Added: 3 years ago
From: deathbringer682
Views: 59,806
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (4,018)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • After listening both of these albums about 1000 times i have to say that both are fucking amazing and only bad thing is sound quality particulary in some of the KIMB's solos

    But KIMB is better for headbanging

  • surely METALLICA

  • Metallica is good but Megadeath is God

  • MEGADETH!

  • creo que megadeth, objetivamente los 4 pirmeros discos de megadeth eran opacados por los 4 primeros de metallica, el unico disco que pudo por asi decirlo igualar a uno de metallica fue rust in piece, pero la voz de mustaine se es tan buena como la de hetfield, pero de ahi en adelante megadeth bajo de de 8 a 5 y metallica de 10 a -45666666, megadeth a logrado mantener su nivel pero en los 80 metallica wera la mejor band ami gusto

  • MEGADETH EVER

  • Mustaine wrote both

  • i honestly think that dave mustaine is a better musician than kirk but i still enjoy metallicas music more

  • ala verga hoy dia es mejor megadeth metallica despues de load se convirtio en MIERDALLICA y cada dia terminan por cavar mas su tumba como la colaboracion con lou reed una verdadera mamada

  • las dos bandas son casi lo mismo lo distinto es el ritmo pero el primero fue metallica pero megadeth mejoro el ritmo por la experencia que dave mustiane tomo en metallica !!arriba ambos!!

  • megadeth wins anyways since mustaine helped to compose the only good metallica's songs

    inb4 a metallitard replies with a butthurt comment

  • Metallica e puede gustar sin que te guste el metal pero Megadeth tienes que ser un verdadero Metalero

  • @MegaCesar117 metallica de echo a sido la banda que mas atrae a gente a acercarse al metal cuando en realidad es trash metal al igual que megadeth, pero con letras mas suaves y ritmos tipicos y no tan rapidos comolos de megadeth

  • Megadeth...Haven't you heard St. Anger?

  • who gives a fuck? just stop bitchin and enjoy the work of gods

  • Prefiero a Metallica

    Pero respeto a Megadeth

  • @xXsliipknoteroXx lo mismo digo pues metallica casi casi creo megadeth por que dave estaba en metallica y ahi tomo la experencia para hacer megadeth

  • megadeth fue hecho para ganar mas fama y darle competencia a metallica es mejor best is metallica

  • So its daves great riffs vs Daves great riffs eh? Hmm... I'll go for all of them

  • M E T A L L I C A a webbo

  • megadeth is better than metallica obiously

  • some faggot thinks megadeth ripped off metallica when dave actually wrote the riff

    go to this video and prove this faggot wrong:

    Megadeth rips off Metallica again!

  • I'm gonna have to say Metallica simply for the fact that Megadeth has stolen so many of Metallica's songs

  • @VitalSigns1 sorry but dave mustaine wrote most of the songs of kill em all and one or two from ride the lightning before being fired out of the band so i think he has a right to play his own songs with his own band. Who cares anyway megadeth and metallica are both for me equally awesome

  • Only 3 songs on kill em all are originals: anaesthesia by cliff, seek and destroy by james and lars, no remorse by james and lars. 4 of the ones are by dave. Hit the lights lyrics are by james but guitar written by hugh tanner and lloyd grant. Anyway, Killing is my business is better

  • @yadrition You are a wise man thank fucking God someone else realizes this other than me!

  • megadeth 4ever

  • heeeeeeey , In kill em all Many songs are composed by Dave Mustaine , MEGADETH!

  • Megadethhhhh

  • Metallica FUCKERS!!!!

  • Mustaine is way far better guitarist than kirk...

  • Metallica aun que hay estaba Dave  :S

  • @Metal4Brains, yes but Mustaine wrote most of them, Kirk plays them

  • Solo Time

    Kill em all - all solo Dave

  • MUSTAINE IS WIN!

