There really is no debate, as Americans For Fair Taxation's OWN RESEARCH states this fact: the "Fair" Tax aka National Sales Tax-Inclusive aka NASTI would on average raise the effective taxes (i.e. raise the amount of taxes they pay) of those making from around $15,000 to $150,000 ,and would on average lower the taxes paid by those who make more than $150,000 a year. It is a very bad idea, and would destroy the US economy if enacted. Thankfully it never will even be considered for a vote.
999 looks like 666 upside down. DUH! Cain is a Federal Reserve Chairman and knows and approves of all that they do and is in agreement with them that the Fed needs no audit. BS
People who work for a wage in exchange for labor do not owe a "tax". Originally Tax was to be on "PROFIT" only. A company takes the revenue less expenses and pays taxes on net profit. I am unable to write anything off of my taxes. If we didn't have a BLOATED government we wouldn't need the BLOATED tax revenues. DUH!
(people wo like this play) did you idiots at least spend 30 minutes on this plan, study hard then Ill take back about you guys being idiots. look at both arguements
Re the "Fair" Tax, from Americans For Fair Taxation's own research--
"Not every household would benefit equally, however. (edit) Mid-income category households* would lose because the FairTax would impose a relatively higher tax rate on them." tinyurl 593htl
*those making from $15,000 to $150,000 a year
Supporters cannot challenge the statement that it would raise the effective tax rates of the middleclasses, because doing so negates the research they base their other arguments on.
@1969was1969 Have you actually read the Fair Tax book? I have. I had many questions as I was reading it but, by the time I finished it I had no unanswered questions.
@glrivera1 Many falsehoods in the book have been revealed. Boortz makes many false styatements, but then, there is no good reason to accept Boortz, an ultrarightwing radio DJ, as some kind of authority on economics anyway. Have you read Americans for Fair Taxation's research, the research Boortz touts? Their own research states very clearly, those making from $15,000 to $150,000 a year "would lose" if this tax were enacted, because they would on average pay in more in as federal taxes.
His 9-9-9 plan would be the biggest shift in wealth from the poor and middle class to the rich in history. He doesn't have a clue about foreign policy. He thinks being gay is a choice. He would not appoint a Muslim to any position in his administration and he is against abortion EVEN in the case of rape and incest. Cain blames the unemployed for being unemployed while business have cut 14 million jobs. Herman Cain is a humongous hemorrhoid....
47 % don't pay INCOME TAX ! Why , they are too fucking enslaved to the Lucky Predator Class . This is the guy , Boortz , who referred to the ppl in the Superdome
@Redlocokixx Please note that Herman Cain's plan also includes some 000. No payroll tax saves all workers 15.3%, no capital gains tax, no dividend taxes. These 0's all create jobs and a flow of capital to the USA. Plus you get someone who is from a humble background that is very articulate in getting America behind a bold new plan. I don't see RP having much success rallying people to get Congress to attack our problems. Cain is Abel to take them head on with his communication style!
@CPAsheldon thank you for the information, its realy good to know more.....but also did you know the Cain did work for the FED, and he never did see the house collapse coming and he was very critical to Ron Paul, that pridict the collapse in 2003 to 2007 ? don't take my words, do like i did to your information, i did chek and search b4 sanding this to you..Thank you.
He tells people that his 999 plan will decrease taxes for the poor, while actually it increases taxes for income levels below $200,000.- and decreases taxes only for those with an income greater than $200,000.-
Your question Why do I get an exemption for beging married? You don't ,you get a personal exemption, you and your husband, if it disappears you will pay more in taxes...
Why do I get a deduction for having children?It's meant to help working families (less taxes) which your are for..... less taxes?
Do you have children? If you do you pay less in taxes, because of them....
Just as I expected, Herman Cain unveils that he will give special incentives for people in poor communities. He is just like all other authoritarians who use tax code to punish and to control behavior. Again, Ron Paul is the only principled candidate with a perfect record of sticking to his philosophy.
