Doeas anybody know of a song that has this same kinda drum beat & drum sound & it kinda sounds like maybe it could be an Ulrich Schnauss song, but I don't know... & if you hear the song "halfway dreaming" by CFCF ti should remind you A LOT of the song I'm trying to find & it's instrumental with heavy echo/reverb on the melody & the beat stops for a while before the end & just the melody plays. Might be a girl choir voice sound. I heard it new in the last 5/6 years maybe longer ago please help!!!
BEST one Ever... I was going through some Ulrich's musics the other day and today this one was on the recomended videos. Youtube never got one so right before!
I saw him live, last Saturday... He is indescribable, but for sure inimitable and most innovative! His sound has an amazing clarity, that is why no matter how loud the music was, no matter how much my clothes were dancing on me from the vibration, it was pleasurable, as if I was not any more made of flesh, but consisting only of pure spirit! I am very touched by his work and would only count the days till his next live show in my place! God bless him really!
This is a song that reminds me of snow skiing where you start at the top of the mountain and ski down. I think it would do great as a music track for a ski video.
Great track. For some reason, I keep imagining this being the music for the final scene of a epic crime thriller along the lines of Michael Mann's Heat. It would be pretty cool if Ulrich Schnauss scored a Michael Mann movie (Mann worked with Tangerine Dream on his first couple of movies),
Offcourse I love this track, but I also envy the guys on the cover. I would like to be on a similar place, watching the sea an listening to nice music, without any of the everyday crap on my mind.
I love ambient and/or mellow electronica like this. If you like this, and you haven't heard of Brian Eno, Boards of Canada, or also an album called "Kismet" by Aurah, or maybe also Aphex Twin (though Aphex twin is not always mellow)... then you should check those out too. I've heard other good ambient stuff, but I can't recall any other names. If anybody knows something really similar to Ulrich Schnauss, please recommend it to me.
@grezgorztube You may also like bands such as Tangerine Dream and Kraftwerk.
There are also solo artists you may like. Klaus Schulze, Vangelis, Yanni, and Mike Oldfield. All of these artists compose music almost exclusively with various keyboards and synthesizers.
You're the 3rd person today who has mentioned Boards of Canada in their comment. It looks like I'll have to check them out!
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
i think this Schnauss dude just wanted attention to make his music more popular. yeah, it sounds the same as the very beginning of Riad N' the Bedouins, but who cares? i doubt Axl's ever heard of Schnauss. i know i never heard of him before this.
your an idiot. of course some retarded hair metal fan isn't going to have heard of schnauss.. but its obvious he sampled the fucking song, he didnt even bother to change the eq or speed or reverse it or anything. its sampled verbaitem. go back to watching your shit metal garbage and die.
Wow yer dumb, it is clearly exactly the same. Big names ripping off indie electronic acts is not new. Timbaland stole a bunch of music from the demoscene website, didnt even give them liner credits.
Rock and HipHop are dead, electronic music is where its at
Perhaps not so much that they are dead.. but that the up and coming 'kids' of our generation are going to be using the likes of ableton, a tone of virtual synths and DSPs, instead of guitars.. which will lead to the music of the future predominately being electronica in its broadest sense..
I fucken love this song and most of Ulrich's. It is burned crisply into my brain forever, I just surfed perfect waves with this song in my head, playing deep and strong and I love it and makes my life good. It is an amazing ensemble of sounds. Thanks Ulrich.
Dudes! Bach transcribed a multitude Vivaldi's FULL works from orchestra to organ concertos without even changing a single note. Rachmaninoff took themes of Paganini (again without changing the melody) and created his own versions. The same thing is going on with rap artists who use samples of others' pop music as their background. Yet no one says anything about that. I don't see what the big deal is here.
