Yes really IS too bad! And I LOVE Mindy Gledhill, I looked her up when I saw your reply! Thanks for introducing me to yet ANOTHER artist that ACTUALLY has talent. And I am VERY enthusiastic. Lol sorry! : P
If you were an ice cream flavor you'd be my favorite one <3
@manfromregina Oh? and I certainly don't see your name anywhere under the category of "International Professional Vocal Singer." So, yea. Besides, I'm fairly certain that she CAN play the vocal part on her piano. Not like this is a piece that has more than four chords. Why are you picking this apart like a complex jazz piece? It's comparable to Grayson Chance's cover of Paparazzi. Not complicated, but pleasant because it is a new perspective on things.
@hitthecouch Britney did exactly what the public in the 90's wanted her to do. Saying she has no talent is a little ridiculous.. lol I bet she is more talented than you?
@MrEricrockinout Correction, she did what her creator/ handler wanted her to. Yes, she is a no talent ass clown that was taught to sing, dances to other's choreography, doesn't write her own music, nor does she play an instrument. I bet she has more money than me, and well I guess that's the important thing. However, cool story bro!
Just heard that she did a cover of the song. I like Britney's version, but this cover is awesome. I love hearing a person with a voice sing a song and make it their own.
You people are so stupid.... All you need is a piano (or some other instrument), a non-sexual artist, a boring -a.k.a. artistic- performance and you would call everything art! Britney's waaaaaaaaaaaaaaaay better!
@ragnaroc86 Spears is not even talented. her sexuality is what made her famous, not her music. it's not like she writes her music or sings especially well. what's so good about this version is not just the piano. it's the fact that she seems to have so much more passion while singing this song. Britney doesn't have half her passion and it's her song.
@joncastro5 shut up!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!1 Britney Spears is unique. There will always be "better" singers and so on. Whatever, Britney transcends the material and animates it with a personality and an image. It
at first it was I didn't know what to think...the rendition starting growing on me as she progressed in the song and then bam! Hit me wit that jazz/funk/r&b groove at 3:45 and I was like awww shit now!
top comments? i dont understand the logic, spears wrote the song, the melody, the diminuendo's that everyone finds endearing. Ive seen the static lullaby cover and plenty others, all of which are very good (including this one) but they are in fact and irrefutably only covers...
@PALUCHMUSIC Well, the song was actually written by Christian Karlsson and Pontus Winnberg. So the song, melody and diminuendos may have been first known through her, but they aren't hers.
@PALUCHMUSIC most artists nowadays dont write their own music,not like the old greats,u really think britney has the vocabulary for a song like this,no way
and miss.Naim is far more talented than britney and made the song her own anyway
i hate britney spears with a passion....but this cover is just fucking amazing, so seductive with a beautiful jazz like genre. God yael naim can turn shit into awesomeness. Bravo
DONT READ THIS CAUSE IT ACTUALLY WORKS. YOU WILL GET KISSED ON THE NEAREST POSSIBLE FRIDAY BY THE LOVE OF YOUR LIFE. TOMORROW WILL BE THE BEST DAY OF YOUR LIFE. HOWEVER IF YOU DO NOT POST THIS COMMENT TO AT LEAST 3 VIDEOS YOU WILL DIE WITHIN 2 DAYS. NOW UV STARTED READING THIS SO DUNT STOP. THIS IS SO SCARY. PUT THIS ON AT LEAST 5 VIDEOS IN 143 MINUTES WHEN UR DONE PRESS F6 AND UR LOVERS NAME WILL APPEAR ON THE SCREEN IN BIG LETTERS. THIS IS SO SCARY CAUSE IT ACTUALY WORK
@ItsBeckhamBitch Wth is wrong with? I think your name may be appropriate for you because that was rude and uncalled for. Why does it matter if she's jewish? D:<
@monkiebrane101 the name i have is from a britney spears song.....#2 i have the rights to say whatever the hell i want...YES IT DOES MATTER THAT SHE'S JEWISH what the fuck are you going to do now???? shut up and stop replying to my comment...
@ItsBeckhamBitch Wow your not worth it. You do have the right to say what you want so I'll give you that. I feel kind of sad for you. You're probably excluding a lot of people that you could have been friends with. Oh well. Have a nice life... :/
As far as pop songs go, "Toxic" of course isn't a bad song to start with but this version really makes it a GREAT song!
