It was a fantastic performance accuracy wise and overall playing. BUT he didn't have much emotion as one should have while playing this piece. But like I said, really good playing :)
... Mister Spooner ... this is terrific stuff ... thankyou ... ! ... yes ... you have legitimised the grand pianforte ... in a way you have become a teacher of mine ... you play the singing line very well ... !
Have you tried playing it yourself? It's got to be one of the most taxing pieces for a pianist (even the original accompaniment, never mind the Liszt transcription). Think of the repetition of all thos fast notes.
@HerrHansCastorp1 I think so. There's nobody in the audience. Probably just doing a relaxed runthrough to get used to the piano for a later performance where he'll unleash all the fury! I've seen him live, and he's very capable of it. ;)
Come on, dude. He did it so us pianists who can't sing for shit and who can't hire a singer whenever it takes our fancy can play this whenever we want. No, Liszt isn't saying "here's how I would've done it." He's saying "here, now we can sing (play) this gorgeous music too." This isn't the only Schubert song he transcribed, I think he did almost all of them.
Well, likewise I'll disagree with you and respect your opinion. I actually love Liszt, playing his music is exciting and comfortable for me (since he was a pianist's pianist, so to speak, his music fits my hand nicely). I love his ouvre. (And yes I'll admit some of it it is a bit superficial...)
I think his motivation was to bring Schubert's music home to more people, and the same goes for the Beethoven symphonies.
But to each his own, the world is better when populated by individuals :)
ok yeah my last comment was retarded, but i played this piece for a competition, the judge said i had marvelous talent but i should have picked a song the was writen for the piano, sure this song was written to be sang, but honestly the way u play it, it should have been written for the piano, and i wanna show that judge this video cause this was amazing, i ended up getting a second place on the solo because of her opinion of my song choice, good job
ok it is very cool and fast, but the arragangement im playing is in triplelets to really emphasize the horse, which really adds to the story, here i dont get the feeling, and in the middle its supposed to be dolce, i dont feel that here, but, really really nice job
amazing. my Advanced Ladies choir is singing this piece in German at our next concert; i loved the enthusiasm and feeling put into the piano. verrryy well done.
The real technique for keeping the RH going is to use the 4th and 5th fingers alternately for the repeated octaves and just "flap" the hand back and forth. Cziffra uses this technique.
omgosh that is the most awesome song ever!! my piano teacher taught me how to play that today and i thought i was going to die with the speed and the chords but i thought i did well. but now after seeing this guy i just feel like i did horrable haha.
My hand was sore after two minutes at the Erlking's major mode of cajoling. It's not bad, but he's beat's a little off here and there for the right hand. But bravo anyways
(The energy and feeling sometimes derives from the crowd and the energy from there enthusiasm. I'm no expert, nor can I play piano, but throughout performances on stage, I can say that energy does come directly from your audience.
I think the recurring bass-motive in octaves is smudged by bad pedalling and a weak tonal control...where is the 'mystery'?it should rather be a menacing whisper-(yatata-tatata-tam-tam-tam...)
I like the resonant melody line, he brings out pathos...but I find the whole performance in general too loud and messy...it needs a more refined approach...
The song isnt technical hard. But to play always the staccato on the right and left hand ist very hard! I played this song not in this tempo.. little bit slower, but it was hard enough :)
Wow, I heard Steven Spooner play live at a Music camp I was at. He really is fantastic. He wrote a song called Etude-Toccatta that is the hardest piece I have ever heard played.
It's a bit slower, yes, but also extremely refined, polished, and shaped. It's easier to bang through it and not shape anything--this is professional playing
Your video clip is great and I've rated it as awesome. Please check out mine on an old trading card set of classical music composers: Schubert, Bach, Mozart, Beethoven and many more included.
