OUTLANDER
7:46
Added: 5 years ago
From: Jaqueline001
Views: 91,805
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:
see all

All Comments (129)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • Well, Tony Curran isn't a traditional "beauty" stereotyped, fake, trivial and built as hollywood typical actors, he is a typical scottish pure blood male. Rough, strong, damn sexy and HOT! He was perfect for this role 15 years ago. Now he has 42. Is too late also for Gerard Butler, older than Tony and without his amazing, stunning, flaming, curly hair. At the end, a perfect video with a perfect primary roles. ;)

  • please do NOT cast tony curran as jamie he is sooooooo ugly!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

  • The actress for Claire is spot on, especially with her facial features. I also like this Jenny far better than the others I've seen. The best thing I can say about you choice of Jamie.... at least he's a naturall red head. ; D When does the next book come out?

  • Excellent movie you made, only, when I read the books I just picture Kevin McKidd. He could pull off all the ages of Jamie, I think.

  • I am not sure who this man is that you have picked for Jamie- but he does not look how the book describes him other than the red hair. Jamie is very young and very good looking- something this actor is not. Sorry. But I do like the rest of your picks!

  • ugly jamie need someone a little handsomer for heaven sakes everyone in the clip looked better then him

  • bitte bitte den jamie nicht! die anderen gehen ja noch aber jamie? der iss doch nicht so hässlich ;_;

  • I actually think Tony Curran would be a good "Jamie", but what about Drew McIntyre from WWE Smackdown?

  • That is not JAMIE!! He is not at all the right person to play the role! UGH---

  • Every Actor fits perfect - but Jamie....NO. I'm sorry, but Tony Curran doesn't look good enough for OUR Jamie...who does?...

  • wish they would make a movie of it..."Does the hurtin' ever stop Sassenogh for wantin' ye?

  • Mi spiace ma questo attore non può essere Jamie :( Gerard è perfetto per la parte XD. E Liam non và bene x Colum, sarebbe un perfetto Dougal!! E anche l'attore scelto x Frank/Jack ha troppo la faccia da bravo ragazzo, meglio Jason Jsaacs!

  • No, sorry, absolutely not my choice.

    They should cast unknown actors, which fit the characters perfect. They must exist anywhere in this world.

  • I agree with you.

  • oh my goooood that's not jamie!!!!!!!!!!!

    tony is ugly and old and ugly and old! bleahhhhh!

  • No, that is NOT Jamie at all.

  • Please not Tony Curran. Gerard Butler is the only one who has the looks and expresions to be Jamie. As for age they can easily make him look younger with makeup or whatever they do.While your reading just imagine Gerry doing the part, like teaseing or showing his love for a woman and he is Jamie!!!!!!

  • Wrong guy to play Jamie!! I am partial to Kate Winslet playing Clare. But ya gotta find a much better looking Jamie then this guy.

  • No way is that guy Jamie!! Yuck!

  • Ugh! That is NOT Jamie!!! No way!!! And wtf with Colum? He's not tall and strong like LIam, his legs are bowed! I don't think it would work even with CG.

    Did you even READ the character descriptions?

  • RSL for Jack/Frank? No...

  • PS: I love Tony because he is a redhead and he has curled hair and blue eyes. And he looks great in a kilt ;o)

  • Tony Curran is not that old, and not ugly! He had a charismatic face, a smart voice, many talent and a nice smirking. Im not objective, because i like him very much as an actor. But to say he's ugly, this is no opinion, this is just shit.

  • I know the bloody nursing scenes must have been verra tempting :) But she's not my vision of Claire. I always picture Claire looking like a young Emma Thompson, like in Much Ado.. Great pick for Murtagh though! Such a great character, and much overlooked IMO. I like your picks for Leghair, though I would switch Colum and Dougal.. Love the Jamie choice, who is that man?

  • I totally agree with you about Claire- I have ALWAYS envisioned Emma Thompson - she is the perfect pick!

  • Oh, wait....Robert Sean Leonard as Frank/Jack? He's a pussycat, there is no way he can play such an evil character. It's laughable really.

  • Tony Curran as Jamie? ICK!!! That is just plain scarey and unattractive just to think about.....nothing sexually appealing there!!

  • lol, Rupert Grint as Hamish :) Good cast ideas overall--Dougal looks perfect, and Laoghaire, and Murtagh, and most everyone. Not sure I agree with the Jamie. Kate Beckinsale looks good for Claire, though Kate Winslet might also be a good choice.