People just don't understand that they are paying those taxes now. Just because you can't see it, doesn't mean it's not there. The other presidential candidates know but most of them don't WANT to give up the gov's ability to control what we do with the tax code. One of the best things about Cain's plan is that we eliminate the gov's ability to continue social engineering with taxes. Romney said it won't replace state taxes. No, Mitt, the feds can't take away the taxes MA is saddled with.
@mrgetrealpeople Why do I get an exemption for beging married? Why do I get a deduction for having children?
You are thinking of the new system in the same terms as the old. Money earned will be taxed less and the price of goods won't be as bad as you think because the taxes that are involved in the price of things now will be gone or drastically lowered. Besides, you have control over that tax. Buy less. I don't have control over being paid less.
@Rhiannon003 999 doubles taxes LLC's, S CORP'S,.LLP's..92% of business owners....example c-corps make up just 8% of american business.
that means 92% of the income passes to the business owner is taxed once, current law , 999 tax plan taxes 9% business 9% income to the owner from that business....effectively taxing 92% of Business owners twice... this law treats all business as c-corps .....the devil is always in the details...
Try this: Abolish the IRS, and instead of taxing, JUST PRINT MONEY.
I'm only half-kidding. We're already printing fake money. Why have an IRS if we're going to do that? Just print a little more and save everyone the headache of filling in forms.
Indeed, the people would still pay, in the form of a diluted dollar, but it's still the most efficient way, and you can't get a fairer tax than that!
Dig deeper folks. 9% is a big tax cut for the rich. If your income is from investing then you pay nothing since the capital gains tax will go away. The rich get richer and no, they don't always buy new. They spend most of their money on collectible stuff (cars, boats, etc) that usually are not new. Businesses will not be able to deduct their expenses anymore which will drive up the cost of the merchandise they produce. Add the 9% fed tax + the state + local sales tax and wow, super inflation!
Boortz, like Cain, does not give a damn about the poor or the middle class, they are neither one in either of those segments of society. The only people they care about is how to lower the taxes on the rich and keep from having to pay their fair share.
Herman Cain (Kong) will never be the republican presidential nominee. The one and only nigger president America has ever had has already done too much damage. I will work with Cantor, Paul Ryan and my other GOP brothers to make sure Cain (Kong) fails. Mitt Romney will be America's next president! God bless the GOP!
Why would people think it is going to be better for the wealthy? Rich people spend more money! Rich people buy NEW things. They do not buy used items like most people do. No tax on used items. HUGE taxes on New things. Wealthy people would be the back bone of our Social Security and Medicare.
Here is what EVERYONE is missing with the 9-9-9 plan that Cain claims to be transparent. Most states have a state level sales tax that is passed on to consumers and larger cities even have local sales taxes on top of the state sales tax. Add another 9% as a federal sales tax and in most states consumers will be paying 15% to 20% in sales tax alone! And this will improve the economy??? Will Cain try and persuade the states to drop their tax base (LMAO!) or would this be the 'gotcha' in the end?
What the hell was with the attitude when he said "the 999 plan, have you heard about it?" He doesn't even know what it is, why is he being a smartass?
I like how Ron Paul doesn't participate in class warfare. What's good for America is good for blacks. "Thy BlackMan.com" compares Cain to Paul and chooses Paul! Google "Ron Paul & Herman Cain's Different Philosophies" by Staff
Re: Israel, Google "Are Evangelical Christians Warmongers" by Pastor Chuck Baldwin
Ron Paul re: Hispanics - great interview /watch?v=oHiKRVm7ziA
Cain said "I don't know much about foreign policy, but I can learn."
We need a TEACHER, not a student! Ron Paul, President 2012
@SmallTimeMusicians I'll tell what you owe under his 999 plan, it's a hell of a lot more then you're paying now if your poor as you claim, no deductions for your kids or interest for you house ..... 9% income 9% business tax 9% national sales tax, new car average around 25,000x9=2,250 in tax, average new house 243,900 tax=21,951
Food,energy,clothes,anything new additional 9% national sale tax 88% people will pay more in taxes..