  • megadeth 4ever

  • megadeth all day

  • i like both albums

  • ur a dumbass bc in kill em all dave mustiane played all the solos not kirk some of the songs onn ride the lightining was his too so get ur facts straight

  • @thrashmetalfreak17

    What the fuck are you talking about? Dave doesn't play all the solos on Kill 'Em All.

  • im just tryin to let you guys know, metallica/megadeth is not that great, and so isn't the thrash metal genre. They did perfect 1 thing though, that is hypocrisy. They try to be heavy,thrashy but it just turns out to be trashy, which makes no music sense whatsoever. mediocre drumming, basslines that 12 year olds can think of, its just decent guitars that can call this a genre. btw if dave sucked in guitar, you guys know megadeth would be even worse than it already is... again, im not favoring...

  • @Altairman117 DUDE SHUT THE FUCK OFF!!! ENJOY THE GODDAMMIT MUSIC!

  • for all the megadeth fans that say "it doesn't matter about the vocals for megadeth", yes it does. As a band, a band is supposed to have a vocalist, a drummer, bass guitarist, and atleast a lead guitarist. pretty much the vocals of megadeth are utter garbage. He has no knowledge in notes. so you might as well take off 25% with that. with metallica, lars ulrich is like the dave mustaine vocals of drumming, terrible. TBH, the guitars are terrible and generic not gonna lie. im not favoring anyof em

  • @Altairman117 Dave's vocals fit the songs. I couldn't imagine it without dave.

  • 80's : Metallica is better !

    90's : Megadeth is better !

    2000's : Megadeth is better !

  • Dave actually made many songs on KILL 'EM ALL before he was kicked out of metallica.

  • @btyrenhagen heres the thing, dave only made the solo's, james wouldnt let him do anything else. and it was that way up until st anger

  • @btyrenhagen he wasnt kicked out he quit to make megadeth

  • @drew3996 no, if you read his biography he said he was kicked out because of his behavior

  • @drew3996 Wrong. 100% wrong.

  • Pfff metallica is megadeth father

  • @Ciborock neee jajajajajaja

  • @Jucermy33 es mejor metallica megadeth solo es para bajar fans a metallica

  • @selk71 jajajajajajajja dave the guitar is practically the album and helped him to do without there would kill em all, fucking ignorant .|.

  • dude "last rites/love to DETH" is one of the best riffs in all the fucking world! who the fuck cant fight with that?

  • the winner is only METALLICA!!!!

    but!!!! DAVE MUSTAINE he's veri coool

  • IMO killing is my business is better, it's so trashy, outstanding, probably in my top 3 of megadeth's best album along with peace sells and RIP. however kill em all is also a great album but, i just don't like it as the way I like killing is my business.

  • I think that they are both great but all the metal and rock bands should team up to destroy the crap music like rap, and hip hop etc. because they tryed to destroy metal and rock forever

  • /V\EGADET}-{!!!!!!!!!!!

    both good though:)

  • megadeth !

  • Half of Kill Em All is Dave Mustaine :D

  • man didnt dave mustaine write like more than half of killem all? infact didnt he kinda carry metallica for a while singing for james hetfield. lotta footage of early mustalica where its pretty much all mustaine, lead guitar and lead vocals. shoulda been like master of puppets vs killing. thats more hammet

  • @thrashfury mustaine co-wrote four of the ten songs on kill em all. phantom lord, metal militia, jump in the fire, and the mechanix (now the four horseman). in my opinion none of those besides the four horseman are the best songs on the album

  • @thrashfury He never did vocals.

  • none of the 90's albums from each band sucked. part of being a musician is testing your musical abilities by trying new things. some fans are too butt-hurt from the fact that their favorite band tried something new and narrow-minded fanboys don't man up and appreciate their music. un-fucking-believable. if that's classified as "selling out" then i feel sorry for you for thinking that because the bands do what they want with their music, regardless of what we think.