Thumbs up for that. That's so right. that's why they're millionaire rappers the world over. They just say anything. They have the worst beats in the world that a child could create. Their words don't inspire. Man they get worst by the decade.
when rappers do it, they get sued. all the fuckign time. and the people filing the lawsuits almost always win... if he got the samples cleared. and paid for them it would be different.(rappers also, its kind of a part of beat making, so its expected. if you hadn't known gnr ripped this off, you'd be thinking, oh shit. gnr does awesome ambient intros.) gnr doesn't deserve credit for this guys work. gnr sucks.
i don't know...i always thought the intro to Riad N' the Bedouins was a little weird. i never thought, "oh shit. gnr does awesome ambient intros." it was more like, "what the hell is this?"
HAHAHA!!!! It´s exactly the same! with the other crappy track of schnauss on top of it. Anyways, Chinesse democracy rocks, and its a great album. But can´t help but wonder why in the hell Axl need´s to rip off this guy when you can do this kind of sounds with any music/audio software?? what the hell was he thinking?
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
U know its not Axl's Fault. This song does sound like Riad N Bedounis but Axl is not the person to Blame, Its that Chris Pitman who does the Beats Stuff in the band. That Chris Pitman is a Useless Person in Guns N Roses, They really dont need 2 Keyboard Players. Dizzy Reed is enough for the band and well Chinese Democracy was an amazing Album and Axl is an amazing vocalist and a songwriter and a composer.
the intro does sound a little bit the same and with the same tempo.. but it lasts just 7 seconds on Riad n bedouins and it's hardly noticeable. maybe they used the same sample library... still it's plain ridiculous to say the "song" was plagiarized.
is true, the first 10 seconds are very similar, but not even part of a riff or part of the song. is very confusing, but it is not plagiarism, Guns N 'Roses does not need that.
while these do sound very similar...they clearly are not the same, no copy paste job here. all it is is a couple of alternating notes on a synth with the volume following along a simple parametric equation......yeah with all this technology how in the world could two separate people come up with something similar?
For people saying Ulrich just hit a button and this sound came out, you are dead wrong. I know for a fact a lot of time and effort went into creating this music. This sound wasn't just in a MIDI bed, he crafted it. It's his own work.
For a producer on Chinese Democracy to sample this without credit is illegal, and Ulrich Schnauss will win in court.
it's what gives some rock fans a smug sense of self-worth. if i had a £ for every mate who has told me that electronic producers merely rip-off other people's work...
and house music has a history of sampling that perhaps only hip-hop can match - it's a history that goes back to it's disco roots, and is pretty undeniable.
when it's done well you end up with summat like bucketheads - the bomb, when it's done badly you end up with deep dish sampling dire straights.
C'mon, don't make it into a "Rock vs Electronic" debate. It has nothing to do with it.
It's about work and getting paid for it. Record companies have complaining about having their albuns stole by the internet community, but when a signed artists steal from an indie composer then its okay? Two wrongs don't make a right, dude!
I shouldn't generalise. I know lots of nice and intelligent Americans... It just angers me so when I see idiots (see above) post on here when they clearly have no idea what they are talking about.. I need to get off the internet.. haha
I have this as an option on my synth. I just can't believe GnR used it in their music. It is too simple to make. I should sue Ulrich for using my sample.
@icpillusions - Enough with the bullshit, dude... He uses mostly modular synths and vintage stuff, and some software. Ulrich is above all a sound designer and wouldn't use a preset like lazy producers.
it's obviously a direct sample used by Guns N' Roses. Can't believe people saying this isn't a big deal. If you were a struggling musician and someone who's being paid millions to record an album doesn't pay you what's due, you'd be pissed.
The news is that a production member gave the band some cool sound effects to use, and had claimed he had them legally, obviously not...but hey, its only the groovy intro
id say it was more of a sample, hes an idot for not asking for it, well he would look real dumb taking all these years and wanting to use someone elses stuff...and now he does anyway coz after all that ppl clocked on!!
i don't know why they're flipping out about this...it's such a small part of riad n' the bedouins, and it's not like it made the song any better. personally, i'd like the song better without the intro, or at least a shorter one.
