Added: 6 years ago
From: istoyk
Views: 185,911
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:
see all

All Comments (336)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • I said it at the time of the show, that this was one of the best performances of any song that I have ever seen. I understand why they didn't choose her but she can really sing and sign INXS songs as well. The backing band on that show was also one of the best I've ever seen. Thanks, Dennis - ultimatevocalgroup dot/com

  • next to Freddy no one has done it better

  • What about the house band in this. Ever song they could do just as good if not better than the originals.

  • What about the house band in this. Ever song they could do just a good if not better than the originals.

  • I think the girl had...."balls"...to sing that song and sing it really really good!!Thumb up to her!!Queen forever!!

  • fantasic!!!

  • I still shake and get goose bumps when watching this almost 4 years ago. Most spectacular TV event cover on LIVE TV that I've ever seen for a QUEEN song. WTG Suzie!!!

  • OOOHHH!... MAMA MIA...MAMA MIA....SUZIE'S VOCAL GIVES ME DA CHILLZZ DOWN MY SPINE....THREE CHEERS 4 SUZIE MC NEIL...HIP HIP HURRAY!!...if u like it...u rockers!... show ur support to da world of ROCK

  • Still amazing all these years later. I rooted for her from the first show. Yeah she had some down performances but this... this was a once in a generation TV performance. And people have to remember the context that she had less than a week to arrange and rehearse before she sang on live TV. This performance was simply head ans shoulders above anything before or after it on the show, it was the high point. And its still amazing today.

  • @Heru3005 I couldn't agree more. She should have won. Her performances were hands down the best.. Fortune was and is, in my opinion a talented mimic. Susie has her own voice. I think INXS made a horrible mistake, I truly do.

  • Terrible!

  • She should have won instead of J. D. Fortune

  • beautiful performance! love it!

  • owwwww this is much than i expect

  • I agree with other comments here that if you were fortunate enough to watch this LIVE, it was one of the best performances on tv ever. American Idol is pure garbage compared to Rockstar INXS. I always believed the guy who came in 2nd should have won. INXS would probably still be playing and making hits. Unfortunately they chose a druggie who ruined their comeback.

  • @jazzmannca I was totally amazed when I watched. I was like 12 or something, and it made me want to be a musician (:

  • Er...Pretty great for a QUEEN copy!!

  • someone needs to tell me what the fuck this song is about

  • @pomegranateish nobody knows coz the band keeps it a secret

  • GO SUZIE!!!!!!!!

  • This woman just made it 10 times worse. MERCURY FOREVER!!!!

  • I completely fell in love with this girl on that show. I had a gen-u-ine Suzie-crush going. Never had that happen before or since for somebody on TV. Watching this brought it all back! I'm happy to see she's out there performing.

  • She is amazing

  • Allright, I'm not being sexist but this song simply HAS to be sung by a male voice.

  • @JakeViciousPB i know what you mean.. it sounds weird without the deep baritone

  • gotta be canadian baybay

  • I agree with you Maverick, i never got into Idol, cuz I dont want an idol. I want a ROCKSTAR!!! THEY NEED A NEW SEASON OF THIS SHOW!!!

  • A star from the beginning :)

  • it's gotta be ( i know not much) one of the hardest songs to sing. nothing but praise from me!

  • @balazsaboo mmm , yeah it's one of the hardest songs to sing... for a man, for woman instead is quite simple =) however I mean for a singer.

  • Nice voice!!! and nice cover!! bohemian rhapsody has a really difficult hhigh voice notes. So for me its an excellent effort by her

  • This is cute.

  • this is fucking gorgeous!!

  • is it just me or she is untuned sometimes? :s

    anyway, it was good

  • @GranRuc

    like where? Sounds okay to me. I read somewhere that people love working with her because she hits pitch immediately, without first starting and quickly rising up to the note which is very common in vocalists.

  • @littlegoobie not just that but she does it without wearing hearing aids that are so common these days.

  • i agreee queen did it the best but she did ok hear few missed notes .

  • please no comparisions with the original...that would be insulting but nice vocals

  • Agreed. This is a good effort, but the original just sits on its own level. Its just one of THOSE songs that cant be bettered by a cover.

  • her high notes (which really arent very high) sound uncomfortable.

  • She has an amazing voice, and did a great job singing this song. Not so good at the INXS songs, though.

  • If she was not so good on the INXS songs, it doesn't say much for the others, as she was by far the best

  • Not bad...prefer Freddie Mercury but this was enjoyable in its own right.

  • I've hear this song covered by Axl Rose & Paul Rodgers and Both have not perfectly nailed it like Freddie. However this was an awsome performance.

  • How many songs out there (but for Hendrix's "All Along the Watchtower"), are really better than the original?

    On the the whole, nothing beats an original! (song, movie, etc.)

  • 5+  5+

  • She was great, had her own style but still sounded good doing the INXS songs (especially Bitter Tears). I was pissed when she was booted from the show.

  • best performance of this song i've seen!

  • if you mean better then queen go fuck your ass through your face ya dick

  • umm, did i say better than queen? no darling.

