American Idol - Top 5 Recap

[tiarnantman]

1. Brooke White (IAB not so much, but IAIS was far and away the best of the night)

2. Syesha Mercado (Both performances were quite strong)

3. David Cook (song 1 = yuck, but song 2 was alright-ish)

4. Jason Castro (FIBJ was cute, but SM was a snore...arguably his worst night)

5. David Archuleta - horrible on the first song, bad on his second.

[rockislotis]

brooke was terrible

[MP5141]

I agree Brooke was terrible...bye bye Brooke.

Thanks for posting :)

[mochakitty967]

Jason is horrible. He is like the new Sanjaya. Syesha, she is realllyyyyyyy good!!! So is David Cook!!!! David Archuleta is on/off. I'm VERY happy Brooke was voted off. She was not very strong, and cried a lot. David Cook would be like, a better Daughtry.

[MP5141]

Syesha's first song was terrific, her best so far. Jason was just ok, he tends to sing everything the same. Maybe he gets the boot next go around. Archuleta has become a bit boring, David Cook is my fav. Hey, thanks for posting : )

[paperroses101]

ya I agree

[crazylady857]

I think David A. won that round, however I'm still for David C. for the win. (David! David! David!)

[MP5141]

David Cook sure is doing well, very strong every week. The next few weeks should be interesting. Thanks for posting !

[CanadianVandal]

thanks!

[MP5141]

You're welcome, hope you enjoyed :)