Like the first 5 times i listen to this i cried like a baby. It's a azamzingly beutiful song with very deep lyrics that you can think about for hours. Joseph Arhturs version is slighty better i think but coldplay does a good work with it. To summerize it all up:
thanks ghost but i was wondering which of the Michael Stipe versions. I checked out the Arthur version and I just didn't feel it. Plust Stipe and Martin are my top favorite vocalist along with Mick Jagger.
I agree... They fit better because his voice sounds like the moody, brooding kinda voice that I feel is associated to this song...Also he sings it much slower.. But all in all I still love coldplay :D
This is a great compilation of art and music. Beg to differ on the 'insult to Joseph Arthur' comment. The lyrics to this song are fabulous - but speaking as a writer, sometimes the writer can't make the words come alive. The combination of Michael and Chris reaches in and grabs my heart. Sunshinewings - really nice job on the video.
Since you had the voice of reason, I gave the Joseph Arthur version another listen. Stipe has him on vocal passion hands down - BUT - Arthur far outdoes Chris Martin there. I just noticed there's a REM/J.Arthur post of this song that I'm going to check out....And Anyway....my hats off to the depth of the lyrics - they do make the song.
nice song i like the original better and gd work on the video can you or anyone tell me the name of the artist whos picture of the cyrstal ball at 1.06 i cant think of hes name? ! o/ peace
Does anyone have the piano tabs of this faboulous song? If yes, I would be so thankful if somebody gave it to me.. :-D Please tell me!! I've been looking for them fo a long time!! THX!
It's not a competition. Michael loves Joseph and in particular this song. He covered it because it's a great song. R.E.M. members don't cover bad songs. its the rules!
Good news for all of you short of money: register at Fulltiltpoker com using the JUSTMORE Referral Code, play poker, and receive exclusively $ 600! But do it now, ´cause I don´t think they will offer this awesome bonus very much longer!! Americans are very welcome there!!
then im going to have to disagree with you. this version is super boring and kinda shallow feeling. when joseph arthur sings it you feel like he cares.
Beautiful work sunshine wings, you presented it so well. It makes me think of innocent perspective i used to have of this world as a child. Everything was so much simpler and beautiful then.
Great job Mayke! Your video clip is super!! I love that song and you picked exactly the perfect pictures for each statement of the lyric. Really great job!
Please, you obviously have access to the internet, so do your due diligence and stop spreading misinformation. Peter Gabrial performig the song, once, at a benefit, does not make it his original. JA wrote it, it is HIS son.
I think this version is just very Cool and its jsut great ... Good singers like Michael Stipe and coldplay, and good speed of this song .. Nice job, it could pretend in any cover :) ...
this version is better than the original one....that joseph sounds sooo booooriiiing. very much american.....wich is - as I already said - very boooriiiiiing an very emotional. Michael & Chris have saved this song by reforming it.
does anyone know where to find the bass tab or know the bassline in this? i play bass but i was wonderin does anyone got it cuz i looked everywhere but yeah great song
I like this one better than Joseph Athur's version, which in my opinion is too slow and cumbersome..... This one books. Plus I like Chris Martin and Michael Stipe's voice better. But that's just my 3 cents.
I liked this, but Arthur's version just has this sense of losing and finding what it important to him. It almost seems like these are two completely diffrent songs
regardless of who wrote it i agree with bertisfan rem are eqaul status of any band and they are timelessly beautiful. Stipe is a truly talented singer.
This si a great song and while i always feel the original writer/performer should be credited as much as possible, this version blows the original out of the water imho. Stipes vocals fit perfectly and lend the song something Joseph Arthur just cant match.
Brilliant lyrics and I love both versions.
mslestancia 1 month ago
Beautiful :)
ProuaSeeJaTeine 3 years ago
Beautiful :)
ProuaSeeJaTeine 3 years ago
Its better than Joseph Arthur's! :)
Kasumi112 3 years ago
This is trully a wonderful song... it's for you, where ever u are... may god's love be with you... always
Wednesday10112007 3 years ago
wow....This song is simply amazing!
A friend of mine can play it on guitar and everytime she plays this song i almost start crying.
Where there pictures from M.C Escher?
Foxikkun 3 years ago
i like this version
genepipper123 3 years ago
Like the first 5 times i listen to this i cried like a baby. It's a azamzingly beutiful song with very deep lyrics that you can think about for hours. Joseph Arhturs version is slighty better i think but coldplay does a good work with it. To summerize it all up:
I LOVE THIS SONG :)
nilhel007 3 years ago 3
i was try to figure out what version of this song i should buy off of itunes, the live or this studio version. any suggestions?