I agree but shorter is better, like when the guitar starts fading in, i went and edited the intro out and it sounds very weird with axl's screeching coming straight at you :P
it's all keyboard generated sounds.... should yamaha or korg or whatever keyboard manufacturer sue everybody who uses there programed sound.... it's rediculous
I understand where you are coming from, but I have to believe that Schnauss' label would have contacted him to confirm the sounds he used in his songs are not just some synth factory presets, a loop from a sample library or a built in loop from some popular DAW that GnR may have also used. It's very likely that both have access to the exact same synth or software in the studio.
Sounds similar but its not the same, theres more going on in this as opposed to the Rhaid intro that they're claiming. As far as I'm aware of, you can only copywrite the lyrics and melody and a "coincidental" sound effect is neither one or the other. But if the courts favor Ulrich, I wouldnt be shocked because "Chinese Democracy" was problematic from the start.
What a joke (not the song) the lawsuit..... all that is, is a synth on a computer, please that dude aint getting a million anything from the GNR Crew.... like the song though
Nice one 13086 :D Be sure to check out his Suddenly the Trees Are Giving - one of my faves!
Just thought, this would've been a good track for GTA IV's ambient Journey radio station. Loved to have flown over Liberty in a heli at sunset with this on the speakers!
Really a great track, simple, light, yet powerful. I discovered US by instance when someone on YT compared him to BoC but this track sounds quite differently, like of Mix of Jean-Michel Jarre & Max Melvin -- just great :)
I think that there are some tracks like this one, that although you hear them for the first time, its like they remind you places and people. Just as if you had heard them back then :)
Doeas anybody know of a song that has this same kinda drum beat & drum sound & it kinda sounds like maybe it could be an Ulrich Schnauss song, but I don't know... & if you hear the song "halfway dreaming" by CFCF ti should remind you A LOT of the song I'm trying to find & it's instrumental with heavy echo/reverb on the melody & the beat stops for a while before the end & just the melody plays. Might be a girl choir voice sound. I heard it new in the last 5/6 years maybe longer ago please help!!!
QUIZFILTER 2 days ago
Brilliant song! Listening to this as I write - very inspirational...
samthesung 1 month ago in playlist Music 2
Thanks you Guns N' Roses for sampling this amazing song.
Peace.
Slash91xxx 3 months ago
this track fucking rides...nothing but good...
xylemxorro 3 months ago
BEST one Ever... I was going through some Ulrich's musics the other day and today this one was on the recomended videos. Youtube never got one so right before!
youdontknowxpand 3 months ago
... begleitet mich schon seit 2005 ... und noch immer perfekt ... !!! Dankeschön ...
IsabellaSchermann 4 months ago
so immersive ...
seb666fuckers 5 months ago
you'll always be in the music everything i hear it ...missusm
MovieJunky21 6 months ago
this music is so insanely significant to me
deambulant3 7 months ago 3
Love this song :D
xxXSweetAmirahXxx 8 months ago
This has got to be my favorite song ever.
fwaggylover 9 months ago
very cool! sounds just like Boards of Canada - Music Is Math Amazing!
stratocharger 9 months ago
I saw him live, last Saturday... He is indescribable, but for sure inimitable and most innovative! His sound has an amazing clarity, that is why no matter how loud the music was, no matter how much my clothes were dancing on me from the vibration, it was pleasurable, as if I was not any more made of flesh, but consisting only of pure spirit! I am very touched by his work and would only count the days till his next live show in my place! God bless him really!
SonofaBeach2 10 months ago 3
This is a song that reminds me of snow skiing where you start at the top of the mountain and ski down. I think it would do great as a music track for a ski video.
mddg1515 1 year ago
@mddg1515 and which track would remind you of snow skiing where you start at the bottom and mountain and ski up ?
vizionthing 8 months ago
@vizionthing lmao
MightyHealthy1 7 months ago
Riad N' The Bedouins :)
BaconDude 1 year ago 4
Great track. For some reason, I keep imagining this being the music for the final scene of a epic crime thriller along the lines of Michael Mann's Heat. It would be pretty cool if Ulrich Schnauss scored a Michael Mann movie (Mann worked with Tangerine Dream on his first couple of movies),
MonoAzul 1 year ago 2
@MonoAzul
MM and TD are epic as well.
