See, from 0:48 to 0:56, a kid gave a teacher an excuses that a kid didn't have time to write his name 20 times, so the teacher whips him 10 times on his back with a small but hard string.
@Martin19950926 No why should a child get punished for something that they obviously struggle with? He should of been helped first then if he did not do it then punished.
@CaRyS469 We cant know if he been helped before. I mean dont have time for home work is not a good reason. And 3 tries is enough and yes helping before works but helping to mutch does not give any effect. Because if it hurt you do it better next time. Like if you get punish by a older guy in school you will not threath him more because you gets scare of him because hes stronger.
Physical discipline made kids resilient as they enter the adulthood. That's why you have so many failures in the west, education of love...laugh my ass off.
@mickey3348 This is Taiwan, and by the look of their uniforms, it is a highly ranked school system. The west has higher failure because shifts the responsiblity away from the student/parents, and places its burden to the teachers to babysit, where the responsibility is largely ignored, and should be on the parents. This teacher is a good example of one who gives a damn.
I like the idea behind this movie! I thinks it's done very well. And the actors are amateurs, so please leave them alone. I think the boy is doing a great job for his age. And this is probably his first camera-experience, so be patient with him!
Actually its a beautiful film. The actors sucks but this is a critic to all those teachers that beat their student without knowing the circumstances of those kids.
omg this suxks ass hope woh ever likes this shit rools over and dies. this should be deleted for suxing so dam bad i hate u and ur mothers u dumb fuckers!!!!
this do really happen especially on chinese culture. i once saw this from a chinese friend where his mom would beat him up for failing to memorize some chinese paragraph, and sometimes even write half of the pad paper just to memorize writing those paragraphs.. i wonder if this kind of education has long term side effects like brutality etc...
I thought the film was done well. I guess some people don't understand the difference between reality and fiction. It may have been based in facts, but the footage shown was enacted after the fact. Nice Job!
..so this means i can hit my dog or cat? No? How about hitting criminals in jail? No? What about hitting my wife when she is bad...again, No? But oh yeah, when a small child makes a mistake in his young new life, hit them with a cane or board...This is "LEGAL CHILD ABUSE".....and dont tell me it isnt, i am not listening!
This isn't from China, people. I think it's a Malaysian film- sounds like from the accent. Anyway, I come from an education system that also used to believe in the harsh method of punishment to bring results. And it's not hard to see why, because truly it does produce the results, although it usually stems from the fear of the student and is at the expense of the student. Fortunately,rote learning is slowly being abolished and replaced now. This just reminds me of how growing up was like then.
鞭..?打一下就斷了=.=
xx456322 2 weeks ago
fake crying lol
hokangkia 2 months ago
好爛= =看不下去了...
herryhoho 3 months ago
The kid doesn't look like he's crying...
KatLoverz123 6 months ago
Poor kid
brucevideo1997 6 months ago
吊你老母咁都成個燃樣 又喊得難聽
s045604 7 months ago
See, from 0:48 to 0:56, a kid gave a teacher an excuses that a kid didn't have time to write his name 20 times, so the teacher whips him 10 times on his back with a small but hard string.
chenvincent54 8 months ago
Comment removed
chenvincent54 8 months ago
槟城有一间中学名校采用了''铁血政策'',那就是英文的'realpolitik'.自从有一位新主任升任过后,校规被改革得不知所谓,例如连头发怎样pin都被规定.还有就是,这位主任本身也是有教书,但是她可以喜欢喜欢进入随便一间课室训话,正在教课的老师就马上没有机会讲课了,她完全是没有给过其他老师面子,只是我行我素,因为她被她主任所拥有的权力冲昏了头脑.最可怕的是,只要学生不会回答她的问题,她马上破口大骂,而且是用吼的,她竟然还打电话给学生家长,非常小题大作.曾经有一次周会,学生犯了小错,她就对着全体接近200个人面前怒吼,弄得学生极尴尬.网友们,你们说,这类主任是不是很过火,且没有师德.
TANLL1 8 months ago
haha your first funny movie?
lotteboyhk 10 months ago
很假咯...
scar5230 10 months ago
That was right he did get like 3 chanches then punish and then you help him. Thats what should been in every school
Martin19950926 10 months ago
@Martin19950926 No why should a child get punished for something that they obviously struggle with? He should of been helped first then if he did not do it then punished.