  • WHAT? Tony Curran as Jamie? No way! red hair+blue eyes only aint Jamie!! He is to old and to ugly for Jamie! What about Gerry? Why didnt you pick im for your video?why do you ask people to vote for him then?

    But I like the idea of Kate Beckinsale as Claire.She has the looks and the strength ike Claire.

  • this guy never looks like Jamie!!!!!!!!!!

  • And can I ask why you cast Tony Curran as Jamie, but are featuring a petition to have Gerard Butler cast? I sense a disconnect in the force.

  • I agree with you...and Jamie is beautiful, Mr Curran is too old and ugly to play this part..

  • Kate Beckinsale and Robert Sean Leonard???? You've been watching too much Much Ado about Nothing. I'm almost surprised you didn't suggest Kenneth Branagh as Jamie, and stick in Denzel Washington and Emma Thompson somewhere.

  • jamie is much better looking then the guy you chose. if that's going to be your jamie, you need claire to be uglier as well...

  • Oh, there's a Lord John book? Great! I just discovered all these Jamie/Clair vids... does anyone know of any Bree/Roger ones?

  • How about Kate as the young Claire and Alex kingston as the older one? Make the hair curly and the same color...??

  • Ok so this is just a montage right? I just began reading the first one and almost finishing it, and I'm finding out more and more bout' it. It proves to be a very popular book worldwide and it's popularity is catching up more and more. And (without spoiling the rest of the books) would someone tell me what those "The Lord John Books" are?

  • Oh my god...I think you have no imagination...this ugly guy as jamie???...never ever...sorry...Jamie is handsome...jenny and Ian are perfect...kate beckinsale as claire...hhhmmm???...maybe!!!.­...I think alex kingston is the right one.

  • il video è fatto molto bene, ma Jamie è orribile...complimenti per il resto

  • where did you find the map of Scotland with all the outlander locations on it? I've often thought that there should be one printed in the books for reference.

  • I love the outlander series <3 this video is amazing :)

  • Jamie is too horrible I'm sorry...and he's young!!!!!!! put congratulations for the video

  • Very good! What is the name of the actress you put for jenny? It was a good match.

  • Nicely done!! I have spent the whole afternoon enjoying all these videos of possibilites...

  • kate beckensale as claire? Really...

  • Great Jenny and Ian, Karl Urban is perfect!

  • best jenny I,ve seen so far.. we all need to petition and get hbo or show time to make a series there is a large enough fan audience to carry it through to the end.. a movie wont do it justice. ( the vampire chronicles)interview with a vampire. the left out key parts.

  • You hit the nail right on the head! I really hope it gets turned into a series. I do also believe that in a movie alot of vital parts will be left out. :)

  • Your video is awesome. I am new to Outlander and I am currently reading it. Your video rocks. I think Kate is Dead On For Claire. I would probably pick some one different for frank though.

    Tony Curran is Awesome and I love his firey red hair. He probably could pull it off, but When I think about Jamie I only see Gerard So if they ever make it into a movie I So Hope he does it. That man is phenominal.

    ~Chell from the U.S.

  • LOL! I love the book series, and was amused at your outlook! nice!

  • JAMIE IS SIMPLY HORRIBLE!!!

  • I seem to have gotten that alot! LOL! It's okay though.....Check out my Jamie-isms vid if you haven't already. ;)

  • Your Choice for Jamie in this video is not "SIMPLY HORRIBLE" I think Tony curran is a fantastic Actor and could probably pull it off. But You know who I want! lol

    ~chell

  • @Cloudette91

    I totally agree with YOU !!!! Tony Curran does NOT "fit the bill" as Jamie Fraser !!!! He doesn't have those gorgeous cat-eyes either !!!!

  • Brazil ;)

  • Very nice =D

    LOVE the choice of Karl Urban for Ian!

    Very handsome ^^^

    I'm from Brazil, btw...

    hugs

  • BTW: I'm from the UK (Scotland, actually. Aberdeenshire.) So any "Crosstitch" reference means "Outlander", honest!

  • Good video Jaqueline! I must admit the idea of Tony Curran as Jamie is a little disturbing. I agree however that Gerard Butler would probably do a stand up job, he's a mighty fine actor & not a bad looker either! I still have doubts even on that score,tad old maybe? But you'd probably need the age to get a good actor. Mind you I'm not sure Crosstitch should be made into a series, it may ruin it for some and no actor would ever fill Jamie's shoes I fear. Well sorry for waffling, good vid!