Just look at Robert Leiner, he borrowed much from TD and is still one of the best.
TINNFOLIE 10 months ago
@MonoAzul That's Moby at the end of Heat. Song is called "God moving over the face of the waters'
MightyHealthy1 9 months ago
Comment removed
MonoAzul 1 year ago
GREAT
seb666fuckers 1 year ago
stellar
mw08149272 1 year ago
FATPB has been the sound track to every single one of my shroom trips
BigRipzz 1 year ago 3
Offcourse I love this track, but I also envy the guys on the cover. I would like to be on a similar place, watching the sea an listening to nice music, without any of the everyday crap on my mind.
kourampioulis 1 year ago
So funny that the GnR song that illegally sampled this can't even be put up on youtube without a copyright claim by GnR's label.
Colunga210 1 year ago
just when I thought music was getting a little boring...
dubmarine122 1 year ago 2
His work seems amazing, awesome, incredible. I have to download it. No, wait… I have to buy it. He deserves my money.
Ottomatik0 1 year ago 11
The thumb downs are coming from the Guns N' Roses die hards.
quantum64 1 year ago
sometimes I sit here in the dark and listen to this magical track...
it feeds my soul with optimism and hope.
at least for a few minutes I can forget all my problems.
EFFRec 1 year ago 9
@EFFRec i feeelll this
niallz 1 year ago
@niallz Penis
MrMindfuck23 1 year ago
I love ambient and/or mellow electronica like this. If you like this, and you haven't heard of Brian Eno, Boards of Canada, or also an album called "Kismet" by Aurah, or maybe also Aphex Twin (though Aphex twin is not always mellow)... then you should check those out too. I've heard other good ambient stuff, but I can't recall any other names. If anybody knows something really similar to Ulrich Schnauss, please recommend it to me.
grezgorztube 1 year ago
@grezgorztube You may also like bands such as Tangerine Dream and Kraftwerk.
There are also solo artists you may like. Klaus Schulze, Vangelis, Yanni, and Mike Oldfield. All of these artists compose music almost exclusively with various keyboards and synthesizers.
You're the 3rd person today who has mentioned Boards of Canada in their comment. It looks like I'll have to check them out!
LUDWIGPARIS 1 year ago
@grezgorztube TYCHO!!!!!!!!!!!!
reggaeroots23 1 year ago
Are u kidding me? This is musical genious!!
snowman4440 1 year ago
Awesome track !!! just listen and drift away............x
gladiatordave67 1 year ago
have a same similiar as goodbye song
Resky89 1 year ago
Ulrich can end any song he wants to. I'm just gonna hit Repeat again.
Chiangmai007 1 year ago 5
Ulrich,
Love the music. If i buy it on iTunes can i use it as background music on a friend's art website ? It would be a showcase of one of his sculptures.
lynnfriedman 1 year ago
@lynnfriedman I wouldn't count on Ulrich personally trolling YouTube forums. :)
planaheadsoftware 1 year ago
You can't help but smile and bob your head to the beat to the joy of this song. Thank you Ulrich Schnauss
GoreTorn16 1 year ago 3
I absolutely love songs like this that just make you imagine things... It opens the mind to new worlds of ideas.