  • i don't want to sound racist, but black people can't sing the song, it sound very gospel instead of operatic

  • goosebumps!

  • has anyone noticed how she changed since the first time we saw her sing to now (2009)? same bright smile though! (=

  • to bad she didnt do the whole song

  • how the hell did she not win!?!?!?!? that made me so mad

  • Nossa que privilégio ouvir isso .Acredito que o Freddie se orgulharia muito de ver a sua música estrela maior sendo tocada e lembrada assim .Parabéns veneramos nosso amado Freddie Mercury sempre .Forever

  • Is she famous in the US at all?

    I know she gets a lot of radio play here in Canada, but I'm curious how she's fared on the other side of the border.

  • she isn't unknown, but she's not as big as she is canada.

  • ive havent heard her since the show aired. too bad though shes an amazing singer

  • So I guess she hasn't made it in the States then.

    She's on the radio all the time where I live. On tv too. She does a commercial for some quit smoking product and she hosts a tv show on YTV.

    And her song "Believe" is sort of the unofficial anthem for the Canadian Olympic athletes.

    youtube com/watch?v=aByA-svpXYw

    These are some of her other singles:

    watch?v=QnvpePY8BKU

    watch?v=Pr3smyE88QQ

  • this show like made her, shes way awsome and famous now

  • they REAAAAALLY need to make another season of this show. this is SOOOO much better than american idol. I honestly couldn't watch american idol after this show...just seemed amateurish.

  • I agree completely! American Idol pales in comparison!

  • @maverick6589 Agreed, this was one of the best shows ever on television. And this performance is one of the best I've ever seen on television. One interesting thing about it is I think it is the first time it have ever been performed live, including the choral part. When Queen did this song they would leave the stage and let the recording of them singing it (with over 100 overdubs) play. Suzie is great, RockStar was great, the House Band was great. YES, bring it back!

  • Definitely, this house band was freakin awesome. They had to learn up to 12 songs a week, arrange them, and played them very, very well.

  • I just remember that this house band was awesome

  • Okay, I thought the vocals were inferior to the original by Freddie Mercury, with the possible except of the transition into the rock break ("Beelzebub...."). That was sexy. I'm not even going to bother comparing or criticizing the opera part, since Queen never tried to perform it live. But I actually prefer many of the instrumentals of this version over Queen's.

    Both of them are really good, but I still prefer the original; nobody can sing this song as expressively as Mercury did.

  • They performed it live at Wimbledon in 1986.

  • What was this for? I wish she could have performed the full song....

  • for a t.v. show called Rockstar INXS.

  • She has an amazing voice, i believe this sounds better than Queen's original version of the song, even though they have Freddie Mercury.

  • She has a good voice and it was ok.

    Now for you to say that she sounds better than Queen's original, you have shit for brains. And I mean, a huge pile of shit and no brains whatsoever. As dumb as a doorknob, dumb dumb dumb. How fucking dare you compare anyone to Queen? Freddy Mercury didn't have a voice, he had a musical instrument disguised as vocal cords. The guy was a genious musically as well as a great singer.

    Dumb, dumb dumb dumb.

  • totally agree with you!!! she couldn't even hit some of the notes that only freddy could hit!! for anyone to compare her to freddy on this song, she did ok but nothing special.

  • Baloney from Maloni, it was the Queen's drummer who hit the high notes, Queen didn't even perform the whole song live.

  • who gives a flying fuck who hit the high notes, it was the whole band queen in general that worked together as a team to make this fucking song awesome!! and for your info l don't like baloney.....lmfaoooooo!!

  • Ah maloni, maybe you should have been more accurate in the first place. So it was the whole House band and Suzie in general that worked together to make this ******* version of the song so awesome.

  • whatever you say buddy...

  • I love the arrangement and instrumentals...

  • amazing

  • great!  <3

  • so amazing!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

  • aweeeeeeeesooooomeeeeeeeeee!!!­!!!

  • This is one of the videos I wish I could rate 6 stars

  • this is one of those songs very much like "Metal Health" and "Blackened" where when the riff begins, your head involuntarily begins banging. dunno why it is.

  • one of d best rendition of d song n from a female.. she rock it!!its a memorable performance til now..

  • She should have won, lol...they wanted a guy--for sure she was the best singer in that line up--whatch her video 'I Believe," for the upcoming 2010 Olympics in Vancouver....it is awesome, I believe.

  • where is the raise in tone 2:05? :O atleast an octave too low

  • For a female vocalist on this song she was fantastic. Plenty of vocal power and attitude.

  • that was amazing

    she can kick some ass

  • wow. this is GREAT, but nothin compares to Queen

  • When she hits the chorus she rocks it!

  • ruka415,the girl play mui biem,wonderful.maravilhoso,oti­ma,very good.,

  • excelente,very good,muito bem cantado.nota 8,5

  • wonderful,mui biem,otimo, i like,maravilhoso.(Brazil)

  • why? is there a reason? cuz hating is not good....

  • what? are you a 5 year old???

    "hating is not good...."

  • yea... how did you know...? but in a day i'll be six! my sis helped me type.