This has been flagged as spam show
There really is no debate, as Americans For Fair Taxation's OWN RESEARCH states this fact: the "Fair" Tax aka National Sales Tax-Inclusive aka NASTI would on average raise the effective taxes (i.e. raise the amount of taxes they pay) of those making from around $15,000 to $150,000 ,and would on average lower the taxes paid by those who make more than $150,000 a year. It is a very bad idea, and would destroy the US economy if enacted. Thankfully it never will even be considered for a vote.
Diskatopia 4 months ago
why is everybody all of a sudden interested in cutting taxes or changing the tax system?
question em!
concussedcarneous 4 months ago
@concussedcarneous You have Got to be kidding!
glrivera1 3 months ago
999 looks like 666 upside down. DUH! Cain is a Federal Reserve Chairman and knows and approves of all that they do and is in agreement with them that the Fed needs no audit. BS
People who work for a wage in exchange for labor do not owe a "tax". Originally Tax was to be on "PROFIT" only. A company takes the revenue less expenses and pays taxes on net profit. I am unable to write anything off of my taxes. If we didn't have a BLOATED government we wouldn't need the BLOATED tax revenues. DUH!
organichik 4 months ago
(people wo like this play) did you idiots at least spend 30 minutes on this plan, study hard then Ill take back about you guys being idiots. look at both arguements
tnuoccak3v 4 months ago 2
Comment removed
tnuoccak3v 4 months ago
Should high school students pay taxes? How about college students?
wosh11 4 months ago
Re the "Fair" Tax, from Americans For Fair Taxation's own research--
"Not every household would benefit equally, however. (edit) Mid-income category households* would lose because the FairTax would impose a relatively higher tax rate on them." tinyurl 593htl
*those making from $15,000 to $150,000 a year
Supporters cannot challenge the statement that it would raise the effective tax rates of the middleclasses, because doing so negates the research they base their other arguments on.
1969was1969 4 months ago
@1969was1969 Have you actually read the Fair Tax book? I have. I had many questions as I was reading it but, by the time I finished it I had no unanswered questions.
glrivera1 3 months ago
@glrivera1 Many falsehoods in the book have been revealed. Boortz makes many false styatements, but then, there is no good reason to accept Boortz, an ultrarightwing radio DJ, as some kind of authority on economics anyway. Have you read Americans for Fair Taxation's research, the research Boortz touts? Their own research states very clearly, those making from $15,000 to $150,000 a year "would lose" if this tax were enacted, because they would on average pay in more in as federal taxes.
Diskatop 3 months ago
but why did he win Navada? who could possibly vote for this guy?
concussedcarneous 4 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
His 9-9-9 plan would be the biggest shift in wealth from the poor and middle class to the rich in history. He doesn't have a clue about foreign policy. He thinks being gay is a choice. He would not appoint a Muslim to any position in his administration and he is against abortion EVEN in the case of rape and incest. Cain blames the unemployed for being unemployed while business have cut 14 million jobs. Herman Cain is a humongous hemorrhoid....
rocky19421 4 months ago
Im as left wing liberal as they come. And I fully support the FAIR TAX.
999 kinna sounds pretty much like the same thing.
nanerrat 4 months ago 2
47 % don't pay INCOME TAX ! Why , they are too fucking enslaved to the Lucky Predator Class . This is the guy , Boortz , who referred to the ppl in the Superdome
as trash .
hieronomy 4 months ago
i like 0 0 0 from Ron Paul
Redlocokixx 4 months ago
@Redlocokixx Please note that Herman Cain's plan also includes some 000. No payroll tax saves all workers 15.3%, no capital gains tax, no dividend taxes. These 0's all create jobs and a flow of capital to the USA. Plus you get someone who is from a humble background that is very articulate in getting America behind a bold new plan. I don't see RP having much success rallying people to get Congress to attack our problems. Cain is Abel to take them head on with his communication style!