First heard this on pandora, It's totally awesome.
fwaggylover 1 year ago 4
-_- ~ahhh I love how this song is so smooth and relaxing~
LamboPaul 1 year ago
I think I'm addicted to this song
puck28 1 year ago 4
It´s only first effect, this effect is patented? sound of piano is patented?, Raid n'The Bedouins is other music category, the demand is stupid.
sebasland 1 year ago
@sebasland My thoughts exactly.That'd be like bucket suing morello for using the whammy pedal.Its bullshit
JohnBurninate 1 year ago
Nice work!
jwatering 1 year ago
amazing song. especially starting at 1:34
ChrisDowneyMusic 1 year ago 6
At 0:55 starts that amazing bass sample which is flirting with the high tunes all the way through the song.
danzas 1 year ago 5
This comment has received too many negative votes show
i think this Schnauss dude just wanted attention to make his music more popular. yeah, it sounds the same as the very beginning of Riad N' the Bedouins, but who cares? i doubt Axl's ever heard of Schnauss. i know i never heard of him before this.
frenchfry612 2 years ago
your an idiot. of course some retarded hair metal fan isn't going to have heard of schnauss.. but its obvious he sampled the fucking song, he didnt even bother to change the eq or speed or reverse it or anything. its sampled verbaitem. go back to watching your shit metal garbage and die.
metropolis1927 2 years ago
Wow yer dumb, it is clearly exactly the same. Big names ripping off indie electronic acts is not new. Timbaland stole a bunch of music from the demoscene website, didnt even give them liner credits.
Rock and HipHop are dead, electronic music is where its at
Svperstarr 1 year ago
@Svperstarr
Perhaps not so much that they are dead.. but that the up and coming 'kids' of our generation are going to be using the likes of ableton, a tone of virtual synths and DSPs, instead of guitars.. which will lead to the music of the future predominately being electronica in its broadest sense..
mcozire 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
i have this song ;D luv it
mariokart6444 2 years ago
stop arguing about copyright and enjoy the track :)
Dominik12345678910 2 years ago 45
@Dominik12345678910 while you can.. i may add :)
TheRocksolid89 5 months ago in playlist Jon Hopkins
I fucken love this song and most of Ulrich's. It is burned crisply into my brain forever, I just surfed perfect waves with this song in my head, playing deep and strong and I love it and makes my life good. It is an amazing ensemble of sounds. Thanks Ulrich.
wavedancer17 2 years ago 65
@wavedancer17 This sounds like an excellent surfing song.
technicallyabsurd 11 months ago
Dudes! Bach transcribed a multitude Vivaldi's FULL works from orchestra to organ concertos without even changing a single note. Rachmaninoff took themes of Paganini (again without changing the melody) and created his own versions. The same thing is going on with rap artists who use samples of others' pop music as their background. Yet no one says anything about that. I don't see what the big deal is here.
rpyka1 2 years ago
It's because most rap is mindless stupidity that doesn't sound like music.
PrometheusSD7 2 years ago 5
Thumbs up for that. That's so right. that's why they're millionaire rappers the world over. They just say anything. They have the worst beats in the world that a child could create. Their words don't inspire. Man they get worst by the decade.
Izzyblizz 2 years ago 2
when rappers do it, they get sued. all the fuckign time. and the people filing the lawsuits almost always win... if he got the samples cleared. and paid for them it would be different.(rappers also, its kind of a part of beat making, so its expected. if you hadn't known gnr ripped this off, you'd be thinking, oh shit. gnr does awesome ambient intros.) gnr doesn't deserve credit for this guys work. gnr sucks.
metropolis1927 2 years ago
i don't know...i always thought the intro to Riad N' the Bedouins was a little weird. i never thought, "oh shit. gnr does awesome ambient intros." it was more like, "what the hell is this?"
frenchfry612 2 years ago
cut the talk and either thumbs up this track or thumbs down i definately thumbs up its a emotional rollacoaster of a song love it
sg2massive 2 years ago 4
This does not sound like the beginning of Chinese Democracy
Stop wanking about it and just enjoy the brilliance of the song
hikaruonline 2 years ago 7
You know what they say about imitation and flattery...and Ulrich deserves the compliment quite frankly...
birdandbloke 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
HAHAHA!!!! It´s exactly the same! with the other crappy track of schnauss on top of it. Anyways, Chinesse democracy rocks, and its a great album. But can´t help but wonder why in the hell Axl need´s to rip off this guy when you can do this kind of sounds with any music/audio software?? what the hell was he thinking?