Stbuster31 3 years ago
Joseph Arthur version
ghost491 3 years ago
thanks ghost but i was wondering which of the Michael Stipe versions. I checked out the Arthur version and I just didn't feel it. Plust Stipe and Martin are my top favorite vocalist along with Mick Jagger.
Stbuster31 3 years ago
i know what you meant, lol. Arthur version is the only version to buy mate
ghost491 3 years ago
Go on limewire and get both for free :-)
QWERTYCOCK1 3 years ago
i like rockdog81s version better
9josh182 3 years ago
I like Joseph Arthur's version better
BoredomKills92 3 years ago 9
beautiful.
yarriaga1007 3 years ago
Excellent images with the song. Excellent!!
EternityToNthDegree 3 years ago
Thank you. I appreciate your comment. :)
Best wishes,
Mayke
sunshinewings 3 years ago
I agree... They fit better because his voice sounds like the moody, brooding kinda voice that I feel is associated to this song...Also he sings it much slower.. But all in all I still love coldplay :D
shawnhoong 3 years ago 2
its almost hard to think this version is better. i mean. both are AMAZING. but josephs vocals are better for this song. they fit much better
whitethrash93 3 years ago 3
lets agree tht each version is better depending on what mood your in
shimmy19 3 years ago 3
joseph arthur was soooo much better!!!
PepperMoose 3 years ago 3
Amazing
RiikardHansson 3 years ago
Beautiful
lobenos 3 years ago
really great song!!
orei9110 3 years ago
i think joseph arthur's is way better this one just doesn't seem right it sounds like a robot is singing lol
triplexproductionsxx 3 years ago 2
i love stipe and martin, but joseph arthur's version is so much stronger. I swear it ends chills down my back.
walrusman422 3 years ago
i like the song. Joseph arthur did the original am i correct? Any other versions of it?
audisport 3 years ago 2
Der absolute Hammer Chris Martin macht den unterschied
ThreeManUtdLions 3 years ago
Weiß jemand auf welcher CD finde ich diesen wunderbaren Song finde?
horsevision2008 3 years ago
Haus obst ja?
thriftyh4xx 3 years ago
Very nice video!
It's too amazing to do this kind of video!
The lyrics are intellingent and mature
thank you and bravo!
snancy2008 3 years ago
i dont really like this version...too fast and not really that passionate
the best is joseph arthurs but check out howie days version its better than this
brbrbr1571 3 years ago
i think this version is the best :) (not so boring) but we are different..:)
and Mayke, good work! :D
RenataHorvath 3 years ago
This is a great compilation of art and music. Beg to differ on the 'insult to Joseph Arthur' comment. The lyrics to this song are fabulous - but speaking as a writer, sometimes the writer can't make the words come alive. The combination of Michael and Chris reaches in and grabs my heart. Sunshinewings - really nice job on the video.
CarleeArlee 3 years ago 6
have to disagree i'm afraid.
i think joseph arthur's voice is way better suited to this kind of song. I also think it's lost something in being played slightly faster.
Not to say this is bad, but seems very average compared to the brilliant original.
weirdchild 3 years ago 3
Hi W-child.
Since you had the voice of reason, I gave the Joseph Arthur version another listen. Stipe has him on vocal passion hands down - BUT - Arthur far outdoes Chris Martin there. I just noticed there's a REM/J.Arthur post of this song that I'm going to check out....And Anyway....my hats off to the depth of the lyrics - they do make the song.
CarleeArlee 3 years ago
its good to see that some people on the internet can still hold a discussion without resorting to childish namecalling :)
you reckon you could provide the link for the REM/Arthur post?
would love to give it a look
weirdchild 3 years ago
Really really really beautiful song! Always Coldplay!
afcacantbestopped 3 years ago 2
Michael Stipe made this song great. Neither of them wrote the song, though.
Coldplay sucks!
csrcjr 3 years ago
That is your opinion... Coldplay is not for nothing the best tie of the world;)
afcacantbestopped 3 years ago 2
i love this song (l)
rockskii 3 years ago
yea i dont mean to take anything away from coldplay or stipes they rock but this cover is an insult to joseph arthur
airsofter8888 3 years ago
Most beautiful song. EVER!
