Brigitte is AMAZING but I do not like Gruberova ; she has not the right "feeling" to sing this Role and looks like a "woman" and not like a "young girl" - on the other side Fassbaender is absolutely PERFECT : I love her and wath a sense of the music ! We are lucky Brigitte has done many Moovies !!
This Vienna Opera performance is the best ever. Popp and Fassbaender are such fine actors that you soon believe they are youngsters caught up in this adventure with the wicked witch. Their wonderful singing is matched by Hermann Prey as their father. The staging is magical, too. Georg Solti conducts the opera and the audience is all childlren who watch Hansel and Gretel with expressions of fear and joy that reflect the story being presented in the opera. It all is available on DVD--a must.
Fassbaender-- what a musician. These are the best performances of this opera....they are the only ones that embody the German style. There are some things that only Germans should sing......
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
im sorry to say so but if i were gruberova i wouldnt appear as silly as she appears in this role...she is supposed to be a kid here and she is how old exactly? 40++??? estheticaly dreadful!
Do you honestly think she looks more ridiculous here than she does as Gilda in Ponnelle's Rigoletto?
Actually, I think the makeup and wardrobe department, coupled with the oversize sets, did an excellent job of making she and Faasbaender look like little kids.
Lohengrin thinks Gruberova looks ridiculous here; I must respectfully disagree, although I do think Judith Blegen looks more girlish in the Metropolitan opera video.
It's fine but nowhere near the level of her German stuff.Bel canto gives her more freedom and she unfortunately resorts too often to mannerisms that spoil it for me. My favourite Italian Gruberova role is her Giulietta.
I think she is really a bel canto specialist, she uses much legatos, as you say scooping. I think that this "scooping" is really difficult to sing, for exapmle I think Sutherland couldn't do it.. this is just edita's style. take it or leave it.
I take the roles she does that I like, and leave others. I didn't mention scooping and I didn't mean just that. The fact that it's difficult to scoop doesn't make it correct. Pushing the chest voice (something Gruberova doesn't do) is also difficult and an impressive effect but it's not right if you're singing bel canto.
and who says it;s not right... you? nodoby says scooping is correct and nobody said pushing chest voice is also correct. or do u want to tell me you were born in the 18th century to know what's bel canto..?
Wonderful! They are both fabulous and a joy to watch! Thanks for posting! Going to look for more. Hope you posted!?
Paddy818 1 month ago
So schön! Der Grubi hätten sie die Zöpfe aber lang lassen können.
Die beiden spielen so toll und singen phantastisch. Könnte es mir nicht besser vorstellen!
sniebling 1 year ago
Was ist das schön...
PapagenoHannover 1 year ago
Comment removed
PapagenoHannover 1 year ago
Edi ist soooooooo süß drin!!!!!!
SopranoYuHong 1 year ago
Do you have the next scene with Hermann Prey as the father? The acting in all the parts are just fantastic(of course the singing is great)!
Sriverkiller86 1 year ago
Brigitte is AMAZING but I do not like Gruberova ; she has not the right "feeling" to sing this Role and looks like a "woman" and not like a "young girl" - on the other side Fassbaender is absolutely PERFECT : I love her and wath a sense of the music ! We are lucky Brigitte has done many Moovies !!
Nilakanta1955 1 year ago
Ja, das ist klasse!
BUweB 2 years ago
1st, not 1th
Justinchess 2 years ago 2
Prefiero la versión de Ann Murray y Gruberova!!
Thiktum 2 years ago
Wundervoll !!!
Ich liebe Gruberova und Fassbaender.
parker930 2 years ago
This Vienna Opera performance is the best ever. Popp and Fassbaender are such fine actors that you soon believe they are youngsters caught up in this adventure with the wicked witch. Their wonderful singing is matched by Hermann Prey as their father. The staging is magical, too. Georg Solti conducts the opera and the audience is all childlren who watch Hansel and Gretel with expressions of fear and joy that reflect the story being presented in the opera. It all is available on DVD--a must.
11777766 2 years ago
This is not Popp; it is Gruberova!
parker930 2 years ago
Sorry. It is Groberova, and great.
11777766 2 years ago
Fassbaender-- what a musician. These are the best performances of this opera....they are the only ones that embody the German style. There are some things that only Germans should sing......
goto41 2 years ago
Eines der besten Opern die es Gibt.
