Tarja & Anette in Slaying The Dreamer

[nartajana]

al terminar de escuchar la cancion queria vomitar, anette canta orrible y siempre ac los mismos coros para tratar de alcanzar las notas..... kien dijo k anette canta bien esta drogado por k solo asi puedes escuchar una buena voz en esa vieja, tarja siempre sera la mejor! es irremplasable en NW

[dark7700]

cuanta envidia hay por aca, anette es la posta igual que tarja, pero tarja se nota que su voz en la banda ya no hiba, se agravo bastante y si seguia en la banda, su soprano se hiba a escuchar menos, asi que anette esta haciendo un exelente trabajo en nighwish, a todos los que no les gusta mi comentario CHUPENME BIEN LA VERGA , ANETTE NUNKA SE VA A IR DE NW XD JAJAJAJ AUNKE SE QUEJEN DE ELLA BIEN QUE LES GUSTA Y LE TIENEN ENVIDIA, SI CANTASE MAL, ENTONCES NO SERIA TAN FAMOSA, Y NO IRIA GENTE ;)

[wishmaster018]

3:25 - 3:30 ???? O_O!!!

XD!!!!!!!!!!!

[anthrax4456]

TARJA 10 X 0 ANETTE

[Triskellatlante]

With every songs Anette sings : yeah yeah yeah , i hate that , it destroy songs , and especially in a band of symphonic métal

[LucianaPuma]

Puedo entender que tarja y tuomas pelearan, o ese tipo de cosas, y que por eso la echaran....pero contratar a este esperpento? No es por nada, pero es como comparar a michael jackson con justin bieber...

[Amandio099]

anette...a ver si un dia te das cuenta de que a nadie le gustas en NW y te vas de una vez....arruinas temas y arruinaste una banda...no es por mala pero cantas peor que yo :_

[Amandio099]

ANETTE METETE EL BYE BYE BEAUTIFUL POR EL ORTO!

[dark7700]

@Amandio099 andate a la mierda XD jajajajaajjajaaj no sabes un pito de musica tarjista debes ser e.e ajajaja

[Amandio099]

anetteeeee deja de cantaaaaaaaaar!!!!! vas a arruinar odios si seguis cantando!

TARJAAAAAAA SOS UNA DIOSAAAAAA

BELLATRIX Y TONKS TE AMAMOSSS SOS UNA DIOSAAAAAAAAA! VOS SOS Y ERAS NIGHTWISH...AHORA ES UNA BANDA DEL MONTON RE POP

TARJA FOREVER!

[angshilez]

Anette, please go home and cook rice!

[Feanor2345]

Anette GO HOME!

[lscosta23]

that's not even possible to compare the two of them. i love tarja, she's very good, but anette has a very different tone, it's impossible to compare. and yes, i do agree that the old nightwish songs, the ones that made me in love wuth nw, are impossible to hear by anette.

[jujuliedu59]

euh desolée pour les fan mais anette on dirait que on est en trein de l'egorger la ou alors si vous préféré elle pousse des crie de pucelle enfin chacun ces gout moi je suis pour tarja

[evelinkn]

Tarja is the Best!!!!!

[XCnidaria]

3:55 = Ouch D:

[yohandry666]

OmG Tarja sin duda barrió el piso con anette!

Anette your voice kill my ear! U.u

[Darkcountess]

Sorry my question but this real or isn't? :S

(Anyway I prefer to Tarja)

[4C4rly4]

omg 3:56 made me lol, thats so bad

[Harmoner]

@4C4rly4 Lol me too ^^

[oOSanbOo]

God, I think Tuomas was on crack when he chose this girl with NO vocal training at all... Specially because he (and the other band members) are well trained musician... what the hell?!

[Mandysall]

I think this is the ugliest thing I've ever heard...O_O I won't sleep tonight...3:56 minute was horrible...I still hear her awful scream in my ears...How can Nightwish choose this "singer"??This is not a singer,this is a slaughtered duck...with no vocal technique...Oh my God,how I missed Tarja in Nightwish! T_T

[fantasyminas]

did Anette fuckin lost her voice at 3:56? O.o oh my god!! she totally scream like a little girl! worst she scream in the whole song! this is one of the song that's not fot Anette

[slade535]

It wasn't so FUCKING hard to just low it down a couple of notes and make the same melody as Tarja but with a different octave... But NO, let's fuck it up so fucking bad this way! I don't know if it was Tuomas' idea or Anette's, but that was ridiculous and unproffesional. Pathetic. I saw another video of Slaying the Dreamer in their official YouTube and for the "Wake up mow the weed" part they already leave Anette back stage.

