American Idol Recap 2008 Season 7 Episode 3 San Diego

[elponito1]

David Archuleta has a paralyzed vocal chord thats why he cant breathe that well and is gasping alot...ok...doesnt make him a bad singer ....because in my opinion he has an amazing voice...one of a kind.....i wonder if ppl critizing him on that can do any btter...probably not

[MidNYtERYdUhS]

The Perry Dude Was The Shit.

[RUUBEEAA]

david archuleta ♥ & carly smith ! AMAZINGS

[cristal342]

archie the best!!!!!!!!!!!!!! (in my opinion!)

[GrOoVyChIcK90]

Ahhh ARCHIE <3 :D

[itstheapocalypse]

1. generic

2. decent

3. trying too hard

4. pretty good, but please stop singing Aretha

5. who the hell forgets the words of a song they pick themselves? only sang about two good bars of the song, and gasped too much and too loudly

6. was good until she Mariah'd all over the place

[grrimalionbaby]

@itstheapocalypse he breathes like that because he had throat surgery before i think. you are stupid and your judgments are awful

[itstheapocalypse]

@grrimalionbaby You can learn breath control even if you had throat surgery. Anthony Federov had a problem with his throat but I don't remember him gasping for air like that.

[grrimalionbaby]

@itstheapocalypse ok well idk what exactly he had but it's something that messed with his throat. and if i recall he was one of the top two. he was great and still is, and as i said before your judgments are awful

[itstheapocalypse]

@grrimalionbaby I don't get it. What is calling me stupid, like you did in your previous comment, and calling my judgements awful going to accomplish? Do you think I'm going to magically change my mind? I stand by my opinions, just like you stand by yours. Neither of us are going to change our minds.

[grrimalionbaby]

@itstheapocalypse well i can disagree with your opinions, and so i did, and i don't think your judgments on singing is very good. and maybe my calling you stupid was childish but it's too late to take it back

[elponito1]

@itstheapocalypse hmmm i wonder if u can do any better...5.--.ummm yea and he made runner up on that season...okayyy

[itstheapocalypse]

@elponito1 Of course he made runner up. The quality of the talent on this show went down after season six.

[elponito1]

@itstheapocalypse haha Dont start talking about quality cus thats all bullshitt.. What would u know about quality...

[itstheapocalypse]

@elponito1 What do I know about quality? I HAVE EARS.

I stopped watching Idol after this season because this is not a singing show. It's a reality show. The producers aren't interested in finding a great singer. They just wanna make good TV. Which is sad. I wish this were actually a show about singing, then I'd watch it again.

[blue2slugger2]

lol randy on david archuletta

[xsilverxdustx]

Samantha Musa looks like Mindy from Drake & Josh hehe :D

Amazing voiice! They're all great singers.

Miss this season.

[melissaluvsld]

archie =]

<333

[mcdread2005]

Carly Smithson has vocals for days. She really should have won

[ledheadlover]

michael johns fuck yea

[disneyloverx2]

michael john is HOTTT

[lea9239]

I love Archie!!!

[xxCrazyForCampRockxx]

ARCHIE!!!!<3

[xxCrazyForCampRockxx]

DAVID ARCHIE!!!! LOVE U!!

[archgirl14]

ARCHIE!!!!!!! <3

[madesv6]

my fav is the 2 guy he is the best

[zidani22]

love the second person

[triamera28]

I LOVE YOU CARLY SMITHSON!!!

go go go!!!

Im still waiting your album..

[angierox77]

i love david archuleta

[saydeja82091]

That Boy said "its hard to be persistant"when its "hard to beat the system" @ 3:00. lol

[imabookfreak]

that's nothing, I used to say "mamma don't take my cordless phone away", when the lyrics are "mamma don't take my chotochrome away". LOL!

[laniebcx]

lol i like that!

[blonde0632]

i love samantha musa-she should get a record deal thats pure talent

[adventuregal678]

archie rules!

[saydeja82091]

whats the name of the song the 1st girl was singing?

Does Anyone kno

[rjs5146]

its called someone to watch over me

[saydeja82091]

Thanxx

[RUUBEEAA]

PERRIE CATALDOOOOOOOOO!