It's got that same spooky vibe as Tori Amos' version of Slayer's "Reign in Blood" yet it isn't just an experiment but a really sexy piece of music which isn't hard to listen to at all...great great great...
Cover? This barely qualifies. Yeah, the words and essential tune are the same, but the song has been transformed and metamorphosed, as though Britney's version was a pupa---but this song is a butterfly.
this song is simply amazing... it's so versatile works for every style... not only a great pop song but also jazz and even rock ;) one of the best pop songs out there and the best from mrs. spears although her cover might not do the justice but brit's a performer not a singer ;)
this is like devilish sexy....ppl that dont like this just dont understand this old stand. THis version is for the grown, sophistocated, that know what seduction sounds like... lol let the kids keep the regular version
I camed from toxic 16bit remix
is she is isreali?
Hmoood96 6 hours ago
@hitthecouch fuck off this song is britneys ;) if she had no talent she didnt sing this song! and she didnt sale a lot of records!
shakeproductions1 1 week ago
she's pure sex) so beautiful)
Prrexx 1 week ago
Haunting.
viiviiixxtactic 1 month ago
I like her accent so much! And I think Yael is more a classy woman than Britney
Ninxx90 1 month ago
AMAZING!! This is how Britney would sound if she went jazzy and actually sang live. #NOT =P
muleke18 1 month ago
Now I´m sure that each and every single music in this world can be beautiful with the right musicians.
bruto 1 month ago 4
Amei o video, Sua voz é perfeita !
eucuidodomeioambient 1 month ago
Never expected that toxic had such a potential. This is really great. Hope she will come to the Netherlands (or witch country you from)
crazysjaak 1 month ago 5
that's real?
heriqc 1 month ago
does anyone know the chords she is playing?
itsbrandon4life 2 months ago
People...she is a mixture of French and Israeli......and I had no idea how awesome she is! #shocked:)
girlsgilmore6teen 2 months ago 4
bouleversante
MrJejedrummer 2 months ago
perfectly avant-garde cover.
russianviolet 2 months ago 2
opino que britney deberia venderle los derechos a yael naim!!! ella se lo merece mas!!
kaZenOonNa 3 months ago 3
she can actually sing unlike all that crap with rebecca black
frolicious911 4 months ago
DIMPLES ARE AWESOME I HAVE DIMPLES
frolicious911 4 months ago
DIMPLES
frolicious911 4 months ago
when she says the last "now" she sound like a kitty cat!
MsRacoonTail 4 months ago
THIS is talent, not that Ke$ha or Lady Gaga crap that seems to be all they play on the radio.
LeihWrightify 4 months ago 2
@LeihWrightify i know right! :) its to bad singers like yael and mindy gledhill are not as widely known as pop singers.
MsRacoonTail 4 months ago
@MsRacoonTail
Yes really IS too bad! And I LOVE Mindy Gledhill, I looked her up when I saw your reply! Thanks for introducing me to yet ANOTHER artist that ACTUALLY has talent. And I am VERY enthusiastic. Lol sorry! : P
If you were an ice cream flavor you'd be my favorite one <3
~ Mindy Gledhill ( =
LeihWrightify 4 months ago
@LeihWrightify ur welcome!! ^_^
LUL's
--M x
MsRacoonTail 4 months ago
@MsRacoonTail
LUL ?
LeihWrightify 4 months ago
@LeihWrightify love u lots- sorry lol :)
--M x
MsRacoonTail 4 months ago
@MsRacoonTail
Oh no its okay! I'm usually the one who has to explain my acronym's. Lol, sorry!
LUL! ( =
LeihWrightify 4 months ago
she sings with her heart
it sounds almost like a beautiful sourceress!!!
MsRacoonTail 4 months ago
o my gosh-; the french bit at the end... it broke my heart- in a good way!
MsRacoonTail 4 months ago
omg, AWSOME. much better than britney.
nathaliadecastro1 4 months ago
This version is SOOOOOO SEXYYYYYYYYYYYYYY!