[shfdsf1]

just MUST say this:

ever heard the quality of both songs?

the used song of anette is bad quality, as the song used for tarja was high quality.

so this is not very fair is it?

and ok...... an on tar songs = bad choice ;)

[UnhappyRc]

3:25-3:57 Jesus Christ Anette! WTF?!

[SeychelleK]

@UnhappyRc I literally laughed out loud!!

[MrsLesleyOlivia]

Omg Anette is just screaming,

It's an insult for Tarja ..

[DEYRUN1]

tarja vuelve!!!! los fans de nightwish te necesitamos...no vez ke me deprimo cada vez k veo komo anett echa aperder tus canciones....//.//

[Blackmusic4ever]

i think it's not only chicken trying to sing with tarja i think it's a half dead in pain chicken who got something stuck in her throat trying to sing with tarja... even my grndma would sound better...

i'm sry i don't mean any harm for annette bt this is seriously makin her lk bad.

sry annette i respect u as a singer but not as a nightwish singer, specially not after tarja...

[asiangirlmob]

anette is good singer. I do like tarja's way of singing. they are too different to be comparing. i think that classical singing sound better with symphonic

[xenafan15]

Tarja ONLY!! :D

[dedloureiro]

tarjaaaaaaaaaaaaaaa

[kofkamus]

tarja for ever...... anette shit and big stupid

[BiipoOO]

tarja!!!!! regresa!!!!!! :'( por favor!! T_T u.u

[thevalefor]

Anette doesn´t sing ... she scream ... thats ridiculous. the people whos defending anette here is the new kiddos who never saw Tarja live on flesh as i do so chill out crybabies.

[Nightwishoneandonly]

3:51 - 3:56.... ok Im a big fan of Nightwish so I wont tell you what I think about this...

Its not actually her fault. The song was not written for her. But I just wonder why they let her sing this since there´s an original song with a more powerful voice to compare this to?

[IvyPane]

Oh geez, people are still crying over Tarja. Just get over it already.

[nightwishfan06]

ok they should really just let annette sing her songs and let tarja sing hers because when annette trys to sing tarjas it just sounds like shes about to puke!

tarja could sing annettes easily but she chooses not to why? because that would just be wrong on so many different levels

[uccew]

Annette seems fucked by a bull!!

[uccew]

ahahaha A chicken really!!

[marisaMURDERER]

I don't think the whole fight between 'tarja-fans' and 'Anette-fans' is fair. I like them both.

[blackchildproduction]

Oh my god..... this is a good way to kill someone because anette do not sing she SCREAMS!!!!

[zborifluturas]

Anette suck!!Tarja rulz!!!

[MrsLesleyOlivia]

Anette sucks !!

Tarja the best.

[NiloArch]

Anette is slaying the song >.<

[Tupca97]

Anette can't sing Slayling the Dreamer well but she isn't that good like Tarja....Tarja IS THE BEST!!!!

[LaliqueLioncourt]

Now that Anette's touched Tarja's songs, I think it's only fair that Tarja give a go at Amaranth or Bye Bye Beautiful. I'd like to see her take on it definitely.

Anette's not that bad but this is like being an English major and having to write an essay in Chinese or something.

[patkajape]

@LaliqueLioncourt Tarja's? Are you serious? Do you even know who wrote this song?

[LaliqueLioncourt]

@patkajape

Well I'm not Nightwish crazy but I'll give a go at it and guess Tuomas? I guess people like you would have liked it better if I wrote, "Tuomas' songs that he wrote for Tarja, the singer of Nightwish at that time," instead of, "Tarja's songs".

[ComaLies225]

@LaliqueLioncourt It'd be weird if Tarja covered Bye Bye. Seeing as how the song is directed to her.

[rockinguy31]

@ComaLies225 Totally agree!!!

[grimreaper11114]

Anette is it possible for you to fail more?

[el1986th]

Replacing Tarja with Anette is like trying to replace James Hetfield with Bryan Adams...

Tuomas needs to stop shooting himself in the foot and hire someone who could actually sing Nightwish songs the way they are ment to be sung like Vibeke Stene or Floor Jansen...

[oceansoul02]

is that really Anette???? .__.

where can i find the video of this song?

[oceansoul02]

0:59

damn shit... Oo

[vampiregirl6810]

anette lastima mis oidos tarja es la mejor no debieron sacarla

[MegaLiopleurodon]

I'm laughing - I'm crying - but at 3:56 I couldn't help but lmfao, calling this chick a singer is just ridiculous. Going back to my favorites now, my ears seriously need some medicine, called TARJA :-)

[Isanan]

Tarja is better than anette.Tarja makes an awsome vibrato,Anette doesn´t know how to make a vibrato.