  • youre an idiot!?!?!?!?!?!?

  • I love this one.....

  • One of the best Bohemian Rhapsody copy i've ever heard.

  • Comment removed

  • @dotjolt Freddie Mercury would definitely approve

  • Very decent effort overall, It's not really a big deal for a woman to sing this song as it fits in their natural vocal range. Real beauty is for a man to sing this range in modal voice without getting into falsetto. And Fredie is the man and it is much more than the range when he sings it.. the magic in the voice..

  • so canada is known for singers like neil young

  • ow the comments are so toned down--do you not know great vocals, yes spectacular dnamics when you her them?

    Keep it up Suzie--love you!!

  • no one like freddy...sorry

  • duh....that doesnt mean people can't sing his songs....imitation is the best form of flattery

  • Horrible video quality.

  • i belive it isn't as difficult as for a man to sing this song, women can reach the higher notes better.

  • shes really good

  • nn male

  • Saw her live on New years eve in Toronto, shes really talented.

  • Suzie è proprio una mezzasega

  • I'm totally in this video. 2:22 Black guy rocking out FTW

  • what show was this on?

  • Rockstar INXS

  • rockstar INXS

  • ooooo que pesados

  • 1:20 till 2:00 is awful but the rest is very good. Love her voice but this is not the right song for her

  • ..............................­..

  • Me encanta la voz y el grupo es muy bueno, todos estan muy compenetrado, la proxima save to love un saludo

  • HAVE YOU GUYS SEEN HIM LIVE?! i've had the honor of a masterclass wif the band and lemme tell you, Rafael is one of the best guitarists out there wif the chops and the heart..

  • I usually hate queen covers because well no one has been remotely close to as good as them but I love this cover

  • You can't compare this to the original, but it was probably the best cover of it I've ever seen.

  • nothing really matters to me...

  • Start was bad,but then she realy startet to sing good.

  • Urm... Greatest song ever.

  • The house band was so much better than INXS or supernova

  • her voice is a little too low, but that was good

  • powerful and kinetic... can't say much more than that...

  • ^_^

  • quite good

  • i loved that show it was amazing soo was she!!

    i was soo pissed she did not win

  • AMAZING!

  • TORONTO CANADA FOR THE WIN !

  • AWESOME! goosebumps

  • hell yes canada!! two in the top four!! and a winner!!

  • I LOVE HER!!!! SHE'S SO AWESOME

  • I like what she did with the song but I don't really like the tone of her voice. She's not even that good, in my opinion.

  • para mi gusto el mejor cover de bohemian rhapsody el de elton jhon y axl rose

  • she was on rockstar inxs finish at 4th and she did wwry

  • No one beats Queen!

  • Who is Suzie McNeil?

  • you are an idiot

  • charlyenance is an idiot. Suzie McNeil was a contest on an American Idol like contest to find a lead singer for a worthless INXS band. she was one of the top 5 contestants, and did a great job obviously with this song.

  • is she meat in wwry musical?

  • well obviously it wasn't her intention to beat the original, but she did pretty well

  • in my opinion she was better than the original i mean it's hard to top queen but i did love suzie mcneil

  • She did a good job with it, but you can't beat the original.

  • I like her version, but i think that the Zawajus´is better. They made a concert in my city and it was awesome!

  • disgrace

  • Urghh

    This song should have

    been buried with Freddie.

    No one else should have the

    right to sing it besides him,

    and to Ghob1317, I don't really

    give a fuck what you think.

    This is MY opinion and you cannot

    criticize me for it.

  • ok, its your opinion, but still, anyone can sing it, just say what you like and dontlike and be on with it :P

  • she xcame to my school, to visit our school's rock band. no one knew who she was. lol

  • To 54spiritedwill54. You don't know anything about music. A true musician not only knows how to write their own music from their heart, such as Freddie and Queen, but a true musician also must know how to learn a piece of music and interpret it with their own personality. You, spiritedwill, are and epic fail for saying that Freddie "should only sing it" and know nothing about a true musician.

  • shame

  • i would like to ask, was constantine (american idol 4) the first person to sing bohemian rhapsody on an american reality tv show? coz it seems like every1 occasionally followed year by year after tat

  • he wasn't the first to sing it. The first to sing it was Vanessa, season 2.

  • this was a queen song... only freddie should sing it

  • wow....she didn't do all that well in the competition, but she actually did really well on this song. I'm glad they let her do an encore :-)

  • this is merely my opinion. i don't like her voice. i mean she can sing well but the song will never be as good with a feminine voice.

  • I love suzie she's so awesome!!

  • Middle part was terrible but the rest was AWESOME!

  • callenla mercury debe estar revolcandose en su tumba por oir como interpretan una de sus mejores obras maestras ademas no la canta completa.

  • eso es una burla pa queen y mas para freddy mercury

    no se olviden que tiene que ser rock no pop

    y por lo menos cantar bien la pasrte del juicio

  • Oh really eltrompeta333, u prefer the original? Who doesn´t?! Can´t compare to the original, take it for what it is. She rocks the house anyway and did a good job!

  • she is sexy

  • excelenteeeeeeeee