May god's love be with you .
bluetallund 3 years ago
This is a great performance from the reat voice of Michael Stipe and together with Chris Martin it makes it a song to sing over and over
toinemaree 3 years ago
It's not Joseph Arthur's "version." It's his song. He wrote it, this is a cover.
Don't give credit where credit is not deserved. I personally don't like this cover anywho, not up to caliber with REM or Coldplay's talent.
ArsEstAevum 3 years ago
to each their own ya?
aardbeigirl 3 years ago
I love this song! Great lyrics!! <3 :-)
Audrey2music 3 years ago
is this being sung by the lead singer from REM?
Luckyisafamilyguy 3 years ago 2
yup
rjept007 3 years ago
joseph arthurs version is much better
c2iabsence 3 years ago 2
I like kit .. thax ^^ , what a wonderful songs ..lolx
StarGazer862 3 years ago
I was caught in between all you want and all you need.
When you showed me myself, I became someone else...
tekata5 3 years ago
prefer joseph Arthur's version
ayeates 3 years ago
good. it's true ... this song is very passionaly.
perkoke 3 years ago
passional
perkoke 3 years ago
Do you mean passionate?
betamick 3 years ago
yes ... sorry ... my english is bad!
perkoke 3 years ago 2
one of the best songs ever :-)
jemp92 3 years ago 3
nice song i like the original better and gd work on the video can you or anyone tell me the name of the artist whos picture of the cyrstal ball at 1.06 i cant think of hes name? ! o/ peace
3flow 3 years ago
That would be M C Escher
cheetahspirit37 3 years ago
yes thats him! niceone thank you friend:)hes art is amazing
3flow 3 years ago
Amazing pictures to an amazing song (and version), thank you for sharing, my friend!
19Nirvana89 3 years ago
a bit of chagall in this video? i think yes....:))) magic paintings...r.-
rg72rp 3 years ago
incredible beauty.roberta
rg72rp 3 years ago
Chris Martin is the only good part cuz hes a pimp
iEatFetusesByDozens 3 years ago
the org is WAYYY BETTER.
this is horrible!!
omgitskelsey31 3 years ago
it doesn't have that certain something that u need in a song
yak52aholic 3 years ago
it doesn't have any treble
naryanr 3 years ago
its beautifull,...
TECstarNR2 3 years ago 2
i love REM but this cover is TERRIBLE!
whiteboyedmund 3 years ago
in aint a cover....
coldplay and the leadsinger of REM are singing this TOGETHER
moron
TECstarNR2 3 years ago
yes it is you clod. the original song is by joseph arthur. thats a little embarrasing isnt it?
whiteboyedmund 3 years ago 2
kinda :P
TECstarNR2 3 years ago
lol.
whiteboyedmund 3 years ago
you guys cracked me up. I am enjoying this beautiful song by 2 amazing artists. ;-)
mountainDreamer 3 years ago
i think stipe pulls it off, but if only rem could still write a song this good.
iscistim 3 years ago
i agree with you, he does it justice and i like the "still" bit of your comment.
tubekillers 3 years ago
i hate this version
no offense but the orginal by Joseph Arthur is much more deep n singin wise
Heyimloved 3 years ago
awesome video for an awesome song :)
rodyspace 3 years ago
FAVOLOSA
paololaura 3 years ago
Does anyone have the piano tabs of this faboulous song? If yes, I would be so thankful if somebody gave it to me.. :-D Please tell me!! I've been looking for them fo a long time!! THX!
Audrey2music 3 years ago
So, the way to do something kinda close,,, get the guitar and bass chords, then make it ur own version:D
Oldwise123 3 years ago
100% English , I like it
shabinot 3 years ago
i really like the original but i love r.e.m. and coldplay and this version is great, i guess it is kind of perfect for me!
Naddi2787 3 years ago 2
the more i listen to this version the more i like it over the original, i wasn't too sure about this one at first, but its actually pretty amazing
Equinoxx7 3 years ago
i love this song sooo much
andresvon 3 years ago
Joseph version is still better... he puts more soul into and only the create can sing it the best
chunkyjb 3 years ago
i think peter gabriel's is the best version...
but this one isn't great at all...
parrecords 3 years ago
actually i havent heard that version
chunkyjb 3 years ago
It's not a competition. Michael loves Joseph and in particular this song. He covered it because it's a great song. R.E.M. members don't cover bad songs. its the rules!
johnnymarrplayguitar 3 years ago 4
amazinnnnnnnng song!
it doesn't get old!
