Unbelievable..what a glory..what a voice..what a personality.. Please singers LEARN!!! Tears and joy fight eachother listening to this God-Given Artist..
these comments puzzle me--the technical ones I do not understand though I have gad musical training--but don't we all realize what we have here?Will there ever be anything like it again?
If Maestro Christoff heard this, I think he would've felt very offended(joking). It's known that he definitely wasn't in good terms witch Callas. There's even a story floating around that she offended him very rudely regarding his ethnicity and he "bitchslapped" her, lol.
I doubt that it is 100% true, but there is always some truth to these rumors :)
You mean to tell me Callas sang Boris Godounov? Wow, her fans give her even more credit than she was due. Please, boris1281, relieve me of this horrible mental picture of Callas as Boris G. I respect Christoff too much.
Dont be silly, I mean the operatic part in general, the wway they elaborate the stage character seems equally elaborated, complex and creative whther its Boris, Gilda, Da Silva or Manon Lescaut.
As another great Christoff fan, I agree with you. He never had as powerful a voice as many of his colleagues.
But power is not everything. It is not even important in my opinion.
The voice of Boris Christoff possessed the most unique timbre (and the darkest one!) as well as the most immense ability for shade and colour I've ever heard. Such cliches like "velvet tone" or "golden tone" suddenly make sense when one hears him. Not to mention his miracluous psychological insight in all of his parts
As much as I cannot agree on the statement about BCH's voice power the more I cannot accept a similar one about His basso profoundness. BCH is THE basso profondo. His Genius is in the ability to use the power not at all costs but where it's just (He can be a Tunder but also a Mildest Touch) that, in fact, is the core of your comment's second part (which I totally support).
I don't know about "basso profundo" - it's a term that makes no sense to me.
It is quite true that Boris could produce a real thundering notes when he wanted to, but I don't think this was his usual voice. Which is all the better and add subtle colours one is not likely to find anywhere else. Indeed, many other basses often sound to me just like shouting (no names so there will be no offended)
Anyway, all this doesn't matter at all. Boris Christoff is simply unique and that's that.
One way or another "basso profondo" is an existing term that evidently attains different meanings depending on the point of view. I might be totally wrong but for me it's not bound to the overall power but to the lower register excellence and depth of the voice (incl. velvetness, subtleness...) even in pp.
And you are right the unutterable cannot be explained.
as a collector of all the recordings of Christoff (more than 30 years now) this magnificant. Since I was 16 I am addicted to his voice. Please add more if possible
At the beginning he whispers in the conductor's ear: "It was good, but not wonderful", probably referring to the feminine word "repetition". Someone says "shall we keep that one", and Christoff replies "no, we'll do it again!" ... just in case anyone was wondering. What he whispers to the bloke sat at the piano we'll never know!
He is the pride and glory and boast of my native Bulgaria
cantorga 1 year ago 2
Fascinating. Thank you!!
winobuff 1 year ago
That is nothing short of pure genius!!
adeverger 1 year ago
Unbelievable..what a glory..what a voice..what a personality.. Please singers LEARN!!! Tears and joy fight eachother listening to this God-Given Artist..
ernstdaniel1 1 year ago
The greatest voice I have ever heard. Is there a DVD?
vivascargill 1 year ago
@vivascargill Yes you can find Boris Godounov/Christoff CD from EMI Cluytens directing...
clytemnestre1 1 year ago
@clytemnestre1 Yes thank you I now own it!!!
vivascargill 1 year ago
these comments puzzle me--the technical ones I do not understand though I have gad musical training--but don't we all realize what we have here?Will there ever be anything like it again?
vivascargill 1 year ago
I don't know what to say--he walks in some talk and then it is like heaven! I have never heard such beautiful sound from a human voice
vivascargill 1 year ago
why is it we worry to much about breathing technique.....abdominal, lateral...etc.......look at the begining of the aria...is that chest breathing?
AHbassbaritone 1 year ago
@AHbassbaritone Do you want to teach Boris Christoff way of singing?
Do you do better? I hope......
Christoff interpretation is NOT transcended till now! Even there are great Boris, but without any theatral and musical interpretation...
clytemnestre1 1 year ago
Sublime Christoff Gratie !
bodiloto 2 years ago 2
invaluable post. thank you gabba02
ruffoite 2 years ago 2
..I have the feeling that Tchaikovsky, Mussorgsky and the Russian composers of the 1800s would favor this bass over all others.....
j72050 2 years ago 7
@j72050 YES . ITS IS PUBLISHED BE EMI too. integral Mussogsky and the five composer too
clytemnestre1 1 year ago
Comment removed
rwbagley 2 years ago
A miracle! How did you find such a gem? Thank you so much for preserving this treasure.
vstasov 2 years ago 9
E' vecchissima, eppure l'audio è ottimo ! Qualcuno che si intende di audio mi spiega perchè certe registrazioni più recenti fanno schifo ?
Nemorino11 2 years ago
Che interpretazione, quest'uomo diventa ciò che interpreta....grandissimo
Sirianne59 2 years ago
Une voix sublime et des expressions extraordinaires ! Boris, tu es le plus grand !
thoukout 2 years ago
Incredible!!! The goose bumps are will never go away.
ceb2633 3 years ago
I love him. He is the best Boris of all non-russian singers. Actually - better than most russians. Excepting Petrov and Pirogov.