(L)

[iqkid1212]

the first girl was on canadian idol shortly after but she didn't make it that far

[mrsjonas4life13]

okie dokie lol

[MusiicFanatic]

Michael Johns kicks butt :]

[xinger617]

i wasurprised samantha didnt make it her voice had great potetial her tone had a mixture of anastasia and a 23 year old celine dion

[mLsurfer182]

the first girl reminds me of mikayla gordon a little

[crystalAura]

I really liked the first girl. Love that song too.

[saydeja82091]

WHATS THE NAME OF THAT SONG??

[Nightmare89XF]

Which song ?

The song David Archuleta sings is called "Waiting on the world to change"

[saydeja82091]

No tha name of the song the 1st girl was singing

[RUUBEEAA]

someone to watch over me

[miljkovicgirl]

Carly Simson was amazing

[skaterkid1001]

that means your gay cause david archaleta is a homo

[lasalseracubana]

yes it does. and it also means that you are a jesus-freak southern idiot... stereotypes, anyone?

[stefanackermann350]

this is soooooooooooo amazing!!!! LOVE DAVID ARCHULETA!! i got his cd on friday & i can't stop listening to it! the 12 songs are soooooooooooo addictive!!!!! :D

LOVE IT!

please watch my video:

"YOU CAN (2ND TIME!)". it's me singing david archukleta's You Can

;) thnx

[middlekid95]

which is ur fave song?(i have the CD too)

[aidean88]

David Archuleta looks like Dandruff Danny from Hannah Montana

[GossipGirlxx3]

archuleta was and IS amazing :)

[xxdonnamarie]

ARCHIE <3

[RUUBEEAA]

michael johns!

BABAAAAAAAAAA

[freezeyou88]

cant believe samantha didnt make it!!

[rjs5146]

i agree! i LOVED her. she had everything going for her: she's young, attractive, good personality AND she has a hell of a voice!!!

[mymindisblanc]

oki doki... x)

[blue2slugger2]

MICHAEL JHONS IS GAY

[april4domerese]

How do you know? He is married!!

[archieroxz]

david archuleta audition was incredible!!!

[AischaSabra]

I don't know why evryone is so crazy about David Archuleta...

He's good...but nearly every guy who made it to Hollywood was better...

[scrumptiouus]

MICHAEL JOHNS! amazingg

DAVID ARCHULETA! incredable

CARLY SMITHSON! amazingg ,, ima hugge fan!

everyone in this video had a fantastic voice!

[teteemas]

well i thind david archuleta is doing awesome here!!

[actionmanrandell]

i hatearchalette he is so overrated

[EyeLoveZacEfron]

I don't think that's his fault, it's his crazy fan base that will do anything just to be in the same building as him. He's pretty talented!

[homiep543]

you forgot david hernandez, danny noriega, and chikezie!!!

[143dvdarch]

David Archuleta (my baby), Michael Johns and Carly Smithson!!!! XD

[dannylov39]

omg i love carly! and micheal johns!!!!!!!there voices are great!

[LindsayHartleyFan]

David Archuleta, Carly Smithson, Michael Johns!!!!!! <3333

[Mercilesstantalus]

Michael Johns!! Wow, his voice blew me away...again. :)

[rosiitaaah]

who is it at 1.56? :S

[homiep543]

The was the sister of the girl that was auditioning.

[boyrcool]

that was Samantha Musa

[ashleynichole93]

OMFG the guy who sung I'll Make Love To You was amazing!<3

[JeniferTisdale]

OMG! David Archuleta!

[irishsweethearttx]

Carly Smithson :D!

[devilslittlegirl101]

Whats the song Perrie Cataldo was singign? (Even though i love that song) PLEASE TELL ME PLEASE!!

[artty132]

oldsong school

Boys II Men - ill Make love 2 you

[devilslittlegirl101]

Ty.

[rebellauniverse]

SUCH a pleasure listening to!!!!! thank you so much for uploading, makes me smile:D

come on over and hear me sing too, maybe I won't suck?? - take a chance on me;p

much love and respect Rebella

&hearts;

[rockstar13243]

DAVID ARCHULETTTTAAAAAA!!!!!!!!