  • wow some people on here are idiots. mustaine created metallica's best songs? ya i will call bullshit on that. i'm not taking anything away from mustaine's talents but metallica's best work was on ride the lightning and master of puppets, in which dave did virtually nothing besides co-write the songs ride the lightning and call of ktulu on the album RTL. any metal fan, not metallica fan, would know that ride the lightning and master of puppets are metallica's BEST albums. nothing to do with Dave

  • @abigsandwich123 I couldn't agree more with you. 100% right.

  • DETH

  • Both Albums are as good as one another but the only thing which makes Kill Em All have the advantage over KIMB is the good quality audio and equipment; and Cliff Burton's bass solo.

  • @ZlatanZindabad "...but the only thing..."

    *lists 3 things*

  • @nastyguard007 come on man there are 2 things :P

  • @ZlatanZindabad Equipment and sound quality aren't the same thing. =P

  • SLAYER IS THE BEST TRASH!! .l.

  • K I R K H A M M E T T / W I N N E R / S O L O 

  • M E T A L L I CA W I N N E R!

  • Metallica!

  • and about the Death Magnetic and EndGame

    Death Magnetic debuted in 1º billboard 200, sold 490.000 copies...record sales

    Endgame debuted in 9º billboard 200

  • if either band sucked, they wouldnt be considered 2 of the greatest metal bands ever, its just a personal opinion on which style u like better...its as simple as that....

  • EXODUS

  • METALLICA 1980-1989 RIP

    MEGADETH RULES!!

  • Every peolple came to videos say shit's like"fuck metallica" and "metallica sucks" but or you blind or just cant enjoy havy metal songs, and if you dont like metalllica and mega. you cant say that you are a havy metal guy ! who is the person who say that loves havy metal and only listen megadeath ? or when says the same and just listen metallica ?? The point is, if you like havy metal and enjoy it, you need to be a fan of the both bands, if you dont, you can say that you suck, not them.

  • Megadeth

    

  • DETH TO METALLICA!

  • Judas priest wrote the song called "epitaph" im sure most of you know...so,what do you call them then?sell-outs for trying to sound like elton john?nope..i say they are great musicians who have made "breaking the law" and also songs like "epitaph" reflecting the lighter side of them.

    Black sabbath made "solitude"...so,now the god fathers of metal are sell-outs as well right?

    grow the fuck up people...don't take the musician out of these people...

  • Megadeth is just generic metal..nothing unique..dave always had this inferiority complex that the band he used to be in is the biggest band on earth now and he is no where to be seen in their league.

    It's evident from this video you made and all the bitching megadeth fans have been doing not to mention from dave himself right down to his fans...which says a lot that metallica is more successful and beyond anything megadeth could do...metallica is diverse but megadeth? meh..

  • megadeth yeeaaaaaaaaaaaah

  • @sergiozone888 the world only care about metallica ..sorry

    sad but true..

  • lulu it's not Metallica's album.... fuck man the people are stupid.... the last album made from Metallica is Death Magnetic not LULU. Lulu is from ''Lou Reed'', watch the interview with Lars, he said that Lulu it's not Metallica Album.

  • th1rt3en vs lulu

  • Metallica until the black album...

    MEGADETH IS FOREVER \,,/ \,,/

  • after Lulu, Megadeth and Pantera become my favorites bands

  • someone said 'I hate this kind of music' well thats ok. ur opinion but then 'there is no talent anywhere' ummmm u sure ? then:

    ' justin bieber is the BEST!' FUCK U

  • METALLICA. THE BEST 

  • miren las 2 son bandas grandiosas cada quien por sus justos, y ademas no entiendo esta cuestion de andar enfretandolos

  • the two bands are great!

  • I love Kill Em All. It helped me start off playing metal on guitar when I was starting off. Though Killing is My Business and Business is good made me progress faster than Kill Em All because of how damn technical and faster it was than Kill Em All. Love both albums but Killing is better in my opinion.

  • DAVE IS MORE FAST

  • @jackwilsontube

    it' faster not more fast

  • They are both great (Nowadays only Megadeth), but great part of the goodies of metallica on Kill 'em all was thanks to dave mustaine.

