I feel the same way, the movie actually had a better ending. It was far more realistic than the book. Both are good, but to me, I like the movie better.
the book is way better than the movie i cried and i really thought that anna was gonna die in the movie and she diddnt - - can any one tell me why?? somebody put below, the ending is impossibe how?? how isa girl dieing in a car chrash impossible?? reply xx
@XxjessrocksxX I think the message of the movie is different from message of the book. Why they changed the message? Dunno exactly but the movie emphasizes on "dying gracefully" and the book doesn't... I think the producers just wanted Kate to die? What do you think?
I lked the mother (sara) in the movie but I couldn't stand her character in the book...
I love her! Anyways...I liked the movie...although they should have stuck with the ending of the book....it added a type of different meaning to the story...if you know what I mean. =]
Well, the mediacal diagnosis indicated that it is impossible to donate a kidney to her, as that kidney would begin to fail at once with that kind of Leukemia.
In other words: the kidney would be donate in vain and she dies anyway.
in the book anna dies from a car accident and while shes braindead, the take her kidney and giv it 2 kate and in the end kate ends up surviving and beating the cancer
OMG!! I saw the movie the week it came out and it was so good!!! even though it was interupting crying teenagers on the part the boy......... never mind but it was good. And sad. VERY SAD!
There were so many things about the movie that I liked, but it still just makes me so mad that they didn't trust the audience enough to keep the original ending. The book's ending was done for a very, very specific reason, and beyond that, I think it would have enhanced Sofia's performance that much more if they stuck with the right ending. They could have made it work if they really wanted to, and it could have been an amazing film in its own right. It was still okay, but much more cliched.
dont believe me fine then BUT I SWEAR i used to look like sofia when i was 6!and ever sence iv seen it for the first tiem we named my grandma nanny idk y thats where we got the name nanny for my grandma from LOLZ
@stephenswodadancer in the book anna doesnt win the case through a series of events that takes place so kate gets the organs that she need and become heathly again
@stephenswodadancer in the book at the end her sister gets into a car crash and she dies but this girl that had cancer stays alive! it doesnt really say if her sister donated her kidney
as much as i loved the film i prefer the book because that ending is better and you dont see it coming. the book is better than the film it is much sadder, if you cry at the film wait till you read the book
When I saw her on this I kept looking at her face and the way your mouth moved and was like, She looks familiar where did I see her? And then I searched her name and I was like OMG! She was from Eloise i loved that movie!!!!! lol
i know! i cant believe she shaved it all off!! did you see how long it used to be?!?!?! i dont think i could EVER do that. unless one of my parents or children had cancer...
i know right!!! but i'm into acting and if there was a movie or play that i really wanted to be into and that would send a good message and i would do it. :) oh and btw her name is spelled soFia :)
Um uh I don't think she shaved it off really bcuz then i couldn't live wit myself so she had 2 do like the "bald cap" thing i saw one on a person it looks like u really are bald. So i think they just put a bald cap one her or she really does have cancer.
BOOK SPOILER IF YOU HAVES READ IT!
@glamorous94girl no Anna won the case but then got in a car accident and then her lawyer gave the kidney to her sister who grows up a dancer
kristenheartsyou97 1 month ago
her TV show MEDIUM just ended its run months ago. i wonder if we'll ever see her on TV again after she finishes college.
troyboy7962 6 months ago
i saw it and it was sad my moms like " see anything can happen what if that happened to your sister" then me and my sis hugged each other!
superluv15 6 months ago
I can't believe how much older she has gotten ! I remember watching her in the Eloise movies when she was soooo little !
ash19964 7 months ago
didn't she play eloise in "eloise at the plaza"
omgaglover99 1 year ago
@omgaglover99 she did =)
LittleMEAndJB 11 months ago
@omgaglover99 haha thats exactly what i thought when i first saw the movie. im pretty sure it is though :)
897doc 9 months ago
@897doc yea it is
omgaglover99 9 months ago
LOved that Movie!
myanh1213 1 year ago
she looks better with Long Brown hair like in My Sister's Keeper . can you say sexxxyyy :)
TheSlipknotGurl 1 year ago
her voice is so calm and soothing, i love her voice..
AM89602 1 year ago 2
I love her voice <3
mclehann 1 year ago 3
she is very softspoken. and seems meek. love her in my sisters keeper.
bittybaby95 1 year ago
i cried at this film
UkSavannahOuten 1 year ago
I feel the same way, the movie actually had a better ending. It was far more realistic than the book. Both are good, but to me, I like the movie better.