  • Hey, I think your vid is really well done! And most of your choices are spot on. But Tony Curran seriously upsets me as Jamie lol... I prefer someone like Gerard Butler, but then not everyone does :)

  • Ahh touche, I see you like Gerard too :P

  • LOL!!! You saw the Jamie-isms video? If you haven't you should check it out! ;)

  • oh my fuckin god! what's that? thats not jamie! jamie is....handsome and sexy and so on, not like tony.

    (i'm german so sorry for mistakes)

    but dougal is also disappointing. in the first book (i don't know how it's called in english...really "outlander"?) dougal is described pretty attractive.

    kate looks really like claire, only the hair... but (i don't know how it is called) a hair curler (?) could help =)

    i was surprised how good murtagh fits. i never could imagine murtagh before.

  • You should check out my new Jamie-isms video...with Gerry Butler. I know that alot of people didn't agree with Tony and Jamie....and that can be helped LOL!!!& Kate's hair should be curlier...LOL!

  • Continued: Dougal also was a disappointment; he should be a darker, older more cynical version of Jamie. Most of the rest of the casting I agreed with ... Murtagh should be shorter/more wiry.

    I also LOVE Diana Gabaldon's series ... have read all six books at least 3 times and also listened to a couple on my MP3 player in unabridge audio versions! Looking forward to more ... I nearly cried when I finished "A Breath of Snow and Ashes"

  • Kate as Claire is beautiful, but didn't quite fill the bill; Agree that she shouldn't be a blonde (that is Geillis and Lagohaire) but lighter than Kate; more med brown with sun bleached lighter streaks and very curly! Tony as Jamie is a total miscast! I agree with others that he should be VERY handsome, VERY large (tall and broad) as well as having gorgeous red hair.

  • Thanx for the comment! Since you don't agree with Tony as Jamie you should check out my new Jamie-isms vid....with Gerry Butler. I hope he is more agreeable.LOL!!!

  • This video was nice...but That WAS Not JAMIE FRASER!!!! I have read the total series. I Love Big Books!! And i'm thinkin bout readin it over

  • Well since you don't agree with Tony as Jamie you should watch my Jamie-isms vid...I am hoping that everyone will agree with Gerry Butler as Jamie! LOL!Thanx!

  • Well in some small way I do agree that a movie should not be made....there would be alot of details that would be lost...but still it would be great to actually see with your eyes instead of with your imagination! Look at how well Braveheart was...I think Outlander would make a great movie!

  • I can't wait for the movie!

  • i personally think rachel weiss or madeline stowe with curlier hair and either david wenham or gerard butler are the best claire and jamie characters. i agree with what people are saying though...there is no character that is jamie's equal. until that day...i don't think this movie should be made.

  • Rachel Weiss over Madeline Stowe...and Gerry Butler over David Wenham......

  • Its funny how I thought of how they would make this a movie over the 9 years I have been a huge fan, but every time, I knew of no one who could pull off Jamie. I think it would not do these absolutely wonderful books justice until you could fulfill this character.I did like the other characters though.

  • I think Gerry Butler could pull it off....come by my page and take a look and my new vid... and my new backround! ;)

  • I absolutely love Jamie and Claire and for the most part I can see the charachters but I agree with everyone else when it comes to Jamie. I picture him more handsome and with straighter hair. (sorry Tony but you don't do it for me!!)Diana has built this guy up to be super sexy and, well, you don't do it for me! Maybe an unknown?But, great work as it's lovely to see how many people love Jamie and Claire as I do!!

  • Not exactly who I would have pictured for Jamie, but he kinda grew on me, ya know? This is really great. The only things I thought were that Murtagh was a lot uglier, and I would have seen Sean Connery as Sir Marcus (yes very cliché, I know). Anyhow, thanks for sharing this. I know a lot of people have disagreed with your character choices, but overall I think you did really well.

    I'm from Vancouver Canada by the way.

  • Wow! I didn't even picture Sean Connery as Sir Marcus...what a great match! Thank you soooo much for your support. This was one of my very first videos....so I tried hard :) If you can stop by my page and check out my backround....It looks really good! :)

  • what a crack up ! Thank you for doing this; it was so fun to watch. i think i can express my opinion since i've read them all and listened to them all and gone to Scotland like alot of us outlander junkies. i thought it was fun and i liked your choices and come on ladys...casting Jamie is going to be hard, it's like finding the perfect face to play God in a movie. I can say that because i'm a Pagen at heart.

    thanks again for the fun movie and all your time.