CaRyS469 8 months ago
@CaRyS469 We cant know if he been helped before. I mean dont have time for home work is not a good reason. And 3 tries is enough and yes helping before works but helping to mutch does not give any effect. Because if it hurt you do it better next time. Like if you get punish by a older guy in school you will not threath him more because you gets scare of him because hes stronger.
Martin19950926 8 months ago
@Martin19950926 Yeah but did you learn to write all by yourself or did you get help? He obviously wasnt getting help at home.
CaRyS469 8 months ago
這位老師真的是好老師 但其實有時候還是不得不打 因為在別的孩子眼中 會變成偏心!
所以即使....還是要處罰 但其實老師也都知道 打的也痛心...這種老師 希望台灣能多一點........
hgvezhoo 11 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
請問能不能用我的短片做個簡單的回覆呢? 後半段有表明台灣教育爛的概略,希望您能
夠給小弟這個機會在youtube上和您做個交流。
crapuncivilized 11 months ago
Laughing or Crying?
TheHabboGIrlBoy 11 months ago
@TheHabboGIrlBoy i'm crying
roymonkey123 11 months ago
no bad, that helped me to practice my chinese xiexie
compos23 1 year ago
Rubish
cliff01x 1 year ago
好像是新马说的华语的腔调 O:
XiaoDeep 1 year ago
the boy face at 0:31 was annoying
ihsannysrock 1 year ago
the boy acting is horrible i mean when he was crying it was like he was smiling
I Hate this boy
ihsannysrock 1 year ago
Pathetic that they try to make out teacher do from love. no one who commits violence loves the person they beat.
She has LOT of choice what method of punishment she use
corpunthailand 1 year ago
*Sighs*......Taiwan sucks..........one must wonder how bad the crime rate is.
This teacher does seem somewhat remorseful, though.
JohnnyDart76 1 year ago
that's not you in the video is it?
Well anyways good movie
and no offence but it was hilarious.
diahanniah1 1 year ago
wtf!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
HAMIZOWA 1 year ago
= ="so hai lie all 乜
Linger94cheah 1 year ago
What the hell happend at 0:55
ThomasAZBB 2 years ago
@ThomasAZBB playing SM?
mangoPANGo0o 10 months ago
1:16開始就在笑 O_o
daopeng 2 years ago 4
Good intention & great efforts. Hope to see more and greater attempt.
chendimension 2 years ago
This is a made film LOL
Its not actually real. Since you could see all the effects and him crying. He wasn't really crying, was he?
ToMzLad 2 years ago 5
樣衰
d70073 2 years ago 2
why not look for better actors when you have good idea.
the expression is misleading.
ZH0224 2 years ago
lol his crying looks too fake, but still a powerful video
WarzJWG 2 years ago
lmao at the fake crying.
JadeJuvenescent 2 years ago 6
he looks like smiling more than crying lol
TormentedCurse 2 years ago 5
@TormentedCurse yeah it does
singerdancer07 1 year ago
I know it's played, but...
Quote: "i have no time"
Why doesn't this teacher question that?
Maybe the kid got bad parents that won't let him do homework.
And, smacking is never good!
Ok, i have an IQ of 148, but i want to help!
Ask me how to raise children without smacking!
HomoTriSapien 2 years ago
o video foi adicionado no dia do meu aniversário :)
DameImSchatten 2 years ago
嗨 怎么中国都是这样的老师 我当初读小学老师也是这种
a810319569 2 years ago
條友笑住...
waIb0bby248 2 years ago
hitting messed both of them up . never hit . if he didn't write his name ask him to draw a picture then sign his name..
123demaio 2 years ago
Physical discipline made kids resilient as they enter the adulthood. That's why you have so many failures in the west, education of love...laugh my ass off.
dasteufelhund 2 years ago 2
@dasteufelhund The west has failure? Stop making ridiculous jokes, Korea is messed up.
mickey3348 1 year ago
@mickey3348 This is Taiwan, and by the look of their uniforms, it is a highly ranked school system. The west has higher failure because shifts the responsiblity away from the student/parents, and places its burden to the teachers to babysit, where the responsibility is largely ignored, and should be on the parents. This teacher is a good example of one who gives a damn.
dasteufelhund 1 year ago
用心良苦啊!
s031508 2 years ago
ROFL ON 0:55 THROUGH 1:31
jsmoothie312 2 years ago
I like the idea behind this movie! I thinks it's done very well. And the actors are amateurs, so please leave them alone. I think the boy is doing a great job for his age. And this is probably his first camera-experience, so be patient with him!