66SiK 1 year ago
i love you sofia
mbayeta 1 year ago
WTF? she was in medium? I couldnt recognize her in My Sister's Keeper.
ghillas16 1 year ago
i love the movie :)
but different ending in the book :-I
sofia's really pretty :D
madtwisterfoo 1 year ago
i like this ending much better..the book version where anna dies is too dramatic, my opinion anyway.
mistytears4 1 year ago 3
the book is way better than the movie i cried and i really thought that anna was gonna die in the movie and she diddnt - - can any one tell me why?? somebody put below, the ending is impossibe how?? how isa girl dieing in a car chrash impossible?? reply xx
XxjessrocksxX 1 year ago
@XxjessrocksxX I think the message of the movie is different from message of the book. Why they changed the message? Dunno exactly but the movie emphasizes on "dying gracefully" and the book doesn't... I think the producers just wanted Kate to die? What do you think?
I lked the mother (sara) in the movie but I couldn't stand her character in the book...
ditzydee1 1 year ago
In the book Anna ends up dying in a car accident and ends up givig her kidney to kate.
Softballs4KoolKids 2 years ago
this reseshin sucks i hate utube
jessejames031 2 years ago
The book was better.. but the movie wasn't bad.
niceniecey 2 years ago 4
brokenteddybear alot of people call their grandma nanny...
graybeccproductions 2 years ago
is that the ending in the book ?
sharnz1992 2 years ago
I love her! Anyways...I liked the movie...although they should have stuck with the ending of the book....it added a type of different meaning to the story...if you know what I mean. =]
HannahEmily100 2 years ago
@HannahEmily100
Given medical facts, the ending of the book is impossible.
The script writer had to fix that problem of the novel.
schusterlehrling 2 years ago
what do you mean impossible.?
lola101pink 2 years ago
Well, the mediacal diagnosis indicated that it is impossible to donate a kidney to her, as that kidney would begin to fail at once with that kind of Leukemia.
In other words: the kidney would be donate in vain and she dies anyway.
schusterlehrling 2 years ago
the book ended different?? how?
2136261 2 years ago 3
in the book anna dies from a car accident and while shes braindead, the take her kidney and giv it 2 kate and in the end kate ends up surviving and beating the cancer
partygirl100100 1 year ago
@partygirl100100 lol i think u got the characters mixed up. u mean Kate got into an accident, not Anna.
Puplove07 1 year ago
@Puplove07 no. in the book anna has a car accident. but in the movie kate dies.
aevelazco 1 year ago
oh wait i lied. I got the characters mixed up. lol sorry.
Puplove07 1 year ago
@partygirl100100 and kate lives the life shes always wanted :)
zeldadork5000 1 year ago
this movie is so good. but what was the original ending to the book???
CalissaBFF 2 years ago
in the ending kate survived and her sister died in a car accident and ended up giving her kidney yo kate...also she won the case
dancegirlva93 2 years ago
no shes didnt..
hugskises 2 years ago
yea she did.
dancegirlva93 2 years ago
SHE WAS ELOISE!
(:
Jjadorejuicy 2 years ago 3
sooooooooooooo cool!
goofey4ag 2 years ago
wow what a great movie..... and great acting by sofia!!!
ravishethwala 2 years ago 12
OMG!! I saw the movie the week it came out and it was so good!!! even though it was interupting crying teenagers on the part the boy......... never mind but it was good. And sad. VERY SAD!
ConverseGirlsBand 2 years ago 5
This has been flagged as spam show
not to be rude but im just wondering? Did she really die in real life? cuz i thought i heard that some were?
dancing4mee 2 years ago
There were so many things about the movie that I liked, but it still just makes me so mad that they didn't trust the audience enough to keep the original ending. The book's ending was done for a very, very specific reason, and beyond that, I think it would have enhanced Sofia's performance that much more if they stuck with the right ending. They could have made it work if they really wanted to, and it could have been an amazing film in its own right. It was still okay, but much more cliched.
rosek102 2 years ago 19
what was the original ending of the book? i havent read it
stephenswodadancer 2 years ago
In the book, Anna dies. and Kate lives
soccergurlchikk 2 years ago
i havend read the book....but this ending seems to sad...and not rghite...
OOdaniellaOO 2 years ago
woah...
so the book ends sadly and the movie dos too.
i thought everyone would live in the book ):
TheMysticalBlaze 2 years ago
dont believe me fine then BUT I SWEAR i used to look like sofia when i was 6!and ever sence iv seen it for the first tiem we named my grandma nanny idk y thats where we got the name nanny for my grandma from LOLZ
brokenteddybear100 2 years ago
@stephenswodadancer she lived and the other sister died
butterfly23320 1 year ago
@stephenswodadancer in the book anna doesnt win the case through a series of events that takes place so kate gets the organs that she need and become heathly again
glamorous94girl 1 year ago
@stephenswodadancer in the book at the end her sister gets into a car crash and she dies but this girl that had cancer stays alive! it doesnt really say if her sister donated her kidney
qandol7 1 year ago
@rosek102 How is the ending in the book?
andreea140794 3 weeks ago
@rosek102 Oh , it doesn't matter anymore :)) I found out already :D
andreea140794 3 weeks ago
no, she didnt.
xoxoixoxo 2 years ago
Um no. Why would she be dead?