Britooh 4 months ago
she is adorable and this version rocks!
tw881000 4 months ago
She is French. Amaaaaaazing artist
rachelmareekeeley 4 months ago
@rachelmareekeeley
She is Israelian.. not French :S
OldSchoolerify 4 months ago 2
@OldSchoolerify she's israeli but is from france
dailysugar 4 months ago
@dailysugar her accent is so beautiful, just loved.
nathaliadecastro1 4 months ago
booooooring
Chaosbaron1 4 months ago
@Chaosbaron1 beautiful
bribunni98 4 months ago
She has an accent. Is she Jewish?
15iiii 4 months ago in playlist Homophobia-"Fuck You", by LILY ALEN
@manfromregina Oh? and I certainly don't see your name anywhere under the category of "International Professional Vocal Singer." So, yea. Besides, I'm fairly certain that she CAN play the vocal part on her piano. Not like this is a piece that has more than four chords. Why are you picking this apart like a complex jazz piece? It's comparable to Grayson Chance's cover of Paparazzi. Not complicated, but pleasant because it is a new perspective on things.
MrMichaelMadness 5 months ago
huh this s a great cover
manfromregina 5 months ago
Lame for a Jazz cover.If you can't play even the vocal bit on yer piani ,,then don't even attempt.
manfromregina 5 months ago
@manfromregina lame for a jazz cover? well great, it's not supposed to be jazz!
IngridBerg 5 months ago
@IngridBerg Fair enough. what kind of cover is it?
manfromregina 5 months ago
@manfromregina It's a Yael Naim cover. She has her own style, period.
IngridBerg 5 months ago
@IngridBerg yer right. Neil Young can't always sing in key either.
manfromregina 5 months ago
I want to hear a French Version of this song now. :p
Colliecool 5 months ago
goosebumps.
Gjonikki 5 months ago
Wonderful version!!!
johannaloquilla 6 months ago
i love this version, i love her voice she is an excellent singer :)
PauEncre 6 months ago
A little dark/avant garde. I love it, far better than Miss no talent Spears.
hitthecouch 6 months ago 22
@hitthecouch Britney did exactly what the public in the 90's wanted her to do. Saying she has no talent is a little ridiculous.. lol I bet she is more talented than you?
MrEricrockinout 1 month ago 6
Comment removed
hitthecouch 1 month ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@MrEricrockinout Correction, she did what her creator/ handler wanted her to. Yes, she is a no talent ass clown that was taught to sing, dances to other's choreography, doesn't write her own music, nor does she play an instrument. I bet she has more money than me, and well I guess that's the important thing. However, cool story bro!
hitthecouch 1 month ago
Beautiful singer, really really dislike her accent though.
Wanglestick 6 months ago
Without the dirt it's not as good, but it certainly is classy.
Classy as shit.
staticbb 6 months ago
i love how everyone acts like britney wrote it, newsflash- she didnt !!!!!!!
MKEdubstep 6 months ago
Just heard that she did a cover of the song. I like Britney's version, but this cover is awesome. I love hearing a person with a voice sing a song and make it their own.
kclaude 6 months ago 2
i heard britney did a cover of this song, yeh, not as good! yael naim owns!
markRochester 6 months ago
The REAL GENIOUS HERE IS MAX MARTIN WHO WROTE THIS AMAZING SONG> IT IS NOT THE SINGERS< ITS THE MAX MARTIN SONG.
plinden 6 months ago
You people are so stupid.... All you need is a piano (or some other instrument), a non-sexual artist, a boring -a.k.a. artistic- performance and you would call everything art! Britney's waaaaaaaaaaaaaaaay better!
ragnaroc86 6 months ago
@ragnaroc86 Spears is not even talented. her sexuality is what made her famous, not her music. it's not like she writes her music or sings especially well. what's so good about this version is not just the piano. it's the fact that she seems to have so much more passion while singing this song. Britney doesn't have half her passion and it's her song.
joncastro5 6 months ago 2
@joncastro5 shut up!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!1 Britney Spears is unique. There will always be "better" singers and so on. Whatever, Britney transcends the material and animates it with a personality and an image. It
s show business.
plinden 6 months ago
@plinden ...so you admit Yael is a better singer. haha
joncastro5 6 months ago
@ragnaroc86 The chronically average chimes in with a little opinion. How amusing.