Pretty good dude, I love Erlkönig and Die Forelle, they both have similar musical themes at least to me they do! Pretty good playing! I've sang Die Forelle, but yet to sing Erlkönig gotta get a little older!
it's amaaazing!!!
kanfyetka 3 months ago
It was a fantastic performance accuracy wise and overall playing. BUT he didn't have much emotion as one should have while playing this piece. But like I said, really good playing :)
Lawliet3843 7 months ago
... Mister Spooner ... this is terrific stuff ... thankyou ... ! ... yes ... you have legitimised the grand pianforte ... in a way you have become a teacher of mine ... you play the singing line very well ... !
MusicPredominates 1 year ago
omg its such a pain on your right hand to play this honestly .... this piece requires intense endurance
DJponkthispartay 1 year ago 2
He was one of the teachers at the Missouri Fine Arts Academy!! Him and his wife, too bad they are thinking of cutting the academy from the budget.
MrBassSinger 1 year ago
oh mann ich habe so etwas geniales noch nie auf dem Klaviere gehöhrt, I never hear some genial piece anywherer
glance777 1 year ago
Wonderful!!!!!! amazing!
ShlomoBarOn 1 year ago
Too slow...Is he practising?
HerrHansCastorp1 1 year ago
@HerrHansCastorp1
Have you tried playing it yourself? It's got to be one of the most taxing pieces for a pianist (even the original accompaniment, never mind the Liszt transcription). Think of the repetition of all thos fast notes.
twistoph 1 year ago
@HerrHansCastorp1 I think so. There's nobody in the audience. Probably just doing a relaxed runthrough to get used to the piano for a later performance where he'll unleash all the fury! I've seen him live, and he's very capable of it. ;)
OrangeSodaKing 1 year ago
People should be watching him!!! Where are you peoples?!?!
TheBilly0101 1 year ago
BRAVO!!!!! DAMN!!!!
paytoplaynj 1 year ago
bravo! i have tried to learn this piece...it's so difficult
mistressmozart 2 years ago
isnt this solely by schubert?
onecrazdorito 2 years ago
I take it that the solo piano version is very difficult. I've also met him. =) He's a really cool guy.
He can play Alkan's "Le Chemin de Fer!"
OrangeSodaKing 2 years ago
Comment removed
PJinBston 2 years ago
Comment removed
PJinBston 2 years ago
Come on, dude. He did it so us pianists who can't sing for shit and who can't hire a singer whenever it takes our fancy can play this whenever we want. No, Liszt isn't saying "here's how I would've done it." He's saying "here, now we can sing (play) this gorgeous music too." This isn't the only Schubert song he transcribed, I think he did almost all of them.
goobleglob 2 years ago 10
Comment removed
PJinBston 2 years ago
Yes, it's better as Schubert wrote it, but I do think Liszt's transcription has its merits and is a good compromise. I hope we can agree on this? :)
goobleglob 2 years ago
Comment removed
PJinBston 2 years ago
Well, likewise I'll disagree with you and respect your opinion. I actually love Liszt, playing his music is exciting and comfortable for me (since he was a pianist's pianist, so to speak, his music fits my hand nicely). I love his ouvre. (And yes I'll admit some of it it is a bit superficial...)
I think his motivation was to bring Schubert's music home to more people, and the same goes for the Beethoven symphonies.
But to each his own, the world is better when populated by individuals :)
goobleglob 2 years ago 2
Comment removed
PJinBston 2 years ago
pretty intense
EpicF4ilure 2 years ago
Tempo slows down (e.g. compare 0:44 with 0:00). Other than that, well played.
rhapsodyinblue18 2 years ago 2
Amazing! *-*
rosesrebecca 2 years ago
Bravo!
tnifty 2 years ago
ok yeah my last comment was retarded, but i played this piece for a competition, the judge said i had marvelous talent but i should have picked a song the was writen for the piano, sure this song was written to be sang, but honestly the way u play it, it should have been written for the piano, and i wanna show that judge this video cause this was amazing, i ended up getting a second place on the solo because of her opinion of my song choice, good job
Pian0playa22 3 years ago 3
man, that sucks.
tnifty 2 years ago
ok it is very cool and fast, but the arragangement im playing is in triplelets to really emphasize the horse, which really adds to the story, here i dont get the feeling, and in the middle its supposed to be dolce, i dont feel that here, but, really really nice job
Pian0playa22 3 years ago
yeah, its not like the horse was running for the whole song.