  • First of all, Dougal is HOT not FAT and UGLY!!!

    second of all. WHAT THE... why the ugliness for jamie??? why? what did he ever do to you? just kidding. but seriously. murtaugh is basically better looking, which is just messed up.

    but i do really like the braveheart music... nice

  • I LOVE THIS BOOK. IM IN THE MIDDLE OF THE SECOND ONE SO FAR...

    Kate is perfect for Claire! You have good choices but there are a few I would disagree with. First of all, that is NOT JAIME FRASER!!! He isn't even good looking and just not the right fit at all. And I would swap your characters for Dougal and Colum. I see it the other way around definately!!!

    I'm in San Francisco, and I LOVE this book!!!

    AND I LOVE JAIME AND CLAIRE!!!

  • A very lovely video but I don't agree with some of your choices especially Jamie. I'm sorry but IMHO this guy is just plain ugly and we know our Jamie is not that. Also, I don't agree with Frank/Jonathan Randall. That's Wilson from House MD and he is a soft and gentle soul in my mind. I could never believe him as BJR. I think Kate Beckinsale could pull off Claire.

  • Where's Jerry Cournelius when you really need him?

  • When I think of Jamie I think tall, well built. The choice for Jaime is not what I picture. He should look more like a Viking, ruggedly handsome.

  • I thought the video was great. The only person I would change is Dougal.

  • Two comments:

    1) Gerard Butler would be a fantastic Jamie. He's 6'2" and already has the accent; all he'd need is red hair!  As well, he has that aura and charm that Jamie possesses.

    2) I don't know where some people are getting the idea that Claire is blonde, because Jamie repeatedly refers to her as 'mo nighean donn' (meaning, 'my brown-haired lass'). I was never, at any point in the entire series, under the impression that she was anything but a brunette!

    Other than that, fantastic casting!

  • I agree! Kate Beckinsale is a great choice for Claire. I don't like the choice for Jack Randall, he needs to be more dark and less baby looking. I liked all the rest of the choices.

  • Fantastic! I laughed all of the way through it! Great use of characters, imagery, music! Very creative!!

  • What a surprise! Imagined Jack Randall more like Dirk Bogarde. I think the majority agrees that Jamie here is NOT "our" Jamie, I have no suggestions but to keep looking for a replacement.Good going. On the whole great work!

  • OKAY!!! I GET IT!!! LOL! I can see that perhaps there could be someone better to play Jamie! So far I think there has been one person that agrees with my choice of Jaime! LOL! Check out the video response! And Claire is NOT Blonde!!!! She is a brunette! Jamie calles her "MO DUINNE"(MY BROWN ONE) am I right? or am I right!

  • I think yours is great! When I saw him in "Flight of the Phoenix" I thought of Jamie! I love your clip!

  • yay yes tony is great!

  • Hi Jacqueline!

    I'm from Laval Canada and I'm aslo a fan of the series. I just finished the last books last night... Can't wait for the next book! It's really like I can't wait to be with the whole gang right before bed ya know? And now I have to wait... (tear drops)... LOL... Great great great story! My favorite series EVER!

  • I love it!!! Except Jamie. Who can fill the roll of that character?? I wonder?!

  • Well, I can't remember what they say in the books, although I read all of them thouroughly, but I got the old version and on the cover, there is a picture of "Claire", a "blond" (not really...between blond and light brown) and I guess I stayed with the image of that lady as Claire. Anyone know for sur what hair color is Claire?

  • As far as I can remember Jamie describe her as being a mousey brown with gold ringlets....I think

  • Jamie never refers to Claire as mousey brown, its "MO DUINNE". It does refer to her eyes as being amber or as the color of whiskey when the sun shines through it.Her hair is never refered to as blonde

  • Go back and read the chapter entitle "One Fine Day." It's near the end of that section. Or, in Voyager chapter #26 "Whore's Brunch." It very clearly says in those sections that Claire is a brunette.

  • Geilis Duncan and Laoghaire were perfect tough. And Jenny! bravo!

  • I agree with everybody, Jamie is ugly in this video. He is supposed to be tall, very attractive and strong-looking. And Claire is supposed to be blonde! What's that brunette I see??? No no no! :P But bravo anyway for the video, u put a lot of effort into it ;)p-s: When in the world will a movie come out for this wonderful series?

  • where in the book does it say she is blonde? I know her to be brunette

  • i agree, I know her to be bruette...blonde???Where did that come from???

  • Claire is a brunette with curly hair...I really don't know were that came from! LOL! Thanx for watching...You should check out my Jamie-isms vid! :)

  • Claire is not blonde! mo duinne means my brown one, brown, curly hair! read the books again.

  • I don't see Tony Curran as Jamie, sorry...