Lynleyland 6 months ago
@Lynleyland The chronicallay average thought don't cover songs of other artists to make some noise about themselves. How mysterious!
ragnaroc86 4 months ago
This is not a french accent, but hebrew
evg217865 6 months ago
Eh, not feeling her voice.. I won't vote it down though, it's just personal preference.
AkumosBDF 6 months ago 2
i like the end.
foxsux6000 6 months ago
this is great! the french accent is supersexy!
katrinchardon 7 months ago 27
@katrinchardon actually its a hebrew accent lol
demondoogle 3 months ago 4
@katrinchardon actualy it's a hebrew accent, very slight =)
foobargorch 3 months ago 5
@katrinchardon actually she's israeli too, so it's not only french accent your'e hearing
Joty1280 1 week ago
WOW !!
4MinuteTV1 7 months ago 3
at first it was I didn't know what to think...the rendition starting growing on me as she progressed in the song and then bam! Hit me wit that jazz/funk/r&b groove at 3:45 and I was like awww shit now!
dismissed7 7 months ago
one word..............................amazing
mzkimberley 7 months ago
top comments? i dont understand the logic, spears wrote the song, the melody, the diminuendo's that everyone finds endearing. Ive seen the static lullaby cover and plenty others, all of which are very good (including this one) but they are in fact and irrefutably only covers...
PALUCHMUSIC 8 months ago
@PALUCHMUSIC Well, the song was actually written by Christian Karlsson and Pontus Winnberg. So the song, melody and diminuendos may have been first known through her, but they aren't hers.
gmaull 8 months ago 4
@PALUCHMUSIC most artists nowadays dont write their own music,not like the old greats,u really think britney has the vocabulary for a song like this,no way
and miss.Naim is far more talented than britney and made the song her own anyway
collezione111 7 months ago
@PALUCHMUSIC she didn't write it
CandleAshes 6 months ago
That piano bench was probably soaked.
FLOK980 8 months ago 3
@FLOK980 I don't know about the piano bench, but I know where I'm sitting is!
extra4lfu 7 months ago
Comment ne pas tomber sous le charme de Yael Naim! Je l'adore
Chococacaooo 8 months ago
my mom just told me she doesn't like this song AT ALL...i think i am adopted.........
raynicole3 8 months ago 4
Hate Britney, but always kinda liked this song. So glad to hear a real artist perform it!
Nannanabanana7 8 months ago
Better than original :)
Ivushqa12 8 months ago 2
i love the accent <3 !!
so sexy
TheMusiclover15 8 months ago
i just fell a sleep.
itsandresduhhh 8 months ago
The link to this video should be in the dictionary after the words 'Sensual' and 'Seduction'
kellyx12 8 months ago 4
che pezzo ! groooove a bombaaaaaaaaa !
TonyBellardi 9 months ago
wow this is truely amazing...
jlo11473 9 months ago
Her accent <3
MJHxoxo 9 months ago
i hate britney spears with a passion....but this cover is just fucking amazing, so seductive with a beautiful jazz like genre. God yael naim can turn shit into awesomeness. Bravo
jaws1785 9 months ago
If anyone knows, what does she say at the end in French? (I don't want a translation lol)
zzzonkers 9 months ago
@zzzonkers "Appelez s'il-vous-plait le Telethon, 3637 pour faire un don"
Maxcube10 9 months ago
@Maxcube10 Thanks so much! :D
zzzonkers 9 months ago
it's great that this is britney spears' song, but she does it so much better
krinkdink 9 months ago
This version makes me feel so naughty : )
effilang 9 months ago 3
israeli proud
roihac101 9 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
DONT READ THIS CAUSE IT ACTUALLY WORKS. YOU WILL GET KISSED ON THE NEAREST POSSIBLE FRIDAY BY THE LOVE OF YOUR LIFE. TOMORROW WILL BE THE BEST DAY OF YOUR LIFE. HOWEVER IF YOU DO NOT POST THIS COMMENT TO AT LEAST 3 VIDEOS YOU WILL DIE WITHIN 2 DAYS. NOW UV STARTED READING THIS SO DUNT STOP. THIS IS SO SCARY. PUT THIS ON AT LEAST 5 VIDEOS IN 143 MINUTES WHEN UR DONE PRESS F6 AND UR LOVERS NAME WILL APPEAR ON THE SCREEN IN BIG LETTERS. THIS IS SO SCARY CAUSE IT ACTUALY WORK
lolafergie87 9 months ago
hot.... very effin' hot....i would much rather see a woman dance to this than the Britney version. sexy as hell... love ya, Yael
ProphetOfSekhmet 9 months ago
dudus adorei!