EpicF4ilure 2 years ago
I like the opening piano playing, but I hate the story of the song. A kid dying while riding in the woods with his dad kinda sucks.
Sora572 3 years ago 2
most lieder end with someone dying or going insane. :D
phantasma616 3 years ago 2
love this composition :D
djjosor 3 years ago
there needs to be a guitar cover that would be tght
Raylj318 3 years ago
i thought the same thing. im probably gonna transcribe it for 2 guitars.
wolfisloose 3 years ago 2
yo--josh ritter with hilary hahn
japanawon 3 years ago
Liszt, as well as Berlioz, also orchestrated the original piano accompaniment.
JupiterIV 3 years ago
nicee
MrWasab1 3 years ago 2
If you like this, go see the real one (another youtube clip) where he plays it at tempo...this is a rehearsal but still very good.
pianonerd 3 years ago
this is his slow practice...
geoslav 3 years ago 2
amazing. my Advanced Ladies choir is singing this piece in German at our next concert; i loved the enthusiasm and feeling put into the piano. verrryy well done.
cookiemonstercrazy 3 years ago
How do you want to play it much faster? A Lang-Lang can do that... it is so difficult...i once tried it but soon failed i must admitt.
IMGTheBomber 3 years ago
The real technique for keeping the RH going is to use the 4th and 5th fingers alternately for the repeated octaves and just "flap" the hand back and forth. Cziffra uses this technique.
Grigor99 3 years ago
I agree. The whole performance is very far from being a chase in the forest. Check out Slavchev's.
olivierochanine 3 years ago
looks like this shit'll give you CT in your right wrist
Xahmbi 3 years ago
too bad the kid dies at the end. such a wonderful piece.
camdaddy09 3 years ago
omgosh that is the most awesome song ever!! my piano teacher taught me how to play that today and i thought i was going to die with the speed and the chords but i thought i did well. but now after seeing this guy i just feel like i did horrable haha.
SyLviialuvsNiCkj 3 years ago
My hand was sore after two minutes at the Erlking's major mode of cajoling. It's not bad, but he's beat's a little off here and there for the right hand. But bravo anyways
xxGarraSandofWindxx 3 years ago
Man, it's hard to believe human hands can play this Schubert masterpiece...
Klaus126 3 years ago
it is not hard to believe they can do so, it is hard to believe how a human being can write such an incredibly difficult piece... a real masterpiece
IMGTheBomber 3 years ago
why does it say liszt, its by schubert?
COCONUTB00BS 3 years ago
The original piece was by Schubert for choir. Liszt did the piano arrangement.
wolfesw 3 years ago
this one of liszt is not easy but you are brilliant :) amazing!!!
londonparisny 3 years ago
you're amazingly excellent!
kevint412007 3 years ago
Bravo!
effelunga 3 years ago
das schubertismus thus
3NUNS 3 years ago
das noisie at first but then BEAUTIFUL
3NUNS 3 years ago
Very well done!
(The energy and feeling sometimes derives from the crowd and the energy from there enthusiasm. I'm no expert, nor can I play piano, but throughout performances on stage, I can say that energy does come directly from your audience.
lsmithbauer88 3 years ago
i do think he could put a little more feeling and mystery in it, though he's really good. and it's a really beautiful piece!
mib1996 3 years ago
This is very good.
DAISUKITYOUUN 3 years ago
I think the recurring bass-motive in octaves is smudged by bad pedalling and a weak tonal control...where is the 'mystery'?it should rather be a menacing whisper-(yatata-tatata-tam-tam-tam...)