[MattXICE]

daaaaaaaaaaaamn

[kishankakarla]

Thanks for uploading.

[tankgolfer]

The Otis Redding Msg is for (LUV3BOIS) cause the people who replied to it were just a lil off on who they thought sings the song Michael sings.

[NYsweetheart449]

obviousley didnt make it

[iGatorade]

wtf wat happened to the girl at like 1:54

[babisweetszx3]

LOVE david archuleta<333

[Froboy12345678]

Highlights

Tetiana Ostapowych

Perrie Cataldo

Michael Johns- One Of My Top 5 Favorites

Samantha Musa

David Archuleta- Perhaps The Most Talented

Carly Smithson- The Girl To Beat

wow they were all good

[boogernigger]

me gusta la chuleta frita!!!!!

[LUV3BOIS]

at 2:14 what song was that? David is fricken amazing!

[michellelad]

thats luther vandross - until you come back to me (thats what im going to do)...

[HersheyRainbow]

Thats Aretha Franklin, NOT Luther Vandross

[tankgolfer]

Actually it's Otis Redding Ive Been Loving you.

[lilswimmer888]

i love david archuleta

[middlekid95]

yeah the 16 year old! him yesh!! :D i love him!

[middlekid95]

♫♥ i LOVE David!!!! ♥♫

[Simplenotion]

Tatyana is simply natural and beautiful voice...

[rmga0305]

I Love CARLY + DAVID!

[mano0n]

omg one of them sings john mayer... and THAT is fuckin great <3

[lilswimmer888]

David Archuleta is the one that sings it

[petrickjorokgila]

david is from junior star ,

he should rock american idol!!

[sweetprinces4lyfe]

i like pierre even though hes no in top 24 :(

[siitha]

I LOVE CARLY!!! she's amazing!!!

[grricantgetaname]

i love david =D (and carly!!!)

[Ags9121]

Carly is my all time favourite!Absolutely brilliant man!

[LOseIDon]

they all sing the same style godamit

[Fashizzlex]

Its' cuz we're from california iight? Ever state has a difdfent style. You see texas singing country not pop or rapp and since california is populared with asians hispanics ect we developed mostly rap hip hop abd pop GOTA PROBLEM BLAME NATURE!

[LOseIDon]

wow sorry...wata load of BS but still...calm down...

we also have metal and psychedelic hippie stuff that originated here...so yea...

[kimbec]

who on earth is the gitl with glasses? sz i dint watch ths ep lol

[Postitsaresticky]

all are awesome

[HamoGirLRia]

htat last girl? shes bloody BRILLIANT!

[Heiresss89]

Absolutely agree!

[lovemylife221]

that is carly smithson... she got to the top 6 and then got voted off after her best performance.  fuck the voters

[kiriaka1972]

I'll visit your ringtones site ...I'd rather by ring tones from a YT user that contributes, then some nameless faceless hack. Thanks for uploading and taking a chance with the powers that be, and thanks for the legal info, maybe others can tag that along with their uploaded "recaps" to provide some protection against removal. Right on!!

[KNBsanb]

omg perrie is awesome

it was so sad yesterday when he got elemenated..

i actually started CRYING when they said perrie had to go home..

so sad :(

[surfergurl4u7]

i hope carly wins!! she is the best one by far!! that is quality sound!

[kalakalachuchu]

i like the ending of david.. so totally awasome.. hhahaha.. i hope he make it to the top 12 and samantha..

[milatiadess]

aww david's performance was really great...and I like john mayer, that was a great song choice.

[didledeeBWFC]

David has the best voice FACT .. the note he hit to end is song is quality

[musiclover1026]

i like tetiana and samantha i think david should win..he's my favorite!!! i can soooo see him making good songs...but if he comes into the right genre..

[mmw21111]

that very last one can sing for a white girl

[uynonymous]

Bravo bravo

[Niisany]

Perrie* was cool.