CPAsheldon 4 months ago
@CPAsheldon thank you for the information, its realy good to know more.....but also did you know the Cain did work for the FED, and he never did see the house collapse coming and he was very critical to Ron Paul, that pridict the collapse in 2003 to 2007 ? don't take my words, do like i did to your information, i did chek and search b4 sanding this to you..Thank you.
Redlocokixx 4 months ago
@1soccerfanful I think you got anger issues.
Marksnotebook 4 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
He tells people that his 999 plan will decrease taxes for the poor, while actually it increases taxes for income levels below $200,000.- and decreases taxes only for those with an income greater than $200,000.-
--> tinyurl(dot)com/cainsays2
croakingembryo 4 months ago
Your question Why do I get an exemption for beging married? You don't ,you get a personal exemption, you and your husband, if it disappears you will pay more in taxes...
Why do I get a deduction for having children?It's meant to help working families (less taxes) which your are for..... less taxes?
Do you have children? If you do you pay less in taxes, because of them....
mrgetrealpeople 4 months ago
Just as I expected, Herman Cain unveils that he will give special incentives for people in poor communities. He is just like all other authoritarians who use tax code to punish and to control behavior. Again, Ron Paul is the only principled candidate with a perfect record of sticking to his philosophy.
VINNYMOR 4 months ago
People just don't understand that they are paying those taxes now. Just because you can't see it, doesn't mean it's not there. The other presidential candidates know but most of them don't WANT to give up the gov's ability to control what we do with the tax code. One of the best things about Cain's plan is that we eliminate the gov's ability to continue social engineering with taxes. Romney said it won't replace state taxes. No, Mitt, the feds can't take away the taxes MA is saddled with.
Rhiannon003 4 months ago
@Rhiannon003 You're a fucking idiot ,the average person will pay a lot more in taxes, with this new plan,
example
1.no mortgage interest deductions....do you have mortgage interest.
2.No personal exemption, you or your spouse ....This means you..
3.No children deductions.... Got children?
4.No second home interest deductions....You ?
5.No Ira deductions ..You?
Now everything you buy new, Cars, Homes,Food,energy,smart phones,clothes,tools, gets a 9% national sells tax.
mrgetrealpeople 4 months ago
@mrgetrealpeople Why do I get an exemption for beging married? Why do I get a deduction for having children?
You are thinking of the new system in the same terms as the old. Money earned will be taxed less and the price of goods won't be as bad as you think because the taxes that are involved in the price of things now will be gone or drastically lowered. Besides, you have control over that tax. Buy less. I don't have control over being paid less.
Rhiannon003 4 months ago
@Rhiannon003 999 doubles taxes LLC's, S CORP'S,.LLP's..92% of business owners....example c-corps make up just 8% of american business.
that means 92% of the income passes to the business owner is taxed once, current law , 999 tax plan taxes 9% business 9% income to the owner from that business....effectively taxing 92% of Business owners twice... this law treats all business as c-corps .....the devil is always in the details...
mrgetrealpeople 4 months ago
@mrgetrealpeople
999 will create jobs and Entice Companies to invest into the USA
Retailers will actually lower the price of goods to augment the the National Sales Tax!
430 billion dollars could be saved by scraping the IRS tax code
lower the lobbyist influence of Congress
yomamajama777 4 months ago
@mrgetrealpeople
999 is bullshit and so are you if you are bitchin and whining cause you might lose all the above subsidies .
hieronomy 4 months ago
Reverse Robin Hood
WHITEHOUSE1600DC 4 months ago
Try this: Abolish the IRS, and instead of taxing, JUST PRINT MONEY.
I'm only half-kidding. We're already printing fake money. Why have an IRS if we're going to do that? Just print a little more and save everyone the headache of filling in forms.