grinchorock 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
U know its not Axl's Fault. This song does sound like Riad N Bedounis but Axl is not the person to Blame, Its that Chris Pitman who does the Beats Stuff in the band. That Chris Pitman is a Useless Person in Guns N Roses, They really dont need 2 Keyboard Players. Dizzy Reed is enough for the band and well Chinese Democracy was an amazing Album and Axl is an amazing vocalist and a songwriter and a composer.
kblp 2 years ago
noo nada q ver cn la de gnr por dios q hijos de puta
fabroscot 2 years ago
the intro does sound a little bit the same and with the same tempo.. but it lasts just 7 seconds on Riad n bedouins and it's hardly noticeable. maybe they used the same sample library... still it's plain ridiculous to say the "song" was plagiarized.
MrJeanmik 2 years ago
This is one of my favourite songs by Ulrich. The depth is amazing....
anagram81 2 years ago 7
There are similarities.
The question is who first made music.
I hope GnR.
Marko0190 2 years ago
come one, guns n roses has playing Riad N' The Bedouins in 2001. The GNR song was written earler.
new5597 2 years ago
This song was released in 2001 by Ulrich in Europe, and he wrote it in 1998 - try again dip shit
djquikfix 1 year ago
GNR TOTALLY ripped this off. I can't believe they would do that. Not like he's a reasonable guy.
VitalemRecords 2 years ago
is true, the first 10 seconds are very similar, but not even part of a riff or part of the song. is very confusing, but it is not plagiarism, Guns N 'Roses does not need that.
yeahlucciano 2 years ago
It most certainly IS plagiarism. You can't rip off a full 20 seconds of someone's stuff and not pay them for it.
VitalemRecords 2 years ago
one my fave tracks. great publicity for Schnauss!
Dunx 2 years ago
while these do sound very similar...they clearly are not the same, no copy paste job here. all it is is a couple of alternating notes on a synth with the volume following along a simple parametric equation......yeah with all this technology how in the world could two separate people come up with something similar?
heyjgeo 2 years ago
but please
are 10 damn seconds
the intro, is a part de SXF of "ambience sound"
yeahlucciano 2 years ago
For people saying Ulrich just hit a button and this sound came out, you are dead wrong. I know for a fact a lot of time and effort went into creating this music. This sound wasn't just in a MIDI bed, he crafted it. It's his own work.
For a producer on Chinese Democracy to sample this without credit is illegal, and Ulrich Schnauss will win in court.
GodsHand 2 years ago
holy crap i hear the resemblance. but i just think its funny that this comes up RIGHT after the satriani-coldplay case got settled. haha
dwagsizzle 2 years ago
it's a sample, not a coincidental note for note transcription on a similar synth. can't believe people have the chutzpah to back rose on this.
he passed off somebody's hard graft as his own work - uncredited.
considering how irate people get when house / techno producers sample their favorite bands people should at least be consistent.
Pulsator 2 years ago
dude you are so wrong there..
There have been many many many occasions of lazy producers ripping off electronic music producers.. This is just another classic example..
not saying it doesn't happen the other way either.. because it does obviously.
jcotteri 2 years ago
"usually".
it's what gives some rock fans a smug sense of self-worth. if i had a £ for every mate who has told me that electronic producers merely rip-off other people's work...
and house music has a history of sampling that perhaps only hip-hop can match - it's a history that goes back to it's disco roots, and is pretty undeniable.
when it's done well you end up with summat like bucketheads - the bomb, when it's done badly you end up with deep dish sampling dire straights.
Pulsator 2 years ago
C'mon, don't make it into a "Rock vs Electronic" debate. It has nothing to do with it.