MelindaRaven 2 years ago 2
哭到很。。。。yong sui lo haha
queener96 2 years ago
stupid fucked up country
andrewattakin 2 years ago 2
@andrewattakin agree, that is a fucked up country
clarksonfan92 1 year ago
條友喊得假,打撚柒佢
kp664 2 years ago 24
Oh dear, I better start studying now!
mzrealm 2 years ago
打人果個好扮野呀,,
我好想打佢
kaopuiyee 2 years ago
Actually its a beautiful film. The actors sucks but this is a critic to all those teachers that beat their student without knowing the circumstances of those kids.
incompleteinsanity 2 years ago
oh wow the kid is bad actor but who the hell would be to lazy to write ther name 10 times plus hes like 12 or 11 how can he speel it wrong 1/5
coltenandscott 2 years ago
我笑了/..
Ryanlau2007 2 years ago
好假
y1w2gt3h 2 years ago 3
yep the actors are suck
derekt423 2 years ago
omg this suxks ass hope woh ever likes this shit rools over and dies. this should be deleted for suxing so dam bad i hate u and ur mothers u dumb fuckers!!!!
narutoyum1 2 years ago
i dunno whats with you americans
you all seem to care too much about yourselves
and how 'cool' you are
and the way you insult people
i could pull a better insult out my hairy arse to be honest.
grow up.
Kodders92 2 years ago 6
THis is the most retardest flim i ever seen in my whole life
joeboiboi1 2 years ago
:D good work
aznboieiji 2 years ago
比人打個個好假.,,我都好想打佢
ken20174 2 years ago
its fake u retards
ReinaMJ 2 years ago
The way he was smiling after he was "punished" kind of made him look like an eight year old masochist
magdalenpetrus250 2 years ago
OH NO 10 WHOLE TIMES!
Vendetta5246 2 years ago
this is a crappy independent film
joliranchers 3 years ago 2
one needs to find a goal and work strenuously towards achieving the goal, as in a case of an athlete.
I personally think that studying doesn't really help to change one's fate.
ryanc519 3 years ago
he seems happy to be punished initially. what a sadistic kid.
ryanc519 3 years ago
he seems to be smiling.
winwinking 3 years ago
it looks like hes smiling
jasonalexjohn 3 years ago
the advice is awesome
MahalKoSiya618 3 years ago 2
我哋全班要掛隊俾校長用木尺打屁股都係咁, 閒事一椿 ,,,, 哈哈,
YAMET2008 3 years ago
陳樹旺~囧....
pcj2424 3 years ago
man that dude is a bad actor..
what a fake cry
dynamitelady 3 years ago 2
He's 8?? or around that? He's not osmond i grant you that
Kawagata 3 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
fucking ugly chinese they shold get their heads cut off
demolisher123 3 years ago
lol thats kinda racist.
cronus00104 3 years ago
this do really happen especially on chinese culture. i once saw this from a chinese friend where his mom would beat him up for failing to memorize some chinese paragraph, and sometimes even write half of the pad paper just to memorize writing those paragraphs.. i wonder if this kind of education has long term side effects like brutality etc...
csp2780 3 years ago
太逗了
149512817 3 years ago
這個像媽媽吧...一點不像老師..
kookinwa21 3 years ago
哭的很假= =
tt741852 3 years ago 2
個細路俾人打完個樣好似笑緊咁 忍住扮喊
calmohk 3 years ago
I thought the film was done well. I guess some people don't understand the difference between reality and fiction. It may have been based in facts, but the footage shown was enacted after the fact. Nice Job!
king9671091 3 years ago 4
太假了。反差太大了。爱打人的老师绝不会装温柔!
audylynn 3 years ago
this is fake it's not real
WHHS2002 3 years ago
LOLOLOL! wtf?
kittymunch22 3 years ago
No offense but this is really hilarious.