Indeed, the people would still pay, in the form of a diluted dollar, but it's still the most efficient way, and you can't get a fairer tax than that!
pburto 4 months ago
Dig deeper folks. 9% is a big tax cut for the rich. If your income is from investing then you pay nothing since the capital gains tax will go away. The rich get richer and no, they don't always buy new. They spend most of their money on collectible stuff (cars, boats, etc) that usually are not new. Businesses will not be able to deduct their expenses anymore which will drive up the cost of the merchandise they produce. Add the 9% fed tax + the state + local sales tax and wow, super inflation!
brcjacks 4 months ago
Comment removed
sargetech 4 months ago
Boortz, like Cain, does not give a damn about the poor or the middle class, they are neither one in either of those segments of society. The only people they care about is how to lower the taxes on the rich and keep from having to pay their fair share.
uummmiforgot 4 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Herman Cain (Kong) will never be the republican presidential nominee. The one and only nigger president America has ever had has already done too much damage. I will work with Cantor, Paul Ryan and my other GOP brothers to make sure Cain (Kong) fails. Mitt Romney will be America's next president! God bless the GOP!
GOPkicksbutt 4 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Im in Calif and 9.99% Fed sales tax + 9.25% State Ca Sales tax = 19.24% Sales tax!!
Good Luck with that idea! LOOSER
m530bc 4 months ago
Why would people think it is going to be better for the wealthy? Rich people spend more money! Rich people buy NEW things. They do not buy used items like most people do. No tax on used items. HUGE taxes on New things. Wealthy people would be the back bone of our Social Security and Medicare.
glrivera1 4 months ago
@glrivera1 Define rich people?
mrgetrealpeople 4 months ago
@mrgetrealpeople I know the government says it is 250k and above but 100k to me is rich.
gingerschance 4 months ago
Comment removed
gingerschance 4 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Here is what EVERYONE is missing with the 9-9-9 plan that Cain claims to be transparent. Most states have a state level sales tax that is passed on to consumers and larger cities even have local sales taxes on top of the state sales tax. Add another 9% as a federal sales tax and in most states consumers will be paying 15% to 20% in sales tax alone! And this will improve the economy??? Will Cain try and persuade the states to drop their tax base (LMAO!) or would this be the 'gotcha' in the end?
paulcoonan 4 months ago
makes perfect sense. Go Herman Cain.
msusesherbrain 4 months ago
You go, Mr. Cain.
somedudeinva 5 months ago
What the hell was with the attitude when he said "the 999 plan, have you heard about it?" He doesn't even know what it is, why is he being a smartass?
DontFriendInviteMe 5 months ago
I'm poor, but I'd rather know how much I am going to owe, rather than have to pay someone to find out what I owe!
A genius takes something complicated and simplifies it!
SmallTimeMusicians 5 months ago 9
This has been flagged as spam show
I like how Ron Paul doesn't participate in class warfare. What's good for America is good for blacks. "Thy BlackMan.com" compares Cain to Paul and chooses Paul! Google "Ron Paul & Herman Cain's Different Philosophies" by Staff
Re: Israel, Google "Are Evangelical Christians Warmongers" by Pastor Chuck Baldwin
Ron Paul re: Hispanics - great interview /watch?v=oHiKRVm7ziA
Cain said "I don't know much about foreign policy, but I can learn."
We need a TEACHER, not a student! Ron Paul, President 2012
vechorik 4 months ago
@SmallTimeMusicians I'll tell what you owe under his 999 plan, it's a hell of a lot more then you're paying now if your poor as you claim, no deductions for your kids or interest for you house ..... 9% income 9% business tax 9% national sales tax, new car average around 25,000x9=2,250 in tax, average new house 243,900 tax=21,951
Food,energy,clothes,anything new additional 9% national sale tax 88% people will pay more in taxes..
mrgetrealpeople 3 months ago