i agree almost completely up until that last conclusion. individualism i think is crucial to that richness of difference that people like butler revindicate. the idea of everyone helping everyone as some sort of imperative above and beyond anything else is potentially destructive.
The one thing i really learn from this interview is that, this is how a great philosopher think and construct ideas, questions about what "it means for us to take a walk" even the word "walk" itself is crucial, for what does "walk' means for someone with physical disability?
I really enjoyed this interview, and I love the works of Judith Butler, but I can't help but feel she spends the whole interview restating what Sunaura says.
That having been said, though, there's definitely something to be said for the fact that Butler is eager to listen to and try to conceptualise the lived and expressed experiences of Sunaura, as a disabled person, within a philosophical context, rather than just pontificating to her about what her own experiences should mean.
I found the "human interdependency" question quite provoking. Everyone does need help, and it's quite alienating to think about life without it. Although, the extent to which we rely on one another is quite shallow, and to see more of it exercised would be a nice change. I worked at a coffee shop before and served an impaired woman by getting the change out of her purse for her, refilling her water and holding it to her mouth, and wiping her mouth after she had eaten the cake she purchased.
If somebody like Judith Butler were asked: what is this? She would never say: this is a bottle of tea. She would say: If we accept the metaphysical notion of language identifying objects clearly and, then, taking all this into account, may we not risk the hypothesis that, in the conditions of our language game, this can be said to be a bottle of tea? Zizek!
@timetochilli I think that any member of a society that feels in some way not respected or whose rights are not respected may still relate to gay community struggles and to the work that judith has done. Her massage is not only the guy community . its much more than that-it is trancedental
DAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAMN JUDITH YOU FINE PIECE OF ASS!!!
(alright, sorry, I had to throw some bad taste joke, I`m actually a fan of Gender Trouble and I`m very excited because Mrs. Butler is giving a lecture in my country in a few weeks)
this was interesting..reminded me of the book by ralph pettman 'going for a walk in the world': i have had interesting experiences as someone who is part Japanese and I look that way as well. When I asked for a glass of water at a fast food counter...the girl serving me wanted to charge me for it. When I asked what I was paying for...she claimed that it was the ice. I felt like dousing her with the contents of the cup I had in my hand. But, I didn't. I also found I didn't have 50cents..
Our religion of seeking happiness in acquisition of STUFF and supremacy of the creed of greed leaves no room for those who are different. Materialism means worshiping the perfect body, perfect orgasm, perfect drink, perfect house...Illusion of course. Since the essence of happiness is not material. Essence of human is not the body nor the brain.
True happiness is not wealth or power but being in the assistance of others.
If only more people would be as open minded as Butler.
Our religion of seeking happiness in acquisition of STUFF and supremacy of the creed of greed leaves no room for those who are different. Materialism means worshiping the perfect body, perfect orgasm, perfect drink, perfect house...Illusion of course. Since the essence of happiness is not material. Essence of human is not the body nor the brain.
True happiness is not wealth or power but being in the assistance of others.
i agree almost completely up until that last conclusion. individualism i think is crucial to that richness of difference that people like butler revindicate. the idea of everyone helping everyone as some sort of imperative above and beyond anything else is potentially destructive.
fede2 5 days ago
Wow, Sunaura is totally out doing Judith in relevance here.
molkomolkomolkomolko 1 week ago
Individualism is the most important aspect of society. When individual rights are lost, so is society.
R6Mike88 3 weeks ago
Shopping with Judith Butler for the queer eye is a show I want to watch! But seriously, this is an important video.
gynoid3000 1 month ago
great video thanks
MrBrucebracey 1 month ago
you have some great stuff here
khijasmith 1 month ago
omegapoint777 and MrDonneiDarko are Fascist, SS, Nazis.
jordnds 2 months ago 2
@jordnds chillaaxxx
vokuvoku 1 month ago
This has been flagged as spam show
fucking dyke bitch
baphomet58 2 months ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
they don't have kids or will ever have kids, why should we believe they care about the future?
MrDonneiDarko 2 months ago
video put me right to sleep
thejuggernautbitch7 2 months ago
Comment removed
thejuggernautbitch7 2 months ago
The one thing i really learn from this interview is that, this is how a great philosopher think and construct ideas, questions about what "it means for us to take a walk" even the word "walk" itself is crucial, for what does "walk' means for someone with physical disability?
climacool85 3 months ago
I really enjoyed this interview, and I love the works of Judith Butler, but I can't help but feel she spends the whole interview restating what Sunaura says.
That having been said, though, there's definitely something to be said for the fact that Butler is eager to listen to and try to conceptualise the lived and expressed experiences of Sunaura, as a disabled person, within a philosophical context, rather than just pontificating to her about what her own experiences should mean.
dROUFrank 3 months ago
i agree with you sullen boy!
sledovane 4 months ago
These are some lazy ass filmmakers.
there's just getting eminent thinkers and filming them walking or whatever.
Sure walking is relevant here, as well as zizek at the garbage dump,
But filmakers could be waaaaay more creative than this.
sullenboy1o3o 5 months ago
@sullenboy1o3o It seems as if these films are less about art and more interested in conveying ideas through a form of media.