RomeoMaestro 3 years ago
Who is Petrov????Who is Pigorov????
theodor28uzunov 2 years ago
magnificient BORIS!
bassoprofondissimo 3 years ago
He has a very similar approach to the part as Callas - the phrasing and the colour of the timbre care for the perfection of this interpretation.
boris1281 3 years ago
If Maestro Christoff heard this, I think he would've felt very offended(joking). It's known that he definitely wasn't in good terms witch Callas. There's even a story floating around that she offended him very rudely regarding his ethnicity and he "bitchslapped" her, lol.
I doubt that it is 100% true, but there is always some truth to these rumors :)
xsavovx 3 years ago
You mean to tell me Callas sang Boris Godounov? Wow, her fans give her even more credit than she was due. Please, boris1281, relieve me of this horrible mental picture of Callas as Boris G. I respect Christoff too much.
ceb2633 3 years ago
Dont be silly, I mean the operatic part in general, the wway they elaborate the stage character seems equally elaborated, complex and creative whther its Boris, Gilda, Da Silva or Manon Lescaut.
boris1281 3 years ago
Brilliant video, thank you!
Imogenn 3 years ago
Cet enregistrement éffectué pour la première chaine de la télévision française date de Mai 1967.
Le titre de l'émission était "Initiation à la musique"(produite par Bernard Gavoty et Marcel Bluwal).
Le chef qui se trouve face à Christoff est J.C Hartmann.
alexandrevlad37 3 years ago
Heart-stoppingly beautiful. Thank you so much. Is this from a commercial DVD?
jkircher314 4 years ago
BRAVO! Thank you so much for posting. Please post more if you have it....
mtmandave1 4 years ago
The most immense basso profundo of all times. One of the strongest pillar of the opera art.
amlirco 4 years ago 3
I'm a big Christoff fan, but he was by no means a basso profundo, and his voice was not "immense." By all accounts, his voice was medium-sized.
BorisGodunov 2 years ago
Indeed? Remarcable confidence... Congratulations!
amlirco 2 years ago
As another great Christoff fan, I agree with you. He never had as powerful a voice as many of his colleagues.
But power is not everything. It is not even important in my opinion.
The voice of Boris Christoff possessed the most unique timbre (and the darkest one!) as well as the most immense ability for shade and colour I've ever heard. Such cliches like "velvet tone" or "golden tone" suddenly make sense when one hears him. Not to mention his miracluous psychological insight in all of his parts
Spiritakis 2 years ago 2
As much as I cannot agree on the statement about BCH's voice power the more I cannot accept a similar one about His basso profoundness. BCH is THE basso profondo. His Genius is in the ability to use the power not at all costs but where it's just (He can be a Tunder but also a Mildest Touch) that, in fact, is the core of your comment's second part (which I totally support).
amlirco 2 years ago
I don't know about "basso profundo" - it's a term that makes no sense to me.
It is quite true that Boris could produce a real thundering notes when he wanted to, but I don't think this was his usual voice. Which is all the better and add subtle colours one is not likely to find anywhere else. Indeed, many other basses often sound to me just like shouting (no names so there will be no offended)
Anyway, all this doesn't matter at all. Boris Christoff is simply unique and that's that.
Spiritakis 2 years ago
One way or another "basso profondo" is an existing term that evidently attains different meanings depending on the point of view. I might be totally wrong but for me it's not bound to the overall power but to the lower register excellence and depth of the voice (incl. velvetness, subtleness...) even in pp.
And you are right the unutterable cannot be explained.
Thank you for your insightful comments.
amlirco 2 years ago
true, but he still is my favorite bass, and one of the best of the 20th c
ahmad123987 2 years ago
Its the first recording,1952.
And he is the one and only.
From other universe.
zehnoffbass 4 years ago
Fantastic interpretation !
fernandobicudo 4 years ago
Magnificient! Post more and more ...please!
emotionbelcanto 4 years ago
as a collector of all the recordings of Christoff (more than 30 years now) this magnificant. Since I was 16 I am addicted to his voice. Please add more if possible
operaruud 4 years ago
Tone, color, expression, sensitivity to the words, drama = magic.
sfkcbf 4 years ago
Was it the 2nd or 1st recording of the opera ,he did two Boris Godanov's the 2nd in the 70's I think?
opera60 4 years ago
At the beginning he whispers in the conductor's ear: "It was good, but not wonderful", probably referring to the feminine word "repetition". Someone says "shall we keep that one", and Christoff replies "no, we'll do it again!" ... just in case anyone was wondering. What he whispers to the bloke sat at the piano we'll never know!
sorbino9 4 years ago
What a great artist he was , thanks for posting.
gvjps123 4 years ago
The best artist and Boris interpretation of that century and future....
mornaymariedomini 4 years ago
Absolutely right!
sorbino9 4 years ago
Magic interpretation...
dustmondo45 4 years ago
wonderfull!besides a magnific voice his interpretation is a of highest artistic level!
stchoukine 4 years ago