  • well Dave rote 4 songs to Kill 'Em All (Phantom Lord, Motorbreath, The Four Horseman (aka Mechahix) and Metal Militia) so I have to put Megadeth's album as a winner. Even tho I think Metallica is much better than Megadeth.

  • I like both bands equal, but Killing Is My Business kills Kill 'em All. Metallica sounds boring on their early records, the songs are good, but they're recorded with no power at all and bad production, Justice was the first record that ain't boring to listen. Metallica excels in their live performances. Megadeth is more a studio band because of Mustaine's voice live. Killing Is My Business wins this one for me.

  • who is megadeth,no one cares.

    metallica wins as usual

  • @vlmmosto, Haha, think again.

  • @Alex7457 yeah megadeth should rethink there career,you are write.

  • @vlmmosto, Lol no, metallica sold out and megadeth still at the top of their game.

  • @Alex7457 no megadeth are not on top of their game,since when,

    metallica have been dominating the industry for the last 25 years,

    come on ,admit that i am right, come on, say it.lol

  • @vlmmosto, Um yes megadeth are still as brilliant, you obviously haven't heard their new album, much better than metallica.

  • @Alex7457 which album 13 and endgame i have them both,

    they are not that great,only the first 2 songs on each albums

    are good,but the rest of the songs on both albums suck,that's

    the probleme i have with most megadeths albums is that

    they always have a good begining to their albums but into it

    from the 3rd song till the end they mostly always suck.

    when metallica make a good album it's good from begining

    till the end. you know i'm right.. by the way lulu is not a metallica album ,

  • @vlmmosto, No i don't know your right, that's just you're opinion, my opinion is megadeth create better music.

  • @Alex7457 yeah but my opinion matters more because it's the majority,

    your opinion dosen't really matter,lol just kidding,,it's all in good fun

  • @vlmmosto, Lol, i like both by the way.

  • @Alex7457 oh i thought you hated them,i guess i'm gonna have to

    like you too now lol. ahhhh....

  • @vlmmosto Metallica hasn't made a great thrash album in about 20 years. Megadeth just made one.

  • @austin2460 metallica only made 1 thrash metal album kill em all,

    ride the lightning was half thrash half metal,also mop and justice

    albums was pure metal,i don't think they are interested in making thrash

    anymore,they wan't to expand their music and not just play fast all the time,

    and i agree with them,it would be boring to here only fast songs all the time,

    like slayer for example,it gets boring after 20 minutes of hearing songs at

    100 miles an hour all the time,but that's just me..

  • sticking to old albums (Kill em all,Ride the lighting,Master of puppets,...And justice for all) metallica kicks megadeth's ass. comparing newer albums (Black Album,Load and Reaload and i havent kept up with any past then) megadeth kicks metallica's ass. both kick ass bands. hard to decide a winner

  • why does everybody diss metallica for trying a new style of music,i mean the black album was amazing and sold more than megadeth could ever dream of having, sure load and reload werent that great but so what,st anger and death magnetic were both amazing albums!

  • hey guys remember megadeth wins this round because dave rote most of the stuff on kill em all

  • why no mechanix??? that would have been a perfect example on all of them.

  • wow... you had to use metallcia's worst ablum XD

  • the solo on the one megadeth song isn't mostly in rhytm with the drums, wtf i was shocked. was the drummer that bad in megadeth before.

  • Metallica! ;D

  • Dave is awesome and so is james, in their own way, but Metallica pales in comparison because of Kirk, his lead guitar work is nothing compared to the virtuosity of Megadeth's various lead guitarists. I think Kirk needs to be informed by Marty Friedman, Chris Poland, Al Pitrelli, and Jeff Young that there are other scales to solo with than the minor pentatonic.

  • }v{egadeth

  • megadeth forever...

  • MEGADETH metallica are sellouts

  • Megadeth all the fucking way

  • EVERYTIME THIS TOPIC COMES UP ( WHICH IS USUALLY IN EVERY VIDEO FOR BOTH BANDS) I ALWAYS SAY THAT ITS A VERY CLOSE CALL...I THINK MEGADTEH IS BETTER THOUGH!!

