Added: 3 years ago
From: paulXray
Views: 543,556
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:
see all

All Comments (352)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • fuck this shit. if u wanna b somebody, dont go to talent shows. no matter how good u r.

  • Nice cover

  • Molto bella! Bacio dalla Toscana! Kiss from Tuscany ;-)

  • you have to do with that feeling sings

  • CLASSY

  • I'd would have liked to seen her perform Leather and Lace by Stevie Nicks while realizing this is a past video her voice would have fit this song.

  • help us get brooke to preform at the 2012 powellapalooza!

  • she reminds me of my school nurse, she also a singer

  • she is really cool! xD

  • Brooke has so much class. this song was so smooth and so natural.

  • i love you Brooke!! this version is great and also you are beautiful!!

  • she looks so serious when shes hearing the judges. kinda cute

  • this is my favorite song brooke sang on idol!!

  • @MsMINDYLEE you suck.

  • @MsMINDYLEE nd ur rude. hush

  • besides good talent, shes pretty :D

  • Life is not Fair, Brooke should have won!

  • best.

  • Dammit girl... i fell in lov with u... shame u didnt won the hole thing but i think u can be a super star =D

  • she has the ability to appear relatively smart, has a nice smile and what a babe. If she didn't win the winner will blow my mind...

  • her voice is sexy and she can play the piano thats for sure... 

  • WOW, what a great voice.

  • I still love her. What a talent

  • Love her, should be a mega hit, why isn't she???? Not a great song for her, as she is clearly not in her comfort zone. I agree totally with Randy's comments.

  • Love her, should be a mega hit, why isn't she???? Not a great song for her, as she is clearly not in her comfort zone.

  • Love her, should be a mega hit, why isn't she????

  • Nice one!

  • I little bit don't like her voice but I really like her, when she played piano !!!!  amazing ! :3

  • She goes to my church. lol she's much prettier in person

  • @mariavera10 wow thats cool

  • @mariavera10 give her regards from Sarajevo-Bosnia

  • This isn't just about 'oh you're a better singer.' It's about being a genuine artist, how you put together the music, how you present it. Brooke was able to give herself through her music, that's why everyone loved her, not necessarily because she was a super awesome vocalist. She was real, same with Jason Castro and the majority of season 7 contestants.

    And people need to get over the whole Kris Allen thing, everyone knows who was better, you can only beat a dead horse so much.

  • Seriously! KRIS ALLEN is probably one of the most rotten winners of AI. Maybe next to Taylor Hicks. I Mean, They are not good. Maybe Simon and Randy back then are being gay and gave higher marks to Kris Allen. It's obvious back then That ADAM LAMBERT and DANNY GOKEY should be in the finals and ADAM is the winner. Kris Allen should be in the eight place because HE DOESN"T HAVE THAT MUCH TALENT. ONLY GOOD LOOKS! 2nd Big mistake of AI aside from not choosing CHRIS DAUGHTRY to win in his season.

  • @StreamerStreamer what does this vid have to do with kris allen? um nothing? and he actually is a very good singer. hes a musician he makes his own music. good he one. stop hating.

  • @StreamerStreamer

    Kris Allen was a fantastic singer, so I don't know why people insist on hating him so much. Plus, Adam Lambert and Danny Gokey also had good looks, so the whole teen-girl votes doesn't really work here.

  • brook white is not good at high notes .. but shes a very emotional and talented on low

  • @Metazio True, she is definitely a pure alto...but she has a great voice. I'm an alto so I can sympathize with the "plight of the alto female voice" lol...I like the touch of huskiness her voice has, almost a smoky, sultry feel. Like you, I love that her emotions are so "on the surface" it really makes her performance feel so real.

  • @whatanightmare1 glad we have same thing in mind ^_^.. probably your good too

  • @Metazio Yeah she isn't constantly screaming and belting at the top of her lungs. Most of the belting that the contestants on American Idol do really hurt their voices. I personally like Brooke. She's the kind of artist that I'd like to listen to and her voice is pretty soothing. I appreciate that she isn't always singing the crazy riffing songs.

  • I can sing better than her

  • @Ryan591991 Prove it then.

  • She's not actually that good..

  • I hate this show, always did, never watch it but how in the hell didn't this girl win?