  • Have to agree that all the characters are good, except Jamie. Jamie should be bigger, younger, and much more intimidating. Tony Curran is just not right for Jamie.

  • nice! I dont like Jamie though eww!

  • This is really cute...but he that guy is NOT JAMIE. hes not attractive and jamies only like 20.

  • Jamie is 24 in the beginning- and I agree with you, this guy isn't Jamie!

  • I was surprised to find an Outlander video.Congrats for the idea and the effort put to make it!I like it a lot! I believe that the choice of actors for Murtagh(yummie!!),Jenny,Ian and Frank were succesful.The actor chosen for Jamie in my opinion doesn't fit.He just doesn't have that special something Jamie does.And Jamie is supposed to be more handsome and younger.

  • Uggh...Tony Curran must go!

  • JACK BLACK RANDALL IS A PERV!!

  • woo cool!! yay tony!

  • PLEEEEASE!not him!

  • i must say, good job, but all the characters look too "pretty" for what i envisioned!!! except Tony Curran he's clearly much older then Jamie was in the book, he'd make a good OLDER Jamie, but for young you need a guy that is 23/24 the time of filming!

  • Oh yes definitly all the characters are spot on!! Shot gurl that was just awesome to watch. the only blemish I feel is Jamie - Gosh! Hez the only one I have a problem with. Someone like Paul Walker for instance - well someone hot anyway

    I hope they make a movie soon!!

  • Karl Urban cast in Outlander is too much to wish for (for me)but he's a great choice. I love Murtagh's character but Guy Pierce maybe too pretty. I don't mind though. cool selection.

  • Verra nice, Jacqueline! Kate Beckinsale is "pair-fect" for Claire! Unfortunately, you missed the boat on casting Jamie. Tony Curran may have fiery red hair, but that's about it. In the novels, Jamie is described as beautiful of FACE and FORM! Now let's have another long and wistful look at the gorgeous Scottish actor, Gerard Butler, shall we?

  • The music is the original orchestral soundtrack to Braveheart. There are 2 CDs. Music from...and more music from...I have them both, they're fantastic.

  • I love Tony Curran as Jamie - no reason why a younger actor can't be cast for the first two years - there was almost 20 years between times and Tony Curran would be perfect for the older, more battle hardened Jamie - and Emma Thompson for the older Claire! Imho of course!

    ** Music - did you mean Ella Fitzgerald and Louis Armstrong singing Dream a Little Dream, or the other?

  • Please someone...what is that amazing music???

  • It is from the movie Braveheart.

  • It's the original orchestral soundtrack to Braveheart.

  • Bravo !!! Even if Jamie could have been cast a bit more manly. I loved this actor in The 13TH Warrior. Bravo, Bravo !!

  • I can see why you chose Tony Curran! He looked his best in the 13th Warrior movie. Looks damn GOOD in a kilt too!

  • Kate Beckinsale is HOT!!!1

  • Wow when i read the book i actually did picture Kate Beckinsale as Claire!!!! I also love your casting of Jenny- inspired. Well done. I have to agree that jamie should be hotter

  • I love it!!! When can we see some more! this is my fav! ^-^

  • Very well put together, thank you. The only thing I highly disagree is your choice of actor to play Jamie. Main reason being that Jamie is 23/24 in the book, and this actor is clearly much older. Also, no offense to the actor, but he does not fit the attractive description of Jamie.

    Also, there was talk about an ABC mini-series, did it actually take place? if so, how can I obtain it?

  • the music is beautiful

    wats it called?

  • Very clever---I liked it. I wonder why there hasn't yet been a movie made...does any one know?

  • I loved the video and love the whole series. Hate to finish a book before the next one is published. I find myself wondering daily what Jamie and Claire are doing today.

  • I'm impressed..but 2 things, the Jamie was not hot, and by accident it said she didn't return to 1745 rather than 1945...yes i am one of those ppl that points out the obvious.

  • Very nice...but I don't think Ian is supposed to be so much hotter than Jamie. ;)

  • Wow

    Very good. May I ask where you get the map, and what is the last song? Thanks

  • I found the map in the Outladish Compainion and the song is the Scottish Wedding song in Braveheart. Thanks for the comment. :)

  • This is quiet a feat, Outlander in less than 10 minutes. Nice job.

  • Ha! I like it!

Loading...
0 / 00Unsaved Playlist Return to active list
    1. Your queue is empty. Add videos to your queue using this button:
      or sign in to load a different list.
    Loading...Loading...Saving...
    • Clear all videos from this list
    • Learn more