jotah2008 10 months ago
O.o Sexy
AvellsAsylum 10 months ago
She looks like Anne Hathaway :P
PaperBagRecords 10 months ago 3
that was unexpected. In a good way
asrod 10 months ago
I'm Jewish and she's amazing.
willhurstep 10 months ago
Instruments in music make such a difference. +++++
TDubb33 10 months ago 3
@movieegrl13 Britney was the original artist of it...
brielizabeth103 10 months ago
Soooo S E X Y =P~
ttvpro007 10 months ago
sounds like a Kate Bush song...
Hedvibelle 10 months ago
This is beautiful Yael Naim is a beautifuly talented singer
sousaluvs2dance 10 months ago
@itsbeckhambitch would you prefer something from the Hoff?
thelastagain 11 months ago
actually the britney song was a cover too.....
movieegrl13 11 months ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
please dont compare German accents to this jewish shit...!!! wtf is this..
ItsBeckhamBitch 11 months ago
@ItsBeckhamBitch
what is worng with jewish???
and why do u care that she is jewish??she is very talented it doesnt matter what she is but how she is and if u dont realize she is a singer
i am proud Israeli
mishi777 11 months ago
@ItsBeckhamBitch Wth is wrong with? I think your name may be appropriate for you because that was rude and uncalled for. Why does it matter if she's jewish? D:<
monkiebrane101 10 months ago
@monkiebrane101 the name i have is from a britney spears song.....#2 i have the rights to say whatever the hell i want...YES IT DOES MATTER THAT SHE'S JEWISH what the fuck are you going to do now???? shut up and stop replying to my comment...
ItsBeckhamBitch 10 months ago
@ItsBeckhamBitch Wow your not worth it. You do have the right to say what you want so I'll give you that. I feel kind of sad for you. You're probably excluding a lot of people that you could have been friends with. Oh well. Have a nice life... :/
monkiebrane101 10 months ago
This is way better than the original! Awesome cover :)
BohemianPiracy 11 months ago
I hope nobody kills me...but I prefer this version, I confess.
Yael is fantastic.
Djeicabe 11 months ago 3
NICE version - I actually wanted to listen to the lyrics (never really listened carefully to the lyrics before when sang by BP.)
SamFGordon 11 months ago
OMG, magnífico, incrivel!
xchegayx 11 months ago
Comme un petit objet (magnifique) qu'on se félicite d'avoir découvert. Thank you for your existence.
sarah76883 11 months ago
In French class my teacher played this song and my best friend Rhilee, at the very end of the song blurts out "That was...creepily seductive."
theLOLsincorporated 11 months ago 3
Looooove it !!! Check my cover if you want ! French fan
musicaaa26 11 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
OMG i am a britney fan, but this is soooo beautiful!!
MizSabrina 1 year ago
OMG i am a britney fan, but this is soooo beautiful!!
MizSabrina 1 year ago
wow nice ! i love it will be ost from 007 james bond !
schwaanism 1 year ago 3
didn't 16bit remix this?
JakeTYLERsounds 1 year ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Omg what a lump of shit that's not singing thats mumbling in a terrible german accent
Mario1Master2 1 year ago
Comment removed
360pezza1 1 year ago
@Mario1Master2 Shes Israeli.
360pezza1 1 year ago
@Mario1Master2 Are you serious!?!?! Have you even HEARD a German accent? Her accent is CLEARLY Israeli...
djinnmasterkeladry 1 year ago 2
@Mario1Master2 Omg what a lump of shit thats not commentary thats American ignorance at its finest (good luck w. mario faggot)
SirHouseFly 1 year ago
this is most beautiful version i've heard so far. loving that funky guitar!
Slcatchpole 1 year ago
absolutely superb, what a glorious voice. oh and great touch at the end 'dans le francais'. just great.
dfg404 1 year ago
I hate Britney, but this is perfect!
1wiki1 1 year ago 5
I like this version better than any of the studio versions.
luwe80 1 year ago
The best Britney cover I've ever heard in my hole life.