  • SHE SHOULD HAVE WON!

  • More amazing Video Youtube search: Heartland Horror

  • She reminds me Delta Goodrem here - allot.

  • @SaiphMcKey So true hahaha

  • Who one that year?

  • @poocutie4 david cook. it was prob the best year of idol tho. a lot of memorabel super talented people. david archuleta was the runner up michael johns jason castro and carly smithson were all that season and prob the best people on the idol stage no lie. each had a super unforgettable performance. 

  • y dident she win ?

  • She's awesome and beautiful.

  • Perfekt! Bravo...

  • Why oh why does she force the American accent.

  • beautiful..*o*

  • @atomicfriendo Fuck you

  • @SigurdF96 agreed hes a dick isnt he

  • @atomicfriendo ur a fucking dick bro

  • @TannerDiedam Do you actually think I give a shit what a fucking moron like you has to say? Get over yourself, yu stupid bitch.. lol

  • LOVE HER!

  • hard to see what kind of people only be 4th... if i look at the people who won the German edition of that show...

  • Fucking Awsome Miley Cirus Learn from her Awsome job Brooke

  • like this song <3

  • good but not better than the original

  • @veddoid :))

  • I ♥ Brooke White

  • wow she can play by sound. amazing

  • what happened to her anyway? she was good, i expected to see more of her...

  • I wish more performances in Season 9 came close to this. Only very few did.

  • I know her brother weeiirrddd!!!

  • She is the best female singer in this generation, i just love her voice! Shes lovely too =D

  • She is talented, yes. I still haven't heard anyone better than Sting/Police's version.

  • Brooke is twice as good as anyone they had on the 2009 - 2010 Idol Show.

  • It's really good....like her voice and the way she performed

  • good job opportunities.. in a New York fine bar....

  • Season 7 was the best. Season 8 was great too, Kradison <3

  • She regressed. Unlike most - she got worse every week.

    She was my favortie that season... until I realized she peaked and she wasn't going to be good again. After "Let it Be" she just went down hill.

  • Whooops.

  • I love you Brooke! You are going to make it big time!

  • she looks like Didi Benami

  • @rolgin47 agree, i just found out today !

  • @rolgin47 shes prettyiar tho

  • even with the bad start, i really like that she sang this song. It matched.

  • @rosseyanna it wasn't a bad start, it was a good start, she just wanted to make it better..

  • @triis it lasted .oooooo5 of a second. are you seriously complaining about that. Sorry it's not fake like the whole world of music. she's real like a real musician.

  • yes i think it is un proffesional. i havent said anything about hr beeing fake, but it is a bad start.

  • @39willieparker how can you say she is annoying? i dont get it

  • beautiful

  • song and voice are match

  • @39willieparker there were some bad ones remember sanjya or whatever the fuck his name was

  • lmao

  • great voice!

  • the other thing to point out is that the audience completely silent and focused on her and her voice in the beginning. when the band joined in, it lost its authenticity and riveting charm.

  • She looks abit like Blake Lively.

  • how far did she get??

  • Top five :P

  • When the tempo picks up it needs the band. The original has the band join in at that point too. The judges dont know what they're talking about here.

  • that was their point...in the original, the band joined in. she had an original version without them in the way she began the song. having the band jump in made it sound like the original only difference being that a female was singing it.

  • that's just showing she's such a good singer that she can figure out her key without any music behind her. shove off.

  • Still one of the best ever.

  • En reponse à OfficialTheresaCrall: Sa s'appelle le live, l'erreur est humaine ;)

  • What!?

  • Brooke can sing. Why put this video on page 26. You TuBe/Fox/AI Prod. treat past contestants shabby and unfair. This video should be in the front section of season 7 listings, not back pages. They do to Ramiele Malubay, Jason Castro, Carly Smithson, David Archuleta, Kristy Lee Cook. They pick LOW view count and/or put them in back pages or hide in Related Video section. Unfair slanted treatment is written all over YouTube sites.

    Brooke, your voice is unique and you are talented!

  • @LTDJA Ever heared of related videos

  • I love brooke White!!!She can really sing.She has some great songs.I love you Brooke.

  • i love her low voice. shes so talented and has an interesting personality.