KuroiiTenshii 3 years ago 18
@KuroiiTenshii LOL THERE ALL LAUGHING INSIDE LIKE DAAAAAAAAMMMMMMMMMMMMNNN!
ange8001994 1 year ago
That Kid Wasn't Crying, He Was Laughing!!
charliehdavies 3 years ago 2
faking u can see through his face and he is kind of smiling
akatsukifan1234 3 years ago
Stupid bitch! That was so mean! :@
WatchOutDuck 3 years ago
演得太差
arroyandfriends 3 years ago 5
most people are COMPLETELY missed the point of this video, although they make some good points
thien0995 3 years ago
假的啦,Pui
DarkHeaVen92 3 years ago 4
Some times it's just better to smash the kid in the face LOL jk
Lawrence818 3 years ago
Huh? I thought it was from China. I recognized some Chinese words. -hallucinates-
llamaperpango 3 years ago
He looked like he wanted to crack up in the beginning.
xCrayonsx 3 years ago
..so this means i can hit my dog or cat? No? How about hitting criminals in jail? No? What about hitting my wife when she is bad...again, No? But oh yeah, when a small child makes a mistake in his young new life, hit them with a cane or board...This is "LEGAL CHILD ABUSE".....and dont tell me it isnt, i am not listening!
fitasafiddle123 3 years ago 4
That "teacher" should have her teeth knocked out. IF she ever hit my kid, she would be eating through a feeding tube the rest of her life!
fitasafiddle123 3 years ago 4
omg,操你媽的
那個小孩哭得多假哦
STa3308 3 years ago 8
so grea!it's short movie but I still like it
nnhangmasiptungkha 3 years ago
ok the movie was gay but what he has to do at home was touching....ima go eat some pizza pockets now ^.^
ilovenoodles1995 3 years ago
Aww. . the part about his home life is kinda sad.
ashlie700 3 years ago
wtf........
UnGotz1 3 years ago
This isn't from China, people. I think it's a Malaysian film- sounds like from the accent. Anyway, I come from an education system that also used to believe in the harsh method of punishment to bring results. And it's not hard to see why, because truly it does produce the results, although it usually stems from the fear of the student and is at the expense of the student. Fortunately,rote learning is slowly being abolished and replaced now. This just reminds me of how growing up was like then.
charlottejena 3 years ago
when spanking is banned all over the world, watch how crime goes up. britain is already suffering from the loss of the cane.
Negrocheetah 3 years ago 2
Miles2662, just go fuck yourself. You don't know anything about child psychology.
Rexionor 3 years ago
his family didn't have money so he had to work with his dad so they could have money and he REALLY was busy!
lilstar5973 3 years ago 2
so you would uderstnd that you should punish acording to age
lilstar5973 3 years ago 4
well escuse me but he is very young to take a spanking with cane
lilstar5973 3 years ago
i know but hes only in like the first grade
lilstar5973 3 years ago
i understand what you mean but she shouldn't hav used a cane.
lilstar5973 3 years ago
哭到很假咯。。。
crazyjimmy5566 3 years ago 2
還在笑- -
pigvincent 3 years ago
dude!!!! you could tell that the kids not crying
and um....... fuck that last word((to change your destiny,you must study))
joshuafag10316 3 years ago
That's not learning. Dude! I'm fucking sick of this asian mother fuckers. That's why so many students come to school in america, maybe?
nightimer5 3 years ago
许多老师以为只要读书就是好孩子。但是现在的学校课本已经今非昔比。不断鼓励考试,造就不好真正人才。对孩子的孩子教育,往往是长辈的言行举止为主。课本只是辅助而已。教育一定要建立在爱的基础上。
hanwudi3206 3 years ago
The teacher shoud've helped him right away in spelling his name.. He just didin't know how too. so sad too see..
simzayy 4 years ago
i wud fuckin pik the cane back up and fuck her up with it.
AntonRockit 4 years ago
Its sad to see a child being punished like this. But the good thing is that this is not allowed in China anymore
trapezagirl 4 years ago
Actually, this video reminds me of the 20 reasons that "I HATE SCHOOL"
MythLedgend 4 years ago
Asian Teacher says Haysha Rav-va Means Face the Blackboard and then Teacher Whoops Chen shu wang ass and Crys. Teacher get fired and go to Jail.
MySniklson25 4 years ago
this is sAD. how mean and rude can people get?
Zebrachicktori 4 years ago
thank GOD this is no longer legal in China! Teacher gets caught,she would be arrested and thrown in jail!
SeattleDad 4 years ago
the guy below me is a fuckface with no heart >:[
imissyoubunchesxoxo 4 years ago
很有意思的片子。。。 唉。。。有几个老师是真的想要鞭打孩子呢?当教师真的不简单啊!
tangtangst 4 years ago