[erjentapa]

pirre made it to the top 24 as well as carly, but im sad that samantha didn't

:D

[erjentapa]

psyche pierre did not make it to top 24

[metal78]

the second singer should win american idol, his voice was amazing

[niklas1005]

lisen all dar synging it saon like afrekan American ppl

[commendercommender]

too much tatoo for carly =[

[gkekb89]

i love carly

[eyesack9]

2nd one was the best

[NYUcutie]

that third guy was hot and had an amazing voice....dang he can serenade me and that alst girl was good but she kinda ruined the song a bit...

[chit7]

RINGGTONESS THANK YOU SO MUCH FOR THESE VIDEOS, YOU'RE GREAT!!. Unfortunately can't watch the show coz I'm in England and it's only watched on cable which I don't have so this is great.

[unejeuneactrice]

it was so cute when Ryan lifted the little girl up so she could watch through the door!

[donkrillp]

btw.. the person that ryan lifted isn't a girl.....

[erjentapa]

why call the child an "it"?

[MazeMedia2]

that little girl was actually a boy :)

[nativegurl100]

at 1:50 i think thts the best one lol. shes hot to

[mateyboy07]

she sounds brilliant.

[Kevwu]

shes the one who's crazy about simon haha.

[vermiciousk1]

carly smithston? remember that name....shes gona kick ass.

[PatrickS2010]

the 3rd guy is gunna be top 3 atleast

[mateyboy07]

3rd guy sounds like Sam Cooke

[tabsandy]

yeah, that's what i say

[smileexkiddd]

lol i love davids face at 3:07. haha.

[royalblueray]

michael johns is da truth!

[petelkaaa]

dude!! you cut the judges say! thats the best part!

[ItsIncubus]

that girl with the tattoo was hizott!!!

[ERSBEP]

dude!! you cut the judges say! thats the best part!

[sssssarrrrrahhh]

david is sooo good! i want him to go farr!!! :D:D

[BoznianBoii]

David all of the way!!!!!!

[ParkerisNeat]

I've been loving you a little too long- Otis Redding

[markusp12345]

what song is michael johns singing? at 1:20

[jennyfer81]

i like samantha's voice

[smileexkiddd]

" waiiting "

ahah.

[Freaky2318]

San diego had the best talent really they were awesome singers

[HarajukuGuy]

Philadelphia all the way so far !

[olaeskenny]

i like samantha, i think all the materials as an idol are already on her....

[1hotmofoglenboi]

They are all really good singers I have 2 say. But Carly's voice at the end of the clip stood out by a mile. I don't think I heard anybody hit a note like that on Idol for a long time. Even since Kelly Clarkson

[tabsandy]

agreed, but she got competition with samantha musa

[1hotmofoglenboi]

Hello!!!! Yeh Samantha has a great voice. And she done a excellent version on that song. But that song that Carly did. It's really difficult to hit that note. And thats why she stands out a little bit more. I dont wont 2 put your hopes down if your a Samantha fan. I saw the spoilers for the top 24. I did not see Samantha on the list. I did see Carly on it. But hey it's only rumours. I do think Samantha deserves 2 b in th top 24 along with Carly.

[shortyrocksoutloud]

carly was really good!

[kittycutelove]

no she wasent

[Freaky2318]

HATER! SHE WAS AWESOME

[qg6ff]

I have to say you all know the top 24 spoilers are up ? well... out of the names only 7 pictures are shown. so that means the rest of the 17 will probly be people we never heard of til the top 24. greeeat. pics are: kady, david archuletta, kristy lee cook, alaina, brooke, carly, and michael...so that means one of them will win??

[ayabuh]

what site did you found this spoiler?..

[qg6ff]

it won't let me put in the URL but if you type in google: american idol blog and click on the first or 2nd one i think it says the word american idol buzz or something click on that and you'll come to a bunch of topics, scroll to like the 3rd heading that says top 24 spoilers and click on the link that says read it here if you dare

[queenamidaldal]

you're weong then coz david COOK woN!!!

[qg6ff]

...what am i wrong about...

[queenamidaldal]

shit. sorry! i think i replied to the wrong comment

[Idolmakercat]

This group of people sure are great. I really like the first girl in Red. Flawless.