JulianasSunshine 1 year ago 20
Que voz y que talento.....WUAU¡¡¡¡¡¡¡¡¡
gatichula1 1 year ago
Me puso "chinita" la piel! MARAVILLOSA
valeeritax 1 year ago
Love it!!!!
QsHoney2be 1 year ago
Orgasm-able
kunlunschamsam 1 year ago 4
wonderfull!!! so sexy! feels like making love!
Donsphynx7 1 year ago 9
wonderfull!!!
Donsphynx7 1 year ago
Oh my God...she's got the voice of an angel! Love this version better than Britney Spears.
ballroomblitzkid1994 1 year ago
This version gives me the chills. I love it
cNMIb19 1 year ago 4
britney got owned
paxpakspax 1 year ago 159
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Meehh I like the Glee version better...
howandreviews 1 year ago
@zoriah first time i've seen this, so beautiful, she's amazing, first time i saw the original new soul too, i loved it
pmwfotos 1 year ago
As far as pop songs go, "Toxic" of course isn't a bad song to start with but this version really makes it a GREAT song!
It's got that same spooky vibe as Tori Amos' version of Slayer's "Reign in Blood" yet it isn't just an experiment but a really sexy piece of music which isn't hard to listen to at all...great great great...
NIMRODakaNIMROD 1 year ago
not bad, and the better the longer the song lasts
i still prefer benfoldsrocks' version (named "surprise?!") at v=7kRcJSYOB9o
greenhousejpb 1 year ago
No offense to the Spear's fans but Yael owns this song.
acastilla115 1 year ago 11
Listening to this version makes me realize that the lyrics of this song are actually quite interesting and dare I say, good.
therising1 1 year ago 5
damn she is so hot
yliang2 1 year ago 4
I Love this version!!!!:D
MagsheartsJuji 1 year ago
The version by Kate Miller-Heidke is even better.
magd2992 1 year ago
This version makes the words come alive.
PrettiNikkiRIghtLEft 1 year ago 3
Brillant!
Irisheyes77christy 1 year ago
Nice, but the tempo of this version is slower. The whole song is slower than Britney's. Has a nice mix.
LaharlD2 1 year ago
the green lighting is just perfect.
rfengr 1 year ago
Comment removed
aromastanica 1 year ago
Cover? This barely qualifies. Yeah, the words and essential tune are the same, but the song has been transformed and metamorphosed, as though Britney's version was a pupa---but this song is a butterfly.
bass1bone 1 year ago 8
this song is simply amazing... it's so versatile works for every style... not only a great pop song but also jazz and even rock ;) one of the best pop songs out there and the best from mrs. spears although her cover might not do the justice but brit's a performer not a singer ;)
totovale13 1 year ago 3
this is like devilish sexy....ppl that dont like this just dont understand this old stand. THis version is for the grown, sophistocated, that know what seduction sounds like... lol let the kids keep the regular version
JazzRockablity 1 year ago 116
@JazzRockablity You'd be surprised what kids understand these days.
FLOK980 8 months ago
@JazzRockablity mm this sounds to alien ish
ChristianKEspanilla 8 months ago
this should be in a james bond movie
MKEdubstep 1 year ago 4
@MKEdubstep Fucking YES!!!! Read my mind three weeks before I even thought of it!
saxmachine7 1 year ago
this should be in a james bond movie
MKEdubstep 1 year ago 3
I love how her accent and the slow sound makes it creepy and old sounding really great
RabbidTea 1 year ago 3
This comment has received too many negative votes show
That's boring, seriously...
Jinryuushi 1 year ago
So Gothic
djhoanna21 1 year ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
boringg!!!
newborn96 1 year ago
Tranquility beauty, it's mesmorizing
YouBritishTuber 1 year ago
what a horrible accent
aandrebs90 1 year ago
@aandrebs90 I think her accent is very sexy! lol
LaInvitada1 1 year ago
this sounds so creepy
BessieGrimm 1 year ago
Holy shit, I could not stop smiling! I was searching for the original, but this surpasses it!
DJKatAnimated 1 year ago 2
Love her!
Brings pride to Israel (:
820AHA 1 year ago
Comment removed
aromastanica 1 year ago