I like the resonant melody line, he brings out pathos...but I find the whole performance in general too loud and messy...it needs a more refined approach...
wujujufu 3 years ago
das ist guht point
3NUNS 3 years ago
This is a very good rendering--obviously not as good as the live concert performance by Lazaar Berman--but still really good. Thanks, much.
shusarik 3 years ago
It is probably encore, because the public has already left :-). Just kidding, I rather liked it, even if it is a little slow.
mltube 4 years ago
The song isnt technical hard. But to play always the staccato on the right and left hand ist very hard! I played this song not in this tempo.. little bit slower, but it was hard enough :)
Heroman310 4 years ago
aaaaaaaa
.......
dont know what to say
first time i listen this song
i'm.....i think
wow...wow...
comosicusguitar 4 years ago
wat the hell r u doing man..wow ruined the whole piece
cchengviolinist 4 years ago
Such an emotional piece, look up the lyrics, this is my favorite piece of Schubert's
jdw8705 4 years ago
no line at left hand, no idea of legato
what he could do is just "HIT" the keys.
it's the wrong way to play forte...
poisonalien 4 years ago
did you ever try to play erlkönig on the piano???? your a fool man
Pumatz 4 years ago 12
Terrific! Great control!
kaltst 4 years ago
Pure virtousity
Rednecksnapples 4 years ago 2
I can only play the first page of this song.
eragonrules1234 4 years ago
Wow, I heard Steven Spooner play live at a Music camp I was at. He really is fantastic. He wrote a song called Etude-Toccatta that is the hardest piece I have ever heard played.
pinkfloydfaneclipse 4 years ago
amazing.
xxrasputinaxx 4 years ago
Good, good! I'm really impressed... however...
You can't sing Erlkönig while listening to this version. It's too slow.
Eltima 4 years ago
can you sing to my tempo? Or is it too fast?
geoslav 4 years ago
Yas I can. A bit faster than usually, but I can ^__^
Eltima 4 years ago
It's a bit slower, yes, but also extremely refined, polished, and shaped. It's easier to bang through it and not shape anything--this is professional playing
pianonerd 4 years ago 2
Schubert was only 18 when he composed it.
geoslav 4 years ago
To be exact... 17 lol =P
1hmm2 4 years ago
Your video clip is great and I've rated it as awesome. Please check out mine on an old trading card set of classical music composers: Schubert, Bach, Mozart, Beethoven and many more included.
creamofcardstv 4 years ago
I love your performance!!
picapin 4 years ago
very tough piece. gr8 job/thank you!
PEACendwarWORLDpeace 4 years ago
Personally I love the forte...makes it a very powerful lieder
urdaaj4 4 years ago
I love the Erl King. It takes loads of talent to play a piece that well. This is truly deserving of the Angel's approval.
APPROVED BY THE ANGEL OF MUSIC
TheAngelOfMusic1 4 years ago
I neevr heard this song before but i just taught my self the first two first pages i am goanna learn the whole thing
lordlactose 4 years ago
By the time you get to the last two last pages, you might get tired! You'd better skip the middle two pages! This is great!
geoslav 4 years ago
very nice! i've gotta learn this one! ty for the video!
bigefe777 4 years ago
5 stars man you play it like a rock star!
lordlactose 4 years ago
You are amazing!
SpontaneousDude 5 years ago
wow 5 stars u play like a rock star!
lordlactose 4 years ago
5 stars dude u play likea rock star!
lordlactose 4 years ago
i love this piece! you play it well!
pianojoe123 5 years ago
Great technique. But all the time so forte! There is needed a piano to make contrast
camilocuesta 5 years ago
i love this track! so dramatic! schubert; a true genius and all this work in just 31 years of his life!
tommyk77 5 years ago
Pretty good dude, I love Erlkönig and Die Forelle, they both have similar musical themes at least to me they do! Pretty good playing! I've sang Die Forelle, but yet to sing Erlkönig gotta get a little older!
NubianKingofHearts 5 years ago
Schubert: Erlkönig
wikketheking 5 years ago
Cool, I really heard the different personas from the song come through in your playing.
sonicv3 5 years ago
I love this poem/song! it's awesome, and you pulled it off well.. great job!
Beckers99 5 years ago
Very good, Mr. Spooner! All them fuckin octaves boy!You must preparing for the
Potato Piano Competition.
Burnsomatic 5 years ago