[VHudgensTheBest]

FUCK OFF HATERS!!! Anette and Tarja sing different styles. I dont think that you would like it if Tarja sang Amaranth or Sahara for example.. But Anette is doing a great job and all of u are assholes! GO ANETTE!! GREECE LOVES YOU<3

[SHADOWSKISS18]

anette CAN SING!! why dont you ppl get that!! she can sing but she cant sing like tarja becuz she doesnt sing opera!! she can do the original songs her own way because its all she can do!! her only problem is that she tries a too hard so she ends up forcing herself which causes her to scream!! other than that she can sing. she has talent. both of them do but we're so used to hearing tarja's version that its hard for ppl to accept a new voice. . and yea anettes screaming is a problem

[onenew34te]

@SHADOWSKISS18 I agree with you, the point is that she shouldn't even touch these songs... they are written for a performer like tarja, however anette is pretty good at for example 7 days to the wolves, eva etc

[hellna90]

Definitivamente esta cancion no es para Anette

[ozzi4everbol]

TARJA the best forever!!!!

[Ghost1cek]

3:50 is tragedy

[LoveofAphrodite]

o.o oh my.....dear lord....

[eylawr]

anettes singing is ok but the scream she does at 3:25 and 3:50 were horrible

[Subsistancer]

I think this is awesome!

Down rate me motherfuckers.

[Smiley88524]

Stop it, Anette! It sounds just terrible.

[Rueneko]

Anette obviously isn't the best at singing most of the old songs. She doesn't have the same level of experience as Tarja, but she is still very adaptable and performs well. To be fair, more than one song should be compared, because Anette does The Siren and Dark Chest of Wonders live quite well. You usually can't tell from any youtube videos, though.

I'd like to see them perform together, it would be really neat. Maybe if the band gets over any hard feelings... But that seems really unlikely.

[Sohaiarana]

3:54 - 3:57 O.o tooo WTF? sooo suck annette dick :D

[Stephen3Asp]

3:54-3:57 O_O

[bittersweetskull]

normaly i don't throw my opinion in an anette vs tarja but yeah i have to say that tarja powns this song..

[makeavelico333]

tarja deja pendeja a anette pero por kilometros

[DThony]

OMG Anette, please dont sing nevermore!!!!

TARJA COME BACK!!!

[Constantine3110]

Its not good to compare those 2 in a song that was made for the first singer imo.Secondly you have put Annete from a live but you havent put a good quality sound sample while for Tarja you have used the best live in youtube :P.

[bwaveforce]

quality aside.

we can compare the two, because A) she's the current singer and B) shes singing the old stuff.

now if she never sang the good stuff, then comparing tarja and anette would be unfair.

but seeing how she does its open game, everyone knows this far exceeds her boundaries so theres no reason why she should be singing these type of songs in the first place.

of course none of this is directed towards her, she does seem like a nice person

[emydown]

Esta banda ya no es la misma, prefiero escuchar el viejo Nightwish.

[elviraluu]

OMG my ears i can´t hear anymore!

i don't hate anette but i think her voice is not good enough for nightiwish's songs D:

she tries to reach tarja's level,and this song it's too difficult for her to sing, because she is not soprano, she sounds a awkward D:

[nemo99ification]

hoffentlich kommt tarja bald wieder zurück! anette klingt das einfach einfach nich!

[danielbox66]

I can't listen the anette's voice in this song! is orribile!!! she jars! she sing POP! so YE-YE-YE!

she scream! not sing!

[Sitexful]

@danielbox66 "Pop" voice don't exist... And what is that "pop voice"? I've heard about sporan, alt, but... pop? Wow, may you create new wikipedia?? :P :P

[Kysentha]

Oh man Tarja pawns Anette!

[christianano1]

100% pour TARJA ! elle reste de loin la meilleure et toujours aussi débordante de talent.

Anette chante faux , sans puissance de voix

Elle plafonne vite.

Elle est pardonnée , le défi etait perdu davance. Hélas !

[emydown]

Tu as raison 1000 % Tarja

[Tarjaholic88]

Annette makes the vocal melodies sound country in here.

[WishMeTillDawn]

tarja es una diOsa

[Gaermanicus]

Tarja is glorious,

Anette is only a little girl.

[Woronwe]

Tarja!!!!

Anette destroyed Nightwish...

[AthenaNoSeinto10]

It sounds bad, because Anette was trying to be at the level of Tarja.

Anette has a really good voice, but she has to stop trying to reach the level of Tarja, or we won`t listen ever again her beautiful voice.