  • I love her voice...great talent

  • She should have won, and Alexis Grace should have won this year.

  • If you use itunes, you can click on "info" after you right click each song (I can't remember if thats the button but whcihever one allows you to change song title and artist,) and one of the tabs allows you to pick the time when the song starts so it can skip over

  • she can rely play piano but i don't like her voice..

  • Someone like her did win AI...Kris Allen...

  • @yumimer she was amazing and I thought that Kris Allen sucked, he didnt deserve to win, I think

  • It would've been so much better if the piano and backing instruments were loud enough.

  • And boom goes the dynomite.

  • bom.......................otim­o.

  • She reminds me of my favorite singer/song-writter Carole King... One day someone like her will win Idol.

  • uuhhh yo veo american idol en sony

  • u can use programs like Video Convert Master, so u can cut it from 1:15 to 3:00. good luck

  • Jason Castro?

  • why cant you cut it off yourself dude? it's so easy, i always do the same work :)

  • wow

  • her voice is very different from others and very special. I love it

  • So refreshing to see something different on American Idol, anytime i switch on its that stereotypical R n B artists.

  • i love her version better

  • me2

  • I like that she's multi-talented in that she not only sings but plays the guitar and piano.

  • I like Brooke's voice and choice of songs.

  • what a beautiful performance and a lovely woman!

  • why did i miss this season?

    i love brooke white. hope she comes here in the philippines

  • i dont care what ppl say,I've heard both versions and I like hers better.Its just as beautiful as she is!XDD.tis wonderful.

  • ya. i think the same.

  • @DoodleTaffy are you listening to the same songs. i mean she is beautiful, but the original is way better.

  • STALKER SONG!!!!!!!!!

  • YES!!!!!

  • this is when AI was the shit..the only season that was in my opinion "spectacular"

  • brooke was my favroite! her and danny! amazing!!!!!!

  • its so much better with 3 judges

  • yea no shit, i was thinking the same.

  • i don't mind the extra judge, i just hate kara dioguardi

  • but i think Idol is much better with 3 judges..w/c is randy.paula and simon...i dont hate kara but i dont like her either(as an Idol judge)

  • ya i agree

  • maybe she is not the best choice for a judge but she gave many many great songs and melodies to us all so there is no reason for hate her - i think

  • she's be-u-te-ful

  • no será beautiful ?

  • WHAT A GREAT GIRL !!!

    I LIKE ONE LIKE HER TO GET MARRY ME...

    TEARS IN MY EYES ... WHILE I'm HEARING THE SOUND !!

  • ah man this girl is lovely

  • Come on, she wasn't the BEST singer of the top..

    I liked her too but I didn't think she was going to win..

  • lol it's weird with only three judges..haha

  • She should have won she was the best out of all the idols that season

  • lol I'm getting thumbs down yet even Randy and Simon say once the tempo rose and the band came in, aka "bubblegum pop" the song lost it's charm. You guys give thumbs down just because she is pretty, there is no way you can honestly say that was one of her "better" songs...

  • WTF? So because drums come into a song, it's automatically "bubblegum pop"?

  • true, its a deep and emotional song, when singing this song u need to sing wif ur heart.

  • Absolutely lovely voice!

  • she looks so different with straight hair.

  • absolutely gorgeous either way :)

  • I love brooke white, but it worried me how she always sounded hoarse when she spoke. take care of that voice girl!

  • i love her

  • She's really good, and I really love this song; thanks for posting it.

    This is possibly the sweetest song about a stalker ever, I mean, c'mon, listen to the lyrics: "Why don't see? You belong to me" and "Every bond you break, every step you take, every move you make, I'll be watching you"

    CREEPER!

  • she looks lik a slightly diff and older taylor swift

  • ok???? who cares  lol

  • i remember this where she messed up at the beginning but she is one of those girl who just went on like it didn't even happen.i love how she sings

  • she's amazing:)

  • dammmmmmm she is hot!!!!

  • DEDICATED TO MY DAUGHTER !!

  • i started crying as soon as she started singing (:<3

  • excelent choice to sing

  • what i really loved about this, she messed up on national television and in front of hundreds and started over...that took guts! it also made her more endearing to everyone watching!

  • Her parents look so young

  • I love her hair straight she's gorgeous and a fantastic singer