Mit wunderschönen Melodien
tenderlahn 3 years ago 10
LOL at the expression on the mom's face while they roll down the hill.
Satirike 3 years ago
Please post the rest of the opera - excellent xD
Satirike 3 years ago 4
lovely!
Klassizismus 3 years ago
Please post the rest! It's so good!
Opreaismylife10692 3 years ago
do i look like linds lohan?
dedniel 3 years ago
Helga Dernesch(die mutter) was also 41 here..
Fafner79 3 years ago
Fassbaender was 41, born 1939=)
Fafner79 3 years ago
Gruberova was 33 in this recording(1980).
Fafner79 3 years ago
Do you know how old was Fassbänder?
NathalieDessayFan 3 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
im sorry to say so but if i were gruberova i wouldnt appear as silly as she appears in this role...she is supposed to be a kid here and she is how old exactly? 40++??? estheticaly dreadful!
Lohengrin 3 years ago
disagreed.
Amanderina 3 years ago 2
Do you honestly think she looks more ridiculous here than she does as Gilda in Ponnelle's Rigoletto?
Actually, I think the makeup and wardrobe department, coupled with the oversize sets, did an excellent job of making she and Faasbaender look like little kids.
nclysander 3 years ago
i dont get it.... who is ridiculous and who thinks so?
theinkbrain 3 years ago
Lohengrin thinks Gruberova looks ridiculous here; I must respectfully disagree, although I do think Judith Blegen looks more girlish in the Metropolitan opera video.
nclysander 3 years ago
i think they are both adorable, but especially brigitte! i loved the clip and i loved them both
! thank you for your response.
peace.
theinkbrain 3 years ago
canto incantevole e meravigliosa recitazione!
das ist echtes Zauber!
Topodiluna 4 years ago
que tiernooo, jijijij, bonito, bonito
melisandedebussy 4 years ago
mit den Füßchen, tapp, tapp, tapp,
mit den Händchen, klapp, klapp, klapp,
einmal hin, einmal her
um, herum, es ist nich schwer...
i would say they are both better than my own mother, who used to sing it to me, when a child (I mean it)...
Both Gruberova and Fassbänder are simply and enjoyably great.
bogdankos 4 years ago
echt scheußliche Aufnahme!!!
Spenger1 4 years ago
Wieso scheußlich? Die beiden sind großartig.
schmitka1308 4 years ago 3
Gruberova and Fassbaender is awesomeeeeee.Fassbaender is real Hansel with her acting and voice.I love her
armida23dalila 4 years ago
Both perfect for their roles. German repertoire suits Gruberova best.
Orfeus80 4 years ago
Well, maybe, but her italian repertoire (belcanto) is nod bad too ...oder?
Dondinin 4 years ago
It's fine but nowhere near the level of her German stuff.Bel canto gives her more freedom and she unfortunately resorts too often to mannerisms that spoil it for me. My favourite Italian Gruberova role is her Giulietta.
Orfeus80 4 years ago
I think she is really a bel canto specialist, she uses much legatos, as you say scooping. I think that this "scooping" is really difficult to sing, for exapmle I think Sutherland couldn't do it.. this is just edita's style. take it or leave it.
I like her bel canto roles the most.
blidloch 4 years ago
I take the roles she does that I like, and leave others. I didn't mention scooping and I didn't mean just that. The fact that it's difficult to scoop doesn't make it correct. Pushing the chest voice (something Gruberova doesn't do) is also difficult and an impressive effect but it's not right if you're singing bel canto.
Orfeus80 4 years ago
and who says it;s not right... you? nodoby says scooping is correct and nobody said pushing chest voice is also correct. or do u want to tell me you were born in the 18th century to know what's bel canto..?
blidloch 4 years ago
Hast du noch mehr Szenen von Hänsel und Gretel??? dringend reinstellen!!!!!
Bikerhannover 4 years ago
Okay...so I like Gretel's voice...but I LOOOOOVE Hansels. Its absolutely georgeous.
Amanderina 4 years ago
Agreed! I'm in love. :)
cleareyedwolf 3 years ago 2
Wunderschön!!!
mariavelasco 4 years ago 2