Debordsbullet 3 months ago
Hahaha oh judith "for the queer eye" lol.
palkom13 6 months ago
oh my god! justin bieber.......
depressedcoon 6 months ago
I found the "human interdependency" question quite provoking. Everyone does need help, and it's quite alienating to think about life without it. Although, the extent to which we rely on one another is quite shallow, and to see more of it exercised would be a nice change. I worked at a coffee shop before and served an impaired woman by getting the change out of her purse for her, refilling her water and holding it to her mouth, and wiping her mouth after she had eaten the cake she purchased.
Refinnejam 7 months ago 3
To tgs41 I think she's referring to deleuze and guattaris anti Oedipus
DrMVUA 7 months ago
Judith Butler looks kinda like Andy Warhol here. That's pretty awesome
anarchovendean 7 months ago
can anyone find a link to the deleuze essay she's discussing?
tgs41 8 months ago
I think this goes at the very heart of the debate between welfare and socialist ideals and capitalist individual ideals, very interesting
djamorpheus 8 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
If somebody like Judith Butler were asked: what is this? She would never say: this is a bottle of tea. She would say: If we accept the metaphysical notion of language identifying objects clearly and, then, taking all this into account, may we not risk the hypothesis that, in the conditions of our language game, this can be said to be a bottle of tea? Zizek!
stephenblackman2003a 9 months ago
Such a beautiful person, to think that someone may have thought she was too much of a burden on a family/society to bring into the world.
browilliams 10 months ago
I would love to spend a day with Sunaura Taylor
lamaya43 10 months ago
I love San Francisco. I'm so glad they decided to shoot this in the Mission District. peace, JCF
JEF2293 10 months ago
I met Sunaura and the director, Astra in a cafe!! Wonderful people!
Check out Sunarua's art and activism!!!: sunaurataylor dot org
(can one not post hyperlinks?)
Dorciainred 10 months ago
wonderful humans,id like to walk with them.
meyiyiyi55 11 months ago 2
Judith Butler isnt only an important person with all the researches she's done, she's also really hot !
Mael3rd 11 months ago 16
@Mael3rd
She important person? In what? In phylosophy or in you life or life in society?
akma632 6 months ago
@Mael3rd this sounds like it belongs on a Feminist Ryan Gosling meme
ubermensch826 1 month ago
people like judith butler took lesbian and gay issues and concentraated only on dat and forgot about others rights
timetochilli 11 months ago
@timetochilli How exactly? This video focuses mainly on how people with disabilities are viewed in our culture.
iggystardustable 11 months ago
@timetochilli I think that any member of a society that feels in some way not respected or whose rights are not respected may still relate to gay community struggles and to the work that judith has done. Her massage is not only the guy community . its much more than that-it is trancedental
aniamourinho 8 months ago
DAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAMN JUDITH YOU FINE PIECE OF ASS!!!
(alright, sorry, I had to throw some bad taste joke, I`m actually a fan of Gender Trouble and I`m very excited because Mrs. Butler is giving a lecture in my country in a few weeks)
WetKant 11 months ago
this was interesting..reminded me of the book by ralph pettman 'going for a walk in the world': i have had interesting experiences as someone who is part Japanese and I look that way as well. When I asked for a glass of water at a fast food counter...the girl serving me wanted to charge me for it. When I asked what I was paying for...she claimed that it was the ice. I felt like dousing her with the contents of the cup I had in my hand. But, I didn't. I also found I didn't have 50cents..
kingofaikido 1 year ago
Brilliant.
Filming done so well too! Walking - wonderful metaphor.
And thanks for the quality captioning (my language being deafened).
siglmgga 1 year ago
Our religion of seeking happiness in acquisition of STUFF and supremacy of the creed of greed leaves no room for those who are different. Materialism means worshiping the perfect body, perfect orgasm, perfect drink, perfect house...Illusion of course. Since the essence of happiness is not material. Essence of human is not the body nor the brain.
True happiness is not wealth or power but being in the assistance of others.
If only more people would be as open minded as Butler.
ManACanadian 1 year ago
Our religion of seeking happiness in acquisition of STUFF and supremacy of the creed of greed leaves no room for those who are different. Materialism means worshiping the perfect body, perfect orgasm, perfect drink, perfect house...Illusion of course. Since the essence of happiness is not material. Essence of human is not the body nor the brain.
True happiness is not wealth or power but being in the assistance of others.
ManACanadian 1 year ago
Think of all the things Judith has done for the world... I think se is a beautiful wonderful person. Judith I love you, I thank you!
TheMamadeira 1 year ago
wonderful.
rachelry 1 year ago
judith butler is absolutely AMAZING.
zitorage 1 year ago
@zitorage
i don't think too. She is dangerous women with very dangerous thouths...
akma632 6 months ago
@akma632 As Iggy Pop said: give me danger!
chapero1 6 months ago
@chapero1
))))
akma632 5 months ago
Michael Douglas
Dawgtha 1 year ago
Good documentary. And I really liked this part :)
koddinn 1 year ago 8
Comment removed
Themechanicalunicorn 1 year ago