賣自己
hydrablue888 2 years ago
Many people have sung this song before, some are very good too. But Ivana Wong's voice, diction and singing skills have certain qualities that are heart-melting, make you indulged! Great artist!
dultizedes 2 years ago 15
sorry but only tori amos is the only one who can REALLY sing this song. this song IS her life after all...
Rockart9 2 years ago 5
totally agree!!!!!!!!
btw..i think faye wong can sing this song well too
hydrablue888 2 years ago 7
i'm not saying her (the woman covering the song) voice isn't lovely. its angelic actually. bt as a tori fan i think there are just some tori songs that are sacred and should never be covered... this song, winter and me and a gun come to mind. i don't know but these song are just so personal...
Rockart9 2 years ago 6
@Rockart9 After listening to the original, i must agree with you...
SunE6792 1 year ago
Ivana's singing is so soothing~
shuko520 2 years ago 8
Sun yan zi version more great..... but ivana voice really a men killer.....( a very nice and sweet voice.)
angelgemini 2 years ago
she sounds way better singing english
i don't like it when she sings in chinese
i don't know why
namrak88 2 years ago 3
佢幾時作番首英文歌比自己唱呢?
y2keith2005 3 years ago 10
Wow can she sing and yes she is so pretty
crippsonian 3 years ago 8
This has been flagged as spam show
fool
shirleywoodsarah 3 years ago
又真係幾好聽喎
niceskyataka 3 years ago 20
she has got very nice creamy skin
really charming when playing music
hardstar54 3 years ago 13
wow, she could speak cantonese, mandarin and english fluently!
jenniferkayan 3 years ago 12
Ivana's beautiful singing of 'Silent All These Years' brings me 'goose-flesh' because I am so moved! Her voice is soft and warm, her diction is very clear! She gives this song a new mystic-beauty feel that touched every heart! Excellent, Ivana!!
dultizedes 3 years ago 17
雖然佢有時成都話自己有天使的聲音,有d誇,但係聽得多真係好天使!
bigbutom 3 years ago 24
我覺得她的歌聲很適合這首歌
第一次覺得有人唱的比原唱好聽(個人感受啦)
ccmno1 3 years ago 72
Very, very sensational singing! Ivana ... a beautiful artist to note!
Pearlykongkong 3 years ago 38
always love this song -- tori amos' original, faye wong's cover & even stephanie sun's version
ivana sings it quite well here
pity that it is broken off by her "small talk"
would really like to hear faye sing it in english :>
cherylmiao 3 years ago 13
wow herr english pronounciation is good! and singing is nice
pinkbreaze 3 years ago 6
Hight quality !!!!!!!
mini1398 ,I love your work!!!
I give 5 mark
stanleyspace 3 years ago 3
Dreamed Ivana to sing this song long time ago!!!Nice!!!!!
midnightcsl 3 years ago 3
why can't we have more true artist like her in HK?
ballhomer 3 years ago 3
its probably because HK isnt a big enough market.
not enough people in Hk will spend money buying a cd.
yipyip01 3 years ago 10
700,000,000 is not a small market, and her talent can go beyond the meaningless borders of HK; Radiohead give away their latest album for free too; it will be the concerts, which mostly only true fans will go, that will pay for her livelihood
ballhomer 3 years ago
700,000,000 is not a small market, and her talent can go beyond the meaningless borders of HK; Radiohead give away their latest album for free too; it will be the concerts, which mostly only true fans will go, that will pay for her livelihood
ballhomer 3 years ago 5
sorry for the double reply, and the population of HK should be closer to 7,000,000 than 700,000,000; otherwise, we will be in big trouble,
ps, would love to see Ivana play both acoustic and electronic guitars more frequently, jamming melodies with other true musicians, but not entertainers, in HK; and i will start a petition soon if i still see those clowns (aka idols) call themselves artists; thank you for patiently letting me to finish my comments, and it is your turn now
ballhomer 3 years ago 8
There Is a slightly difference than the Amos version
at 0:58, it should be "In these jeans of his with her name still on it"
Great work, very sweet voice
MinhTrinh918 3 years ago 3
王菀之...you make my spine shivers ! Great !
takemyfoodaway 3 years ago 6
It's a strange way to re-perform this song, like reading a poem. Awesome!~
36454721 3 years ago 2
i love you """王菀之"""
yaode 3 years ago 5
i love it
vethel 3 years ago 4
love her voice!!!!!!!!!!
czsmyt 3 years ago 4
love her voice!!!!!!!!!!
czsmyt 3 years ago 3
Comment removed
winky323 4 years ago 6
No other artist in HongKong can perform like this but Ivana!!!! She is a Superstar!
tsungfamily 4 years ago 11
ivana stands way behind faye, listen to cold war by faye and u will see
Fayenatic 3 years ago
True. But Faye has got years of experience more than Ivana. Its obvious that Faye will always be the greatest (to me, at least, haha). I don't really get the deal with people always making comparisons between singers. Music should be what you like and not like, not who is better than whom. Comparisons are unavoidable, but we should always respect singers for their craft.
sleeptheclockaround 3 years ago 4
ＷＯＷ！
she's amazing..
neverdiephoenix 4 years ago 3
Her fans always
ShivaHK 4 years ago 3
does anyone know why her mandarin & english is so good leh? hehe
lainawong 4 years ago 6
she went to college in canada. I dont know why her mandarin is so good though.. learned it from hins?
chinamanWin 3 years ago 2
Really?
andyswVids 3 years ago
love ivana!
3lveRs0n 4 years ago 5
good singer
hinlo123 4 years ago 4
She's awesome, she brings out her own style, bttersweet, gosh
doveeryl 4 years ago 5
Ivana is definitely a talented singer!
nat1223 4 years ago 8
Wow! She sounds amazing! Next to "Winter," this is my other favourite song by Tori Amos. I hope Ivana will record her own version of "Winter" as well. I'd really like to see how she would sing it. GO IVANA GO!
pcchau20 4 years ago 5
good song
good singer
vertigogirlgirl 4 years ago 3