  • If you like speed-type technical metal = Megadeth

    If you like power-type well-composed metal = Metallica

  • good, It's is so fun, Metallica is better of course. Do you want to know why? ok, Metallica musics is very very very better, the solos is better, Metallica sold more than 140 millions of discs while Megadeth 30 millions only. the people say that Mustaine did some musics of Metallica, OK it's true, but what musics? only ride the lighting and the four horsemen the others James Hetfield did. Metallica is better!!!

  • @evertonredbull lol dude selling more albums doesn't mean a band is better. And Megadeth has way better solos than Metallica. Listen to Tornado of Souls and you'll know what I mean. Also, Metallica released shit albums after the Black Album. Megadeth has been much more consistent in releasing good albums. Plus James Hetflied lost his metal voice a long time ago and now all he does is sing, which is annoying as fuck. With that said, both bands are great, but Megadeth is obviously better.

  • @HotCheetoAddict trolololololololololololololol­olololololololololol Metallica pwns the shit out of Megadeth! The solos in Metallica is awesome too. Better than Dave could have made them. Kirk only sucks at live performances -.-

  • @Metadeth1997 Dude come on, have you realized that Megadeth beats the shit outta Metallica nowadays? And they do NOT beat all of what Megadeth has put out in the 90s. Rust In Peace and Countdown tops the Black Album like shit! I like Metallica also ( mostly early Metallica ) but just look at the facts man. Metallica may have had Megadeth in the early days but from the 90s on down, Megadeth ruled.

  • @Metadeth1997 Dude, live performances is were you are supposed to be good...

  • @Metadeth1997 Ha ha Kirk can fiddle around in the studio, how impressive, but can't perform well on lead guitar live? Isn't that a bit of an issue? I might say some of Megadeth's lead guitarists solo better live.

  • @HotCheetoAddict

    hm listen to eye of the beholder, fight fire with fire, master of puppets, fade to black, enter sandman, one, metal militia, and justice for all, ride the lightining, for whom the bell tolls, damage inc..... hahahah several musics

    Metallica better of course...

  • Comment removed

  • Metallica forever, sorry megadeth but I say you suck ass.

  • Metallica was the best in the 80s. Megadeth was the best in the 90s. Now they both suck.

  • @HotCheetoAddict Buy Endgame, listen to the first track, and realize your comment failed. Then listen to the whole album, and commit suicide cause you posted this comment. Just kidding man but honestly if you're a fan of thrash Endgame will change how you think of megadeth.

  • @cheetok1ng470 lol there's no denying that recent Megadeth albums kick ass. the problem i have with them is that dave's voice is gone now. he sounds like shit live. but at least his voice was good up till now, unlike James who has sounded like shit for a long time. btw im not a big fan of Chris Broderick, his solos are very boring to listen to. wish Friedman was still in the band.

  • @HotCheetoAddict Justice era Hetfield as vocal with Mustaine as lead guitarist? That was just be...sex

  • @HotCheetoAddict no, Metallica best in the 90s with the black album

  • @Metadeth1997 what about load and reload? those albums sucked. and the black album isn't even that great when compared to the awesomeness of master of puppets or ride the lightning. Megadeth released rust in peace, countdown to extinction, youthanasia, and cryptic writings in the 90s, which were all great albums. Metallica released 1 good album and 2 shitty ones in the 90s. megadeth's only bad ablum in the 90s was Risk, otherwise they had 4 awesome ones. Megadeth ruled the 90s.

  • @HotCheetoAddict metal didn't rule the 90s grunge did

  • @HotCheetoAddict In my opinion, Load didn't suck, it's just a question whether you like that kind of music or not. Reload had way more filler content than killer content. Cryptic Writings isn't really my taste, I don't think Mustaine can sing those kind of songs. Youthanasia still kills Load and Reload though, and can't choose between CtE or Black. Still, Death Magnetic over Endgame, and Th1rt3en over Death Magnetic.