Well, thats my opinion :) And sorry for my English ^^ I`m from Argentina (Argentina and Nightwish RLZ \m/

AthenaNoSeinto10

[nightwish231]

anyone can say where is tarzan? XD i mean please!loool this music is for tarja!but i live anette in DPP album

[GothicAmy4]

'tell me why'' by Anette? Oh my god, my ears get hurt!

Love Tarja.

[rudychidiac]

lol at tarzan :P anette's voice :P

[Stephen3Asp]

3:55 - 3:58. What the hell? Annete's voice must have been destroyed after this. LOL!

[rudychidiac]

wtf thats tarzan :P

[Leignis]

Yes, I think so.

[Sitexful]

@Stephen3Asp Yes, because song for Tarja is for Tarja... o.O

[oOSanbOo]

@Stephen3Asp Totally agree! God, that was painful!!!

[GreekMania000]

@Stephen3Asp L000000000000000L check out 3:27-3:30...

[Spiny0808]

Anette 2:30 - 2:35.. Ow this pain >_> She sucks.

[Sirina7]

I don't know why am I listening to it. It's such a shame to spoil a song like this. Really! Anette is screaming here and Tarja is singing. And no, please don't make anymore videos like this. It's a pain, we already know you just can't compare Tarja and Anette.

[ntt688]

tarja's voice is sweet and powerful.

[wantedcode93]

3:57 Was that annete's scream or am i deaf?

LOLOLOLOLOLOLOLOL

LOLOLOLOLOLOLOLOL

LOLOLOLOLOLOLOLOL

LOLOLOLOLOLOLOLOL

[HailTheCradle]

lol owch my ears! that screaming... OWCH!

[missghotica]

3:54- 3:57 lmao! what was that? xD

[CrankBubble]

No way, this is not the song for Anette's voice, Especially those screaming parts here I mean 03:26, how could Tuomas ever let this happen? O_o

Saying that Tarja is way better with the old songs is not being Tarjaholic, it's being objective.

[Ixidor13]

And realistic

[GothicAmy4]

'' This really hurts in my ears!!

And the name of the pain is Anette Olzon!!! ''

oh my god, it's all the truth! don't sings old songs, Anette. shame. what is that?

love Tarja and love Nightwish <3

[Shpoondel]

Tarja was kicked cose of Marcello. Hate him :'(

[Dr4snus]

It was Tuomas Holopainen.

[jbcn615]

Anette is just disgusting me... I hate this new voice of nightwish!

[TrueSuomiMetal]

This really hurts in my ears!!

And the name of the pain is Anette Olzon!!!

Tarja we want you back !!

You´re an Angel,you´re wonderfull,you´re the only one ,we want to have!!!

[MrReason09]

If Tarja is THAT wonderful and special, tell me why the fuck does she need to be in NW again to worth something?

[BlackIndra]

She's now even more wonderful by her own. Nightwish with Tarja was great, nobody can say is not true, nowadays with Anette, well, let's say is nice.

But afterall, Tarja doesn't need Nightwish anymore to be or to prove how amazing she is.

[sabeJD]

everyone falls at anytime in life and has to start over!  thats the way life is!

[dirac68]

Oh, Dear! There's a chicken trying to sing with Tarja!

[Shadowsilas]

@dirac68 LOL!!!!!

[vagevuur666]

@dirac68 lets chance the song to "slaying the chicken"!!!!!!!

[TranceAnton]

Both are good, but please Anette, do not sing these kind of songs, they are to much for you.

Tarja, you rule and I cant fuckin wait for your new ALBUM!!!

[NightWishOwning]

Ok Creepy i agree with u but some other song's like Dark Chest Of Wonders she can sing aswell... Or another one lets take Ever Dream..... But one thing She Try's it and that is just wonderful!

[CreepyDeathla90]

Ever Dream is one of my favorite and when Anette sings it.. sounds amazing ;D and Dark Chest of wonders not sounds bad at all :)

...but this one does :'(

[NightWishOwning]

Ok i know Ever Dream is amazing with Anette Dark chest of wonders is W0W With Anette!

[CreepyDeathla90]

Well... what you're thinking about Ghost Love Score? I was surprised when I heard that singing by Anette :) she is really good on that :3

[NightWishOwning]

One thing we all can say: We love both right?

Hey wanna be friends?

[CreepyDeathla90]

I agree :)

[wishmaster198]

of course. too bad we're on tarjaholic waters.....

[CreepyDeathla90]

to NightWishOwning;

I mean that this song belongs to Tarja and only for Tarja! Anette is good singer too in Nightwish but there is some (old)songs that she just can't sing, her voice/talent isn't good enough...

exam. The Siren, Slaying the Dreamer, Dead to the World, Nemo, Wishmaster...