It's about work and getting paid for it. Record companies have complaining about having their albuns stole by the internet community, but when a signed artists steal from an indie composer then its okay? Two wrongs don't make a right, dude!
eltrevoso 2 years ago 2
er, i said a few comments back that if you steal someone else's work without credit or permission then you deserve all you get.
i was merely pointing out that it is usually bands complaining about lazy house producers knicking their work.
here a lazy rock artist has been caught red handed stealing original electronic music.
Pulsator 2 years ago
you're right ndzick718..
I shouldn't generalise. I know lots of nice and intelligent Americans... It just angers me so when I see idiots (see above) post on here when they clearly have no idea what they are talking about.. I need to get off the internet.. haha
jcotteri 2 years ago
plus he can't spell their either... what a joke.. i mean seriously
jcotteri 2 years ago
I have this as an option on my synth. I just can't believe GnR used it in their music. It is too simple to make. I should sue Ulrich for using my sample.
icpillusions 2 years ago
@icpillusions - Enough with the bullshit, dude... He uses mostly modular synths and vintage stuff, and some software. Ulrich is above all a sound designer and wouldn't use a preset like lazy producers.
eltrevoso 2 years ago 2
Well said, eltrevoso. I'm not sure how a person can be so ignorant.
billythewill67 2 years ago
Wait a second - YOUR sample? Did you create the patch?
Care to elaborate?
Ulrich is a truly inspiring producer. His work is fantastic!
billythewill67 2 years ago
it's obviously a direct sample used by Guns N' Roses. Can't believe people saying this isn't a big deal. If you were a struggling musician and someone who's being paid millions to record an album doesn't pay you what's due, you'd be pissed.
bobbymoz24 2 years ago 2
The news is that a production member gave the band some cool sound effects to use, and had claimed he had them legally, obviously not...but hey, its only the groovy intro
TheImperialNinjA 2 years ago
id say it was more of a sample, hes an idot for not asking for it, well he would look real dumb taking all these years and wanting to use someone elses stuff...and now he does anyway coz after all that ppl clocked on!!
ijfox87 2 years ago
The synth sounds similar, that makes it plagarism? Wow, I've seen much bigger rip offs then this that have been let to slide.
SidVicious10101 2 years ago
I Agree With Scottamass. It honsestly all programming, soemthing is always going to show up in someone elses song, theres no way to avoid it.
FromTheMusic 2 years ago
i don't know why they're flipping out about this...it's such a small part of riad n' the bedouins, and it's not like it made the song any better. personally, i'd like the song better without the intro, or at least a shorter one.
frenchfry612 2 years ago
I agree but shorter is better, like when the guitar starts fading in, i went and edited the intro out and it sounds very weird with axl's screeching coming straight at you :P
BNTfilmsonline 2 years ago
HAHaha I thought it was a melody or riff what was going to sound similar, wtf so now every synth intro around will be a plagiarism!!
dieggnr 2 years ago
I cant wait till the time comes where you'd be able to sue someone for having the same not in a song.
XNAspotlight 2 years ago
thanks to Axl, now I found a cool song
sleezboy 2 years ago 3
WOW THIS IS exact Axl is SUCH A FAG
ElectricityCity 2 years ago
it's all keyboard generated sounds.... should yamaha or korg or whatever keyboard manufacturer sue everybody who uses there programed sound.... it's rediculous
scottamass 2 years ago 3
I understand where you are coming from, but I have to believe that Schnauss' label would have contacted him to confirm the sounds he used in his songs are not just some synth factory presets, a loop from a sample library or a built in loop from some popular DAW that GnR may have also used. It's very likely that both have access to the exact same synth or software in the studio.
halogen8 2 years ago 3
true, good call
scottamass 2 years ago
Sounds similar but its not the same, theres more going on in this as opposed to the Rhaid intro that they're claiming. As far as I'm aware of, you can only copywrite the lyrics and melody and a "coincidental" sound effect is neither one or the other. But if the courts favor Ulrich, I wouldnt be shocked because "Chinese Democracy" was problematic from the start.
sycoticbeige 2 years ago
Come on, what's 20 seconds? Big fucking deal.