Filll81 3 years ago
very nice video...i think that this version is better than josephs arthur.
seborig 3 years ago
I think it is really cool......
3311969 3 years ago
no where near as good as the original
faz1987 3 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Good news for all of you short of money: register at Fulltiltpoker com using the JUSTMORE Referral Code, play poker, and receive exclusively $ 600! But do it now, ´cause I don´t think they will offer this awesome bonus very much longer!! Americans are very welcome there!!
mikalanz15 3 years ago
May God's love be with you always.
BeginXtheXBegin 3 years ago
Stupenda, la preferisco cantata sa joseph arthur ma il cantante dei rem con i Coldpaly meritano di sicuro :D
wikky85 3 years ago
no hablo ingles pero me gusta mucho este tipo de musica
chiapaneco1284 4 years ago 3
i LOVE it soo much!!!
BorzCica 4 years ago
very nice job !
APOYS 4 years ago
es una de las canciones mas bonitas que he escuchado
nadiabalu 4 years ago
es una de las canciones mas bonitas que he escuchado.
nadiabalu 4 years ago
I like the pictures and song is beutiful
MACPAC256 4 years ago
Beautiful
kousmas 4 years ago
nah do do not know michael stipe or coldplay,this is a brilliant version,love it.
doggingdave 4 years ago
i agree with the joseph arthur version being better bcoz u can hear in his voice that he cares
triplesexmachine 4 years ago
Was this part of the anti war movement?
rrlg1 4 years ago
in one interview joseph arthur says the collaboration with michael stipe / chris martin was for a hurricane katrina benefit show of some sort.
chanelnofyv 4 years ago
yeah it was. thats why you can hear the cheering etc.
shcoon 4 years ago
Thanks. Great song
rrlg1 4 years ago
This is nice and everything
But Joseph Arthur's version is much better
54spiritedwill54 4 years ago 3
i'm going to have to disagree with you there.
shcoon 4 years ago
then im going to have to disagree with you. this version is super boring and kinda shallow feeling. when joseph arthur sings it you feel like he cares.
XkingbisonX 4 years ago 2
hm. *listens again* true... but this version has coldplay in it!
shcoon 4 years ago 2
yeah! i think the best part is the chris martin part..... but .... joe's version is still better!
chanelnofyv 4 years ago
Beautiful work sunshine wings, you presented it so well. It makes me think of innocent perspective i used to have of this world as a child. Everything was so much simpler and beautiful then.
Angaurboy 4 years ago 3
Good job sunshinewings. Thanks for sharing it!!
lobenos 4 years ago
Thanks so much, lobenos. I appreciate your comment!
sunshinewings 4 years ago
love this version---absolutely!!
judyblueeyes 4 years ago 2
this is good, but joseph arther is better
leedsleedsleeds09 4 years ago
For some reason, i absolutely adore this song!
CobraSnake7 4 years ago
Ya... Joseph's version is better by far.
sogaender 4 years ago
Joseph Arthur's is smoother. I like it better.
PIELOVER375 4 years ago
i like joseph arthur's version a lot better
movielovr43v3r 4 years ago
eh, i don't. his voice is a little too 'foggy' for me.
shcoon 4 years ago
*__* Nice.
AutumnCzun 4 years ago
this is good but Arthur's version is better
tankboy8442217 4 years ago
chris martin is great,stipe always the same
bomelito1 4 years ago
If you are insulting Michael Stipe then you need theropy.
bobobrick 4 years ago
yes i agree 2 of my fav bands together,thx realy nice
doggingdave 4 years ago
Great job Mayke! Your video clip is super!! I love that song and you picked exactly the perfect pictures for each statement of the lyric. Really great job!
May God's love be with you! :-)
Audrey2music 4 years ago
i like joseph arthur's version way more, but the song is amazing <3
smartiepants333 4 years ago
inthesunfoundation dot org
yzindel 4 years ago
Enigma+Aesthetic= LIFE JOURNEY
kydazzlingsilver 4 years ago
Sure, buy the CD.
bcrombe 4 years ago
dam, tahts a good song. anyone know where i can download it?
deserttemplar 4 years ago
I like Joseph Arthur's version alot more, but this one is good too.