DimSimToughBitch 2 years ago
as much as i loved the film i prefer the book because that ending is better and you dont see it coming. the book is better than the film it is much sadder, if you cry at the film wait till you read the book
katie0h 2 years ago
i want to see that movie soo bad cause i love abigail breslin she is in to of my top ten favorite movies little miss sunshine and kit kittredge
linatherabbitreal 2 years ago
i love this movie
funkymonkey1222 2 years ago
my mom and i left my sisters keeper it was so sad.....we came back to see the ending.....;)
themagicb 2 years ago
omg the movie was amazing it was so sad tho!
agrox2000 2 years ago 4
omg your right! she is eloise! aw i loved that movie when i was little :) wow shes grown up lol
XOAliceCullen16OX 2 years ago
the movie was sooooooooooo good it is sad though
05227799 2 years ago 4
i saw that movie it was AMAZING!!!
iluvamericangirl12 2 years ago 4
i heard the book was bad
futurecelebrity567 2 years ago
The book is not bad it's REALLY good!
MyMargarite24249 2 years ago 5
you heard wrong, it's amazing, I would say much better than the film
emmakate93 2 years ago
When I saw her on this I kept looking at her face and the way your mouth moved and was like, She looks familiar where did I see her? And then I searched her name and I was like OMG! She was from Eloise i loved that movie!!!!! lol
SweetCupcakeShortie 2 years ago
no way!!!!!!!!!! i didn't think about that until i just read thay!!!!!!! omg! she's so pretty!
futurecelebrity567 2 years ago
OMG she is i loved that move so much
1236w31236w3 2 years ago
Is this ur sister?
blasky8 2 years ago
lol no, its a movie..........
agdollz 2 years ago
is she a step sister or no?
peanutbutterfreak206 2 years ago
i want to see this movie sooooooooooooo bad!
webkinzlover95687 2 years ago
i luv that book
eemmmmaa1616 2 years ago
omg i cannot wait till the my sister's keeper movie comes out!! i LOVED the book!!! she is so adorable and yay her hair grew back!!!
AmericanGirlBroadway 2 years ago 5
i know! i cant believe she shaved it all off!! did you see how long it used to be?!?!?! i dont think i could EVER do that. unless one of my parents or children had cancer...
stephenswodadancer 2 years ago
i know right!!! but i'm into acting and if there was a movie or play that i really wanted to be into and that would send a good message and i would do it. :) oh and btw her name is spelled soFia :)
AmericanGirlBroadway 2 years ago
haha hmmmm that might be why not many people have watched it ;) thanks!
stephenswodadancer 2 years ago
lol :) no prob :)
AmericanGirlBroadway 2 years ago
Um uh I don't think she shaved it off really bcuz then i couldn't live wit myself so she had 2 do like the "bald cap" thing i saw one on a person it looks like u really are bald. So i think they just put a bald cap one her or she really does have cancer.
kitlover1997 2 years ago
nope she shaved
dejavugal101 2 years ago
Y did she SHAVE IT ALL OFF????!!!! Why can't she just wear like that bald cap thing????
max032097 2 years ago
lol i so thought this video was about your REAL sister or something lol. my bad...
agdollfan333 2 years ago
she's so cute! she kinda reminds me of what a younger Reese Witherspoon would look like
disney1nickjluvr45 2 years ago
woah is the hair on her head a wig or real hair? if its real hair it sure grew back fast!!
kinga981 2 years ago
its real. They filmed the movie about 7 months ago
phantomrox87 2 years ago
I want to see it!
coldbills 2 years ago
did you put this on today?! lol i always check up on your videos!
agdollfan333 2 years ago
lol i put it up like at 2am i think
stephenswodadancer 2 years ago
haha thats funny. i keep meaning to put videos up but i never have time because on dance! :)
agdollfan333 2 years ago
I wanna see th movie :]
agdollfan32 2 years ago
me too! my mom and i were going to see it last weekend together and then looked it up and realized it wasnt out yet and we were so upset!
stephenswodadancer 2 years ago
LOL! it looks pretty cool! thnx 4 getting us the interview Sarah!!
yabbadabbs15 2 years ago