  • @MasterofKnees Endgame KILLS Death Magnetic, KILLS. That intro of Headcrusher alone kills entire Death Magnetic which is incredible boring album. And Thirteen kills it even more.

  • @HotCheetoAddict

    yeah!they are good albums only for you megadeth fans which is limited to your circle..load and reload are great albums which is more personal to james and deals with the scars of the injuries he got inflicted upon during his childhood and the troubles within.

    Just listen to it as a music fan not a metal fan.You guys typify the most well-known sterotype that metalheads are narrow-minded...what?a band can't write songs that are honest and more personal?

  • @coolpratheek dude I love Metallica. Master of Puppets and One are my favorite metal songs. I'm just saying Metallica went to shit after the Black Album, unlike Megadeth who have stayed much more consistent in releasing good music. 

  • @HotCheetoAddict

    whoa!so,music which is not "metal" is not consistent and good music?wow!so,you're saying the beatles,led zeppelin,frank zappa,elton john etc. are shit because they don't make metal music?

    heck!even judas priest and black sabbath are shit according to you coz they made songs like "epitaph" and "solitude" respectively.

    Dude, you're a metal-head indeed.

  • @coolpratheek i never said that the beatles and led zeppelin are shit because they dont make metal music. did you not read my comment? what you just said made no sense. i listen to all types of music idiot. and i love led zeppelin and the beatles.

  • @HotCheetoAddict

    The reason metal bands are limited to only a few audience is because they don't play anything outside the things they know-fast riffing,solos,war,anti-govt. themes which are all generic..but exploring different horizons of music is what makes a band potent and can be called musically talented.Metallica is one such band who are great musicians which is why they rose above all their metal brethren and became the greatest band on earth reaching to wider audience...

  • @HotCheetoAddict Another fanboy...

  • @MrHellman777 I'm not a fanboy I like Metallica too.

  • @HotCheetoAddict i'll agree with that. but i still like metallica better

  • 80s Metallica > Megadeth

    90s Megadeth > Metallica

    00s Megadeth >> Metallica

    10s Megadeth >>> Metallica

  • SEEK AND DESTROY, Hit The Lights, Motorbreath, Whiplash, No Remorse.......SON LOS SOLOS 100% DE HAMMETT Y LAS DEMAS CANCIONES TAMBIEN EDITO LOS SOLOS Y LOS ISO MEJOR

  • alone in the wins by large metallica

  • Singer: Dave mustaine

    Lead guitarist: Chris Broderick

    Rythm guitar: dave mustaine

    bass: dave ellefson

    drum: shaun drover

    im sorry megadeth is just better than metallica although i havent listened to the old metallica but kill em all is better than killing is my business

  • @TheJimmypage908 You haven't listened to old Metallica? Just watch this video and it will answer all your questions.

    /watch?v=22W38jJk81s

  • @ProtestAgainstWhores whoops i meant i havent listened to the new metalica cause theyre shit

    R.I.P old metallica

  • One word. Lulu... end of arguement.

  • @TheMandrakeNeverDies Lol, its a album Metallica made with Lulu reed. If Metallica made it themselves it would be alot better. + Megadeth repeats themselves to often

  • @TheMandrakeNeverDies pues no creas lulu en cuestiones de metallica es fantastico, al que ledevemos la mierda de voz es a lou reed

  • metallica and megadeth !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! wins

  • no one wins, it seems stupid to make a versus between these 2 great bands

    The best

  • its good that dave mustaine was out of metallica and made a bettere band than metallica lets face it megadeath is true metal but the vocalist isnt good

  • ALLLLLL THE WAY with METALLICAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAA \m/.......

  • SINGER: james hetfield.

    LEAD GUITAR: dave mustaine.

    RYTHUM GUITAR: james hetfiled (Kirk is sloppy).

    BASS: cliff burton.

    DRUMS: nick menza

  • MEGADETH WINS BY FAR.