HoBgObLiiN 2 years ago
i'd have to laugh if riad was actually the song being copied from...it is pretty old, but i guess the cool intro isn't
TheImperialNinjA 2 years ago 3
holy fuck...
TheImperialNinjA 2 years ago
Okay, this sounds pretty exact, I'm not gonna lie.
Unakau 2 years ago
yeah. but axl coulded save this sue, of those unnecessary 35 seconds of Rhiad, really the song "Rhiad" is great but the intro is boring.
MadridNRoses 2 years ago 2
yeah the intro is the same, maybe the composer of the song didnt tell axl about that.
MadridNRoses 2 years ago
To all the people saying its a coincidence...seriously? Identical to the note is a coincidence?
PyroMittens 2 years ago 2
It doesn't even sound like GNR
macskasegg 2 years ago
the intro of rhiad
papalokio 2 years ago 2
As a big GN'R fan, i'll admit the intro of this and Riad is the exact same
RAMBOvGnR 2 years ago 5
I listened to the intro and yeah you're right, it is the same
macskasegg 2 years ago
What a joke (not the song) the lawsuit..... all that is, is a synth on a computer, please that dude aint getting a million anything from the GNR Crew.... like the song though
sub17runner 2 years ago
Tee-hee, Guns n Roses stole the first 15 seconds of this songs. Just do a search on "Riad N the Bedouins" and you'll hear what I'm talking about :)
lanmas 2 years ago 3
ha agreed
HorseCalledBen 2 years ago
GNR are actually getting sued for this aswell
19911995 2 years ago
Yep, you're absolutely right. But they're suing people who aren't even in the band...Which is stupid.
HUNK735 2 years ago 2
exactly, it should be the band as a whole not individual members
19911995 2 years ago
LOVING IT SO MUCH!!!!
pietex 2 years ago
Love it, one of the best from Ulrich. 5 star song!
duncansebastian 2 years ago 2
nice n calm just the way i like it ;)
123starkiller321 2 years ago
incredible music.. best track
dnbkiller 2 years ago
Nice one 13086 :D Be sure to check out his Suddenly the Trees Are Giving - one of my faves!
Just thought, this would've been a good track for GTA IV's ambient Journey radio station. Loved to have flown over Liberty in a heli at sunset with this on the speakers!
Hughchube78 3 years ago
Yeah, not bad either though I like also his somewhat faster tracks like "A Million Miles away".
If you like something slow & phat, check out "Sand" by Max Melvin -- an incredibly relaxing piece of music!
13086 2 years ago
Someone recommended this guy from a BoC post - cheers! Can't stop playin this.
Youtube 1st for music anyday!
Hughchube78 3 years ago 2
*Hi5* -- that's also how I've come across Ulrich Schnauss ;)
13086 3 years ago 2
In fact its his best track.
paulkazjack 3 years ago
Well, Molfsee & esp. Knuddelmaus aren't bad either but this track has been the reason to buy the album ;)
13086 3 years ago
Really a great track, simple, light, yet powerful. I discovered US by instance when someone on YT compared him to BoC but this track sounds quite differently, like of Mix of Jean-Michel Jarre & Max Melvin -- just great :)
13086 3 years ago
superb.
paulkazjack 3 years ago
freshh banging beats ...
lumpy42069 3 years ago
i love gnr too!
Datdude133d 3 years ago
fuckin dope, excuse my french...
George1984Orwell 3 years ago
One of my all time favourites! Excelent track and artist!
theodark 3 years ago
one of my all time favourites too, just don't ask me why i do not know and i don't think i want to really find out!!
homesicktree 2 years ago
I think that there are some tracks like this one, that although you hear them for the first time, its like they remind you places and people. Just as if you had heard them back then :)
theodark 2 years ago 3
This is a great sound....
lamonts28 3 years ago
i also wanted to upload this. makes me feel so strange, brings up a lot of sweet memories... a miracle. thank you :)
bvikk 3 years ago