TwilightPenguin7 4 years ago
I agree. I first heard it on scrubs - and think the song made the show and not the other way around.
joedontwo 4 years ago
joseph arthur wrote the song
beaudeal 4 years ago
the original is actually a peter gabriel song.
erikcam20 4 years ago
Please, you obviously have access to the internet, so do your due diligence and stop spreading misinformation. Peter Gabrial performig the song, once, at a benefit, does not make it his original. JA wrote it, it is HIS son.
stoptheinanity 4 years ago
you do it all the rem now with coldplay?good amazing song
doggingdave 4 years ago
Wow... amazing song
Tyler031791 4 years ago
This is nice and everything
But Joseph Arthur's version is much better
rhi23 4 years ago
this version is much better than joseph´s...michael stipe is the greatest.
BinkyTheDoormat628 4 years ago
great song,great message,great collaboration!:)
paktagoops 4 years ago
yeah joseph arthur kicks ass..but im guttered i cant find a video of it thats very good quality. i still love this song in all its versions tho!
madzn42 4 years ago
joseph arthurs verson of this song is soooo much better, compared to his, this song sucks majorly
NeonRubberDucks 4 years ago
HEY "whirlpoolzend" how to write in search to find that song you recomendnig :) ?
sadnambo 4 years ago
It simply doesn't get any better than this! Stipe and Martin complement each other perfectly. A complete package!
whirlpoolzend 4 years ago
I think this version is just very Cool and its jsut great ... Good singers like Michael Stipe and coldplay, and good speed of this song .. Nice job, it could pretend in any cover :) ...
sadnambo 4 years ago
this version was too quick, didnt show enough emotion
PointlessPeople 4 years ago 2
this version is better than the original one....that joseph sounds sooo booooriiiing. very much american.....wich is - as I already said - very boooriiiiiing an very emotional. Michael & Chris have saved this song by reforming it.
mica77maca 4 years ago
the joseph arthur one is better coz it's more flowing
and i agree it touched me more
spidachikk 4 years ago
does anyone know where to find the bass tab or know the bassline in this? i play bass but i was wonderin does anyone got it cuz i looked everywhere but yeah great song
duketaylor15 4 years ago
coldplay should do a real cover of this, theyd do probably a pretty good job.
cjdawdj 4 years ago
Nae sure of Stipe at the start of the song.
I do however like Chris Martin's vocals on this.
theneepster 4 years ago
THE song of 2006 sung by the two best male singers of our time...
whirlpoolzend 4 years ago
This is the best song ever written!!!Oh stipe is perfect!!!
solidus9000 4 years ago
tears to your eyes
nova920 4 years ago
beautiful song...beautiful images...thanks for posting this!
hope4grace 4 years ago
I like this one better than Joseph Athur's version, which in my opinion is too slow and cumbersome..... This one books. Plus I like Chris Martin and Michael Stipe's voice better. But that's just my 3 cents.
3point1415 4 years ago
I liked this, but Arthur's version just has this sense of losing and finding what it important to him. It almost seems like these are two completely diffrent songs
cornorama 4 years ago
I agree...I like Joseph Arthur's better. It just touched me more
designstar 4 years ago
put it this way rem ledgends
coldplay great
rem are timeless though
great song still
stipes writes good songs anyway, some of wich are much better than coldplay even though i do rate them
omgimanewuser12 4 years ago
i agree! however coldplay have time to get better but i cant see them being as good as REM.
MikeydeB 4 years ago
Who is the other voice in this rendition of the song?
BTW I absolutely love Joseph Arthur's version, and I love this and other covers too! :)
respaldod 4 years ago
chris martin the lead singer of coldplay(Great band)
MikeydeB 4 years ago
Stipe DIDN'T WRITE this song idiot!!!
corijn 4 years ago
regardless of who wrote it i agree with bertisfan rem are eqaul status of any band and they are timelessly beautiful. Stipe is a truly talented singer.
MikeydeB 4 years ago
Michael Stipe is the best thing to come out of America since the Columbus set foot on its soil. He's a true poet
bertisfan 4 years ago
Chris should sing a little more. michael's voice suits the song but i loooove Chris <3. i have his version =]
laceyness 4 years ago
bellissima e anke le immagine se solo nn piangessi tt le volte ke la sento..
lafeggy 4 years ago
This si a great song and while i always feel the original writer/performer should be credited as much as possible, this version blows the original out of the water imho. Stipes vocals fit perfectly and lend the song something Joseph Arthur just cant match.
AllyWheels 4 years ago
The sweetest song I have ever heard,nice combination- Michael Stipe great delivery
ohanlonclan 4 years ago