[jibber102]

Yes, oh my gosh, The Siren was my second favorite song (after Ghost Love Score of course!), but they CANNOT play it live anymore! I mean, it's ALL opera-esque vocals, so Anette makes it sound all wierd and whatnot.

[CreepyDeathla90]

you are so right!! :)

[MrReason09]

Lol...Opera esque vocals

you should seriously consider listening to the song again without having your head stuck inside Tarja's rear end.

Once is anything but "Opera-like", you were just fooling yourself beliving it was.

"Operatic vocals" were completely left aside after Wishmaster album. Welcome to reality.

[jibber102]

That's why I put the "esque" on there. I know she's a classical singer and not opera, but most goofballs on youtube don't know what that is...Just clearing that up.

[NightWishOwning]

Anette MUCH Betterr!

[CreepyDeathla90]

I guess you never listening Nightwish when Tarja was in..

[NightWishOwning]

Oh guys seriously going in to this? i was joking....

[peluxitahell]

tarja foreverrrr

[CreepyDeathla90]

Anette is slaying this song!

[NightWishOwning]

What you mean with that?

[DMLi66]

Tarja 4 ever

[MaryRailly]

OH MY GOD!!!

The end of the song... what's that??!

A monkey while it is shitting!

The first part of the song... ok, we can listen to it even if it's not so good, but the last part it's something diabolikal... that's not singing, but screming!

I tried to listen to Anette's voice a thousand times, but if I have to hear noise and an horrible voice I prefer something like Britney Spears & Co.

[LifeRenegade]

If you don't like it don't hear it nap

[legeon6]

Of course Tarja.She actually SINGS the song,when the other just TRIES to sing the song.

[shadowedstorm]

Tarja > Anette

nuff said.

[jrmpmal]

Is irritating voice of Anette, Fuck you Anette

[KoolBoyz93]

She is ok..

But she shouldnt sing tarja's songs..

[llauriann]

wtf...?

[SxfavolexS]

OMG O_O

[Crowe921]

Anette extremely sucks in this song.

[elpegoli]

fucking fake...

[NightWishMazter]

QUE KAKA !!!!! XDDDDDD

omg what that fuck?

jajajajaajaajajaaajaa

[ShastaPwns]

This song sounds like Rammstein.

The riff is 2 notes off from being the same.

You know, "Duhh duhh duhh , duhh da duhh..."

:P

[angelfighter0]

Heh, it does kinda!

[NightWishMazter]

what that fuck???????????

this is only shit

[eman3624]

Man, Anette is going to throw out her vocal chords if she screams like that! Plus it sounds BAD!!

[Rdaglog]

anette is bitch

[xoooxGxooox]

This is the only song that really doesn't suit her. Anette tries hard and I respect her very much, but this song is really not for her singing technique range and especially that last part. I am upset when i hear how much she strains herself. Maybe when they think about rearrange it and make it more suitable for her voice it will sound better, like they've done with "wishmaster".

[ADyingFaith]

I rlly rlly rlly love that, they both sound so great.

[lnvm]

w ell i think everybody already know who won this battle and that would be tarja no one cant compete against tarja but anette is still a good vocalist of couxrse they dont have the same vocal because they are the not the same person everybody has a different voice

[Hemanthemannequin]

I think they sound WONDERFUL together, and really show why Anette was a logical choice for Nightwish. It also showcases something that makes me laugh. Tarja and Anette's voices are not that different and the difference are mostly Tarja sings in a half-hearted pop operatic style and Anette sings with a belting technique. Funny thing about these is they showcase Anette has a larger range (which is understandable) but also that Anette has A LOT more power in the upper range than Tarja does.

[caioempty]

Tarja sings it

Marco sings it

Anette ruins it... [2]

[Valetallica]

Tarja sings..

Anette screams.. go to a metal band girl, not to Nigthwish

[AXELCHELO]

Nightwish is a metal band, dude!!

[YulieAna]

Marco screams too, yet you aren't bitching about him.

[Valetallica]

He gets the notes right, Annette has to force her voice to reach them

[YulieAna]

"He gets the notes right"

While screaming at the same time. Why is it ok for you to make excuses for Tarja and Marco, but the same logic is never applied to Anette?

"Annette has to force her voice to reach them"

Here is another "expert" who thinks they got it all about singing.

[Valetallica]

Not all, but I know about singing. And This is my opinion, and I don't need to offend anyone when I make a comment.

Please be logic: Annette has another level of voice, and this song wasn't made for her, That's all. The fact that I don't like her it's another story. :)