my god. i would love to act out the entire book if i could find the friends willing to. this scene was brilliant to just hear. poor lotho. anyhow i wish the movie trilogy of lotr was better. it was lacking the most important parts in my opinion and i would have surely loved to watch it longer if there were more scenes in there.
If Peter Jackson had not been so overwhelmed by the project he could have shot extra Material to make a 6 film version for anniversary release
However movies are a creative hi-bred and PJs effort will stand as the definitive Movie version just as Brian Sibley's will always be the definitive Radio Version.
Much as this scene was enthralling in the book I can see why Peter Jackson changed it in the film. This and the Tom Bombadil/barrow wights parts would've extended the length of the film even further and today;s cinema goers just don't have the patience to sit through four hour films anymore
Not Sure how the Stage Version goes but I can just see it being an opera one day,
fjordland 1 year ago
my god. i would love to act out the entire book if i could find the friends willing to. this scene was brilliant to just hear. poor lotho. anyhow i wish the movie trilogy of lotr was better. it was lacking the most important parts in my opinion and i would have surely loved to watch it longer if there were more scenes in there.
justchecknitout4 1 year ago 2
If Peter Jackson had not been so overwhelmed by the project he could have shot extra Material to make a 6 film version for anniversary release
However movies are a creative hi-bred and PJs effort will stand as the definitive Movie version just as Brian Sibley's will always be the definitive Radio Version.
fjordland 3 years ago
Much as this scene was enthralling in the book I can see why Peter Jackson changed it in the film. This and the Tom Bombadil/barrow wights parts would've extended the length of the film even further and today;s cinema goers just don't have the patience to sit through four hour films anymore
Loftier 3 years ago 2
not really, I think most people could probably watch a 6 hour film. If it there was a pause in it. I could...if it's a good movie.
Hermoor 2 years ago
PJ could use this on the directors Cut...
TeeVeeNZ 3 years ago